Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

One at Uni, one at work…

937 replies

BelleClapper · 20/05/2021 12:23

How do you square this without causing resentment?

Dd (17) is working full time on an apprenticeship course. We are charging her rent/keep/petrol equivalent to 25% of her take home.

DS (18) up until now was planning to leave college and get a job. He announced yesterday that he is now accepting the three University offers he got a while back. As an aside he’s just split up with his GF of two years who was absolutely definitely in no way the reason he wasn’t going…

So we will be in a position of taking money from DD and sending money to DS. Which has totally changed the dynamic. I’m really conscious of causing resentment from DD who already suffers a bit with middle child syndrome and jealousy.

If you’ve been in this situation what did you do? I want DD to contribute for lots of reasons, none of which go away just because DS now needs three more years of support.

OP posts:
trilbydoll · 20/05/2021 13:15

My sister went to uni and I didn't. I lived at home rent free, and my Dad bought me a second hand car (it was £3k 14 years ago so not brand new but not cheap as chips either)

Yes they probably gave my sister more money but I've always felt we were treated fairly.

Comefromaway · 20/05/2021 13:15

I will be charging ds £50 per week if he chooses not to to go to uni. Doing that will be an incentive for him not to sit at home on Universal Credit playing his piano all day but to actually go out and get a job.

FunMcCool · 20/05/2021 13:15

Is there a real need that charge a 17 year old? Don’t give her any money but don’t charge her rent.

OunceOfFlounce · 20/05/2021 13:14

It does seem like she's being penalised for not going to university.

UhtredRagnarson · 20/05/2021 13:13

I think you should provide them with the same. So if you’re covering DS’s accommodation then you shouldn’t be charging DD for hers. If you’re covering his food costs then you shouldn’t be charging DD for hers.

FoxgloveBee · 20/05/2021 13:13

I wouldn't charge her, an apprenticeship is education in my opinion. Not least because she's younger than her brother.

I'd say she needs to transfer you the same amount but you are putting it away as savings for her.

cuparfull · 20/05/2021 13:13

DS needs to work during Uni time and pay his own way like many of us did.
Given the present lack of incomers to the UK, there are by all accounts plenty of PT jobs going in the hospitality industry/baristas/hotel staff.
A niece worked nights at the Travelodge, others worked in hotel housekeeping. Seems the hospitality industry is quite desperate for staff.
And good experience of life moving forward.

skybluee · 20/05/2021 13:13

I'm shocked at the people saying her wage is so low.

When I started one of my old jobs, working in admissions at a university, the take home was under 1000 a month. The job was, I think, £13.1K and I got about £950-£990. £400 went on rent, and the rest stretched for food, transport, bills. It was very, very tight.

It's a tough one because is an apprenticeship seen as a full time job (with a low wage) or as education?

You obviously want to treat them fairly.
I definitely agree with previous posters about being open with her about saving the money she's putting aside. That will make a big difference.

Will DS be moving out - into halls, living away from home? Because they are two separate circumstances and I wouldn't let them affect each other.

I agree that if she's living at home and bringing in what is essentially a full time wage then she needs to contribute, I think your set up sounds about right. How long is her apprenticeship and what happens after?

I'd just treat them as separate situations.

LookingGlassMilk · 20/05/2021 13:12

I'm one of 4, two of us went away to study and the other two stayed at home and went to a local college. Our parents paid for our rent if we moved away, but they bought a car each for the two that stayed at home. I thought it was fair.

Comefromaway · 20/05/2021 13:12

@BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz

It can sadden you all you like. I dont earn the salary to keep two homes - one for the family (which he is welcome to stay in as long as he needs), and one for him.

He wants it? He pays for it.

If you don't earn the salary then he will be entitled to the maximum £9k amount. Parents are expected to top up according to their income. I'm not penalising my kids because I happen to be well paid.
toconclude · 20/05/2021 13:12

@chocorabbit

£250 (a MONTH, don't forget) would in fact only just about cover 1/4 of total food etc, c/tax, electricity, water, internet connection and heating in most households.

Tulipomania · 20/05/2021 13:11

Your DS will be building up a huge debt going to Uni, and there is an expectation that parents contribute to supporting them unless they qualify for the full maintenance loan - but it's still only a loan.

Your DD won't have this.

BelleClapper · 20/05/2021 13:11

@chocorabbit

Why do people need to charge a % on their children's income?! If you really need the money just calculate how much she costs you to feed her, electricity, gas etc she uses and charge that! I don't think it would be £250! I don't understand how this "teaches" them how to handle money. If she is left with e.g. just £300 she could still easily blow this away if she is this kind of person! I know people that have! I also know people whose parents would blow away their (DC's) whole salary so moved away and never contributed anything again and now count every penny to save.
We actually didn’t work it out on her salary, it just happens to be 25%. We said £200 for keep/food, and £50 for petrol (we take her to and from, hour round trip each way).
OP posts:
user1487194234 · 20/05/2021 13:11

I think you risk resentment between your DC,and making it look like doing an apprenticeship is inferior to going to Uni(when in can be the far better choice)

I also think 25% is a lot.
I know taking keep and saving it is popular on Mumsnet but I don't agree,I think it is very patronising and it doesn't teach them to save.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 20/05/2021 13:10

Perhaps he wasn't offered a place, perhaps they don't do his course

Which is why I suggested the alternative of funding it himself.

We are getting to a place in society where parents of university students are still serving their own massive graduate debt and thus cannot fund another person's.

DazzlingHaze · 20/05/2021 13:10

I would consider an apprenticeship as still being in education so I think you're being pretty mean. Apart from rent to you, what else does she pay? Does she pay her own phone bill, toiletries etc on top of that? Those things I think it's fine for her to finance by herself ie, I wouldn't charge a child doing an apprenticeship to live with me but I wouldn't be funding them by paying for phone bills, streaming services, clothes, nights out etc.

Your DS could absolutely get a part time job and I would expect him to. If you expect DD to pay her way you should insist that he has to contribute to his own living costs as well.

I wouldn't be surprised if your DD ends up feeling as though she's being punished for not choose the university route. And I want to clarify I am not against adult DC paying their way if they choose to leave education in favour of working, I just see an apprenticeship as an alternative form of further education.

Planty13 · 20/05/2021 13:10

I would only take money off DD if you will 100% put it aside for her. The thought that she is essentially topping up her brothers Uni income isn’t comfortable with me. He needs to get a job as well. They are both still in education.

JoveWhenHeSawMyFannysFace · 20/05/2021 13:09

I wouldn’t be charging a 17 year old rent unless you desperately needed the money (and if that was the case, I assume you wouldn’t be able to pay towards your student son either)

Is there a middle ground where she pays for food / petrol (sorts herself out or gives you an amount that covers her share) but puts an agreed amount into savings herself, to end up with the same amount in savings at the end of 3 years as the amount you’ve given your DS?

toconclude · 20/05/2021 13:09

@Owesye

I’m blown away you’re charging when she’s on £12k a year! Seems really mean and unfair. They’ve got plenty of time in life to pay rent and mortgages and bills m. Glad my parents doesn’t have this thought process!
It's peanuts compared to what rent and board actually costs. I'm glad my parents DID have this thought process, never been in debt since.
TwoAndAnOnion · 20/05/2021 13:09

@BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz

Why are you funding ds going away to uni? He can go to a local one and remain at home for free, or fund the shortfall in his accommodation himself.
Perhaps he wasn't offered a place, perhaps they don't do his course.
chocorabbit · 20/05/2021 13:09

Why do people need to charge a % on their children's income?! If you really need the money just calculate how much she costs you to feed her, electricity, gas etc she uses and charge that! I don't think it would be £250! I don't understand how this "teaches" them how to handle money. If she is left with e.g. just £300 she could still easily blow this away if she is this kind of person! I know people that have! I also know people whose parents would blow away their (DC's) whole salary so moved away and never contributed anything again and now count every penny to save.

UserAtRandom · 20/05/2021 13:09

My DC are just under those ages, but basically we have some money set aside that we intend will be used to support them as young adults. That means it might be spent on university costs, or training costs or put towards the cost of a car or a house deposit. In the interests of "fairness" they have the same amount. So in your position, DS might be getting a chunk of money to support him through university now, but DD would have more money in the future to support her in whatever it is she wants/needs.

TwoAndAnOnion · 20/05/2021 13:08

@Owesye

I’m blown away you’re charging when she’s on £12k a year! Seems really mean and unfair. They’ve got plenty of time in life to pay rent and mortgages and bills m. Glad my parents doesn’t have this thought process!
How much do you expect a 17yo to earn? because NMW for a 17yo is 4.62. (90.6k equivalency) so when do you expect a working adult to pull their weight? or do you expect all 17yo's to command a CEO wag at the go get?
BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 20/05/2021 13:08

It can sadden you all you like. I dont earn the salary to keep two homes - one for the family (which he is welcome to stay in as long as he needs), and one for him.

He wants it? He pays for it.

Friendofdennis · 20/05/2021 13:07

They are two totally different situations aren’t they? Your son has no choice but pay for his accommodation/food etc from his student finance. Depending on family circumstances and where you live in the UK some of this will become a debt. Even if he gets a part time job he needs some contribution from you to keep his head above water to pay for food travel laundry etc as the amount of student finance simply isn’t enough to live on and eat properly etc . If you are keeping the money from your daughter ring fenced to give back to her at a future date then you are effectively providing free accommodation/utility and food. So your daughter is being treated fairly. It’s just that she doesn’t realise it because you haven’t told her that she will get the money back from you.