Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

One at Uni, one at work…

937 replies

BelleClapper · 20/05/2021 12:23

How do you square this without causing resentment?

Dd (17) is working full time on an apprenticeship course. We are charging her rent/keep/petrol equivalent to 25% of her take home.

DS (18) up until now was planning to leave college and get a job. He announced yesterday that he is now accepting the three University offers he got a while back. As an aside he’s just split up with his GF of two years who was absolutely definitely in no way the reason he wasn’t going…

So we will be in a position of taking money from DD and sending money to DS. Which has totally changed the dynamic. I’m really conscious of causing resentment from DD who already suffers a bit with middle child syndrome and jealousy.

If you’ve been in this situation what did you do? I want DD to contribute for lots of reasons, none of which go away just because DS now needs three more years of support.

OP posts:
FreekStar · 20/05/2021 14:20

Perhaps you could call the money a loan to your DS? With the intention he pays you back when he is earning.

UhtredRagnarson · 20/05/2021 14:19

Sorry, you think we should drive her to and from work, 10hrs driving each week, so she can earn money, and not charge her for petrol?

Will you transport your son to university? Will you pay his train fare home at Xmas, Easter, summer when he calls and says he hasn’t the money for it? He’s in education to give him a chance of earning well in later years. Your daughter is in education for the same reason but has been smart enough to do it so she can earn now as well. Perhaps you will send him a train fare reimbursement invoice in 5 years when he is earning to pay for all the transport you covered while he was in education?

OunceOfFlounce · 20/05/2021 14:17

@Hardbackwriter

People don't seem to be doing this for DS, going to uni. I mean, it would be possible for him to go out to work and earn his uni fees first but (quite rightly) no one is comparing his situation to how he'd have to cope if he was an independent adult with no parents to rely on.

He'd actually be a lot better off if he were being assessed as an independent adult as he'd get the full maintenance loan.

Problem solved! Wink
RedMarauder · 20/05/2021 14:17

OP you are treating them equally as their circumstances are different.

Also be aware that your DD could actually do a degree later on. I've worked with people who have done apprenticeships and done so.

bruffin · 20/05/2021 14:17

*So we will be in a position of taking money from DD and sending money to DS.
We are effectively doing that at the moment. DS has a good job and very well paid and we basically send the £200 a month he gives us to dd, but ds did go to uni for 2 years so we gave him the same £200 when he was there.
However if you DD is only 17 i wouldnt be taking 25% of her wages

Your DS should be getting a part time job to make up any shortfall
Depends on the course. DDs course includes a 1000 hours placement, with 9 to 5 for months at a time. She could not take on a regular job . She has been able to get work since her final placement for 12 hours a week and she has always worked in holidays .
DS was a qualified lifeguard and worked doing that through uni.
We basically paid their food and mobile phone and to learn to drive.

BelleClapper · 20/05/2021 14:16

@Viviennemary

It would be cheeky. Yo are using your DD's wages to subsidise your DS at uni. Not on.
Well this was my initial reaction too. But it’s actually more complex than that.

I’m going to treat the two situations as separate, which they are.

OP posts:
SofiaMichelle · 20/05/2021 14:16

MN is the wrong place to ask such a question OP.

You'll get ridiculous answers from people who think their offspring can't possibly be expected to pay for part of their upkeep, how they'd never be so mean to their precious children, etc., etc.

Back in the real world it's not at all unreasonable to expect a contribution towards upkeep from someone in the household who's earning a decent wage.

It's bizarre here at times. There are threads where 16yos are too old for parents to have any input at all into how they behave and where they go, and others where people advocate treating them as children until they're well in their mid-20s.

Ivy48 · 20/05/2021 14:16

That’s your sons choice. I’m sorry but you either stop charging her and give you son money (if you give him £200 a month and don’t charge her rent then it’s fair etc). But that’s like taking out of your daughters pocket and putting it in his. He’ll have to get a job otherwise. You can’t charge her but sub him that’s awful

Laiste · 20/05/2021 14:15

@Comefromaway

People are talking like going to university to do a degree is a bad thing?
No one is saying going to uni is a bad thing. But i don't think it should be held up as more worthy of a parents financial support than another path.

You have to look at it with a parent's hat on. In the here and now, which is where resentment is or isn't built. Not in 10 years which is hindsight which is too late.

I wouldn't want to stop any of my kids going to uni, but i couldn't pay for one's roof while charging the other.

What they are doing under their respective roof, be it working for a living or learning for a living, shouldn't change anything imo.

Viviennemary · 20/05/2021 14:15

It would be cheeky. Yo are using your DD's wages to subsidise your DS at uni. Not on.

Notaroadrunner · 20/05/2021 14:14

I didn't go to college, started working in late teens. My siblings went to uni. I have no idea what or if my parents gave them. It was none of my business. I decided uni wasn't for me - my choice to go and work. I wasn't living at home but if I was I'm certain I wouldn't have been allowed to stay for free.

There may come a time when your dd will be out of work and need a bit of help, while your Ds will have a job and not need a penny from you. So for now, I would keep charging dd and say nothing about what Ds is getting from you. She has chosen a different path so she has no reason to be be annoyed if you are funding Ds. As for Ds, I'd give him what he needs for accommodation and food but as for socialising - that's for him to fund.

BelleClapper · 20/05/2021 14:14

I left home/was kicked out (my parents and I disagree on the circumstances of this) at just turned 16. It wasn’t fun.

I absolutely would never ask any of mine to leave before they wanted to, or could. But I am a firm believer in paying your way and having responsibilities.

OP posts:
Hardbackwriter · 20/05/2021 14:12

People don't seem to be doing this for DS, going to uni. I mean, it would be possible for him to go out to work and earn his uni fees first but (quite rightly) no one is comparing his situation to how he'd have to cope if he was an independent adult with no parents to rely on.

He'd actually be a lot better off if he were being assessed as an independent adult as he'd get the full maintenance loan.

nokidshere · 20/05/2021 14:12

When my eldest started at uni we were both working full time so he only qualified for approx 5k maintenance loan. His uni halls were 6.5k and we were expected to make up the difference and help out with living costs to top up his part time job.

By the time my second went (older one was in 2nd yr) we were both retired and on a much lower income so they each qualified for the full 9k loan, they both had part time jobs and managed without any topping up from us.

They are both adults, they understand that circumstances aren't the same. When my oldest finishes uni next month and gets a job he will be expected to pay his share of household costs, the younger one won't until he finishes and is also working. He doesn't feel hard done to because we gave money to his brother for a year. The older one won't feel aggrieved because he's contributing and his brother won't be.

However, I've always told them that they have to contribute when they are working, it's not a surprise to them and they fully understand the cost of running a home will be part of their responsibility as well as paying for their own lifestyle.

I see nothing wrong with the op's scenario.

OunceOfFlounce · 20/05/2021 14:10

@BelleClapper

Ok so a few things.

DD is working full time, earning a full time salary. She is also earning a qualification. She’s not on a reduced salary or part time.

DH and I drive her to and from work, 10hrs driving a week, actual petrol costs c£100.

Either DH or I cook a proper dinner every evening. We have a once a week takeaway that we pay for for everybody.

I pay for her phone because it’s all on my contract. We have high speed internet, full sky tv package, Netflix, Amazon prime.

She has a large double bedroom and shares a bathroom with her siblings. Regularly entertains her friends here. Will be walking around with the best part of £750pm.

DS will be (hopefully) going away to Uni potentially six hrs away. He’ll be in halls, so a single room with shared facilities. He’ll be studying full time. No luxury tv packages, no home cooked meals, or free takeaways, money will be tight.

I’ve thought it through and DD has by far the better deal!

Do you worry you're spoiling her, OP? Would you consider asking her to move out?
nancywhitehead · 20/05/2021 14:10

@BelleClapper

Ok so a few things.

DD is working full time, earning a full time salary. She is also earning a qualification. She’s not on a reduced salary or part time.

DH and I drive her to and from work, 10hrs driving a week, actual petrol costs c£100.

Either DH or I cook a proper dinner every evening. We have a once a week takeaway that we pay for for everybody.

I pay for her phone because it’s all on my contract. We have high speed internet, full sky tv package, Netflix, Amazon prime.

She has a large double bedroom and shares a bathroom with her siblings. Regularly entertains her friends here. Will be walking around with the best part of £750pm.

DS will be (hopefully) going away to Uni potentially six hrs away. He’ll be in halls, so a single room with shared facilities. He’ll be studying full time. No luxury tv packages, no home cooked meals, or free takeaways, money will be tight.

I’ve thought it through and DD has by far the better deal!

Ok but what's your point?

Once your children reach adulthood they are really making their own decisions and you can no longer enforce equality between them.

Do you think she needs to learn something? Is she immature or irresponsible with her money? Do you think she'll struggle in future if you don't teach her what the world is like by starting to charge her rent?

If she's a mature, sensible young adult then I just don't know why you would take money from her if you don't actually need the contribution.

Hardbackwriter · 20/05/2021 14:09

@Comefromaway

People are talking like going to university to do a degree is a bad thing?
They really are. You'd think that the DS had announced he was becoming a drug dealer and the OP was giving him seed money for it from the way people are talking! There's a weird resentment of the idea that the DS will have things 'easy' by going to university.
Laiste · 20/05/2021 14:06

@UhtredRagnarson

I think you should provide them with the same. So if you’re covering DS’s accommodation then you shouldn’t be charging DD for hers. If you’re covering his food costs then you shouldn’t be charging DD for hers.
This.

If you want to treat them equally then the way to do it.

I agree with a pp that you're taking money from DD with one hand and giving it to DS with the other otherwise.

motogogo · 20/05/2021 14:06

Oh and remind your dd that at some point she might decide she wants to go to university, lots go much later these days

BigSandyBalls2015 · 20/05/2021 14:05

I have twins, one at uni, one working. We don't charge the working one as we are supporting her sister through uni and it doesn't seem fair. She does buy the odd meal/bottle of wine/takeaway, but it wouldn't feel right to charge her rent at the moment. That will change when her sister gets a full time job.

Comefromaway · 20/05/2021 14:04

People are talking like going to university to do a degree is a bad thing?

Hardbackwriter · 20/05/2021 14:04

@Bluedeblue

I can't believe that two siblings who are in education or training are being treated so unequally

Because their situations are different. The Ops son will most likely leave Uni with a minimum £27k debt (if he does a 3 year course). The Ops daughter will have no debt. Should the Op pay off the son's debt, so that they are both even? Even, in so much as both children have no debt. But wait...then Op will have given her DS £27k and not given her DD a lump sum. How do you square that circle?

I think this is the fundamental divide, which is why people disagree so much on this - whether you're trying to give to them equally or to give them equal outcomes. My parents gave according to need - so I was supported through uni, a masters and they paid my first rent deposit; my brother lived at home rent-free for years, they put a lot of money in when he started his own business and I think they may still give him some financial support now. To me this seems appropriate and fair, even if the amounts don't even out exactly, but in other families it would be outrageous because the key thing is that the parents give exactly the same amount of money to each. That would have left me unable to eat at university and my brother unable to start a business (or would have involved giving us each random cash lump sums), which seems nonsensical to me.
OlivesTree · 20/05/2021 14:04

Ah, I’ve just read your update. Her deal is even better than I thought! She’ll never move out at this rate! Grin
OP I think you’re being equally generous and fair and making her take on financial responsibilities is good for her.

motogogo · 20/05/2021 14:04

I wouldn't take money from an apprentice but would put that money into an account for when she leaves home/goes to university

Francescaisstressed · 20/05/2021 14:04

I had the same type of issue with my siblings growing up. I chose to go to university which my parents helped to fund, they chose to work and stay at home and had to pay rent.
At the time I didn't even think about it, as it was my parents decision but if we argue it is routinely thrown in my face that I'm the favourite and that I had it easier than they did. Looking back, I can see why they might feel that way and it does bother me that they feel they got an unfair deal.
Theybdo forget other loans (that were never paid back) etc.
I don't think you can expect one to pay and fund the other, unless you explain the money given to the one going to uni is a loan, and you expect it back or that the other is for savings and she'll get it back.
Alternatively, you say if your in full time education you will find, but tbh an apprenticeship is education and she isn't getting a full salary so you are in an awkward position.

Swipe left for the next trending thread