Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Which school would you pick?

93 replies

redbluechristmas · 25/05/2021 22:07

I'm driving myself slightly mad with this decision.

We are moving to a new area and need to decide on a primary school for DS, who is in year 2. Our options are:

School A - local village school. 10 minute walk. Fairly good reputation, has been a bit mixed in the past but still a relatively popular school. Results very slightly better than average.

School B - school on edge of nearest town. 12 minute journey by car (I have timed it at school run peak!) Excellent reputation. Very good results, well above average.

Both schools feed into the same secondary and are a similar size. I WFH so although it's not ideal logistically to drive to school, I could do it and still be home in time to start work just after 9am.

DS does well at school, quite enthusiastic about learning. Above average but not top of the class. He is fairly resilient but I don't want to get this wrong and have to move him again!

What would you do?

School A - YABU
School B - YANBU

OP posts:
SummerHouse · 26/05/2021 12:09

Go with your gut. We walk past an outstanding primary school with better facilities to get to our school (both are walkable but ours is twice the distance). The school we are at just won my heart when we visited. The nearer school would have probably been great but I have not regretted the decision. Ever. In fact I think it's one of the best decisions we ever made. Academic results were similar and didn't factor in really.

TropicalFairyCake · 26/05/2021 12:01

I think its sometimes hard when they're young thinking about what will suit them when they're at the older end of primary.

Certainly walking to school is a rite of passage here. As well as walking home with friends to play. It also facilitates friendships in our case as we made friends with those we walked with or at least were more familiar with them.

There's also ease for popping in forgotten pe kit and turning up for assemblies and all the other 101.

Being part of your local community is such an amazing thing I hadn't appreciated pre kids but I now love that I know many TAs from other local things, they went to local.clubs and knew half the people, they took part in local pantomime with friends in other school years but its a same shared experience etc.

redbluechristmas · 26/05/2021 12:00

I honestly wish I had never mentioned results! But I'm talking about SATS results.

For the record, we chose DS' current school over another school with better SATS results because we thought it suited him better. I am not making my decision based purely on SATS.

We have viewed both schools. We loved school B and think it would really suit DS. It also has lower turnover, better ofsted, more outside space etc etc. Also better local reputation e.g. when I ask around people have said "oh that's a LOVELY school". School A seemed ok but didn't stand out to us. When I ask around, people say "oh yes, that school is fine. I knew someone whose kids went there and they seemed happy". A couple of people on social media have said they moved their kids out of the school but that can obviously happened anywhere and they're not leaving in droves.

On that basis, is it worth picking school A because it's closer. That should have been my question I guess. My fault for writing a rubbish OP.

OP posts:
SheilaTubman · 26/05/2021 11:50

My yr 6 child loves walking home with his friends. There's a big gang of them and I'm so happy he can do this.

He transferred from a "good" school to an "outstanding" school and I have to say, there were definitely elements of the "good" school I preferred. But we moved.

What results are you talking about at primary? SATS?

YellowFish12 · 26/05/2021 11:29

Village school.

Children’s main determinant of academic success in primary is their parents education levels... the school generally makes fuck all difference to most children’s attainment at primary level.

Pick the village school for an easy life and for local friends and a quick in to the local community.

Dora33 · 26/05/2021 11:25

As you will be new to the village, definitely school A. It will be one of the easiest ways for your child & maybe yourself to make friends in the village. I was always able to walk my children to and from primary school. For the older years in primary school, they walked with their friends
While your child can also make friends in activities outside of school, there is no guarantee they will want to stay doing the activities you put them in.
My children did have friends with the children who had 10mins or more driving to school but the ones the played with most, were their school friends who lived nearby.

UserAtRandom · 26/05/2021 10:38

@Lykia

School B every time it's a no brainer. I always find NM always go with the opposite of logic. As if the majority of people wouldn't send their children to the better school. They'll tell you one thing and do the other. Hmm
My parents sent me to the further-away-perceived-better school. As a result of this, my DC go to the local school.

Not having local friends is a miserable lonely existence through weekends and holidays and badly affected my self esteem and self confidence. It is massively easier to support with academics than it is with things like this. If OP is prepared to do a lot of running around it might be possible to mitigate that, but even then it will mean her children will miss out on the spontaneous playing out which you can do with local children. If OP's DC is sociable she may be able to build local friends through clubs etc. but this is harder - once DC get to the "playing out" age they do play more with school friends. I ran a Brownie pack for many years and I can tell you that there were very few instances of DC making good friends with anyone outside of their school. And I don't think there were any, where the friendship continued outside of Brownies.

And you shouldn't underestimate the physical toll of travelling. OP says it is 12 minutes at peak time, but you then have to factor in actually getting everyone into the car, finding somewhere to park and then walking to school at the other end.

barnanabas · 26/05/2021 09:59

@redbluechristmas Thanks Smile

I think the other thing to say in terms of sleepovers/playdates etc is that it isn't your son who is going to be inconvenienced by his friends living further away in primary school - it's you. And if you're able and willing to put in the effort to ferry him around, you can essentially eliminate any difficulty with living further away at that age (not saying you should, just saying that you could!).
I agree with the posters who have said look beyond Ofsted and results. The primary my kids went to was good when they started, outstanding for a bit, and towards the end of their time their was given 'requires improvement'. It was a lovely school all the way through. But the more you post, the more it sounds as if the 'better results' stuff is a bit of a red herring, and you actually like school B better. So if you're happy to take on the commute that sounds like the best choice for you.

Sweettea1 · 26/05/2021 09:23

My area has 2 schools school A good school outstanding ofsted reports but in 2018 2019 only a handful of children passed there Sat's in year 6. school b an OK school rated good by ofsted had alot more children pass Sat's in year 6. It really does depend on the child an how much they want to learn I choose school b as it is closer but my child is doing great.

TropicalFairyCake · 26/05/2021 09:15

School A. Teachers and those with knowledge of schools dont tend to give too much importance to Ofsted. And Sats are a strange assessment of limited subjects. Really better a child leaves loving learning and having had a broad curriculum than spending all of year 6 (if not ks2) drilling for sats.

Knowing both these things influence a teachers choice strongly. "Results" at secondary is a very different ball game to that at primary.

IdblowJonSnow · 26/05/2021 09:14

Have you visited the schools? I'd also do that and go with your feeling on where your kids will be happiest.

IdblowJonSnow · 26/05/2021 09:13

A. Primary is much more important for making friends. As school A sounds fairly good I'd go for that over B.

roadwarrior · 26/05/2021 09:13

School B, hands down. We live in a village and first few years we sent the kids to the village school. It was like it was being run by the local knitting club. So we moved them to a better school in the nearest town. They have friends in the village and some of them go to the village school and some are in their school in town.

Lykia · 26/05/2021 09:12

School B every time it's a no brainer. I always find NM always go with the opposite of logic. As if the majority of people wouldn't send their children to the better school. They'll tell you one thing and do the other. Hmm

FatCatThinCat · 26/05/2021 09:09

In my experience reputation doesn't mean a thing when it comes to choosing a school as it doesn't reflect heart of the school. I sent my DD to a school that was the best in the area by a long shot and it was a massive mistake. We ended up moving her to an average school after years of unhappiness.

So if I were you I'd go and visit both schools. Meet the headteacher as they set the tone of the school. Go with whichever one feels right. You'll know which one is a better fit for your child. Go with your instincts, not by what others say.

MagicSummer · 26/05/2021 09:07

I'd choose B, particularly as he is showing aptitude. If it's a better school, it will encourage him to stay thirsty for knowledge. He will make friends there too - it's not that faraway. There are more important things than sleepovers and playdates!

redbluechristmas · 26/05/2021 09:06

I've viewed both schools and prefer school B. The results aren't slightly better at school B, they're significantly better.

OP posts:
redbluechristmas · 26/05/2021 09:05

@barnanabas you've summed up the situation better than I have in my OP Smile

I focused on results in my OP to keep things short but what I was trying to say is I do prefer school B in every way and if they were next to each other it would be absolutely no contest, I'd go for school B.

But is it worth going for school A, for proximity and making friends closer to home, as long as it's 'good enough' - which I think it probably is.

OP posts:
UserAtRandom · 26/05/2021 09:03

@JemimaJoy

School A wouldn't even be an option for me and I'm shocked that so many people would choose it over the clearly much better school. IMO if you choose A you'd be choosing convenience over the best option for your DC.
I think that's the problem for me. Nothing in OP's post says B is "clearly much better". Slightly better results are likely linked to intake and reputation is a nebulous being which may or may not bear any resemblance to the actual school.
Peace43 · 26/05/2021 09:03

My kid doesn’t go to the village school because it’s welsh language and she has enough additional needs that this isn’t appropriate. The car journey is a pain in the bum though. She could walk home alone now if she was in the local school.

UserAtRandom · 26/05/2021 09:01

Have you seen the schools in person (I know this might not be allowed at the moment)? I wouldn't set a great deal of store by "better on paper" tbh.

My view is with the majority - always go for the local school unless there is very compelling reasons not to, or very compelling reasons to choose another school. If you have "compelling reasons" I don't think you have articulate them on this thread. That's not to say there aren't any!

Though, if both schools routinely have places, I guess you always have the choice of moving schools if whatever you choose doesn't work out.

BendingSpoons · 26/05/2021 08:55

How big are the schools? I'd be strongly tempted by A as I would hate having to drive to school, but that is mainly due to parking being tricky. However I am a bit wary of some small village schools. DD is in a 3 form entry school and this gives more options in terms of grouping them across the year.

Acupofcamus · 26/05/2021 08:51

I’d always opt for the closer school. You never know whether there’ll be an issue with your car one day that means you just can’t get to the other school and living in a village, I know public transport is basically non existent!

massistar · 26/05/2021 08:49

I'd go school A. I live in a village and I loved being part of all the activities like summer and Christmas fetes and stuff that really made you feel like you were part of the community. Loved the walk to school too.

Our village school was rated excellent though I still think I'd have sent them there if it wasn't quite as good.

barnanabas · 26/05/2021 08:43

My kids are teenagers, and one thing that stood out in your OP is that both schools feed into the same secondary. I think at secondary school, going to your local school is massively beneficial from a social point of view. That's a point in favour of school B if you like that one better.
I think if you feel that school B is better in every way and don't mind driving I would go for that. Personally, I placed a high value on being able to walk to primary school (we had two schools within walking distance and another two a short drive away) and felt the kids and I all benefited from being able to walk, but it's not the be all and end all!