Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is why people’s ideas of portion sizes is messed up.

411 replies

Meruem · 03/06/2021 20:30

Watch any diet/healthy eating show and they talk a lot about portion size. I had an M&S butter chicken curry tonight. It costs £4 and comes in what people would commonly believe is a single potion size. I do actually only eat half at a time, mainly because I have it with naan bread, but can easily see why someone would eat one on its own. Yet look on the back and it says, in small print, “portions 2”.

DS has been eating a lot of tinned soup lately rather than more calorific lunches as he is trying to lose weight. But again look on the back and 1 tin is apparently 2 portions. So why don’t they sell it in half tin sizes? You get half tins of beans, spaghetti etc so why not soup.

Many, many other foods are sold in portions of 2, sometimes even 3 or 4. But it’s not clear unless you go looking for it.

If we want to tackle the obesity crisis then why doesn’t it say in big letters on the front “x amount of portions” rather than bury it in small print on the back? Yes you could argue that people should look and inform themselves but realistically, until a person is already overweight, most won’t bother.

While I don’t disagree that people need to take personal responsibility I do think that the way things are packaged and sold has had an influence and that highlighting to people what a single portion is could go some way to making a difference.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
lceniWarrior · 05/06/2021 07:24

As an aside, has anyone ever been able to recreate a homemade tomato soup that is better than Heinz? All my other soups are better than shop bought, but homemade tomato soup taste crap.

3Britnee · 05/06/2021 07:00

Even slimming world do it. I bought their tomato soup, assuming the 37 or whatever calories on it were for the whole pot, they weren't, they were per 100g. Who would really measure out 100g or 200g of soup? I think packs should be listed with per 100g and per entire pack, some are, but a lot don't.

CorianderBee · 05/06/2021 00:11

Wait you butter naan bread? 😂😂WTF

CorianderBee · 05/06/2021 00:09

Portion sizes are marketing nonsense not health recommendations. They make them smaller so the calories look lower. Tons of soup are usually under 300 cal. A normal meal. Don't get caught up in it,

Arbadacarba · 04/06/2021 23:40

I've attached a photo demonstrating the most ridiculous example of this I've seen so far. The cake in the photo was sold as serving 6 people and as you can see it is smaller than my hand - and no, I don't have freakishly large hands. They are in proportion to my size 3 feet!!

My husband and I always laugh at those cakes. I'm a fattie but my husband is a teeny-tiny - 7.5 stone at 5'8 - even he, the world's slowest eater, can eat half of those cakes in one sitting.

Ddot · 04/06/2021 23:39

Suck on a damp cloth, bowl of gravel at t weekend and be glad of it

3Britnee · 04/06/2021 23:28

Don't forget Campbell's condensed.
That makes twice as much.
You'd be pretty greedy to eat a whole one of those made up double.

But maybe that's what a pp's mother used to feed 4.

PattyPan · 04/06/2021 22:54

The closest I’ve seen to half tins of soup is the weight watchers ones which are a bit smaller but they’re not the size/shape of half baked bean tins

LouLou198 · 04/06/2021 22:52

Can't you get half tins of soup anymore? I used to have them all the time when I was a student!

PattyPan · 04/06/2021 22:50

@Isidore

Nobody wants to be anorexic.

Not sure there. I recovered from anorexia many years ago. I'm now slightly overweight after having a child and not doing enough exercise. I do find myself wishing I could just "not eat, like I used to when I had anorexia" so I could just lose weight quickly. Sometimes I look at images of very skinny women with an almost "hope" that it will trigger some kind of urge to not eat.

But then, you could argue I'm just not mentally recovered despite being physically recovered. I guess that would be a valid argument.

I am the exact same! Former teenage anorexic, recovered and now overweight and the same thought occurs to me at least once a week. We just have to remember that it’s much healthier to be a bit overweight than go down that road again.
SchrodingersImmigrant · 04/06/2021 22:34

@Grellbunt

I wonder how many "portions" the jumbo popcorn bucket at Cineworld is....
If it's anything like large in Showcase... Trillion😂
Grellbunt · 04/06/2021 22:31

I wonder how many "portions" the jumbo popcorn bucket at Cineworld is....

FatCatThinCat · 04/06/2021 22:22

I like hot buttered toast dipped in tomato soup. Proper comfort food. I could easily polish off a whole tin and half a loaf. If tins were smaller I'd just buy 2.

Maireas · 04/06/2021 22:22

@SmidgenofaPigeon

Personally, I’ve taken to using the plates from my Sylvanian Family country house set. I find they give me just the right portion.
😂😂😂
kennycat · 04/06/2021 22:18

@3scape

You can get lids for soup to keep in the fridge if you're not sharing a tin. Shop around for significantly smaller plates, or use ones sold as side plates. Most dinner plates are far too big.
You aren’t supposed to store things in tubs apparently. I do, but it’s not a great thing to do. But yes plates and bowls are now huge which doesn’t help. My mum’s plates are tiny compared to ours. Ironically I’m tiny compared to my mother…🙊
SupremeDreamz · 04/06/2021 21:15

If I get a pizza I always cut it into 4 slices rather than 8, because I think 8 slices of pizza is too much. drum solo

Seriously though @Meruem "portion size" is a bit misleading. Most of the supermarket ready meals contain loads of salt, partially to increase the shelf life and then lots of sugar to make them taste good. So that's why people are surprised when they buy something like a lasagna from M&S and see it's intended to provide more portions than they thought.

People are missing the point about the tin / half tin of soup argument.

It's not the calories in the other half of the tin that the traffic lights thing is flagging up as bad...it's the salt and sugar content.

Being healthy and a healthy weight is not synonymous with small portions. You can be unhealthy on small portions of bad food and healthy on massive plates of good food.

TheVolturi · 04/06/2021 21:01

Half a tin of soup is not even worth having, unless you have a load of bread too, and then you're better just having the full tin of soup with no bread!

WisconsinRaw · 04/06/2021 20:59

Aldi's salted caramel brownie dessert is labelled as being two servings, even though it's the size of a Volvo.

(I took on that challenge and won btw.)

Nocutenamesleft · 04/06/2021 20:26

@Meruem

I’m sorry if you find it crass but it’s genuinely true. She has banged onto me for years about how she’s wishes she could throw up so she could eat what she liked. She badgered my slim daughter by going on about “are you anorexic” with genuine admiration in her voice until I had to firmly tell her to shut up as she was upsetting DD. You may find it crass but it’s been my reality for many years.
I was w size 4 until I hit 35.

Every single day someone asked me if I was anorexic and it’s incredibly upsetting. I wanted to tattoo my forehead with i eat!!! I could polish off 6 ice creams a day without gaining weight. Nothing changed until I got a bit older. Im a size 8 now but that feeling of never being enough never goes away.

Nocutenamesleft · 04/06/2021 20:24

So my kids were really really tiny. Grew up very very short and slim. I had a long discussion with my pead and nurse. Who says they are so used to seeing obese children. That they panic when someone small comes to them. We discussed why that is and she said portion sizes are a real problem. That and the sugar in food. Baked beans for example have some ridiculous amount of sugar. But primarily it’s down to education. Not realising ribena has sugar in it for example and thinking because it’s fruit. People think it’s healthy.

Things like that. We need to bring back cooking lessons. Cooking from scratch. Too many foods are so over processed. Which then emits the feel good feelings in our brain. So we eat more of it. Even when full. Where as our own cooked chicken nuggets for example don’t make us crave so much more of it.

It does work.

aintnothinbutagstring · 04/06/2021 20:14

People are so black and white thinking when it comes to being fat and obesity. Sleep seems to be one of the most important things to staying slim, as I have just found out, lost loads of weight after quitting shift work without adjusting a single bit of my diet, and it was a bloody hard physically demanding job as well.

Grellbunt · 04/06/2021 20:04

@Isidore

Nobody wants to be anorexic.

Not sure there. I recovered from anorexia many years ago. I'm now slightly overweight after having a child and not doing enough exercise. I do find myself wishing I could just "not eat, like I used to when I had anorexia" so I could just lose weight quickly. Sometimes I look at images of very skinny women with an almost "hope" that it will trigger some kind of urge to not eat.

But then, you could argue I'm just not mentally recovered despite being physically recovered. I guess that would be a valid argument.

Sorry to hear that

It isn't easy.

Best wishes

boompah · 04/06/2021 20:04

@RaspberryCoulis

OMG you eat HALF a butter chicken with naan? OMG all those CARBS. If I ate that much, I wouldn't need to eat again until Halloween. A slice of cucumber at breakfast and i'm STUFFED for the day.

Do love a competitive under eating thread.

Cucumber? Humph. Gluttony.

I rinse my mouth with water for breakfast and spit it out and I'm full for the day.

Grellbunt · 04/06/2021 20:03

Whoever is astounded should read the other thread I am on about UPFs and kids etc....in my view there is a widespread belief that kids food should be somehow different from adult food and often inferior. Why? Many and various reasons - that's a whole other discussion!

Happymum12345 · 04/06/2021 20:03

Ready meals are often packed with fat and calories, so the amount you get in one of those compared to a home cooked meal would likely be less. It really does depend on what you’re eating.