Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lunchtime supervision

112 replies

KindergartenKop · 26/05/2021 16:02

DS is in Y1. He's a bit of a fussy eater. His school offer 3 lunch options and some days he doesn't like any of them (usually due to them all being potato based. Other than chips, potatoes make him gag).

Today he says he only ate his pudding and put the rest in the bin. I'm a bit concerned that it seems he's not being challenged on this and is allowed to chuck his whole meal. Obviously he might be lying though. It causes problems because he's in a terrible mood after school and any snacks I give him then mean he rejects his dinner later on. Packed lunches are allowed but that makes so much more work for me as he also has a brother who has school dinners. I don't want to pander too much to the fussiness.

Aibu to email school and ask politely whether they could pay a bit more attention to what is being thrown away?

OP posts:
Notaroadrunner · 26/05/2021 16:48

Packed lunches are allowed but that makes so much more work for me

How will it make so much work for you? Make it the night before, leave it in the fridge and he can chuck it in his bag in the morning. It would take all of 5 minutes to make a wrap/sandwich and thrown in a couple of extra bits that you know he will eat.

year5teacher · 26/05/2021 16:47

When I was an LSA the children had to eat 2/3 of the things on their plate and then put their hand up to be dismissed. Realistically though, there were over 100 children and 5 LSAs so things can be missed. They are paying attention; it’s just impossible to see every single child every single time. YWBU to email.

WorraLiberty · 26/05/2021 16:47

Packed lunches are allowed but that makes so much more work for me as he also has a brother who has school dinners.

So much more work?

Seriously? Confused

Mooloolabababy · 26/05/2021 16:44

I am a midday supervisor and it's surprising how many children say to their parents that they don't eat anything at school when they definitely do! In our school the children have to ask us if they can have their pudding, we always ask them to eat some more if they haven't eaten much of their food before we let them have pudding but there are those children who just won't eat more dinner (but will definitely scoff their pudding down!). There's only so much you can do, you can't force them to eat anything and letting them eat pudding after eating no dinner is better than them not eating anything at all. I would contact the school and ask them to keep a food diary, that way they can monitor what he is eating.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 26/05/2021 16:43

My Ds is fussy, but I wouldn’t want the supervisors putting pressure on him to eat things he doesn’t like.

I give him a packed lunch on the days he doesn’t like the food - by year 2 he’s tried everything they offer at least once.

You could also move dinner forward so he doesn’t fill up on snacks?

Beseigedbykillersquirrels · 26/05/2021 16:42

Just send him in with food he will eat. You're asking over-stretched staff to remember he doesn't like potatoes and which day of the week there is only potatoes on offer and then try (and surely fail) to get him to eat food that you know makes him gag. He's your child. It's up to you to try to get him to eat food he doesn't like or to send him in with food he does like. The MDSAs aren't personal nannies for individual children.

bookworm20 · 26/05/2021 16:39

Thinking on it though, the dc ALL had the same lunch. There was no chosing off a menu. Exceptions only to those with food allergies or vegetarian etc. And they all sat at the same time and had to stay at table until the whole table were told they could leave. I think in my friends school they have a menu choice and also can leave whenever they feel like it.

bookworm20 · 26/05/2021 16:36

I think you are reasonable to ask the school and see what they do there. It could be the lunch supervisor could check on him for a few days and try and encourage.

In my dc's school, especially there were not many lunch supervisors (I think 3), but they would encourage all children to at least try everything on their their plate even if they didnt eat all of it.

I don't understand how schools with 3 or 4 supervisors cannot do this with most of the children who look like they are not eating. Surely they dont just stand around watching?

By doing this my dc tried pretty much everything 'because Mrs X told me to" and therefore started eating loads more than I could get them to try at home! think radishes and beetroot for a start. I was well impressed.

They weren't being forced to eat it, just encouraged and told they had to try just a small amount if they were unsure. All the children treated the same and when a few tried, the others followed suit more easily.

I see no reason why lunch supervisors can't help encourage them to try things. My friends dc school was the opposite to mine and dc never encouraged or told to try things, and they were the same attitude in that they can't force the dc to eat/don't have time/too many dc to supervise etc. Yet I've seen it working in my DC school perfectly.
Seems once theres a pattern/routine/understanding by ALL the children that they should try even a tiny bit, it just becomes something they ALL more easily do.

kravestix · 26/05/2021 16:35

@Ragwort

Just make him a packed lunch, it's only on Mumsnet that it seems a huge drama to make a sandwich & chuck a piece of fruit and a biscuit into a box Confused.
This. Fgs, if your kid won't eat school dinners, two choices, make him a packed lunch or he goes hungry.
KindergartenKop · 26/05/2021 16:34

They do offer some things he likes. It's only once a week that it's wall to wall potatoes! Their fussy kids option is a jacket potato, which isn't a great solution for him! At home we give him stuff he likes and bits of stuff he doesn't to try. If we have potatoes then we give him a bit or substitute potato smiles or bread. We don't eat a lot of spuds though, we are more rice lovers.

OP posts:
Ragwort · 26/05/2021 16:30

Just make him a packed lunch, it's only on Mumsnet that it seems a huge drama to make a sandwich & chuck a piece of fruit and a biscuit into a box Confused.

the80sweregreat · 26/05/2021 16:28

I have spent many lunch times trying to get reluctant children to 'eat a bit more for me ' in a primary school.
The minute your back is turned they sneak off. It's hard to supervise every single child. Or they just cry and tell me that ' mum said I dont have to eat it if I don't want to' or tell you they have ' Tummy ache' or some other reason they can't eat it all. I'm sure the staff try their best, but it's so hard and with only an hour to do it all you just can't monitor every one. You would be there all day.
I'm no longer a midday assistant. It's a job that's harder than it looks!
Packed lunches do get eaten a lot better.

Watermelon222 · 26/05/2021 16:28

Oh and I don’t mean only getting up from the table when they’ve eaten everything, just making sure they have enough time to sit and eat if they want to.

I can remember not eating a lot as a child and I don’t believe in forcing anyone to eat things at all if they don’t want to.

CoffeeCakey · 26/05/2021 16:27

Make a packed lunch you know he will eat and then work on the fussiness at home. You can't expect them to make sure he eats, they are supervising loads of kids at once. Its unfair on his teachers and him to let him be hungry all afternoon.

Watermelon222 · 26/05/2021 16:26

How do you manage this at home @KindergartenKop?

Do you only serve chips and never any potatoes in other forms?

I think I’d be working on trying to encourage him trying a wider selection of food at home and sending in packed lunch on days when there are limited things he will eat for now. They must have pasta or spaghetti or rice on some days surely?

When I went in to help with school dinners once I was shocked by the wastage though, so I understand your concerns as I hate any food waste too. I would like to see the younger kids eating together, having a bit more time and only getting up from the table when they have all finished as I felt some of them just wanted to go out and play and couldn’t be bothered eating.

SummaLuvin · 26/05/2021 16:25

I was someone who didn't want to eat my lunch at school, packed or school dinners, and no amount of coaxing/gentle bullying/telling off from the staff made any difference. They did check on if kids were eating their lunch, as I was a known problem I could never sneak to the bin without one of them checking. There were countless dinner times I spent the whole break in the lunch hall as they told me if I wasn't going to eat I wasn't allowed to go out to play, even that didn't make a difference.

TeenMinusTests · 26/05/2021 16:22

I'd go through the menu and agree which days each week he can have packed lunches, max 2 per week (or 1).

FelicityPike · 26/05/2021 16:21

If he’s gagging on his food send the poor wee soul a packed lunch with stuff he actually likes!
I can’t believe you’d rather him go hungry or put the responsibility onto someone else than make him a sandwich and a snack to take to school!

rainyskylight · 26/05/2021 16:21

Throughout primary school I hated school lunches and used to wait until the dinner ladies were all occupied to go up and quickly scrape my plate and leave the hall. I’d happily wait quite a while for that moment rather than have to eat another mouthful of horrid food. They can’t supervise the kids all the time.

ShoutingBirb · 26/05/2021 16:21

Anyone remember the scary dinner ladies in the old days? Ours had a hammer that she would whack a bell with if there was too much noise, and she would patrol the room like a lieutenant.

TwoAndAnOnion · 26/05/2021 16:19

I'm a bit concerned that it seems he's not being challenged on this and is allowed to chuck his whole meal.

My childrens school had a policy of not making an issue on foods - several reasons, a midday supervisor cannot possibly cajole 20 children at once/parents don't like their child force-fed/parents do want their child force fed/disordered eating patterns. But primarily, time constraints

MadeOfStarStuff · 26/05/2021 16:17

YABU

They can’t force him to eat it and they’re not going to make him eat something he gags on

Just send a packed lunch so you know he had food he’ll eat!

Howshouldibehave · 26/05/2021 16:17

I feel like he could be told to eat a bit of ie

Schools can encourage, they can’t tell children to eat.

Hensintheskirting · 26/05/2021 16:17

I used to work as a mid day meals supervisor. In my experience there is a huge amount of waste involved in school lunches. Loads of kids barely touch the meals provided. There are only so many times you can say "come on Dave, just eat a few peas, just for me, just try...?". If they're not going to eat it then they're not going to eat it. Long gone are the days when dinner ladies would scare you into clearing your plate!

He probably does have to show his plate before he scrapes it off, but if the staff have told him 3 times to try to eat a little bit more and lunchtime is over, what can they do?

DysmalRadius · 26/05/2021 16:16

What would you like them to do? I think going in with a suggestion is much more likely to get results, but it has to be realistic.

Swipe left for the next trending thread