Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

One at Uni, one at work…

937 replies

BelleClapper · 20/05/2021 12:23

How do you square this without causing resentment?

Dd (17) is working full time on an apprenticeship course. We are charging her rent/keep/petrol equivalent to 25% of her take home.

DS (18) up until now was planning to leave college and get a job. He announced yesterday that he is now accepting the three University offers he got a while back. As an aside he’s just split up with his GF of two years who was absolutely definitely in no way the reason he wasn’t going…

So we will be in a position of taking money from DD and sending money to DS. Which has totally changed the dynamic. I’m really conscious of causing resentment from DD who already suffers a bit with middle child syndrome and jealousy.

If you’ve been in this situation what did you do? I want DD to contribute for lots of reasons, none of which go away just because DS now needs three more years of support.

OP posts:
UhtredRagnarson · 20/05/2021 14:53

OP have you said yet what your sons degree course is?

Bluedeblue · 20/05/2021 14:52

It would be cheeky. Yo are using your DD's wages to subsidise your DS at uni. Not on

What? You could literally say that about anything the Op spends money on.

By this reckoning, Op decides to book a week in Spain = Ops DD is paying for her Mum to go to Spain! Gasp!

Makes no sense. She's 17 and working. She pays board.

Things won't always be equal. My DD needed extra tuition in one subject @ £27 per week. My DS didn't. I didn't give my DS the same amount in cash. My DS played sport, my DD didn't. So what?

CaMePlaitPas · 20/05/2021 14:50

I wouldn't be taking any money out of a 17 year old's pocket OP, it's not like she could be living elsewhere with a rent contract considering she's a child.

OwlBeThere · 20/05/2021 14:49

I would resent you too if I was her.

BiBabbles · 20/05/2021 14:48

At 17 & 18, talking with them both and work through options and concerns if there are any is probably the best way to square it. Different people will view it all differently. My 16yo DS isn't resentful when we discussed and agreed that a certain amount of his money goes on household buying, some on his own bills, some on his transport needs, and so on, but I know others with similar age teenagers who get very resentful about some of those.

I wouldn't recommend going in with how DD is 'actually better off'. I don't see how framing the situation that way is going to help prevent resentment and jealousy or do much expect maybe assuage some parental guilt. It's possible the DD has no issue with it and those feelings come from previous things.

I was very envious of my older brother growing up for so many reasons, but - as much as some people thought otherwise as it was a very visible difference between us - I never had any issues with my brother getting cars even when he was on his fourth when I was 17 because I didn't want to drive, I hated driving and his car fiascos only strengthened my idea that it was more trouble than it was worth even if he got way more spent on him for all those cars and repairs and insurance than I did for a bus pass. That was never an issue, we chose two very different options and had very different needs, but it would have been really annoying if I was told I was better off for having chosen the less expensive option. Balance things how it suits, but it should be about making things work well for them, not who comes out better. No one but them is going to be able to make those sort of comparison in any sort of way that means anything to them.

greenwichvillage · 20/05/2021 14:48

I'm shocked at the amount of posts being surprised that DC being charged rent on a £1k take home pay.
I have 2 kids both at uni, me and my dh have always made it clear to them that when they start working they need to contribute to the house. Whether we use the money to pay the bill or save it for them till a later date is neither here nor there, (we probably will save it for them but we certainly won't be telling them that). What's more important is that they understand the value of money. They need to understand that not everything is handed on a plate, that running a house costs money. Both my DH and I grew up contributing to the family expense pot and it didn't do us any harm, infact it made us more money savvy.
The DD in question will still have £750.00 a month with which she can do what she likes, a lot more than people who rent or pay a mortgage have left over at the end of the month.
I know I will be advising my kids to use the 25:35:40 rule. % towards keep, 40% to use as they wish and 35% to go towards savings.

Phphion · 20/05/2021 14:48

I would think of it like this:

Each of your children has 'income' from an external source (loan for DS that he is given on condition of doing his university work, wages for DD that she is given on condition of doing her apprenticeship work).

From this income, they must pay for all their outgoings - rent, bills and other expenses.

The market cost of these outgoings is, e.g. £1000 pcm.

Your DS is using all his income to pay for his outgoings and receives £100 pcm from you to enable him to pay the market rate for his outgoings.

Your DD is using one quarter of her income to pay for her outgoings and receives £750 pcm from you as a gift in kind matched against the market rate for things you provide to her that she would otherwise have to pay the market rate for.

She is, in fact, getting considerably more absolute value from you than he is.

Chewbecca · 20/05/2021 14:47

My sibling went to Uni, I did not. I paid (very low) keep to my parents whilst they were sent cash. It didn’t and doesn’t bother me at all, it was perfectly logical.

I bought a property much earlier than my sibling and my parents helped me out with that. They there helped my sibling out financial during a divorce.

My point is, my parents have helped us when we needed it. That has been uneven. I’m good with that.

Bibidy · 20/05/2021 14:47

@PaperbackRider

The one at home is being supported by only being charged a fraction of the costs of housing, food and transportation

She's 17. She shouldn't be paying anything, her parents are obliged to maintain the minors in their care.

Come on, loads of kids that age pay some board to their parents to get them used to paying their way.

Tbh I think it doesn't matter how old someone is, once they are working full-time their parents are within their rights to ask for a contribution if they want to.

Popsicle30 · 20/05/2021 14:47

I don't think there is an easy answer to this but I do think it's worth pointing out that your DD does have a job with training, so she is continuing her education too.

However, she is also earning and I think it's an important lesson to learn how to manage money and budget as soon as you start earning, including saving money. So it could be, as others have said a way to save for your DD too.

Depending on her area of apprenticeship, the opportunities available with her employer/sector of work she may progress to a higher level in her apprenticeship including degree level. The work experience, skills, knowledge plus the qualifications she will gain will hopefully provide some good career opportunities, plus no student debt! Maybe there are degree apprenticeship opportunities in the area your DS is looking at?Just a thought.

I think it's getting that balance and being open and transparent with them both so they understand. Good luck!

Youcunnyfunt · 20/05/2021 14:47

You sound like a good mum, BelleClapper. It doesn't sound like either of your kids are missing out. You're supporting them both. £250 is nothing, plus it's the life lesson.
University is hard even getting minimal support from parents, so your boy isn't getting an easy ride compared to his sister.

LadyMacbethWasMisunderstood · 20/05/2021 14:46

I absolutely would not charge her rent whilst giving your son money. Whatever the good reasons may be why you want(ed) to have her pay keep they cannot, in my view, I overcome the huge sense of injustice she will feel if this arrangement continues once your son goes to uni.

Tell her you are going to save her “keep” for her. Or just don’t take it at all. The sense of wrong she will likely feel could have serious consequences for your relationship.

I assume, if you are taking a quarter of her take home pay, then this will be a sum that comes some good way to being what you will be paying to your son. You won’t be able to avoid the inference that she is working to support her brother. That’s unfair, not a good message to be sending any young woman of today and could do damage not only to your relationship but the sibling one too.

I have also to say that, unless money is so tight it’s unavoidable, I really dislike taking money from actual children for their “keep” and/or from those still in training or education. But I know that is not what you asked.

I am also the parent of 3 (20,16 and 10). I am acutely aware of how badly my (absolutely lovely and generous hearted) DD2 would feel about such a plan were it ever to be implemented in our house.

Hardbackwriter · 20/05/2021 14:46

It's a combination. Yes she is earning, but she would be earning more working in a supermarket, therefore the lower wage is partly because its an apprentiship. I missed the fact she is only 17 as well, I think that's pretty savage personally.

A 17 year old would absolutely not be earning more than £12k working in a supermarket

Dora33 · 20/05/2021 14:46

@a8mint

I can only imagine the 'he needs to get himself a pt job' brigade, have been humanities graduates who swan in for only a few hours a week. Many courses just do not allow a student to have the availability to do that, many university towns don't have enough of the kind of termtime jobs a student could do.As for tutoring, universities arrange for their students to do tutoring for free so that they have some experience if they want to apply for a phd. I don't think there would be a market for anyone who charged!
Would have loved to do some swanning around but I worked weekends while doing a degree that I attended college 9-5pm. Often stayed late to use facilities while working on projects.
DreamingNow · 20/05/2021 14:46

@BelleClapper

I’m also doing an apprenticeship. It’s very definitely work and not education.
The i think you’ve missed the whole point of doing an apprenticeship!!

Apprenticeship is about learning first and foremost. Learning on the job and getting support from other people in your company. You end up with a qualification.
And yes you are working too because that’s how you are learning. But working isn’t the main aim.

UhtredRagnarson · 20/05/2021 14:46

But I am a firm believer in paying your way and having responsibilities.

Just for the one child though. Not both.

WithIcePlease · 20/05/2021 14:46

DD will clear over £900 a month. I'd be sitting down with her and discussing regular savings accounts, how much she needs for 'fun' and petrol etc and maybe when she sees how much she can put aside and see it grow it may stem any resentment as DS will be left with debt
It depends on the individual child. My DD 22 will be on a decent wage soon but I'm not charging her living costs. She's a frugal soul, not a drinker or party girl She gets her own groceries and petrol, exercise classes and I'll be happy to see her pile money into savings for her future. If she were a spendthrift, I'd definitely charge her rent though so that she'd learn some sense about money

Budapestdreams · 20/05/2021 14:46

If you top your son's maintenance loan up to 9k (which is the full amount) then he basically has 9k a year.

Your daughter earns 12k a year.

She is still better off, although you take 3k rent (a fair amount I think) so she also ends up with 9k.

Difference is that her 9k is all spending money. His is for rent etc too.

Present it to her purely as how much money they both have.

BelleClapper · 20/05/2021 14:46

Again, she wouldn’t be earning more in a supermarket because she is actually earning 125% of minimum wage.

OP posts:
lakesidelife · 20/05/2021 14:45

I went at 17, perfectly normal in Scotland.

Fishandhips · 20/05/2021 14:44

@lakesidelife

She's 17. She shouldn't be paying anything,

This is nonsense as any student will tell you, they get charged for accommodation, have to pay for their own food etc.

The difference is that the 17 year old is paying a fraction of the true costs and the student is paying the full whack.

Which is why even with parental support the student will have debts.

How many University students do you know who are 17?
Bluedeblue · 20/05/2021 14:44

So, if they both live at home in 4 years time, and Op's DS earns £70k and her DD earns £15k, they should both pay the exact same amount of board then?

DreamingNow · 20/05/2021 14:44

If i was your dd I would be resentful of the fact that I am paying and my brother isnt.

If you want to be fair, you need to be sure you are giving the same support to all of your dcs.
Whatever you are laying to your dc1, you should give the same to all your other dcs incl your dd.
It’s not because one of them is starting to earn money earlier than the others that they should pay the price for it. Working instead of 3 years having fun and little responsibility etc... and on the top of it also having to pay their way....

Fishandhips · 20/05/2021 14:43

@BelleClapper

I’m also doing an apprenticeship. It’s very definitely work and not education.
It's a combination. Yes she is earning, but she would be earning more working in a supermarket, therefore the lower wage is partly because its an apprentiship. I missed the fact she is only 17 as well, I think that's pretty savage personally.
lakesidelife · 20/05/2021 14:43

She's 17. She shouldn't be paying anything,

This is nonsense as any student will tell you, they get charged for accommodation, have to pay for their own food etc.

The difference is that the 17 year old is paying a fraction of the true costs and the student is paying the full whack.

Which is why even with parental support the student will have debts.

Swipe left for the next trending thread