Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Organ donation in partner’s family

95 replies

Flawedperfection · 04/06/2021 17:24

Hi,

First time poster, longtime lurker.

As the title suggests, I have a question about organ donation in my partner’s family.

My partner’s brother needs a kidney and has done so for a while. Some family members have been tested to no avail and now it’s widely considered to be my partner’s “turn” to do so. The issue is that they are not close and whilst my partner is concerned (naturally, as a fairly decent human being) about their sibling, it’s a big thing to do for someone you don’t care for/aren’t in touch with and are unsure if you want to take such a risk for.

Sadly, the sibling really does need the kidney and has two young kids. Their partner is not a match. Not relevant, but financially they are ok. My partner is not ok financially and is a job hopper with no real security (same for me).

I’m concerned that my partner would give the organ and if something went wrong be screwed, financially and health wise. We have no support of any sort from family and are private renters. For full disclosure we don’t have kids as it didn’t happen for us so we don’t have young people to let down, but I also feel this is why we are feeling pressured for my other half to test and donate.

Thanks for reading!

Yanbu- it’s a risk with no guarantees for all involved
Yabu- don’t be selfish- it’s just a kidney; your partner will recover, should be able to mange with just one and must help!

OP posts:
Namechangedandoverwhelmed · 05/06/2021 11:40

And hamster, that is not a guilt trip, it’s a genuine consideration. I don’t think the words “bad person” have been uttered. It’s just a case of what people can live with. Rocks and hard places. Sometimes there are no easy answers. You just have to be able to live with your choice.

Namechangedandoverwhelmed · 05/06/2021 11:37

YANBU, however, if the brother dies for a lack of a kidney, could your partner live with that?

I think in his shoes I’d do it, because I’d rather risk being financially screwed than risk the self-hatred of knowing I could have saved my brother’s life but chose not to and now my niece/nephews are fatherless.

You never know- he may not even be a match.

osbertthesyrianhamster · 05/06/2021 10:43

@FortniteBoysMum

I know all about low contact. I have not seen bio father in 30 years. Most of family I have not seen in 17 years but look at it another way. Could you leave those children without a parent? How ever shirty the relationship it could be improved but only if their breathing. If it was your partner needing an organ would he be asking the sibling in question to donate. It doesn't hurt to get tested he can still say no even if they are a match and if not nothing they can do anyway but say they tried.
What a sick guilt trip! That's honestly a disgusting thing to say. He doesn't want to do it, he doesn't need a reason. This does not make him a bad person.
osbertthesyrianhamster · 05/06/2021 10:41

[quote DreamingNow]@Flawedperfection your partner needs counselling.
As you were clearly described, it’s not a black and white situation and whatever he does, it needs to sit well with him.

If I was him, I would contact the centre who does the test and ask for counselling around that subject. He needs to explain why and have the opportunity to think about it. You might also need some counselling together once he has taken that decision (because whatever his decision is, it might sit well with you iyswim).

You’ve already looked at all the 8s and outs and haven’t reached a clear conclusion. So having a NEUTRAL third party will help you.

FWIW I think the biggest issue here is his family and the amount of guilt and pressure they are putting into to both of you, aka basically making responsible for the brother’s death if he says NO.
Imo he wouldn’t. I can understand the wish of a parent to do anything to save their child’s life. But they shouod never out any pressure on another of their children (or anyone else) to make such a decision about their body for their sake.[/quote]
Why does he need counselling? He doesn't want to do it! His family are being shit, he's not close to them, they'r pressuring him and they've made it clear they won't help him if it goes tits up. He needs to find a way to tell them NO not bloody ins and outs and getting tested. He needs a backbone and quite honestly, to get away from these people. They have no right to put any pressure on him.

'I'm diabetic. I can't donate.' The end.

ShroomShroom · 05/06/2021 10:34

It is always possible that some of the other family members who have already been tested may have been positive matches but were "rejected" because of they weren't actually 100% on board. So they have looked willing but weren't actually.

suspiria777 · 05/06/2021 10:20

Sounds like DP's sibling's family need to look into altruistic donor chains if they're so adamant they would donate if only they were a match.

DreamingNow · 05/06/2021 08:38

@Flawedperfection your partner needs counselling.
As you were clearly described, it’s not a black and white situation and whatever he does, it needs to sit well with him.

If I was him, I would contact the centre who does the test and ask for counselling around that subject. He needs to explain why and have the opportunity to think about it. You might also need some counselling together once he has taken that decision (because whatever his decision is, it might sit well with you iyswim).

You’ve already looked at all the 8s and outs and haven’t reached a clear conclusion. So having a NEUTRAL third party will help you.

FWIW I think the biggest issue here is his family and the amount of guilt and pressure they are putting into to both of you, aka basically making responsible for the brother’s death if he says NO.
Imo he wouldn’t. I can understand the wish of a parent to do anything to save their child’s life. But they shouod never out any pressure on another of their children (or anyone else) to make such a decision about their body for their sake.

fallfallfall · 05/06/2021 01:41

If your not a good match it’s a non issue. I’d do the testing then decide from there.
I’d also be honest with the team regarding your personal issues.

AnotherKrampus · 04/06/2021 21:39

There is no way that I would donate an organ to my siblings. I cannot stand them and would not feel any remorse or moral obligation. They did absolutely nothing to care for a dying parent. Despite my mother begging them to come to at least see my father before his death, they went on a holiday. He died quite young but they were told how serious his condition was. I used up all of my savings to look after my father for several months and dealt with the enormous physical and emotional strain.

FortniteBoysMum · 04/06/2021 21:30

I know all about low contact. I have not seen bio father in 30 years. Most of family I have not seen in 17 years but look at it another way. Could you leave those children without a parent? How ever shirty the relationship it could be improved but only if their breathing. If it was your partner needing an organ would he be asking the sibling in question to donate. It doesn't hurt to get tested he can still say no even if they are a match and if not nothing they can do anyway but say they tried.

kidneynewname · 04/06/2021 20:59

@Castlepeak

20 years is the old number. It was generated at a time when that was really the longest data available.

My DH is over 25 years in and still going strong.

Just to also agree with this-a transplanted kidney lasting just 20 years is an old number to use.

When going through the process of a living donor, the match is usually much better than from a deceased donor. That, coupled with better drugs regime and post transplant care means 30-40 years is not a ridiculous number. I've been told I may not need another kidney until I'm in ripe old age. (This also assumes the patient doesn't have any other health concerns)

I've just read through this read in a little more detail OP and just be careful as there's quite a bit of misinformation. Those who have been through it or have close contact with someone who has are probably best informed.

osbertthesyrianhamster · 04/06/2021 20:37

[quote HavelockVetinari]I forgot to mention - there's an NHS policy to reimburse expenses/financial losses of donors:

<a class="break-all" href="https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=www.england.nhs.uk/wp-content/uploads/2018/08/Policy-Reimbursement-of-Expenses-for-Living-Donors-Updated-August-2018.pdf&ved=2ahUKEwjD9YDp1f7wAhXMOcAKHXTBDds4ChAWMAd6BAgHEAI&usg=AOvVaw2N2ork68ctuajuIXC52QHc" rel="nofollow" target="_blank">www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=www.england.nhs.uk/wp-content/uploads/2018/08/Policy-Reimbursement-of-Expenses-for-Living-Donors-Updated-August-2018.pdf&ved=2ahUKEwjD9YDp1f7wAhXMOcAKHXTBDds4ChAWMAd6BAgHEAI&usg=AOvVaw2N2ork68ctuajuIXC52QHc[/quote]
Completely inadequate to a person in the OP's DP's position. For one, no mention of Universal Credit so completely out of date. Also puts the onus of proving loss of earnings on the claimant, that's hard to do given the DP's insecurity of employment.

And if the DP's health is permanently altered by it, UC it is! Ever seen what it's like for disabled/ill people? It's SHIT. In fact, thousands of disabled and ill people have died since the inception of UC and PIP.

Tbh, his family is shit for pressuring him but making it clear to him they won't help if he's the one who becomes ill. For this reason alone, this is a non-starter and a no go.

NeverDropYourMoonCup · 04/06/2021 20:23

I'd do it for DP, his children or mine. Not that I could due to health stuff, but if I could, even at vastly increased risk, I would.

Everybody else can get fucked if they're getting anything from me - it's not as if they would do the same for my benefit.

Castlepeak · 04/06/2021 20:22

20 years is the old number. It was generated at a time when that was really the longest data available.

My DH is over 25 years in and still going strong.

OutrageousFlavourLikeFreesias · 04/06/2021 20:12

If your main concern is managing family perceptions, then your DH could talk to the donor team and say that he doesn't feel comfortable with the idea. All your BIL will be told is that your DH wasn't a suitable match.

Not donating (or not being tested to see if he might be able to donate) is a 100% legitimate choice for your DH to make. It's his body, his decision. A hundred years ago this wouldn't even have been something he had to consider. Very best of luck whatever he decides.

HavelockVetinari · 04/06/2021 20:07

I forgot to mention - there's an NHS policy to reimburse expenses/financial losses of donors:

<a class="break-all" href="https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=www.england.nhs.uk/wp-content/uploads/2018/08/Policy-Reimbursement-of-Expenses-for-Living-Donors-Updated-August-2018.pdf&ved=2ahUKEwjD9YDp1f7wAhXMOcAKHXTBDds4ChAWMAd6BAgHEAI&usg=AOvVaw2N2ork68ctuajuIXC52QHc" rel="nofollow" target="_blank">www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=www.england.nhs.uk/wp-content/uploads/2018/08/Policy-Reimbursement-of-Expenses-for-Living-Donors-Updated-August-2018.pdf&ved=2ahUKEwjD9YDp1f7wAhXMOcAKHXTBDds4ChAWMAd6BAgHEAI&usg=AOvVaw2N2ork68ctuajuIXC52QHc

NovemberRain2 · 04/06/2021 20:03

I was in a similar situation. My stepsister needed a transplant and I got tested and was a good enough match but then decided I couldn't go through with it as I was the only real provider for my child and if anything went wrong, my child would suffer. I decided my child's wellbeing wasn't any less important than stepsister's kids.

It was hard as she got quite poorly and my stepmum kept hinting at how terrible it would be if something bad happened to SS. Totally understand that no parent wants to lose a child but I did feel some pressure.

Happily stepsister got a donor from the waiting list and is now almost back to full health.

StrawBeretMoose · 04/06/2021 20:01

I know two people who have been living kidney donors, both for their children.
It is absolutely not something to be for lightly. One is a relative and I didn't want my sister to be tested as she had young DC and hadn't really thought of the impact on her own health.
I don't know if I would have done it, probably not if I'm really honest.
My recipient relative died after a few years. For their parent donating had been worth it to have more years with their child, for one of us younger generation I think it would have been harder to take.
Absolutely everything will be donated after my death but I'm not sure about beforehand (I appreciate that the fact it is now hypothetical for me is a luxury some people don't have).

OP it sounds like your partner is not suitable for several reasons. I think counselling to help him work through his feelings might help.

Flawedperfection · 04/06/2021 19:56

Thanks @SandysMam and @kidneynewname- I am grateful for hearing the other side of the story- that of the recipient and the future recipient. It is truly an eye opener to hear your opinions/accounts and to have maybe more empathy than previously. I wish health and happiness to you both.

OP posts:
Gassylady · 04/06/2021 19:49

It’s a really difficult one. If he speaks to the transplant team they may agree he is not suitable (ie he doesn’t want too and is being arm twisted) This can they be relayed to the rest of the family as “just not suitable”

SandysMam · 04/06/2021 19:44

I need a kidney transplant and despite being desperate to survive for my two small kids, I would never want to take one from someone who wasn’t absolutely sure they wanted to. It is not a high risk op or they wouldn’t do it (the health of the donor comes before the recipient) but it is definitely not zero risk and not a minor procedure. That said it is an incredible amazing thing for someone to do for someone else and that might be something your DP could find very fulfilling. The process is so thorough and there is no way he could be coerced into doing it, they would only let him if he really wanted to (and was very healthy). Have a chat with the transplant nurse, she might be able to answer some of the questions you have but no one should ever feel pressured into doing this.

On another note, for any kidney patients we have a rubbish kidneys support thread in general health if you need any mumsnet support on the matter.

kidneynewname · 04/06/2021 19:42

And (in my experience) getting tested without the brother knowing is impossible.

The first thing that will happen is the potential transplant patient is called to see if they know the person and are happy for them to get tested (I know this as I had an old friend ring to get tested on the quiet but my team stated they had to ask me. I didn't want her tested as she is the sort to hold something over you so we came up with a legitimate reason she wasn't eligible)

If your partner is tested, his brother will know.

mollymackandthehat · 04/06/2021 19:41

If he gets tested and can't donate, his conscience is clear.

If he gets tested and can donate, the donation team will give him counselling to make sure he is doing the right thing for him and his brother.

If he doesn't get tested and his brother dies, he might always blame himself.

I would get tested and trust the counselling process to help me reach the right decision.

kidneynewname · 04/06/2021 19:38

Hi OP. I've name changed specifically to comment on this thread.

I received a kidney transplant several years ago from someone very close to me who was tested and a match. There are clearly two sides to this and I'll try and summarise both.

If the brother is at the point of being tested then he must be on dialysis. I was and it's terrible. It only replaces one part of the kidneys functions and the rest are managed as best you can with meds. I can only describe being on dialysis as life standing still for you. Everyone gets on with day to day life but you are beholden to either several full day visits to a hospital each week or hooking up to a machine each night (depending on what type you have)

I say the above as it can totally mess with your view of the world and allow you to create pressure on other people without really realising it. I was soooo careful not to guilt family or friends and very much put on a happy/ brave face through it all so as not to emotionally guilt anyone. But it is hard and at times the facade dropped for me and I had tearful conversations with a family member who was trying to decide whether to donate. In hindsight it must have added so much pressure but emotions run high.

There is also the normal deceased donor waiting list. This is prioritised by need and I have known people wait just a few years to get that gift. Dialysis does damage organs over a long period but it does work for a decent period without doing harm so there is a real possibility that this path may yield results for him.

The testing to donate is rigorous. I cannot stress this enough. You are simply not allowed to donate unless you are considered an absolute specimen of perfect health and your kidney function is well above average. This is then followed up by annual checks on your health. For this reason the one donating does benefit from these annual health checks and in all likelihood any potential problems are caught early

With the above being said, recovery is slow for those donating. It is completely normal as others have said, for the one who receives the kidney to bounce back more quickly. Think of it this way: one person has a full tank of petrol and the other is running on fumes. When half a tank is transferred to the one on fumes, it's like a shot of adrenaline! But the one losing half a tank has to get used to it and although they will get back to full strength, the period of adjustment can be a couple of months.

Also keep in mind that the one donating will likely be done via keyhole surgery unless good reason not to. So the recovery is less from the surgery and more from the body adjusting. My doner ran a marathon a year after donating and luckily is in fantastic health: but that doesn't diminish the risk she took.

Lastly, from a transplant patients perspective, It is the most wonderful gift that I will never be able to put into words. It has changed my life, given me a family, allowed me to walk the dog and do umpteen other things I could only dream of. And dreaming was what I did a lot of on dialysis. So I would urge your partner to think carefully and only get tested if he is sure he will go through with it (if he is in good health to). I had a family member unsure and be tested to then pull out. It was gut wrenching and as they test one person at a time, took up precious time that could have been spent on someone else. I bear no ill will but at the time, it was like the rug was pulled.

I hope the above was helpful and please don't let your partner be guilted as it is not something undertaken lightly.

HavelockVetinari · 04/06/2021 19:33

It's also worth pointing out that there are paired donation schemes out there, whereby his DW can give her kidney to someone in return for her DH getting one from another person related to the recipient.

www.odt.nhs.uk/living-donation/uk-living-kidney-sharing-scheme/