Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be gobsmacked that an interviewee openly told dh that he had looked at our accounts…

989 replies

ChampagneWorries · 24/05/2021 18:40

On companies house?

Dh did an interview today via zoom and the interviewee openly told him that they had looked at our company accounts on companies house to see if we were a healthy company!

Our dividends are on there and I'm really shocked that he basically admitted to being so nosey.

I know they are public information (which i disagree with) but they do show the company income, how much cash was in the bank and our salary etc.

Dh wants to offer him the job as he had some good qualities, but this has really put me off him.

I know people do look at peoples companies on the companies house, but you don't bloody tell them surely?!

Would you still offer him the job?

OP posts:
purplefoxglove · 25/05/2021 11:23

I get that you don't want people knowing how much your company makes - I'd rather people didn't know too! But we also encourage a spirit of openness - I don't think it's an inappropriate thing to admit at an interview - it shows a keen interest and thoroughness - a quality we don't seem to see enough of at interviews because they make it clear you are one of many and they can't even be arsed reading the about us section of our website before an interview! So while I understand your concern over your privacy I think you are getting a bit heated over something that is a positive indication of candidate rather than negative.

Ginuwine · 25/05/2021 11:23

@DaphneDuBois

Also, people correcting your grammar / spelling etc need to get a life. Condescending. I teach English and I still manage not to be a dickhead about it. We all make errors on our phones / in a rush.

The irony is that all the grammar fiends may or may not be earning less than what OP has managed to generate with her business acumen.

Still, let's not let the facts get the way of seizing on any perceived flaw in order to give out a good old fashioned AIBU kicking. Hmm

JosephineDeBeauharnais · 25/05/2021 11:22

@Booksaremylife

This is why, OP, I try to avoid working for the owners of SMEs. IMHO they're all a bit odd in someway, and you'd think every penny spent was coming right out of their pocket there and then.
Agree with this.
WaltzForDebbie · 25/05/2021 11:22

I would think that it's a very good thing to show he has researched the company. In a finance role it would be sloppy if someone going for the interview didn't look at the accounts.

daisychain01 · 25/05/2021 11:21

The Receptionist/Sales Ledger Clerk at our firm paid to have access to the owner's will as she wanted to know how much money their sons had been left! That information really should be private.

Whilst in one sense that's a very vile and inappropriate thing to do - not least of all (presumably) shooting her mouth off telling all and sundry what she'd done, the core tenets of our democratic society is transparency and ability to scrutinise.

Wills are, and should be, a matter for public scrutiny, because it gives the opportunity for people to flag concerns if they suspect wrong-doing. The only way that can be achieved is to make records available for a modest fee. It stops nefarious greedy family members from blocking access to a will they don't want people to see etc. It is also important to see what death duties/taxes are due to the Government.

Whippet · 25/05/2021 11:20

YABVVU
Shows initiative and a financial mindset, with an ability to research and find key data.

Spidey66 · 25/05/2021 11:20

@vivainsomnia

YoP just doesn’t want people to see how much she is paying herself. She says it’s embarrassing. It’s not hard to deduct why it might be.
She has posted elsewhere she spends ÂŁ750 per month on clothes for her children. I don't spend that much a year on clothes for myself, which unless I lose or (more likely!) gain weight I'm not going to grow out of in 5 minutes.
HeronLanyon · 25/05/2021 11:16

It’s been said before but applying to a small firm I think it shows complete common amende to look at how healthy the company is before applying or making any decisions. I’d see this as a hugely positive feature of this applicant and also that he raised it in interview. Why not !?

Good luck op.

StormzyinaTCup · 25/05/2021 11:15

As PPs have said, if filing accounts online at Companies House you only need balance sheet figures, so total assets/liabilities/total no of employees etc. You yourself would obviously receive a full set of accounts with a breakdown of those figures. I can only think your accountant maybe doesn’t do online filing and so sends a full paper copy to CH in which case they will scan in the full copy.

saraclara · 25/05/2021 11:12

@DaphneDuBois

Also, people correcting your grammar / spelling etc need to get a life. Condescending. I teach English and I still manage not to be a dickhead about it. We all make errors on our phones / in a rush.
Yep, that. And given the detail about her upbringing, it's probably that OP didn't get the educational opportunities that some MNers did.
saraclara · 25/05/2021 11:11

You've taken this pretty well, OP. I'm a very private person myself, and now you've explained the background, I can see why you reacted as you did, even though it was irrational.

Definitely get the amount of detail changed on CH if you can. I checked my own details on there and there's absolutely nothing about me, as opposed to the company on there, apart from name and DOB.

DaphneDuBois · 25/05/2021 11:11

Also, people correcting your grammar / spelling etc need to get a life. Condescending. I teach English and I still manage not to be a dickhead about it. We all make errors on our phones / in a rush.

Cheshiresun · 25/05/2021 11:10

It shows common sense. I'm looking at the financial viability of private schools at the moment in a similar way, it's good to know what financial position a company is in, if available, to secure and protect yourself!

ClaudiaWankleman · 25/05/2021 11:09

I asked a guy i know who has a limited company (smaller than ours) and he agreed with me.

And approximately 600 posts here have said the exact opposite.

DaphneDuBois · 25/05/2021 11:07

He’s a smart person and you are being unreasonable. He’s not rummaged through your post! This is public info!

BlackElephant · 25/05/2021 11:06

@blobby10

ChampagneWorries I run a small business with my father and totally understand your dislike of having so much personal information available to anyone. However I too would be impressed that someone was smart enough to check out your publicly available financial information before an interview!

Please check if its possible to show abbreviated accounts as that's all that is available about our company. I have also changed my details as a director/company secretary to show the business address rather than my home address.

Slightly off topic but I do feel that far too much information is available online to people who pay - and many are just bloody nosy! The Receptionist/Sales Ledger Clerk at our firm paid to have access to the owner's will as she wanted to know how much money their sons had been left! That information really should be private.

Are you sure he wasn't shagging her for years on the promise of something in the will?
Gymsmile21 · 25/05/2021 11:05

Really? I’d be impressed and give him the job for using his common sense. Of course he told you about it, his saying “I did my homework, I have common sense, I’m forward thinking”

LittleRen · 25/05/2021 11:05

This is totally fine. We get it all the time, and we would expect interviewees to look at the accounts. Why would you find this weird?

oblada · 25/05/2021 11:03

YABVVVU and it seems that you've realised it.
It shows initatives, good judgment, common sense and honesty! What more do you want? I always check companies house before dealing with a small to medium business in whatever capacity. And as an interviewee it makes sense to 'admit' it.

On a separate but related topics I think salaries in any company should be properly transparent anyway. What's there to hide!

Ginuwine · 25/05/2021 11:01

@ChampagneWorries

I haven't flounced, I'm still here! Its just easier for me to reply in detail with a proper keyboard rather than on my phone.

Its a very small company we have (turnover of just under 1 million)

I have checked the accounts on companies house and it names us individually and what dividends we received each. The accounts are very detailed online.

Its for a 30k a year job, working from home taking inbound calls, call centre type work.

I asked a guy i know who has a limited company (smaller than ours) and he agreed with me.

Anyway dh knows why i felt very uneasy about it (it stems from my childhood and family regarding money, snide remarks etc about other peoples salaries etc.

The candidate in question hasn't been at a workplace for more than 2 years at a time (he’s approx late 20s) but we have agreed to give him a shot.

Many thanks for all the nasty insults, i hope it made you feel worthy and superior to me.

You have been very decent @ChampagneWorries in coming back on here and explaining the background when people have verbally abused you.

Anyone who turns over 1 million a year is no mug and as I said before on here, the personal abuse is unnecessary and without a doubt some of it comes from jealousy.

I still think you were being unreasonable re the candidate, but the concerns you explain above go some way to contextualising that.

StrapOnSallyChasedMeDownTheAli · 25/05/2021 11:00

I used companies house to check on the people who were to take over the company I worked for, from that paper trail I discovered that they were not the sort of people I wanted to work for and so I found new employment before they concluded the take over. I'm glad I did as old business closed within a year and had a trail of creditors chasing them.

I always check companies house, and various other sources, to make sure that I know roughly what I'm walking into.

If this person otherwise meets the criteria for the job then I honestly wouldn't hold it against him that he did his homework. A job/business has to fit both employer and employee.

Spottybluepyjamas · 25/05/2021 10:53

As well as looking on Companies House, I would also look for any news stories, and go into your website in depth - I'd probably talk about that in the interview as well. It shows you're interested, and not just in it for the grunt work or the short-term

blobby10 · 25/05/2021 10:50

ChampagneWorries I run a small business with my father and totally understand your dislike of having so much personal information available to anyone. However I too would be impressed that someone was smart enough to check out your publicly available financial information before an interview!

Please check if its possible to show abbreviated accounts as that's all that is available about our company. I have also changed my details as a director/company secretary to show the business address rather than my home address.

Slightly off topic but I do feel that far too much information is available online to people who pay - and many are just bloody nosy! The Receptionist/Sales Ledger Clerk at our firm paid to have access to the owner's will as she wanted to know how much money their sons had been left! That information really should be private.

grapewine · 25/05/2021 10:49

@Booksaremylife

This is why, OP, I try to avoid working for the owners of SMEs. IMHO they're all a bit odd in someway, and you'd think every penny spent was coming right out of their pocket there and then.
That's been my experience as well. And it's why I went freelance.
Spottybluepyjamas · 25/05/2021 10:48

I would be really impressed with that! It shows he's business minded and cares about the kind of company he might be working for (I.e., that he would hope to be there for a good few years instead of being made redundant fairly soon after he started because they were insolvent). I've done the same before I've started at companies, I can't see why you wouldn't