Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

One at Uni, one at work…

937 replies

BelleClapper · 20/05/2021 12:23

How do you square this without causing resentment?

Dd (17) is working full time on an apprenticeship course. We are charging her rent/keep/petrol equivalent to 25% of her take home.

DS (18) up until now was planning to leave college and get a job. He announced yesterday that he is now accepting the three University offers he got a while back. As an aside he’s just split up with his GF of two years who was absolutely definitely in no way the reason he wasn’t going…

So we will be in a position of taking money from DD and sending money to DS. Which has totally changed the dynamic. I’m really conscious of causing resentment from DD who already suffers a bit with middle child syndrome and jealousy.

If you’ve been in this situation what did you do? I want DD to contribute for lots of reasons, none of which go away just because DS now needs three more years of support.

OP posts:
titchy · 20/05/2021 13:26

How much would a shared room, food, petrol and bills cost her where you are? I assume a lot more than the c£250 a month you're charging. So point out that in fact you ARE financially supporting her - to the tune of £300 a month (or whatever - I'll bet it's a very similar amount to what you'll be supporting ds with).

Lazypuppy · 20/05/2021 13:26

Your DS needs to get himself a job as many students do to put himself through uni. He'll get loansas well

Bluedeblue · 20/05/2021 13:26

I should add as well, that my DS and DD were not always sent equal monthly amounts! At one point my DD's rent was £800pm, whereas my DS's was less than £500pm.

PicaK · 20/05/2021 13:24

Think you're absolutely right to charge DD rent.
In this situation I'd be tempted to work out the full cost of her living there - her full share of all bills etc
Then you can show her what you are giving her - difference between that and the amount you do charge her.

looptheloopinahulahoop · 20/05/2021 13:23

@AOwlAOwlAOwl

Perhaps your DS should get a job and pay some of the shortfall himself, or go to a cheaper university.
There is no such thing as a "cheaper" university - they all charge the same fees, more or less. Some cities are obviously cheaper than others, though.
Bluedeblue · 20/05/2021 13:23

This is one situation where you just can't make things equal though.

If you're talking about buying kids cars, then yes, you can make it exactly the same for all, but this isn't like that.

My DS did a 5 year degree and my DD did a 4 year degree. My son was then on JSA for 12 months, living away from home. My DD on the other hand, came home from Uni and straight into a job here (Teacher). So my DS was being sent money for 6 years, and not paying board, as he was not at home, whereas my DD was sent money for 4 years and then was paying us board. It is what it is.

It's certainly ridiculous to let her earn £1000 pm and not pay anything towards her keep. MY DD earns about £28k, and we only charge her £10 per day to cover food. This is because she is saving for a house deposit. I figure £10 more than covers what she consumes, and the other bills would exist whether she was here or not.

5128gap · 20/05/2021 13:23

Is your son's course actually going to get him somewhere, rather than just being taken as something to do and an 'experience'/social life for the next 3 years? I ask as it's a sudden change of mind rather than something he planned for.
Fine if it is the latter, but I don't think your daughter should be penalised for getting a job, while your son enjoys deferring adulthood for another 3 years with she and you subsidising him.
Unless the course is very intense and has a clear direction into an occupation, I would be asking him to get a job towards his costs.
I think there are a couple of options with your daughter if you end up subsidising your son. You could stop charging her until she is 21, or you could continue, which is a good life lesson as you say, and save the money up for her.
If you can't afford to do either, then you can't afford to support your son.

ForThePurposeOfTheTape · 20/05/2021 13:23

Your child at uni should have a part-time job and be paying 25% of his salary when he's home if he just works holidays. (I assume that he works)

Hardbackwriter · 20/05/2021 13:22

People on the thread seem obsessed with the idea that she might feel 'punished' for doing an apprenticeship but the solutions seem to involve actually punishing him for it, as it seems that a lot of people think you should give him less than you otherwise would, and less than the government expects you to, because his sister didn't choose to go to university.

BelleClapper · 20/05/2021 13:22

@LeilaLiesLow

I don't get your 'logic' here OP.

Your DD could not survive on £12K a year if she had to pay rent, bills, food , transport all on her own ( flat share etc.)

I know a friend whose DD was on that wage for an apprenticeship, living away from home, and they treated it the same as uni and paid her rent for a studio flat and she funded all her other spending.

Your son's loan will depend on your household income. It may meet his needs or you may need to help with housing costs. We paid the rent for both our DCs while they were at uni. They each did science degrees which were full-on 6 days a week in the labs etc, incl evenings, so their holiday jobs were out of term time only.

Your son won't get the equivalent of £12K a year in a loan and he will have to repay it when he works. So compared to your DD who can earn £36K over 3 years he is likely to have a debt of £30K+ in 3 years.

I think you need to accept that you should contribute to his education because your DD is already getting a home, food, transport etc for only £3k a year and has £9K left for 'fun'.

Thank you, it helps to ‘flip it’ like that. She’s much better off.
OP posts:
Comefromaway · 20/05/2021 13:21

@TwoAndAnOnion

I was stuck on this - I would deem an apprentice to still be in education, and earning a reduced NMW of £4.30. It is actually an accredited apprenticeship or is it on-the-job training? Will there actually be a qualification at the end of it?

At 17, you have to be chipping in, if you are working. I don't care if you are in a low-end job, 17yos don't go in commanding high salaries (despite what some posters think) and household incomes vary. If you need the money to balance the household income then so be it.

On a different thread, the same posters will be telling you you can get married at 16, join up and have the vote in Scotland - but are apparently too young to bear some financial equality.

We (or rather my boss) choose to pay our apprentice more than NWM (because he proved himself worth it).

I've just worked out he's on £13,500 per year

looptheloopinahulahoop · 20/05/2021 13:21

@AlfrescoDining

Do you need to charge DD? I'd stop doing so.
I agree, she's only getting an apprenticeship wage. Or at least, make it a lot less.

The one summer when I had a full time summer job I was earning about £150 a week and my mum took £20 a week. I think something like that would be fair (and much less than 25%).

ForThePurposeOfTheTape · 20/05/2021 13:21

I'm in a similar situation.

Dc1 is on an apprenticeship while dc3 is going to uni.

Living rent free is an equivalent of getting money from me and paying me as a landlord iyswim. He's actually in a far better position because he isn't paying me with interest and it's a nicer property than he'd get on a student loan amount.

DottyFlossie · 20/05/2021 13:21

I would not charge my DD if she did an apprenticeship.

notacooldad · 20/05/2021 13:21

Personally I didn't take money from either of mine. They contributed in different ways.
I think it is bloody mean spirited to charge your kids 'rent'. I know you said they have to get used to not having the full wage to themselves but there's different ways if teaching budgeting skills. Mine managed to move out and pay his bills and mortgage without having to hand over money to me.

Ideally we’ll save it for her but I don’t want to let on that I am I always think this is ridiculous and patronising.

museumum · 20/05/2021 13:21

My understanding (my ds isn't uni level quite yet) is that the Government expects students to be supported to live to the tune of £9k by a combination of parental support and maintenance loan. Anything above that they should earn themselves. I know at some Unis the £9k doesn't cover living costs but it's the general rule.
So I wouldn't think of your part of that £9k as 'giving' money to your ds at all, it's more like a tax on your pay to enable him to study.

If your Dd objects you can show her what he has to pay in rent as i'm sure it won't be anything like her £200 she is paying. I'd guess it'd be more like at least double that!

LeilaLiesLow · 20/05/2021 13:20

I don't get your 'logic' here OP.

Your DD could not survive on £12K a year if she had to pay rent, bills, food , transport all on her own ( flat share etc.)

I know a friend whose DD was on that wage for an apprenticeship, living away from home, and they treated it the same as uni and paid her rent for a studio flat and she funded all her other spending.

Your son's loan will depend on your household income. It may meet his needs or you may need to help with housing costs. We paid the rent for both our DCs while they were at uni. They each did science degrees which were full-on 6 days a week in the labs etc, incl evenings, so their holiday jobs were out of term time only.

Your son won't get the equivalent of £12K a year in a loan and he will have to repay it when he works. So compared to your DD who can earn £36K over 3 years he is likely to have a debt of £30K+ in 3 years.

I think you need to accept that you should contribute to his education because your DD is already getting a home, food, transport etc for only £3k a year and has £9K left for 'fun'.

SallySycamore · 20/05/2021 13:18

DD is being paid to learn.

DS getting paid by getting a part-time job takes away from his learning time.

I used to do two hours a week tutoring (in my university city), and then temp for a couple of months (at home) in the summer. It was much easier for me to manage than people who tried to balance retail and bar shifts with studying. In fact, on my particular course we were told to think very carefully about how we'd manage before we took on a job, because we had a lot of contact time, and weekly hand-ins.

HelloOldSport · 20/05/2021 13:18

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

schroeder · 20/05/2021 13:17

I have one at university and one working. We send money to the the first and take money off the second. It's not equal, but it is fair.

There always seem to be a section of mumsnetters who are horrified by charging dc rent. I don't know why, because there have been a million threads about it.Confused

HollyGoLoudly1 · 20/05/2021 13:16

@HappySonHappyMum

I'm interested in this one too. My DS has just started a 3 year apprenticeship but on substantially more at £25k a year. My DD wants to go to Uni. I want to be fair but the balance is very uneven. I think I'm going to have to sit them both down and have a conversation about it all so it is all out in the open and that way there will be no resentment.
Whatever you decide to do, I second this. Have a chat with them so everyone knows what is happening.

It's a tricky one. Reflecting on all the posts so far I am leaning towards not charging her. I do agree that working adults should pay board however I also class an apprenticeship (even paying as much as this one) as education. Your DD is pursuing a qualification that comes with a small salary. Your DS could have pursued something similar; he has chosen a more expensive option and there are financial consequences of that.

As a middle child myself I can already feel the resentment that this would have caused me so maybe that is biasing my view!

user1487194234 · 20/05/2021 13:16

Although TBF I don't want my DC working during term time or taking out loans so they are fully funded by us .MY DC who is having a year out is working,minimum wage ,I don't take anything from him.
My friend still has some resentment as her brother got to go away for Uni and she had to stay at home as parents said they could only afford to pay for one to go away (!) (and that was 30 years ago,and no doubt some sexism involved)

TwoAndAnOnion · 20/05/2021 13:16

I was stuck on this - I would deem an apprentice to still be in education, and earning a reduced NMW of £4.30. It is actually an accredited apprenticeship or is it on-the-job training? Will there actually be a qualification at the end of it?

At 17, you have to be chipping in, if you are working. I don't care if you are in a low-end job, 17yos don't go in commanding high salaries (despite what some posters think) and household incomes vary. If you need the money to balance the household income then so be it.

On a different thread, the same posters will be telling you you can get married at 16, join up and have the vote in Scotland - but are apparently too young to bear some financial equality.

Meghansego · 20/05/2021 13:15

@misselphaba

25% seems harsh. I don't know how I'd feel if I was in her shoes. I'd expect DB to get a job and pay his own rent for a start.
I agree. 25% is ridiculously high. We take 10% from our 22 year old and have insisted that he saves a couple of hundred a month too, which he’s happy to do.
TheTeenageYears · 20/05/2021 13:15

There is a government expectation that parents support DC at university. Parents are means tested for students maintenance loans and expected to top up amount a student can borrow based their income. It is what it is.

In your shoes OP I would support DS as per expectation if you can but keep a note of how much help you give. I would lower DD's contribution slightly and make her aware that at some point you will even the scales. There may be another time in the future where she would like or needs some financial support and so whilst it might feel a little unbalanced now, it will all be evened out eventually and she has to trust you to be fair.