Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be gobsmacked that an interviewee openly told dh that he had looked at our accounts…

989 replies

ChampagneWorries · 24/05/2021 18:40

On companies house?

Dh did an interview today via zoom and the interviewee openly told him that they had looked at our company accounts on companies house to see if we were a healthy company!

Our dividends are on there and I'm really shocked that he basically admitted to being so nosey.

I know they are public information (which i disagree with) but they do show the company income, how much cash was in the bank and our salary etc.

Dh wants to offer him the job as he had some good qualities, but this has really put me off him.

I know people do look at peoples companies on the companies house, but you don't bloody tell them surely?!

Would you still offer him the job?

OP posts:
Theo1756 · 24/05/2021 20:44

I can understand why that may feel like an invasion of privacy but it’s pretty standard to assess The financial health of a company. If applying for a finance or commercial role I would expect it and be interested to hear their opinion.

Merryoldgoat · 24/05/2021 20:44

I wonder if the drip feed is he’s applying for a job as the accountant 🤣

mofro · 24/05/2021 20:43

Good for him doing some DD on future potential employees - great initiative and research skills!

Method · 24/05/2021 20:43

Of course you are unreasonable.

I would check too, then with your directors' details, I would check what your house looks like on Right Move. I'm nosey like that Grin

JBaez · 24/05/2021 20:43

Two way process.
I would expect potential employers to look me up and I would do the same.
Nothing wrong with telling your DH he’s done his research.

MrsFin · 24/05/2021 20:43

As per other comments - i his diligence would make me want to employ him.

Magenta82 · 24/05/2021 20:43

YABVU an interview is a two way process, you seem to think you should be the only ones with power and information. It is totally legitimate to look up a company you are considering working for. The fact that you say the candidate "admitted it" is really troubling. He is an adult doing the responsible thing not a naughty child confessing to a misdeed.

Merryoldgoat · 24/05/2021 20:41

Sweet Jesus - it’s entirely expected, surely? I was asked in my last interview if I had any comments on the accounts of the company.

Minstermouse · 24/05/2021 20:39

I’d be surprised if an applicant didn’t check a prospective employer’s financial health. Really don’t understand your outrage at all. Why do you suppose your accounts are public access?

honeylulu · 24/05/2021 20:39

It's public information and he quite proactively carried out his due diligence- you should be impressed!

You seem to think the job is like a holy grail that he should be begging you for. Has it occurred to you that the right person for the job is a benefit to the company? That they are interviewing you as much as you are interviewing them?

Level75 · 24/05/2021 20:39

You're being odd fretting about him seeing the public accounts.

He's being sensible both for checking and saying so at interview. As you can tell from the responses, it shows common sense and initiative.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 24/05/2021 20:38

@KateTheEighth

Absolutely standard practice

I would also expect an interviewee to search for interviewers on social media

Are you new to this by any chance?

This.

I hope the candidate gets a job with employers who have a basic grasp of business norms.

Creweventus · 24/05/2021 20:38

@mylovelydd

Presumably the posters saying YABU and it's normal to tell you he looked up your financial information on Companies House don't actually feature on Companies House themselves Hmm Presumably they also like their home address being public knowledge and also tell people what they earn too...yeah thought not.

YANU at all Op. It's weird. I even had a potential employee look up on Rightmove our house and they commented that some friend used to live on our road...It might be one thing to look at the financial health of a company pre interview or supplying them but to tell a person to their face that they don't even know, that they know where they live and how much they earn is not normal.

@mylovelydd I run two companies which are limited so details are on Companies House. Neither my salary nor my home address are on there.

Maggiesfarm · 24/05/2021 20:38

@ChampagneWorries

Its the fact he’s told dh that he had looked at them.

Fine to look for your own security but i think it was off to admit it.

I would of thought he would of said that he had looked at our website, reviews etc not bloody financial information!

I hate people knowing our salary and how much is in the business bank etc.

I would never say that to an interviewer.

You are being absurd (are you really an employer, what's with the 'he would of...").

The guy was being honest, that's all. I doubt he was poring over your personal salary details, he just wants to know the company is sound.

KidneyBeans · 24/05/2021 20:37

@ChampagneWorries

Its the fact he’s told dh that he had looked at them.

Fine to look for your own security but i think it was off to admit it.

I would of thought he would of said that he had looked at our website, reviews etc not bloody financial information!

I hate people knowing our salary and how much is in the business bank etc.

I would never say that to an interviewer.

Right, so you dislike honest employees with common sense and initiative? Confused
PandemicAtTheDisco · 24/05/2021 20:37

Your response - if I knew it - would put me off working for your company.

Ladylimpet · 24/05/2021 20:36

This is friggin hilarious. I'm embarrassed for you op.

Sillyduckseverywhere · 24/05/2021 20:36

I always check the accounts, I've been made redundant twice, I only consider solvent companies.
What do you have to hide?
An interview goes 2 ways.

NewMatress · 24/05/2021 20:34

@mylovelydd

Presumably the posters saying YABU and it's normal to tell you he looked up your financial information on Companies House don't actually feature on Companies House themselves Hmm Presumably they also like their home address being public knowledge and also tell people what they earn too...yeah thought not.

YANU at all Op. It's weird. I even had a potential employee look up on Rightmove our house and they commented that some friend used to live on our road...It might be one thing to look at the financial health of a company pre interview or supplying them but to tell a person to their face that they don't even know, that they know where they live and how much they earn is not normal.

It's quite straightforward, if you don't want this to be public knowledge run the business as a sole trader or partnership and take the risk yourself, rather than giving the people you deal with a tiny bit of information with which to assess their risk.
IseeScottishhills · 24/05/2021 20:34

@mylovelydd

Presumably the posters saying YABU and it's normal to tell you he looked up your financial information on Companies House don't actually feature on Companies House themselves Hmm Presumably they also like their home address being public knowledge and also tell people what they earn too...yeah thought not.

YANU at all Op. It's weird. I even had a potential employee look up on Rightmove our house and they commented that some friend used to live on our road...It might be one thing to look at the financial health of a company pre interview or supplying them but to tell a person to their face that they don't even know, that they know where they live and how much they earn is not normal.

My DH’s company accounts are on the CH website and I think it’s totally normal to look up the accounts if you’re applying for a job and to discuss it at interview particularly for a senior role. I wouldn’t expect the a prospective cleaner to do it but anyone taking on a management type role my DH would be delighted if they’d done it (I just asked him). The address stated is the address where the company is based not your private address. Many business routinely look at the accounts and credit scores of their competitors, and customers it’s totally normal in the day and age. Im fundamentally nosey so I look up accounts on local business I use they make interesting and often sadly depressing reading.
UpTheJunktion · 24/05/2021 20:32

Oh, good lord.

It amazes me the people that manage to make serious money, with this kind of understanding and outlook.

And yes, when I worked for a Charity, my salary was discernible via the accounts.

OP - Candidates don't look to snoop on you - they look to see the health of the co, to see if there are any matters that they would usefully (and constructively) ask questions about as part of the interview, and to build a general picture of the operation. Where income comes from, where expend goes, is it building steadily, peaks and troughs - all of which an interviewer could expect a candidate to use in answers to questions if they are well researched and experienced.

Frankly, you sound a bit batshit.

So. What's the decision? Hire, or let this hapless candidate work for a less paranoid employer?

Fishandhips · 24/05/2021 20:32

I thought everyone did this, why shouldn't he say? Weird reaction, hope he finds a job elsewhere.

queenofthenorthwest · 24/05/2021 20:31

In an interview I always ask why the position is available and why the previous person left.

Also what is their staff retention rate.

He sounds switched on.

ICECream821 · 24/05/2021 20:31

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Smidge001 · 24/05/2021 20:30

@mylovelydd you are wrong. I voted YABVU and my company is on companies House, along with my address etc.
I would have thought anyone with a company registered with Co's House would vote that the op is being unreasonable, given they would know full well what the point is of having accounts publicly available. My address is also listed on all my VAT invoices too Grin. Not quite sure how I could run a business from home without doing so.
The fact that 98% of (currently) 1428 people have voted that the op is being unreasonable would probably suggest I am not alone.