Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

One at Uni, one at work…

937 replies

BelleClapper · 20/05/2021 12:23

How do you square this without causing resentment?

Dd (17) is working full time on an apprenticeship course. We are charging her rent/keep/petrol equivalent to 25% of her take home.

DS (18) up until now was planning to leave college and get a job. He announced yesterday that he is now accepting the three University offers he got a while back. As an aside he’s just split up with his GF of two years who was absolutely definitely in no way the reason he wasn’t going…

So we will be in a position of taking money from DD and sending money to DS. Which has totally changed the dynamic. I’m really conscious of causing resentment from DD who already suffers a bit with middle child syndrome and jealousy.

If you’ve been in this situation what did you do? I want DD to contribute for lots of reasons, none of which go away just because DS now needs three more years of support.

OP posts:
OlivesTree · 20/05/2021 14:01

YANBU.

On £12k she won’t be paying tax and only a tiny amount of NI, so she is taking home almost £1k/month. After 25% board she is left with £750 per month!

My household income is over 100k per year. A spare £750/month after bills and very necessary savings would be an absolute dream for me!

Still plenty there for her to have a lovely lifestyle and save for a e.g.car. And she’s learning that nothing in life comes for free.

Does she have a pension OP? I’d really encourage her to put at least 5% into that. If only I’d started at her age! To try and teach my DC good habits I make them save 20% of their (£1!) pocket money in their ‘pension’. They are 9 and 6. BlushGrin

Jenala · 20/05/2021 14:01

The fact he will be in debt at the end of his degree isn't really relevant. He's chosen to do a degree, his sister hasn't. Why should she essentially pay towards his choice? You decide to do a degree, you take on debt. Whether his sister is getting into debt for her education is a red herring that shouldn't factor into decision making. It's not unfair on him that his choice gets him into debt and his sisters choice doesn't. It is unfair on her if she is expected to pay out because its unfair her brother will be in debt and she won't.

She's not being given 12k a year. She's EARNING it. Her brother is being given money.

HoldontoOneMoreDay · 20/05/2021 14:00

The national minimum wage for an apprentice is £4.30 - DD is clearly getting more than this if she brings home £12k a year! She isn't scratching about on pennies. Good on her - but given her petrol costs are £100 pm and her parents drive her - good on them! - she is really doing quite well out of this.

RandomMess · 20/05/2021 14:00

We are in a similar situation with the eldest 3 all doing something different and it's a difficult tightrope to walk.

I'm coming back later to read this thread thoroughly.

Just because my 19 year old didn't go to college or uni doesn't mean she never will, or in fact may do some professional qualifications that she has to pay for and at that point we will help financially.

HeadNorth · 20/05/2021 14:00

My oldest is back working from home because of Covid & we are not charging her rent or bills, even though she has a well paid job. The reason is to enable her to save for a deposit on a flat, which she is doing. We don't need the money and the property ladder is so ridiculous for young people to get a toe hold on due to intergenerational unfairness. I want to help my children up, not take money from them I don't really need.

Dora33 · 20/05/2021 13:59

The arguement of what your dd is saving by living at home might not make her feel better if she is comparing herself to her brother.
They are so close in age and she is still in education though done through her work.
I think 25% is high and I would suggest this reduced to 15%. If you want charge higher, the option of most of the money going into savings for her is good. Though I would discuss this with her and her her buyin. Otherwise this can cause longterm resentment between your dd & you and also your dd & ds.
The wage potential in both career routes they are taking, is important.
I went to college for 3 years at the same time my younger sibling (by 18 months) started working. I worked hard during the summer before college to have the money I needed for during the college terms. I also then worked Saturdays & Sundays. I lived at home but contributed towards my keep, though a lesser amount than my sibling. Also, my parents did help me out with some college costs.

When I graduated, the job I obtained had a higher salary than my sibling and my keep increased.
I thought this was fair and i definitely would not have wanted to be getting help from parents while my sibling was paying 25%.
We were both aware of the reasons for our keep costs. Then when our younger siblings were going to college / starting work, these changed slightly to suit their & family circumstances but it was always seen as being fair by everyone.

Clare876 · 20/05/2021 13:59

How about charging her but keeping it aside in a bank account so you can gift it back to her when she's older and moving out.

BelleClapper · 20/05/2021 13:58

Ok so a few things.

DD is working full time, earning a full time salary. She is also earning a qualification. She’s not on a reduced salary or part time.

DH and I drive her to and from work, 10hrs driving a week, actual petrol costs c£100.

Either DH or I cook a proper dinner every evening. We have a once a week takeaway that we pay for for everybody.

I pay for her phone because it’s all on my contract. We have high speed internet, full sky tv package, Netflix, Amazon prime.

She has a large double bedroom and shares a bathroom with her siblings. Regularly entertains her friends here. Will be walking around with the best part of £750pm.

DS will be (hopefully) going away to Uni potentially six hrs away. He’ll be in halls, so a single room with shared facilities. He’ll be studying full time. No luxury tv packages, no home cooked meals, or free takeaways, money will be tight.

I’ve thought it through and DD has by far the better deal!

OP posts:
nancywhitehead · 20/05/2021 13:57

I think you should base it on whether you actually need a contribution from her or not.

If you don't need it, then don't charge her. When your son is working, if either of them are living at home then they can pay. But until they are both in jobs, don't charge them unless you are actually in need of the money.

Anything else just leads to weird dynamics.

Jenala · 20/05/2021 13:56

OP I love how you keep quoting people who agree with you and saying that's helped you "reframe it" etc Grin

I think £200 a month, plus petrol, is a lot at 17. I get you're trying to teach her responsibility but why not encourage her to save instead of doing it for her? And given you've noted the high cost of your mortgage and bills, and that "ideally" you'll save, you're probably not actually saving for her.

Your children have both chosen further education, your daughter has chosen something where she can earn while she learns, your son has chosen something expensive. It just doesn't seem fair to me that she has to pay because of that whereas he gets money. Fair enough if you couldn't support him financially, that would be one thing. But with your proposed set up she is essentially paying towards her brother choosing to do an expensive degree.

I don't think petrol money is a problem but I think the keep is because it's so unbalanced. Yes a shared room would be more expensive but she's 17, not 23.

PaperbackRider · 20/05/2021 13:56

OP, you wouldn't have asked how to avoid resentment unless you were aware there was a good chance you were going to cause resentment.

Bit much to complain that anyone who says there will be resentment is unreasonable, don't you think?

Bluedeblue · 20/05/2021 13:56

I can't believe that two siblings who are in education or training are being treated so unequally

Because their situations are different. The Ops son will most likely leave Uni with a minimum £27k debt (if he does a 3 year course). The Ops daughter will have no debt. Should the Op pay off the son's debt, so that they are both even? Even, in so much as both children have no debt. But wait...then Op will have given her DS £27k and not given her DD a lump sum. How do you square that circle?

Comefromaway · 20/05/2021 13:55

@UserAtRandom

12k is not a good wage!! we pay our apprentices over 25k plus benefits.

Are your apprentices 17? My 17 year old has a part time job that pays £7.50 an hour and he thought he was doing well!

Can I come work for you?
Mistymountain · 20/05/2021 13:55

I've always considered entering into an apprenticeship as equivalent to attending university or college - it is training and learning after all, and depending on the field may involve exams.

UserAtRandom · 20/05/2021 13:54

12k is not a good wage!! we pay our apprentices over 25k plus benefits.

Are your apprentices 17? My 17 year old has a part time job that pays £7.50 an hour and he thought he was doing well!

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 20/05/2021 13:53

Charging her for the petrol makes sense if it's an additional expense of her having that placement, but I'd encourage her to save/use the other money for driving lessons.

Abouttimemum · 20/05/2021 13:53

My oldest sister and I both went to Uni and were given £1000 per year towards living (this was a long time ago!) we both had to work through studies to see us through. Rightly so.

My middle sister didn’t go to university, worked instead, and contributed to the cost of living at home during her time living there. my parents kept the £3,000 aside for when she needed it. She used it when she moved into a flat.

We’ve always been kept on an even keel, or her wise it creates resentment.

It’s right that each child should receive the same support.

Lollipopmum0183 · 20/05/2021 13:53

@HoldontoOneMoreDay

I do think you're kind of overthinking it.

No working adult should live rent-free, so in terms of your DD I think you've got things pretty much spot on. If she's got £200 in her hand to play with each week then she's not badly off.

Uni is different because it's so expensive and your circs as parents are taken into consideration. So the onus is on you to top up the grant - he'd get more (I assume) if you couldn't afford this.

It's two different circumstances and I wouldn't allow DD to conflate this - however I would make sure DS was taking all the loans he's entitled to and that his walking around money (funded by you) isn't more than DD's - if he wants more, he can work for it.

This.
xela21 · 20/05/2021 13:52

Really tricky. I think it probably also depends on what OP(?+partner) earn.

I was never charged rent/keep etc would just seem absurd to my parents. Now as adults, we happily contribute financially if they ever need it.

No DC yet but I can't imagine I will ever charge them (fortunately have a decent income).

I had friends who did pay rent/keep though which I totally understand especially as they often outearned one of their parents. E.g 18 year old working fulling time in a high street shop compared to mother who works part time as a carer.

I think its very situational!

qualitygirl · 20/05/2021 13:52

12k is not a good wage!! we pay our apprentices over 25k plus benefits.

I personally could never charge a 17 year old rent. Nor would I take it and save it for them (unless they wanted me too) ...I would just insist that they save a portion themselves. They need to get a sense of their own money in a way...charging them rent is pointless as there's no real repercussions if they don't pay is there, you are hardly going to kick them out!

Sheerheight · 20/05/2021 13:51

I agree it will be seen as unfair. I wouldn't charge your dd if you can afford not to.

LolaSmiles · 20/05/2021 13:50

I offered to pay for things and they refused as their logic was we are your parents - you save for YOUR future
I wish mine did that. Mine expected full board off me, knowing local rent prices were prohibitively high for a training salary. Other siblings have had periods living at home rent free or were funded through university.
They retired early and now complain to me that they have no money. Hmm

LigPatin · 20/05/2021 13:50

Like every other student he will need to get a job to cover his expenses.
If his maintenance grant only covers 2/3 of his rent, he needs to find somewhere cheaper.

Serenity45 · 20/05/2021 13:50

My friend was in this position OP. She was the younger daughter. Her sister (one year older) went off to uni and my friend got onto a YTS after 6th form college (showing our age now!), which was a very low wage. She found out that her parents (pretty comfortably off, large house though not wealthy) were essentially giving the exact amount she paid for keep to her sister.

It did breed huge resentment from her. She and her sister don't have a great relationship for a number of reasons tbh, but she has always felt aggrieved by how this was handled. So not advice as such but I think open conversations need to be had and your reasoning behind your decision transparent. Because at the end of the day it IS your decision and your home / family dynamic to manage. Good luck!

Bumzoo · 20/05/2021 13:48

No way I would take money off my DC at 17. I think you've going to end up with a load of resentment towards you and her brother who isn't paying.