Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lunchtime supervision

112 replies

KindergartenKop · 26/05/2021 16:02

DS is in Y1. He's a bit of a fussy eater. His school offer 3 lunch options and some days he doesn't like any of them (usually due to them all being potato based. Other than chips, potatoes make him gag).

Today he says he only ate his pudding and put the rest in the bin. I'm a bit concerned that it seems he's not being challenged on this and is allowed to chuck his whole meal. Obviously he might be lying though. It causes problems because he's in a terrible mood after school and any snacks I give him then mean he rejects his dinner later on. Packed lunches are allowed but that makes so much more work for me as he also has a brother who has school dinners. I don't want to pander too much to the fussiness.

Aibu to email school and ask politely whether they could pay a bit more attention to what is being thrown away?

OP posts:
Purplespup16 · 26/05/2021 20:00

I’m a MDSA, of course we ask children to eat more if it’s obvious that they haven’t eaten much or anything at all! Children have 30 minutes to eat (followed by 30 minutes of play) if it comes to 5 minutes left then children are asked to eat their pudding regardless of how much of the actual lunch they have eaten. Children in our school have to ask if they can have their pudding so we do see how much they have or haven’t eaten. We have children who will literally sit for the entire 25 minutes waiting to be told to eat their pudding!! No amount of just try it, eat 1 potato, eat this fork full will get a child who has decided not to eat their lunch to eat it! When we notice a child has eaten much or not at all that info is passed to the teacher or TA collecting them after lunch. If you are worried about how much he eats then send him with a packed lunch!!

LostSocksBrigade · 26/05/2021 19:58

Speaking as someone who has done this job yabu.
They will definitely be encouraging him to eat.
Its not like they're loading his plate up with potatoes, there will be other things accompanying them. So realistically he's missing a scoop of mash or a few roasties out of a whole meal.
Or, as I suspect, he also won't eat the veg and the main. Its their job, do you really think they're not doing that and a million other things? All you'll do by emailing them is make your child upset because they will then have to have him stay in until he actually eats the food.
I think you just need to get more creative at home and send a packed lunch to school. I understand what you're saying, but you're wrong to assume they're not doing their job based on the story of a small child.

RedHelenB · 26/05/2021 19:56

Yabu because the solution lies with you providing a packed lunch with food you know he will eat

the80sweregreat · 26/05/2021 19:53

It's a difficult job being a ' dinner lady or man or a supervisor. I found it tough and my colleagues who still do that job said it's even harder since they came back from the last lockdown as well.
The worst are the ones that cry over their dinner. Sometimes a teacher will sit with them to eat , but generally it's the poor midday person who is trying to encourage them to eat whilst dealing with all the other problems that magically occur. It is exhausting and if only schools allowed the parents to come in a few times to see how it works , then maybe the parents might appreciate how hard it can be to get them to behave and eat and also have some time to play outside as well as well as cleaning and tidying up their mess.
All under a strict time constraint to clear the halls for PE etc.
Plus the children are not always well behaved either.
You really earn your pittance.

CauliflowerCheese30 · 26/05/2021 19:46

We are in a hall luckily, it took one reception child an hour to eat her packed lunch the other day, she missed her outside play, and that was with us trying to get her to finish quicker so she wouldn't miss it Grin

bluechameleon · 26/05/2021 19:44

I'd be more angry if the lunchtime supervisors were making my child eat something he didn't want or like.

TotorosCatBus · 26/05/2021 19:43

The ration of kids to adult is really high. It would be easy to miss a child who scrapes a full plate when the adult is busy helping with other stuff. Are packed lunches an option?

babybythesea · 26/05/2021 19:43

Also work in a school. We are a very small school - we don’t have a serving hatch or similar so the kids sit down and we serve them their food, and then clear away. Which means we can easily check. We can also ask them to eat a bit more before we remove their plate. But we are also on a massive time constraint - we don’t have a hall so a classroom doubles as a dining room. We have two sittings of half an hour each. We cannot run over at all, because that then impacts on the children coming back into school for afternoon lessons. So if a child refuses to eat, then we have a maximum of half an hour before we have to give up and send them out. That doesn’t take into account time to get them sitting down and serve all the food... it’s a massive rush. We do our best but there’s a limit to how much cajoling we can do. Although I did find myself scraping sauce off meatballs the other day, so the little lad in question did actually get some food inside him!

TotorosCatBus · 26/05/2021 19:42

I think that parents are more likely to complain about a MDS who coaxes kids to eat.

As your son is prone to gagging I don't think that MDS should be coaxing him just in case he gags and pukes or gags and the children near him react.

CauliflowerCheese30 · 26/05/2021 19:37

@KindergartenKop

I love how this has turned into me expecting the staff to force feed my child in the manner of a suffragette or similar. I was just wondering if it was reasonable to expect the supervisors to check what the kids are leaving on their plate and maybe prompt them to eat a bit more. I never suggested they force him to eat anything! Obviously you all seem to think they don't have time for this, which is fine. I will take that on board.
We do do this, we try and encourage them to eat a bit more, I even section off a bit and tell them to eat that bit, some do it, some don't, by the time I've done that I've got more children who want their yoghurts opening, or need the toilet, or want to tell me someone is misbehaving, and then we have to clean up, I'm only there 2 hours, but I'm shattered by the time I get home.
KindergartenKop · 26/05/2021 19:30

I love how this has turned into me expecting the staff to force feed my child in the manner of a suffragette or similar. I was just wondering if it was reasonable to expect the supervisors to check what the kids are leaving on their plate and maybe prompt them to eat a bit more. I never suggested they force him to eat anything!
Obviously you all seem to think they don't have time for this, which is fine. I will take that on board.

OP posts:
MorganKitten · 26/05/2021 19:26

They will have several children to supervise, why don’t you give him a packed lunch? If they made him eat and was sick you’d complain. He doesn’t like the food so what do you want them to do?

Morgan12 · 26/05/2021 19:23

I think you should just leave things as they are. It's totally fine if he just misses a meal. Sometimes I can't be arsed to feed my kids either.

TheUndoingProject · 26/05/2021 19:14

Expecting the school to force feed your kid because you can’t be bothered to make a packed lunch is ridiculous. Do you not think this will create “so much more work” for the school?

Tinkywinkydinkydoo · 26/05/2021 19:12

Just make him a packed lunch, if you find him hard work because he hasn’t eaten imagine how his teachers find him because his mum can’t be messed to make him a packed lunch and she knows he doesn’t like the dinners , you’d have been pulled up about this at my school not the poor dinner ladies who has numerous other children to look and clean after

LostInTheColonies · 26/05/2021 19:03

@ShoutingBirb

Anyone remember the scary dinner ladies in the old days? Ours had a hammer that she would whack a bell with if there was too much noise, and she would patrol the room like a lieutenant.
Yes!! Starting with the dishing-up; if you said no to any item, they'd check in a notebook to see if your parent had given permission for you to skip whatever it was. Nothing to be left on your plate, either - I remember kids trying to hide food under their cutlery 😂 They'd stalk between the tables making sure cutlery was held correctly (no scooping with forks or knives like pens). Zero tolerance approach to fussy eating.

I still remember the name of the scariest head dinner lady, and of the boy who repeatedly got in trouble for squirting mashed potato through his teeth.

For context, this was not at some kind of hard-line Victorian reform school but a bog-standard infants' school in the mid 1970s 🤣 I still hate boiled tinned tomatoes.

SquashMinusIsShit · 26/05/2021 18:57

DD doesn't like a lot of her school dinners so on those days she has a packed lunch... a ham or cheese wrap, some fruit (banana/few blackberries etc) and a biscuit.

Literally takes me 5 mins including washing the tubs from the day behind

Veryverycalmnow · 26/05/2021 18:52

My DS gags on potato too- it's strange- he does it whether mashed or roasted or whatever. He even struggles with chips a bit.
I'd be pleased he's not being nagged by the lunchtime organisers/ midday supervisors.

CoffeeCakey · 26/05/2021 18:49

Packed lunches are allowed but that makes so much more work for me

Does he like cheese? You can get that presliced to make it even easier. Then it's just butter two slices of bread and whack a slice of cheese in and put it in clingfilm. And an apple and maybe some carrot sticks and you're done. Once you get going with it lunches can get a bit more adventurous but if you're finding it daunting just keep it really simple.

audweb · 26/05/2021 18:48

Just make a packed lunch. I used to think it was a lot of work but it’s not really. My fussy 8 year old has also started taking in a thermos with noodles or soup, and she often just has wraps/meat/other snacks. Some days she will pick a school dinner but it’s really not hard to throw something together.

Plumbear2 · 26/05/2021 18:45

Making a packed lunch is not lots of work. I've been making them for years for my kids and it takes 5 minutes from scratch for multiple kids. My year 8 makes his own in less than 5.

kowari · 26/05/2021 18:45

Packed lunch on potato day?
Do you only serve chips and never any potatoes in other forms?
I don't serve potatoes as we don't like potatoes. We eat sweet potatoes, and rice, quinoa, couscous, pasta... just not potatoes.

purplecorkheart · 26/05/2021 18:45

You do know that the school staff are not there to solve the inconvenience for you to be being your child's parent. I am sorry normally I would consider this a vile comment but some of your responses to this thread make me sad. You will consider making a packed lunch for your child a inconvenience????? Unless there are financial restrictions or accessible issues to food that your child will not eat in a packed lunch then sorry but u need to step up. I am not uk but can you access info on the school meals in advance (you may need to contact the school)and work out the days that a packed lunch will be be needed.

Howshouldibehave · 26/05/2021 18:43

whether they could pay a bit more attention to what is being thrown away?

Or you could just pay more attention to your child’s lunchbox and give them food you know they like and will eat and the problem will be solved.

CauliflowerCheese30 · 26/05/2021 18:39

I'm a lunchtime supervisor, I try to encourage them to eat something, but I'm not going to force them to eat, normally it's because they've chosen something they don't end up liking, so I say not to choose it next time, I'm also a parent of a year 2 child, and I know she will not eat most of the stuff on the menu so I do her a packed lunch.

Swipe left for the next trending thread