Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is why people’s ideas of portion sizes is messed up.

411 replies

Meruem · 03/06/2021 20:30

Watch any diet/healthy eating show and they talk a lot about portion size. I had an M&S butter chicken curry tonight. It costs £4 and comes in what people would commonly believe is a single potion size. I do actually only eat half at a time, mainly because I have it with naan bread, but can easily see why someone would eat one on its own. Yet look on the back and it says, in small print, “portions 2”.

DS has been eating a lot of tinned soup lately rather than more calorific lunches as he is trying to lose weight. But again look on the back and 1 tin is apparently 2 portions. So why don’t they sell it in half tin sizes? You get half tins of beans, spaghetti etc so why not soup.

Many, many other foods are sold in portions of 2, sometimes even 3 or 4. But it’s not clear unless you go looking for it.

If we want to tackle the obesity crisis then why doesn’t it say in big letters on the front “x amount of portions” rather than bury it in small print on the back? Yes you could argue that people should look and inform themselves but realistically, until a person is already overweight, most won’t bother.

While I don’t disagree that people need to take personal responsibility I do think that the way things are packaged and sold has had an influence and that highlighting to people what a single portion is could go some way to making a difference.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
Grellbunt · 04/06/2021 13:02

You can't fill up with junk tho

It is designed that way

It's deeply unsatisfying, so you keep eating chasing that feeling of satiety, but it never comes

SimonJT · 04/06/2021 12:56

@Bluedeblue

DH has gained 2 stone, or more, and suggested using Hello Fresh as his son is using that for portion control

Hello Fresh portion sizes are massive. I was really shocked. And I say that as an over weight over eater.

None of the hello fresh meals are particularly high calorie, we buy the meals for four as the meals for three aren’t enough for me, my husband and my son. None of us are fat, or overweight.
PattyPan · 04/06/2021 12:53

@ChangePart1

I don’t think it matters tbh.

Anyone who is watching what they eat or wanting to lose weight will be paying attention to the label and calorie content.

Everyone else will just eat to satiety and decide how much of it they want and will fill them up.

This is the problem though - it’s well known that a lot of processed foods are very calorie dense but not that filling so they trick your body’s satiety mechanisms into over-eating. This can then cause weight gain which might be slow enough for people to not really notice enough to watch what they eat, but it will add up over time, or could cause visceral fat that you can’t see. Think about even something quite innocuous like coconut oil vs a coconut. You’re not going to get fat eating coconuts, it’s way too much chewing. But it’s so easy to add lots of extra calories with coconut oil that does nothing to fill you up.
ILoveShula · 04/06/2021 12:43

@MistySkiesAfterRain

If you look at the fat and calorie content of some of the ready meals - incl. charlie bigham in waitrose and other higher end brands - its shocking. Healthier options is what we need.
There are healthier options. Cook something quick and healthy not a ready meal.
PurpleDaisies · 04/06/2021 12:38

I’ve eaten both portions of a bachelors pasta n sauce. I feel a bit dirty now.

3Britnee · 04/06/2021 12:33

😂

I'm making soup today now because of this thread.

ChangePart1 · 04/06/2021 12:33

I don’t think it matters tbh.

Anyone who is watching what they eat or wanting to lose weight will be paying attention to the label and calorie content.

Everyone else will just eat to satiety and decide how much of it they want and will fill them up.

PurpleDaisies · 04/06/2021 12:29

@Bluedeblue

DH has gained 2 stone, or more, and suggested using Hello Fresh as his son is using that for portion control

Hello Fresh portion sizes are massive. I was really shocked. And I say that as an over weight over eater.

The calories are stated on the recipe though. We had a curry with rice the other night that was massive but 650 calories. Perfectly fine.
PattyPan · 04/06/2021 12:29

Interesting thread OP. I like to buy Amy’s soups (in the free from section) and they are a normal sized tin but say on them that they are one portion. I think for other soups it is to do with the salt content rather than calories. DP is underweight and his favourite soup is scotch broth - I had to ban him from having it as his lunch for a while as it’s only about 160 cal for the whole tin but it’s 40% of your daily salt. Seeing that on the traffic lights would probably put people off.
In terms of curry ready meals I think the rule of thumb is that the ones that come with rice are aimed at one person and the ones that don’t are aimed at two.
I am trying to lose weight and DP is trying to gain which makes cooking challenging. Like a PP I bought the cheapo white plates from Ikea as they are smaller and use those for me and bigger, rimless plates for DP to make it easier to differentiate the portion sizes.

cherrybonbons · 04/06/2021 12:11

If you want to lose weight don't look at portion recommendations- look at the calories. It's literally there for you to see. I will eat a whole tub of soup recommended for 2 people because the calories work for me....

SchrodingersImmigrant · 04/06/2021 12:10

@MasterBeth

Soup is not “very filling”. That is all.
Tinned one? Agreed. My own? Full meal.

I like big soups and I cannot lie... 😁

Bluedeblue · 04/06/2021 12:08

DH has gained 2 stone, or more, and suggested using Hello Fresh as his son is using that for portion control

Hello Fresh portion sizes are massive. I was really shocked. And I say that as an over weight over eater.

MasterBeth · 04/06/2021 12:06

@TheWomanTheyCallJayne

I wonder if seeing food as a treat is an inherited left over from rationing. 1954 may feel like a long time ago but for learned behaviours it’s only a couple of generations which isn’t much. And it would have been a post rationing habit as well to start with.
I think rationing, or maybe the aftermath of rationing, has indeed fucked up the food thoughts of half of Britain. My parents’ view of food is very affected by their wartime experiences and I think that’s fed (pardon the pun) into my attitudes to finishing what’s on my plate, however hungry I am.

Still unlearning in my 50s!

osbertthesyrianhamster · 04/06/2021 12:05

@MasterBeth

Soup is not “very filling”. That is all.
This is MN! You have only to look at the tin of soup to be 'full for hours'.

My son takes a medication that is an appetite stimulant as well (he lost about 2st he didn't need to lose after my father died) and so threads like this make me laugh.

MasterBeth · 04/06/2021 12:03

Soup is not “very filling”. That is all.

Dixiechickonhols · 04/06/2021 11:59

This is a serves 2 m & s curry. This is all of it 2 portions. I was hungry and ate it all as it was only 500 calories and I had it with cauliflower rice not rice. But not a huge portion, most people would think it was serves 1 and eat a full pack. (And yes I usually cook from scratch but I’m only one who eats lamb - it was lovely)

To think this is why people’s ideas of portion sizes is messed up.
To think this is why people’s ideas of portion sizes is messed up.
Dixiechickonhols · 04/06/2021 11:53

Mumsnetters who comment on threads like this are not typical of general population. 65% of women 40-60 and 75% of men are overweight or obese.
I’m near top end of healthy bmi wearing a size 10 dress today.
We as a population have definitely lost sight of what a healthy portion size is.

IntermittentParps · 04/06/2021 11:03

a tin of soup entirely to themselves
entirely. Imagine!
Half a tin of soup is no good to man nor beast. The whole tin, and you need bread.

Ready meals that say 'serves 2' get roundly laughed at in my house. They serve one and then you need to add fresh veg as well (well, I do).

I'm a size 8 and 5' 10" before anyone says I must be huge.

3Britnee · 04/06/2021 11:01

@Graphista I have tonight deleted this app having tried to use it and discovered it's useless because it is completely inaccurate. The majority of the data is from users who are apparently clueless to how to accurately work things out. I was checking an items and checked with the manufacturer info and the mfp results varied wildly and at least one entry was hundreds of cals out. Shouldn't be allowed, false advertising As someone who lives alone it is incredibly irritating that so many products come in sizes of 2/3/4 portions and supposedly can't be stored to use later (I'm learning this isn't always accurate either) It's all to make money of course

You click on the entry and edit it and it gives the real values.

Samsung health's food log is better though, imo.

3Britnee · 04/06/2021 10:55

@MouseholeCat

I'd actively worry about somebody having half a can of soup given that it's usually max 300 kcal a can and that's a pretty measly and rather depressing meal.
The only time I've ever had half a can, (as an adult, I'm sure my mum dished out child portions when I was little) was when DH and I wanted a small snack before a big meal later. We had half each with a slice of toast. We'd never have that alone as a meal though, possibly a lunch if having something else as well.
DoingItMyself · 04/06/2021 10:44

That butter chicken is nice.

I think all food should be sold in single portions. It would make life easier, less wasted food etc. More packaging but every silver lining has a cloud. Discount for people buying two or more of the same for family meals.

TheWomanTheyCallJayne · 04/06/2021 10:36

I wonder if seeing food as a treat is an inherited left over from rationing. 1954 may feel like a long time ago but for learned behaviours it’s only a couple of generations which isn’t much. And it would have been a post rationing habit as well to start with.

shivawn · 04/06/2021 10:33

I probably would have eaten the entire curry by myself and not cared that it was 2 portions. I've been a size 8 since puberty though and never worried about my weight. People just need to adjust what they eat depending on their own bodies.

ILoveShula · 04/06/2021 10:23

With the one pack looking like a single portion but described as 2 portions, chances are you will just glance at the nutritional info and think it healthy or low calorie.

I'm not that bothered and generally don't feel guilty but it is misleading, and when I first noticed I felt cheated.

Gingerwhinger01 · 04/06/2021 09:22

This thread is interesting didn’t know that the portion sizes on processed food were about manipulating the fat, sugar etc content.
I’ve never been overly interested in food restriction, or dieting. I’m not over weight, or bragging about under eating either.
But have felt greedy when I’ve eaten processed food that was labelled suitable for two all to myself . Talk about sending out confusing messages and shaming people that may already feel shame around food.

Swipe left for the next trending thread