Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that muted pastel baby toys that cost about X5 the price of the average are a waste of money and a bit pretentious?

209 replies

FreesiaFairy · 26/05/2021 03:45

Have noticed that some mums seem to only tolerate muted pastel baby toys from brands such as Little Dutch or Liewood, that usually cost about X5 the price of the average for that toy, is this a first time mum thing?

I like to think I have good taste and appreciate good quality, but it's starting to annoy me how snobby some people are about kids toys, surely at some point they are going to have to break free of the muted pastel colour palette? I think Instagram might have quite a lot to do with it.

I get most of my little ones toys second hand and as long as he finds it fun don't massively care what it looks like. I feel like I'm getting judged on my taste for this!

OP posts:
Newpuppymummy · 26/05/2021 08:32

I think it’s both hilarious and a bit sad they feel the need to put on such a show. It’s like those neutral coloured dummies that cost about a tenner.

BlusteryLake · 26/05/2021 08:28

I always bought the very toys you hate OP when mine were small. It was because I preferred them. Can't say I ever judged anyone else for their own choices though. That said, there did seem to be a definite cohort of parents seeking validation for their choice in buying these toys, I was never sure why!

TheKeatingFive · 26/05/2021 08:24

Good quality plastic is a very strong material that lasts for donkeys years. My children are still playing with lots of 30 year old plastic toys from DH & my childhood. Ambi toys that look identical to the ones sold now, a lovely Tomy train set, lego, playmobil, polydron etc.

Absolutely this. I really wonder what people are talking about sometimes, good quality plastic toys are indestructible. Much of our duplo collection is 30+ years old and as good as new.

Plastic is a far more suitable material for kids toys in many ways.

That rainbow is so obviously aimed at pleasing the parents, not the kids.

That f*king rainbow Grin

Anyway, let the insta crew spend their money. Most kids love bright colours and I’m not precious about filling my house with them.

PegPeople · 26/05/2021 08:23

@Donitta

It’s because kids toys are hideous and people don’t want their homes ruined by having brightly coloured rubbish lying around. I forked out for a monochrome ball pit because it’s on display all the time, and a monochrome baby walker. Everything else gets hidden in storage boxes unless it’s actively being played with. I don’t know why manufacturers can’t just make kids toys in bearable colours!
Errrm because the toys are for the children and they prefer bright colours? It really is that simple.

No child is going to choose muted pastles over bright bold colours and people are kidding themselves of they think a toddler wouldn't choose the noisy all singing all dancing plastic monstrosity over a pastle rainbow.

NerrSnerr · 26/05/2021 08:22

secondly plastic toys break easily and let's be honest are essentially disposable,

Some of the plastic stuff we have had is the stuff that lasts years. The fisher price Walker (the one that says 'hello puppy calling') we got third hand and went off to a new family last year. We got all our Peppa Pig toys second hand and they went in perfect condition to someone else recently.

My 4 year old's favourite toy at the moment is a Terminator plastic toy he picked up from the charity shop. Date on it says 1991!

cinnabarmoth · 26/05/2021 08:18

Surely we should be buying our kids toys in a wide variety of colours, so we can performatively teach them their colours
"Please can you pass Mummy the scarlet brick? No darling, that one is vermilion." to anyone in earshot "She's known all the colours in the Pantone chart since she was 12 months old"

unicornpower · 26/05/2021 08:13

I know someone like this, unless it looks good on Instagram her children can't have it. I mean her house is incredible and her children are always beautifully dressed but they aren't allowed anything that isn't neutral or wooden. She specifies it around birthdays etc which is a shame as her eldest LOVES bright pink but isn't allowed it :(

Donitta · 26/05/2021 08:13

It’s because kids toys are hideous and people don’t want their homes ruined by having brightly coloured rubbish lying around. I forked out for a monochrome ball pit because it’s on display all the time, and a monochrome baby walker. Everything else gets hidden in storage boxes unless it’s actively being played with. I don’t know why manufacturers can’t just make kids toys in bearable colours!

montysma1 · 26/05/2021 08:01

I actually can't get my head around you caring what anybody thinks of your taste good or bad.

Nohomemadecandles · 26/05/2021 07:57

"I will only tolerate muted pastel wooden toys" Grin

They'll grow out of it.

BeenAsFarAsMercyAndGrand · 26/05/2021 07:51

@AlwaysLatte

I was curious and looked up these toys as my youngest is 10 and I hadn't seen them. This is crazy - a rainbow in non rainbow colours!
That rainbow is so obviously aimed at pleasing the parents, not the kids.

I agree with the ok above about good quality plastic. My nephews play with Lego that their parents played with as children, still in good condition. Buy decent quality strong toys, whether wood or plastic, because it's treating stuff as disposable that is really hammering the environment.

JellyTumble · 26/05/2021 07:48

YABU. You’re projecting and think people are judging you Confused

People like different things. Some prefer pastels and/of wood and are happy to pay more. Why would that mean they think you’re any lesser for choosing bright plastic colours?

They’re not judging you here, you’re judging them.

BeenAsFarAsMercyAndGrand · 26/05/2021 07:46

YANBU, muted pastels are shit for kid toys. Much prefer bright colours.

flippertygibbit · 26/05/2021 07:44

So it's ok for you to judge pastel toys but not ok for them to judge 2nd hand toys?..............

21Flora · 26/05/2021 07:41

You can buy cheap pastel wooden toys from Primark.

We don’t have any cheap plastic tat because we are conscious about our environmental impact. We don’t have anything that flashes or sings. Why buy a cheap naff swimming pool from Argos that will last a few weeks and be binned.

I do buy good quality second hand this where we can i.e wooden train tracks, blocks. Little Dutch is quite affordable compared to some of the wooden toys available like Grimm!

We do what suits us and our taste as a family, I don’t have Instagram and genuinely couldn’t care less what people think about our choices.

Actuallyabitgreynow · 26/05/2021 07:36

Youre being just as judgy as those you're criticising.

I love pastel coloured children's toys, but also bright colours. I got a lot of stick from friends for having expensive wooden toys for my son - but many of them were second hand and I don't like plastic tat that just breaks. Even now at nearly 5, his favourite toys are the wooden train track and all things Mellisa and Doug and his wooden rainbow. It's generally better quality and therefore better value for money.

Buy your kids the toys you want to buy them, and that they'll enjoy. Don't worry about what others think of you- because you're doing exactly the same to them.

Atalantea · 26/05/2021 07:34

My dc are older now, but we liked wooden where we could, and bright all others.

I blame the beige generation. My female relative does the bland beige clothes and toys, she's all about the Zara home 'vibe'
I despise it

Babynames2 · 26/05/2021 07:34

My SIL is like this. I internally roll my eyes and just buy something for her DD on her birthday/xmas that I know SIL will like (She’s only 1). As she gets older I’ll get things more based on DNs likes. I don’t like the comments and little digs she makes about the toys MIL buys though (her own mother) as they’re usually brightly coloured plastic ones, but the DC all love those sort of toys! And our house is full of that ‘tat’. The plastic baby toys we have are about to be used for the third DC as well, so they’ve lasted very well and will be passed on to others after. They aren’t the same as single use plastic.

MichelleScarn · 26/05/2021 07:32

The greige always reminds me of Kansas before Dorothy goes to Oz! The wooden toys may be more pleasing visually to the eye, but are a lot more painful when lobbed at you!

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 26/05/2021 07:30

Alwayslatte I was given a toy based on this. My children are perplexed by ths fact that of 6 rainbow pieces, 3 are shades of grey. It doesnt get their attention often as it doesnt stand out in the toy box.

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 26/05/2021 07:28

Secondly plastic toys break easily and let's be honest are essentially disposable, thusly they often come with god awful flashing lights and faux American accents

Are you buying very poor quality plastic toys?! Good quality plastic is a very strong material that lasts for donkeys years. My children are still playing with lots of 30 year old plastic toys from DH & my childhood. Ambi toys that look identical to the ones sold now, a lovely Tomy train set, lego, playmobil, polydron etc. The colours are barely faded and the only pieces that have broken are a box that were left in a very hot sunny patch in a spare bedroom for several years so went brittle.*

The toys you are considering as "essentially disposable" are the absolute cheapest poor quality rubbish. There are similarly poor quality wooden toys available - we got given some cheap puzzles and knock off brio and they had split within a couple of years.

People get the wrong end of the stick about plastic. Plastic is a highly useful strong, flexible material. What is bad for the environment is single use plastic.

Use of too much wood can be bad for the environment too - deforestation!!

The point should be to use less overall of anything. That means buying things that will last and last and can be used time and time again, whether they are plastic, wood, bamboo, metal etc.

Bamboo in particular is all the range atm for socks and childrens plates etc and its terrible, it doesnt last 5 minutes!!

Minesril · 26/05/2021 07:27

I keep the tasteful wooden toys in the living room. They're quite brightly coloured though.

The plastic tat goes in the playroom!

JocastaNu · 26/05/2021 07:26

I feel sorry for the kids with these insta parents.

AlwaysLatte · 26/05/2021 07:25

I was curious and looked up these toys as my youngest is 10 and I hadn't seen them. This is crazy - a rainbow in non rainbow colours!

To think that muted pastel baby toys that cost about X5 the price of the average are a waste of money and a bit pretentious?
MrsS92 · 26/05/2021 07:25

This year I have been trying not to buy new plastic toys for my girls, but we’ve picked up bits from car boot sales and charity shops that they have liked.
I do tend to put the tacky plastic toys hidden away in the playroom, or in the wicker storage baskets, and trunk in the living room, and “display” the toys that I personally think look nicer, not that it matters though as my girls just pull it all out anyway 😂.