Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unfair sibling inheritance?

128 replies

Sooperdooper19 · 20/05/2021 18:43

I have 2 sisters and 2 brothers. 3 of us are married and work although none of us are high earners, own small cheap houses and rarely holiday abroad etc. One sister had been on benefits for many years due to MH issues and now also has mobility issues. She lives in an HA flat.

Then there is my youngest sister who is mid 40s. She has never left home and has only worked part time in a minimum wage job for many years. No idea why she doesn’t work full time but that’s her business. She has no medical issues preventing full time work btw.

My mum is very unwell and likely to live only a few months and my dad passed with COVID last year. I have recently found out that myself and my younger sister are executors for their will and have also discovered that my sister is able to remain in my parents house for 15 years after the death of my mum at which time, the house can be sold and split 5 ways. As future beneficiaries, the 4 other siblings are expected to assist in keeping the property in good order during the 15 year period.

I don’t mind as I have what I want and don’t have or want an expensive lifestyle. However, 2 of my other siblings are really not happy that the house can’t be sold within say a year (as they believe that is plenty of time to give my living at home sister chance to sort out alternative accommodation). They feel like she is being rewarded for being lazy and not making her own independent life.

I should point out she refuses to do any care for my mum apart from cooking her meals when she makes her own. Everything else is dealt with by carers.

My mum doesn’t have capacity now to change her will. My siblings wish to contest the will legally when mum dies and expect me to want to do the same. Although I agree to a certain extent and agree my sister is a lazy freeloader, it feels wrong to go against my parents wishes.

So AIBU to help contest the will when I’m not morally convinced it is the right thing to do?

OP posts:
PhillipPhillop · 20/05/2021 19:12

Oops sorry I've realised it's 15 years! That's a long time to keep a property in good repair for future sale. I think I would definitely help your sister with a new property before then.

PhillipPhillop · 20/05/2021 19:10

Crikey, you sound like a bunch of vultures who would rather your sister be homeless so you can get your hands on the cash. The point about the upkeep is that it is in your best interests to keep it in good condition otherwise you could lose ££££ having to sell as a doer-upper. For whatever reason your DM didn't want to see your sister homeless and 5 years will give her time to consider what she's going to do. How about help and encouragement from the rest of you so she might get out sooner?

SapatSea · 20/05/2021 19:01

Unless the estate is worth a lot then the cost of contesting it could wipe out any inheritance. Will the estate be liable for inheritance tax? If so, the house might have to be sold anyway to cover that. Has your DM stipulated that you all contribute to the maintenance of the house, what would happen legally if they didn't. Usually the person who has "leave to remain" pays for upkeep. Did your DM have the will drawn up by a solicitor?