Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

One at Uni, one at work…

937 replies

BelleClapper · 20/05/2021 12:23

How do you square this without causing resentment?

Dd (17) is working full time on an apprenticeship course. We are charging her rent/keep/petrol equivalent to 25% of her take home.

DS (18) up until now was planning to leave college and get a job. He announced yesterday that he is now accepting the three University offers he got a while back. As an aside he’s just split up with his GF of two years who was absolutely definitely in no way the reason he wasn’t going…

So we will be in a position of taking money from DD and sending money to DS. Which has totally changed the dynamic. I’m really conscious of causing resentment from DD who already suffers a bit with middle child syndrome and jealousy.

If you’ve been in this situation what did you do? I want DD to contribute for lots of reasons, none of which go away just because DS now needs three more years of support.

OP posts:
JeffreyJefferson · 24/05/2021 21:36

can she not get the train / bus

JeffreyJefferson · 24/05/2021 21:34

honestly i don’t know why people have kids then expect them to pay just to live at home while they are children Sad

JeffreyJefferson · 24/05/2021 21:32

and you are her parents where else can she go? you are SUPPOSED to look after your CHILDREN- she is not an adult yet

JeffreyJefferson · 24/05/2021 21:31

very harsh she is only 17

Coldwine75 · 24/05/2021 21:28

Just read its 25%, thats just harsh and unkind !

Coldwine75 · 24/05/2021 21:27

I would never charge my child on an apprenticeship, thats unfair but I dont get whole idea of charging your own child to live in their own home thing....my parents never did it for us

elexis969 · 24/05/2021 21:23

There are a few things that do not sit right with me about this, the first when you said "who already suffers a bit with middle child syndrome and jealousy"....to me I read this as you devaluing her feelings, if she is showing signs of jealousy then there is clearly an issue already in the dynamics of the household....its not "middle child syndrome" it's your child telling you she feels less than, id be asking myself if there was something I was doing that could improve upon that instead of pawning it off as just jealousy.

I would then be asking myself is this worth risking my relationship with my daughter? Because if she is already feeling feelings of inadequacy then this could be a turning point in your relationship. There is absolutely no reason whatsoever why your son could not get a part-time job and equally contribute financially if you are so adamant about them paying their way.....to ask one child to pay and not the other while they are both pursuing higher education quite frankly grosses me out.

Children should be treated equally, that's it...end of. You're essentially punishing her for her chosen career path and creating a bigger divide then there already appears to be. Either charge them both or neither of them.

Egghead81 · 24/05/2021 12:21

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

LolaSmiles · 24/05/2021 12:21

Belladonna12
Once parents have decided to treat their children differently, their main focus is usually affirming the decision and finding ways to justify it.

To this day my parents think their different treatment across siblings at various points was fine, gave us useful financial lessons, and is the reason some of us have bought out own homes. It hasn't crossed their mind that when adult siblings discuss money or what support to offer our own DC, the consensus is that our parents were very selective on who and what to support.

Egghead81 · 24/05/2021 12:20

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Belladonna12 · 24/05/2021 12:16

I mean if nearly 2/3 of people had told me I was clearly favouring one child over the other, It would have me at least think.

Yes, only 1/3 of adults think OP is reasonable and this leads OP to think that there is no need to worry about her DD resenting her in the future even though (in OP's words) she "already suffers a bit with middle child syndrome and jealousy."

Belladonna12 · 24/05/2021 12:13

@BelleClapper

Yes. I started a thread with a worry.

I thought stuff through after reading the responses, realised I was worrying over nothing, and moved on. Laughed quite a lot at the nonsense about favouritism and cruelty tbh. Peak Mumsnet.

Considering how many posters think you are right to worry it's a bit weird that the responses on here made you think what you are planning to do is fine and won't lead to resentment. It should be obvious that there is a good chance your DD may feel the same way when she's older so why would you feel less worried?
DreamingNow · 24/05/2021 12:08

@BelleClapper

Yes. I started a thread with a worry.

I thought stuff through after reading the responses, realised I was worrying over nothing, and moved on. Laughed quite a lot at the nonsense about favouritism and cruelty tbh. Peak Mumsnet.

I don't know... More people disagree with you than agree (69% saying YABU)....

Good to see that you think you are right and feeling comforted in your decision. But I fail to see the 'Peak MN' there Hmm

I mean if nearly 2/3 of people had told me I was clearly favouring one child over the other, It would have me at least think.

BelleClapper · 24/05/2021 12:04

You seem very angry. Do you think possibly it might be time to step away from the thread and have a camomile tea?

OP posts:
PaperbackRider · 24/05/2021 11:50

@BelleClapper

Yes. I started a thread with a worry.

I thought stuff through after reading the responses, realised I was worrying over nothing, and moved on. Laughed quite a lot at the nonsense about favouritism and cruelty tbh. Peak Mumsnet.

In other words you had a good idea you were doing it wrong, but ignored anyone who agreed and listened only to those who said it was fine, because then you could feel better about yourself without actually doing anything. And then you started having pops at anyone who only agreed with what you knew to be the case when you started the thread. Yes, Peak MN is right Hmm
Vikingintraining · 24/05/2021 10:45

As someone who manages people in my workplace who are studying apprenticeships, I want to flag up that apprenticeships are a continuation of study. Your daughter is continuing her education as equal as your son. The fact that she is working and earning money is separate. If you said you would support through education then it should be the same support for both.
If your rules are more around earning and contributing then will your son be handing over 25% of any part time job too? That would be fair.
Also I would say don't put your daughter's contribution into savings, whether or not you tell her. I always think it's a bit patronising to save an adult child's money on their behalf. Teach her the value of saving and encourage her to put it into savings herself so she learns and appreciates the benefit of doing that. If you need her financial contribution to your household then accept it from her and spend it, if you don't need it then encourage her to save it herself. 12K is really not much salary at all!
(Disclaimer, I am also the resentful jealous middle child Hmm)

AbsolutelyPatsy · 24/05/2021 09:56

i wouldnt compare the two situations op, no point,
there will be plenty of other parents in the same boat, myself included, your ds may well move home and if he works will have to pay rent too

AbsolutelyPatsy · 24/05/2021 09:55

i wouldnt compare the two

SwimBaby · 24/05/2021 09:48

Some very unfair comments on here.

BelleClapper · 24/05/2021 09:48

Yes. I started a thread with a worry.

I thought stuff through after reading the responses, realised I was worrying over nothing, and moved on. Laughed quite a lot at the nonsense about favouritism and cruelty tbh. Peak Mumsnet.

OP posts:
PaperbackRider · 24/05/2021 09:46

Ok. DD is happy, DS is happy, not issues with money, people are getting cars and everyone is delighted.
And you started a thread worrying about unfairness and resentment for absolutely no reason, having no thoughts at all of unfairness and resentment, and anyone who thinks there may be unfairness or resentment is crazy and mean and trolling. Got it.
Thanks for the clarification Hmm

LolaSmiles · 24/05/2021 09:45

So after 30 posters this was a textbook AIBU
OP: AIBU
(30 pages later)
OP: just so you all know I'm not unreasonable, so there.

BelleClapper · 24/05/2021 09:41

So for anyone still unsure.

Petrol to take DD to and from work is at least £100pm.

Her phone is £25.

We take £250 so the actual amount of keep she’s paying outside of her own costs is £125 a month.

I am GIVING her my car (worth £5k or so) when she passes her test.

DS will work while at university, he is also looking for a ft job over the summer.

I posted just after he’d decided to go to uni and I’d looked up the amount of maintenance loan, my initial thought was that we’d have to top him up. This may not be the case.

I’m not taking from DD so that I can afford to pay DS, which is what some people are saying. The keep arrangement has been done and dusted, DD is very happy with it.

Oh and the Daily Mail can fuck off.

OP posts:
BelleClapper · 24/05/2021 09:34

Daily Mail journo who thinks 25% of 12 is 4…

OP posts:
PaperbackRider · 24/05/2021 09:31

Saying what I see. Your kid drops out of school but is earning a bit of money, and your main concern is taking it off her to fund your other kid at uni. It's your family, do as you like. But now the daily hate has hold of it Grin