Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

One at Uni, one at work…

937 replies

BelleClapper · 20/05/2021 12:23

How do you square this without causing resentment?

Dd (17) is working full time on an apprenticeship course. We are charging her rent/keep/petrol equivalent to 25% of her take home.

DS (18) up until now was planning to leave college and get a job. He announced yesterday that he is now accepting the three University offers he got a while back. As an aside he’s just split up with his GF of two years who was absolutely definitely in no way the reason he wasn’t going…

So we will be in a position of taking money from DD and sending money to DS. Which has totally changed the dynamic. I’m really conscious of causing resentment from DD who already suffers a bit with middle child syndrome and jealousy.

If you’ve been in this situation what did you do? I want DD to contribute for lots of reasons, none of which go away just because DS now needs three more years of support.

OP posts:
BelleClapper · 03/06/2021 14:21

@Whatafuss

"Petrol to take her to work and back (this is a totally separate journey from any other school run/commute so easy to work out) = £100pm.

Mobile phone contract = £25pm.

That leaves £125 per calendar month which is £28 a week ‘keep’."

Utterly disgusting to be keeping tabs in your daughters every step and bite of food. You must realise you're a parent and keeping her fed is your responsibility. Or are you impoverished in which case you'd have an excuse? While you're at it, why don't you backcharge her for breast milk? Lost for words.

I’m what way am I keeping tabs? Are you seriously suggesting I should be out of pocket to get her to work and have an iPhone while she has £1k a month spending money?

I mean, what the actual fuck are you talking about?

People on here are just making shit up now.

Would you be happier if I made her get taxis both ways? Because that would be her entire income. Or do you seriously believe I should be sucking up the extra petrol costs so the poor lamb can keep all her hard earned money?

OP posts:
Whatafuss · 03/06/2021 13:49

"Petrol to take her to work and back (this is a totally separate journey from any other school run/commute so easy to work out) = £100pm.

Mobile phone contract = £25pm.

That leaves £125 per calendar month which is £28 a week ‘keep’."

Utterly disgusting to be keeping tabs in your daughters every step and bite of food. You must realise you're a parent and keeping her fed is your responsibility. Or are you impoverished in which case you'd have an excuse? While you're at it, why don't you backcharge her for breast milk? Lost for words.

Carishina · 03/06/2021 12:55

I think your approach sounds fine to me. Your DS will need support at university and I don’t think him finding a part time job can be guaranteed (and in any case he may not be able to work that many hours if he’s in a demanding course). Presumably you’ll review the situation if your DD decides to go to university?

BelleClapper · 03/06/2021 12:40

Btw if anyone’s found this thread via the article in the Sun, DD isn’t ‘fuming’, they literally made that up out of nothing.

She’s happy, DS is happy, everyone’s happy.

OP posts:
Hockney236 · 03/06/2021 12:27

@tttigress

Haven't read the whole thread, but I do feel a bit sorry for your daughter.

It is not as if "going to Uni" is something special anymore. In fact your son might be doing it for fun rather than to get a serious qualification.

I agree with this. All of the kids I know who are going to uni just seem to see it as a bit of a doss for 3 years. It’s a rite of passage now, I admire your daughter for doing something useful
Nic19832502 · 03/06/2021 12:23

If that’s how it works out for your Daughter then that is good if she is paying about the right amount but if you give your son money when in all honest he shouldn’t need any then you should deduct the same amount from your daughters rent to keep it fair if you think you are getting a bashing then you probably already feel that you are being unreasonable yourself but that doesn’t mean you are, as parents it’s hard to get the balance right, but if your Daughter feels badly done too then break down the cost for example the commute if she didn’t have you what would it cost I.e. taxis, public transport etc let her see the true cost, the mobile phone let her manage the cost of that too when she is 18 let her take over her bill that will teach her how to budget etc, my mum always said to me and my brother that if we are in education then we don’t pay rent but as soon as we leave that we would have too and that is fair but I think you need to consider your daughter being in education, apprenticeships are hard and the work that has to be put into the qualification side is just as important as doing the working side as well. When I was around your Daughters age mobile phones had not been out long and the first real smart phones where only just starting to come out and if I wanted one then I had to pay for it myself.

tttigress · 03/06/2021 12:01

Haven't read the whole thread, but I do feel a bit sorry for your daughter.

It is not as if "going to Uni" is something special anymore. In fact your son might be doing it for fun rather than to get a serious qualification.

BelleClapper · 03/06/2021 12:00

In case you don’t want to read the whole thread:

Petrol to take her to work and back (this is a totally separate journey from any other school run/commute so easy to work out) = £100pm.

Mobile phone contract = £25pm.

That leaves £125 per calendar month which is £28 a week ‘keep’.

Which doesn’t even begin to cover food let alone anything else.

I hope that clarifies things for anyone still queuing up to batter me.

OP posts:
BelleClapper · 03/06/2021 11:53

Oh good, so you agree with me then.

DD is paying just enough to cover food and living costs, as worked out upthread. And DS will be working to support himself through university, with support from us as needed.

Glad that’s all cleared up.

OP posts:
Nic19832502 · 03/06/2021 11:49

Your Daughter is still in education as she is completing an apprenticeship, and if she is 17 would have had to choose an apprenticeship or other further education, your Son has decided to go to uni and unless he is doing something that is difficult and requires more than the usual study time he can get a part time job to support himself through uni I worked in a supermarket other friends worked in restaurants, we didn’t rely on the bank of mum and dad or sister in this case to fund the rest of our lifestyles making him get a job whilst at uni would support him more in the long run as he will appreciate that things are not just handed to you and you have to work for your privilege, I think charging your Daughter a nominal rent is good as it will help her budget/save but you shouldn’t take anymore than to cover food and living costs etc

BelleClapper · 03/06/2021 10:26

Eh?

OP posts:
Nic19832502 · 03/06/2021 10:20

Wow, I’d be pissed if I was your DD 25% of take home pay for rent if she is on 12,000 per year even the government isn’t taking any money from her if you think your DS shouldn’t pay rent and you are sending him money whilst at Uni then you shouldn’t expect your DD to pay either an apprenticeship is education and unless your DS is studying to become something specific I.e. doctor/lawyer then he should get a part time/weekend job to make up any gap between his student loan and his other bills you are teaching one Child financial responsibility very harshly and the other one not at all, a degree isn’t always better or harder than an apprenticeship

HoneyDragon · 03/06/2021 10:16

MN has really moved on I see. I created an account because of the marvellous camaraderie and gratuitous swearing.

BelleClapper · 03/06/2021 08:37

Also I think people are missing the point that DS will be taking out loans, we’re not fully funding him through Uni (that would be batshit).

So he is already contributing at least three times as much as DD.

But that doesn’t really fit the narrative of how terrible I am so it’s been ignored.

OP posts:
SwimBaby · 03/06/2021 07:11

Ignore the haters OP, it’s natural you questioned your decisions but I think you are doing the right thing and you do do that all that matters. My suggestion would be to use some of the £250 per month to help your DD learn to drive. Sorry if you are already doing this, I have read nearly all the posts but may have missed this.
If your DS doesn’t manage to get a holiday job he could do lots of jobs in the house to make life easier for the rest of you who are earning.

BelleClapper · 03/06/2021 06:51

I can’t believe you went to all the effort of joining MN to post that without actually reading the thread.

-he will be working

-I’ve never said ‘just an apprenticeship’

-I’m not taking from her to give to him

-I’ve no idea why I keep responding to this thread.

OP posts:
Eyeroll123 · 03/06/2021 02:43

I literally created an account because of this post.
What you are thinking of doing is so messed up. You clearly favor son or you'd have consistent expectations for your children.
While it's "just an apprenticeship" to you, what your daughter is ACTUALLY doing is learning her education WHILE working. If expectations were fair and equal your son would also be working to cover his bills. I hate when idiotic people don't value those who work and gain an education because they feel it's not the same "value" as going to university. Also, 12k isn't alot, considered poverty level in most places. They are both gaining an education, in fact you daughters doing more, but yet you want to take from her and give to him.
Slow handclap for the misogyny going on in your household 🙄
Do it for both or don't do it at all, unless you don't want a relationship with your daughter in the future

HoneyDragon · 02/06/2021 21:38

Whoops, sorry I was laughing so hard I bolded instead of creepy wee bracketed.

HoneyDragon · 02/06/2021 21:37

ILLEGAL sniggers

Caps lock makes it true.

Kblack · 02/06/2021 21:12

I have a few questions that I didn't see answered earlier. Did your son work and contribute before going to university? If not than I think that it is a double standard. When your daughter goes to university (if she chooses to) will you also support her? If you do not plan on helping your daughter but only giving her contributions you your son for support then I would say that it is an extremely unfair situation for your daughter and will definitely cause resentment that could be very long lasting. If you don't need her money for household bills, why not place it in a savings account for when she moves out or for her future home purchase or possible wedding. There are tons of options to teach her responsibility without making her feel used. And I would definitely feel used if I was contributing just for the money to go to someone who hasn't contributed.

RoSEbuds6 · 02/06/2021 18:43

I think you’ve been through the mill on this thread OP, my comment would be to trust yourself to know your children best and treat them appropriately.

BelleClapper · 02/06/2021 17:40

I’m just waiting for my invite on This Morning or Loose Women or the like.

OP posts:
BelleClapper · 02/06/2021 17:31

@Eilethya

Think this has been picked up by a tabloid
Yeah it was in the DM the other day. Hilariously bad maths and all.
OP posts:
Eilethya · 02/06/2021 17:30

Think this has been picked up by a tabloid

BelleClapper · 02/06/2021 17:30

What is actually wrong with you?

Can you just not read? Or is it massive massive projection?

OP posts: