Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

In-laws overstaying their welcome

167 replies

Chloe1973 · 01/06/2021 22:50

I live with my husband and two children. My in-laws live abroad and come to visit every year for approximately 3 months. This always causes arguments between my husband and I as he wants them to stay the whole time whilst I need a regular break from them. They are lovely people but I feel that they are judging everything that I do, They don't like to do very much like going out to have fun or taking the kids to the park etc even though they are fairly young. They just sit in the front room everyday watching TV. There has been a history of them having an attitude with me when I've upset their son and unfairly judging me in the past. They are very overprotective over their son and treat him like he is a six year old, Them being in my house drains me and I feel sad and pressured. I really want them to leave. My husband has a brother who never takes them due to the lack of space in their house, I've spoken to my husband but he wants them to stay. He says that he understands how I feel but that he never gets to see his parents. They have friends that they can stay with but they appear to want to stay with us. I feel like I'm possibly being unreasonable but they have been rude to me in the past and their behaviour is often strange like sometimes ignoring me when I speak or when I ask a question they'll answer as if my husband has asked the question by responding to him. I just can't take them anymore. AIBU?

OP posts:
AnnieSnap · 03/06/2021 20:09

I agree with other posters. Three months is way too much. As a one off, maybe it would be tolerable, but it’s completely unreasonable for your husband to expect you to accept this on an annual basis! A good marriage must include compromise on the part of both. Your husband should be taking your feelings seriously and some compromise must be reached. If not, it’s inevitable that you will feel increasingly resentful as the years go back and it will damage your relationship with him. Of course he loves his family, but your feelings should be a priority for him and on this, let’s face it, he is just disregarding them. I agree with the other poster who suggested couples counselling. If you can’t get him to listen to your needs and can’t reach a compromise, it would be a good idea to explore it with an independent party.

Maybe you should show your husband this thread. It might (should) make him think!

Chris08 · 03/06/2021 20:01

I couldn’t do it. This can’t be good for your health, sounds quite stressful.
Seeing as you have always welcomed them I doubt they will make other arrangements. I wouldn’t stand for it but I’m not in your shoes. Sorry I haven’t been any help to you but here’s a hug. 🤗 x

Harls1969 · 03/06/2021 19:38

So glad we have a fairly small house as I struggle with having guests for 3 hours, not a chance would anyone be staying with us for that long. I wish you luck, strength and patience

HideousKinky · 03/06/2021 18:32

Do they contribute to the household by helping out with shopping, cooking, cleaning etc while they are there? I really hope you aren't still doing all of these things with no help from them? If someone stays 3 months in someone else's home, different rules apply compared with coming for a weekend ie you pitch in and do your share

Scarriff · 03/06/2021 18:09

Can we assume it's culturally right for your husband's parents to live with you ? And that you are not from this culture yourself? Here is a suggestion. While they are with you take the opportunity to study volunteer or work outside the home. I'm sure your parents in law would be pleased to organise the children or do some cooking and housekeeping? Could they manage to drive? See their arrival as a wonderful opportunity for you to expand your horizons. It might turn out to be the best thing for all of you.

cherish123 · 03/06/2021 17:50

Difficult. I can see both sides. I think DH needs to do all the hosting and you need to go out as much as you can. What did you do to upset DH? Apologies- I can't see if you've already explained.

Nohomemadecandles · 03/06/2021 17:22

Crikey, I don't see my mother 90 times a year and she lives 20 minutes away!!
Oh you poor thing.

katy1213 · 03/06/2021 00:54

Could you take yourself off for a month in the middle? Anywhere - a friend's - air BnB - hotel - and leave him with the kids and the in-laws? They might not be in such a hurry to visit next year!

Kisskiss · 03/06/2021 00:39

You’re a saint, 3 months is way too long!!!

Zerrin13 · 02/06/2021 22:58

I'm really getting the vibe here that there are cultural differences at play here.
15 years ago my inlaws came to stay. It was supposedly to help with their grandchildren who were only 1 and 2 at the time. My husband, like yours, missed his parents and convinced me that them staying for 3 months would in some way be a good idea. They arrived in February in the midst of one of the worst winters on record. My husband was at work all day. I was alone in the house with 2 people who spoke no English. At the time my knowledge of their language was limited.
They weren't unpleasant in any way but after 4 weeks of their constant presence I could take no more. I told my husband if they didn't go home I was leaving with the chikdren. I was exhausted from it all and crying everyday. They returned home after 5 weeks. In those weeks my fil never lifted a single finger. He was used to having a servant in attendance at all times in mil and it started to annoy the hell out of me. He was in his early 50's at the time and not disabled in any way. His utter idleness was breathtaking. He never once even picked up his dirty dinner plate from the table and put it near the sink to be washed. After he had finished a lovely meal that had obviously been cooked for him he just used to get up from the table and leave his dirty plate there ready for mil or myself to deal with. It was one of many things that I just couldn't stand. It was 15 years ago and it it the first and last time they will be coming to stay. Just to add when they did come we payed for absolutely everything down to the passports, visas and everything when they were here.

Tootingbec · 02/06/2021 21:35

Oh, and he wants them to stay for that length of time because "he never gets to see his parents"

Fuck me - he sees them for 3 MONTHS A YEAR - THAT'S 90 DAYS!!!!!

Tootingbec · 02/06/2021 21:30

No and no and no again!!

I agree with everyone on here that 3 months is not a "visit" - they are living with you for a quarter of the year. That is intolerable and not something that can be resolved with with few nights in a an AirB&B.

Without being over dramatic about it, this would be a deal breaker for me re: my marriage. It is so disrespectful to you to impose this on you and give you no control over that decision.

Jesus - I can barely tolerate my own parents for more than a few days at a time and I have a pretty good relationship with them......

salsmum · 02/06/2021 20:49

My DGS live up north and i down south i have not been to stay for about18 months now and miss them terribly, I have a good relationship with my DIL but I really couldn't impose on them for three whole months and feel that's a very long time for most people to stay how ever much we love our family. ThanksWine

FlyingPandas · 02/06/2021 12:20

I couldn't live like this OP. Three nights is my limit for any visitors, and that includes close university friends whose company I really really enjoy!

No helpful ideas for you I'm afraid but huge amounts of sympathy, you're a better woman than me. I would be insisting that they book an air bnb or pay for a short term let for the duration of their visit if they had to be 3 months in length.

Sexnotgender · 02/06/2021 11:56

Good lord I nearly had a breakdown when my in-laws came to stay for 3 weeks!

You need to sort this out before it ruins your marriage (and life).

Bluntness100 · 02/06/2021 10:46

Oh I feel bad for you, this would friggen drive me insane. You’re in a rock and a hard place though. Other than make plans to be out to get a break, or go stay with friends or your parents at times I’m not sure what else can be done.

SafferUpNorth · 02/06/2021 10:42

Good god, three months!! That's a quarter of every year! Both our sets of parents live abroad (in the country we're from) and as much as we love them and get on very well, about two-three weeks is the limit for a visit - them at ours, or us at theirs.

More than that and everyone begins to get agitated = counterproductive.

Unless they are actively helping with house / life / kids, there is no reason for them to stay that long. Even with my parents/PILs' much shorter visits, here's what we do:

  • Give them jobs - shopping, preparing meals, playing board games with the kids, taking kids to their sports etc. My dad also gets stuck into some light DIY when here (bit of grouting/painting/sealing around hte showers)
  • I don't adjust daily life for them - they need to fit in with our weekday routine. Then we all decide together on some fun weekend day trips / activities
  • Take breaks - leave them with the kids for a weekend and go away for a few nights.
areallthenamesusedup · 02/06/2021 10:16

Blimey. We used to live overseas and had this issue. We organised them mini breaks (which we paid for) within their visits just so we could get a temporary reprieve.

CokeDrinker · 02/06/2021 10:14

You ILs and DH are beyond selfish at this point. I truly would threaten to leave him. I would say 2 weeks or ONE MONTH tops. 3 months is well past taking the piss. Your 'D'H doesn't seem to give a damn about your needs.

This would be an LTB for me. But this site has shown me that many women are too weak to stand up for their rights so I have no doubt you will continue to endure it, be miserable and not do a thing about it, not even say one month tops.

FeedMeSantiago · 02/06/2021 10:13

3 months every year!

The very least your 'D'H should be doing is telling them to make themselves useful and to also do the decent thing and spend plenty of time elsewhere, even if just for regular day trips out to give you a break. If coinciding with school holidays they could take the DC out too and maybe babysit some nights so you and DH can have a night out.

Why can't they stay with you for a few weeks, then stay with BIL for a few weeks, then go and stay in a holiday cottage somewhere else for a week, maybe the lakes or Cornwall for a holiday and then come back and break their stay up with a few nights here and there in other cities for city breaks? Surely 3 months on your sofa watching TV is boring for them?

There's no way I would impose anyone on my DH for 3 months every year.

sillysmiles · 02/06/2021 10:02

@Chloe1973 if your husband works from home, is there a reason why he couldn't visit them in their home occasionally during the year (ignoring pandemic) and work from their home?
And then they shorten their time with you?

SpaceOp · 02/06/2021 09:57

@motheroffcod those are really useful points. Especially the point about the rest of the famiy being harmed. I have made that point re the dc ahead of mil next visit but I like the language you used.

SnoopsCaliforniaRoll · 02/06/2021 09:50

YANBU

You have my absolute sympathies OP. I could not live like this (made worst because I am quite an introvert).

Could I ask whether there's a cultural element here too, which makes it even harder for you and DH to confront or manage the situation? For example, I know that in many Asian and African cultures it is very hard to do anything which is perceived as being disrespectful or against filial duty. It's very tough.

Chloemol · 02/06/2021 09:24

Personally I would say no. One months max, they can spend one month at the other brothers, they can always get a sofa bed in the lounge for them and if he wants to see them longer he can go stay with them, abroad, taking the kids so you get a break, that’s the three months!

Hankunamatata · 02/06/2021 09:23

I'd seriously consider moving to a house with a big enough garden to put a cabin in it for them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread