Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that muted pastel baby toys that cost about X5 the price of the average are a waste of money and a bit pretentious?

209 replies

FreesiaFairy · 26/05/2021 03:45

Have noticed that some mums seem to only tolerate muted pastel baby toys from brands such as Little Dutch or Liewood, that usually cost about X5 the price of the average for that toy, is this a first time mum thing?

I like to think I have good taste and appreciate good quality, but it's starting to annoy me how snobby some people are about kids toys, surely at some point they are going to have to break free of the muted pastel colour palette? I think Instagram might have quite a lot to do with it.

I get most of my little ones toys second hand and as long as he finds it fun don't massively care what it looks like. I feel like I'm getting judged on my taste for this!

OP posts:
Ponoka7 · 26/05/2021 10:27

I agree with you on toys being primary colours, that's what appeals to children and they are a teaching aid. However
"I would rather have kids plates and cutlery that can go in the dishwasher rather than over priced bamboo and silicone ones "
They could be chosen because they are buying more environmentally friendly alternatives.

Whinge · 26/05/2021 10:20

Some people prefer pastels. How, in all honesty, does it matter at all to you?

Surely it's about what the child would prefer, not about what colours appeal best to you / your home?

AprilShowerThoughts · 26/05/2021 10:16

When I was expecting my first I was drawn to the muted beige and pastel/wooden stuff but my mum steered me to the colourful noisy plastic stuff saying "that looks fun." It was the first time I really registered that this stuff wasn't for me, it was for my child and I started to think about what they might actually like. As someone else said (noisy) plastic stuff can often be passed on, especially if it's one of the key toys like the jumperoo was or VTech/Fisher Price Activity Toys. Chewed pastel wooden toys less so!

StClairStreet · 26/05/2021 10:14

I think you’re being quite snobby yourself with your slightly sneery ‘is this a first time mum thing’.

Some people prefer pastels. How, in all honesty, does it matter at all to you?

misspattylacosta · 26/05/2021 10:12

I like to think I have good taste and appreciate good quality, but it's starting to annoy me how snobby some people are about kids toys

oh the irony...
Reverse snobbery is just as bad, if not worst

FreesiaFairy · 26/05/2021 10:09

Thank you for your replies, some of them have really made me chuckle particularly @RockPainting and @Sidesaladofchips so thanks for that Grin

Don't get me wrong I also like good quality wooden toys, it seems to be more about the colour palette than plastic VS wooden, although that does come into it. I like having some wooden toys in the mix because at the risk of sounding pretentious in a different way it seems good sensory wise for different textures and they make different sounds when banged etc, they do also look nice. I agree IKEA do some really nicely designed toys for very reasonable prices.

It's more the spending way over the odds on muted tasteful versions of things then being a bit rude about other peoples brightly coloured things that gets me. Seems to be taking it all a bit seriously, since my little one was born I've always thought the thing that looks best to me is a happy baby.

And yes a grey ball pit doesn't sound much fun at all, neither does a rainbow toy all in the same muted colour just different shades haha.

I think some people use these things to express how tasteful they are which is a bit sad tbh, I love art and design and very much appreciate nicely designed things and don't like the feeling I'm getting judged on my taste just because all my little ones stuff isn't bamboo and muted colours.

Think it's probably the age they are at too (12 months), as people have mentioned as they get older they will have their own opinions and will be harder to maintain such strict style guidelines I guess!

OP posts:
NerrSnerr · 26/05/2021 10:06

@21Flora do you have a link to these studies?

PiccalilliChilli · 26/05/2021 10:05

DD is now a teenager but quite a lot of stuff passed to us from family and friends, then was passed on again to other families or went to the charity shop. I admit we had a fair amount of plastic crap, but we tried to freecycle or give away.

As for the pastel aesthetic...when DD was a baby it was all "buy this Scandi-made wooden toy" which were expensive and didn't last long in the sense DD outgrew them so quickly. Good intentions and all that, but friends who bought them, sorry, they were a false economy. Same with "posh" baby clothes...one friend bought her a very expensive cute dress and cardi combo when she was about 6 months old...I think she wore it twice! That went to the charity shop, too good to throw away.

Quite often she was happy banging a saucepan with a spoon or looking at board books. You don't need pricey stuff to entertain your baby.

PegPeople · 26/05/2021 10:03

Studies show that children who have mainly loud and flashing toys have smaller vocabularies, poorer motor skills.

I'd be very interested in seeing these studies. I strongly suspect they will outline other factors such as parental involvement or living in poverty as being responsible for smaller vocabularies or motor skills rather than the toys children play with.

All walkers are detrimental to physical development, whether wooden or plastic so I wouldn’t know.

Of course they are not all detrimental to physical development. Sometimes believe it or not GPs or health visitors actually recommend them.

21Flora · 26/05/2021 09:56

@PegPeople my daughter loves her toys and has fun. She’s not sat in an empty room bored. Studies show that children who have mainly loud and flashing toys have smaller vocabularies, poorer motor skills. Everyone makes personal choices, it just seems mad to call people pretentious for making choices they see to be best for their child’s development and the environment.

All walkers are detrimental to physical development, whether wooden or plastic so I wouldn’t know.

BeHappyAndSmile · 26/05/2021 09:54

[quote 21Flora]@Ilovemaisie nothing I buy only lasts a few weeks. Those cheap blow up ones you see in the shops inevitably get punctured, our neighbours get one of those huge, cheap swimming pool every year that gets chucked away. Don’t try and pretend that the cheap blow up swimming pools are lasting for years and years. They are designed to be disposable.

All of these flashing, singing toys are detrimental to development. The less a toy does the more it benefits children’s development. Sure they attract babies attention but they aren’t better - there are lots of studies that show this.[/quote]
Do you have a source for that? Just saying there are lots of studies is meaningless unless you can show evidence (from peer reviewed papers as there are a lot of "studies" out there that promote the narrative that they want and nothing more)

PegPeople · 26/05/2021 09:39

All of these flashing, singing toys are detrimental to development. The less a toy does the more it benefits children’s development

You do know that sometimes toys can just be fun don't you? They don't all have to have the sole purpose of aiding development.

A plastic walker for example that plays music and makes noises is not inferior or detrimental to development in comparison to a wooden one that doesn't just because it happens to be plastic and light up. It's a very narrow view to think anything colourful, flashing or loud is inferior.

TrickyD · 26/05/2021 09:37

I had not heard of the two brands mentioned by the OP, but I have seen a lot of toys sold by Babipur on my FB page.

I thought these were ridiculously expensive, but at least they are cheerfully painted. The posts by happy customers are amusing. Shots of beautifully arranged wooden toys accompanied often by a photo of the mum in one of the hideous wrap dresses the company also sells.

At least the producers of noisy colourful plastic toys don’t usually try to sell ghastly adults’ dresses.

Minstermouse · 26/05/2021 09:37

Would have thought bright colours more stimulating for little ones?
No doubt someone will let me know Grin

Ilovemaisie · 26/05/2021 09:34

21Flora well I have had Argos pools that have lasted years. They usually even come with a couple of puncture patches so you can mend it if needed. What your neighbours do with their pool is just daft and wasteful. But that's their choice. Personally I would clean, dry and pack away carefully for next year. If you do that then they are fine.

21Flora · 26/05/2021 09:29

@Ilovemaisie nothing I buy only lasts a few weeks. Those cheap blow up ones you see in the shops inevitably get punctured, our neighbours get one of those huge, cheap swimming pool every year that gets chucked away. Don’t try and pretend that the cheap blow up swimming pools are lasting for years and years. They are designed to be disposable.

All of these flashing, singing toys are detrimental to development. The less a toy does the more it benefits children’s development. Sure they attract babies attention but they aren’t better - there are lots of studies that show this.

BeHappyAndSmile · 26/05/2021 09:22

@Donitta

My child has a monochrome room and I don’t see why we should have to live in a pigsty just because we reproduced. Friends talk about how they can’t have nice ornaments because their DC would play with them and break them, and I’m like - Just discipline your child and say no? 🤷‍♀️
I tell my 7 month old no when he's doing something he shouldn't be, I fully agree you should be disciplining children but ornaments are the issue here are they? That's another subject all together. And my house certainly isn't a pigsty, it just has colourful toys that my child loves. They are all over the place during the day and get tidied away when they go to bed 🤷‍♀️ yes some of them are still on show but a child lives here, it's his house too
Whinge · 26/05/2021 09:16

I don’t see why we should have to live in a pigsty just because we reproduced.

Ah yes because there's no middle ground between monochrome and bright plastic fantastic pigsty. 🙄

By all means buy what you want and decorate how you wish, but remember your child isn't you. Their likes and dislikes will be different.

PegPeople · 26/05/2021 09:15

@Donitta

My child has a monochrome room and I don’t see why we should have to live in a pigsty just because we reproduced. Friends talk about how they can’t have nice ornaments because their DC would play with them and break them, and I’m like - Just discipline your child and say no? 🤷‍♀️
Who the duck associates having plastic or brightly coloured toys as living in a pigsty??
TheKeatingFive · 26/05/2021 09:13

Who’s living in a pigsty Confused?

Donitta · 26/05/2021 09:11

My child has a monochrome room and I don’t see why we should have to live in a pigsty just because we reproduced. Friends talk about how they can’t have nice ornaments because their DC would play with them and break them, and I’m like - Just discipline your child and say no? 🤷‍♀️

BeHappyAndSmile · 26/05/2021 09:06

@Donitta

It’s because kids toys are hideous and people don’t want their homes ruined by having brightly coloured rubbish lying around. I forked out for a monochrome ball pit because it’s on display all the time, and a monochrome baby walker. Everything else gets hidden in storage boxes unless it’s actively being played with. I don’t know why manufacturers can’t just make kids toys in bearable colours!
But that's because kids like the brightly coloured "rubbish". I buy what makes my child happy not what makes me happy. They're only little for such a short amount of time who cares if your house has flashing, mismatched, bright toys. A happy, stimulated child is more important than an insta ready house as far as I'm concerned. You do what you feel is right but just because you think something is a bearable colour doesn't mean that's what your child wants.
UpTheJunktion · 26/05/2021 08:42

That’s a lot of judgement about other people’s choices from someone who doesn’t want to be judged.

Abd how do you know they are being ‘snobby’ about your choices? Hmm

Just mind your own business.

Heckythump1 · 26/05/2021 08:35

There's also Grimms and Grapat toys that are not muted, lovely bright colours but £££ and potentially a bit protentious too!

Most kids seems to prefer anything that makes loads of noise and has flashy lights anyway :P

Ilovemaisie · 26/05/2021 08:34

21Flora if a paddling pool from Argos only lasted a few weeks I would return it as not fit for purpose. If you have had ones that only last a few weeks then you aren't looking after it properly.