Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

One at Uni, one at work…

937 replies

BelleClapper · 20/05/2021 12:23

How do you square this without causing resentment?

Dd (17) is working full time on an apprenticeship course. We are charging her rent/keep/petrol equivalent to 25% of her take home.

DS (18) up until now was planning to leave college and get a job. He announced yesterday that he is now accepting the three University offers he got a while back. As an aside he’s just split up with his GF of two years who was absolutely definitely in no way the reason he wasn’t going…

So we will be in a position of taking money from DD and sending money to DS. Which has totally changed the dynamic. I’m really conscious of causing resentment from DD who already suffers a bit with middle child syndrome and jealousy.

If you’ve been in this situation what did you do? I want DD to contribute for lots of reasons, none of which go away just because DS now needs three more years of support.

OP posts:
UhtredRagnarson · 20/05/2021 15:13

One of your children has chosen to skip university and do an apprenticeship instead.

Or one of them has chosen to skip an apprenticeship and do university instead.

user1497207191 · 20/05/2021 15:11

@BelleClapper Maintenance grant will only cover two thirds of rent, for a start.

So why doesn't he get a part time job to earn the shortfall. It's what most Uni students do

drumandthebass · 20/05/2021 15:10

I agree with others about saving the money for her that she pays you

Summersnake · 20/05/2021 15:10

25%
Fucks sake
I’d only do that if we were about to be made homeless

Pinkpaisley · 20/05/2021 15:09

I am going to admit upfront that in my social group and DD’s school in particular, a path other than university is extremely rare.

You aren’t treating them unfairly. One of your children has chosen to skip university and do an apprenticeship instead. That was the child’s choice and it means it is time to start paying for at least a portion of living expenses. Your other child is still in traditional education and you have a moral responsibility to provide financial support.

Comefromaway · 20/05/2021 15:09

@DeadlyMedally

University students can travel from home, study close to home, work and get grants in addition to the loan that they can pay back when they are working. Your son has effectively chosen to be in a position where he requires your continued financial support and you haven't questioned that, which would be fine if it were equitable for your daughter. Without doing any calcs, I'm guessing £12k per month is less than minimum wage. If you want her to learn to save, buy her a book on basic personal finance. There is much more to it that having money taken from you by your parents. If you make your daughter pay by her way during what is effectively education, yes, she's going to resent you.
It's considerably more than minimum wage for a 17 year old.
Ohtheplacesyougo · 20/05/2021 15:09

Give your daughter the money back when she leaves home. Taught her a life lesson and not being unfair.

DeadlyMedally · 20/05/2021 15:08

@LunarSea

Our 19 year old living at home student with a job too pays £200 / month food and board - which actually goes into a help to buy ISA for him (so potentially 25% bonus on that if he eventually uses it towards a house/flat). He's "paying" in terms of committing that much income each month, but we are don't derive any benefit from it.
Even in cases like this, your son would likely get a greater benefit from being taught the value if an isa (H2B or otherwise) and allowed to make a conscious decision to save and invest himself. You're not really teaching anything.
OunceOfFlounce · 20/05/2021 15:07

@a8mint

...and as for choose a cheaper university! What sort of parent would encourage their child to turn down say Durham and go to Bolton instead
I think it's because the 'if she's earning she should contribute' perspective is viewing DD's choice of training in terms of monetary value, people are applying the same perspective to DS's choice.
ClawedButler · 20/05/2021 15:06

Tricky, but she's only 17, she's a child in my eyes. There's plenty of time for tough life lessons.

And charging one rent and subsidising the other could very well give the message that you think university is better than an apprenticeship, and that she is worth less to you. That isn't how you see it, of course, but you can surely understand that she might feel that way?

How about just asking for 1/3 of the groceries (presuming there's 3 of you in the house) but not charging rent? Charging a child rent does seam harsh to me.

DeadlyMedally · 20/05/2021 15:06

University students can travel from home, study close to home, work and get grants in addition to the loan that they can pay back when they are working.
Your son has effectively chosen to be in a position where he requires your continued financial support and you haven't questioned that, which would be fine if it were equitable for your daughter.
Without doing any calcs, I'm guessing £12k per month is less than minimum wage.
If you want her to learn to save, buy her a book on basic personal finance.
There is much more to it that having money taken from you by your parents.
If you make your daughter pay by her way during what is effectively education, yes, she's going to resent you.

Imworkingonit · 20/05/2021 15:06

We have almost this exact situation. DS is working full time and DD at uni. We take £250 a month rent from DS and fund DD so she has £100 a week to live on during term times. During holidays she works in her part time job but pays us no keep.

We take money from DS as we felt it was important for his sense of self worth. He takes pride in being a contributing member of the household and subsequently being viewed and treated as a functioning adult. He knows he will be supported if he chooses to access education and has recently started exploring internship options so a conversation may be had soon.

In the meantime he's happily saving for a new car whilst she's bemoaning at not having one at all and in true sibling fashion, he teases her he's paying towards her keep and she teases him he is still living at home with 'mummy and daddy'. They seem to both be taking it in their stride.

LunarSea · 20/05/2021 15:06

Our 19 year old living at home student with a job too pays £200 / month food and board - which actually goes into a help to buy ISA for him (so potentially 25% bonus on that if he eventually uses it towards a house/flat). He's "paying" in terms of committing that much income each month, but we are don't derive any benefit from it.

Comefromaway · 20/05/2021 15:05

The dd is earning. Child benefit rules make it absolutely clear that an apprentiship is on the job training, not further education.

UhtredRagnarson · 20/05/2021 15:03

I agree with @Usernameismyname01 - just have it as a clear rule, if you are earning you contribute, if you are in education, you don't.

So the DD is both earning and in education. How do you apply that rule?

Comefromaway · 20/05/2021 15:03

@CaMePlaitPas

I wouldn't be taking any money out of a 17 year old's pocket OP, it's not like she could be living elsewhere with a rent contract considering she's a child.
I know lots of 17 year olds living elsewhere in order to either study or work away from their home area.
lakesidelife · 20/05/2021 15:02

Actually to be fair I think OP would have to save the market rent for both dc and then give it back to both of them.
I'm not suggesting this, just to be clear.

But dd is getting the better deal financially. Which is fine because she has chosen that for herself. Ds has chosen a route with more short term pain but probably long term gain.

@fairynick student finances are set up with the expectation that better off parents support their dc to an extent. On top of that many students work depending on the type of course they do.

Comefromaway · 20/05/2021 15:02

@Changemusthappen

HRTHT - apprenticeship is training - maybe yours isn't but that's not right, you should be getting some training.

What will you do when your son has finished uni and comes home, possibly without a job. I assume you will support him?

I think the easiest way to do this is to say, right a degree course is 3 years. We will support all children for 3 years from 18-21 regardless of the route they choose. Afterall uni doesn't suit everyone and frankly is a waste of time for many.

For those who have said said that it's her choice not to go to uni. My brother went to uni, he was encouraged. I didn't want to go but wasn't encouraged anyway and yes, I do have middle child syndrome.

I would assume that if the ds comes home from uni without a job he will come home, claim the £70 per week Universal Credit whilst he is job hunting and pay board out of that.
a8mint · 20/05/2021 15:02

...and as for choose a cheaper university! What sort of parent would encourage their child to turn down say Durham and go to Bolton instead

BelleClapper · 20/05/2021 15:02

Apprenticeships are 80% work and 20% training.

OP posts:
fairynick · 20/05/2021 15:00

When my older brother was at home 18-23 he rarely paid rent. Would “forget” mum wouldn’t chase him, would just let him off.
I’m the middle child, and never missed a payment.
The youngest sibling got a full time job at 20 and refused to pay any rent as they were saving for uni rent. I also used my wage on uni rent.
Ultimately, it’s up to you. But it caused a lot of resentment from me to my mum for not standing up to my other siblings.
I don’t understand why you need to send your DS money - can he not get a job?

Bluedeblue · 20/05/2021 14:57

I'd save the money she gives you and give it to her when she is ready to move out as a best egg she has built up, and add in an equal amount of the same value that you are sending to DS to ensure it is fair

Only this would not be "fair", because Op would be giving her DD back her own money!! For it to be "fair", she'd have to give DD back her own money, plus the amount she'd given to DS over the years. Which quite frankly is bonkers.

notalwaysalondoner · 20/05/2021 14:57

I agree with @Usernameismyname01 - just have it as a clear rule, if you are earning you contribute, if you are in education, you don't.

I agree that there are good reasons to contribute, not least, an adult child not taking accommodation and bills for granted. I think you're doing the right thing - but you do need to probably address it head on when both of them are around, to avoid resentment or moaning. But present as a fait accompli - 'this is how it works around here' not a discussion. It's your house after all.

Fishandhips · 20/05/2021 14:55

@Hardbackwriter

It's a combination. Yes she is earning, but she would be earning more working in a supermarket, therefore the lower wage is partly because its an apprentiship. I missed the fact she is only 17 as well, I think that's pretty savage personally.

A 17 year old would absolutely not be earning more than £12k working in a supermarket

Yes they would, most supermarkets pay all staff the same regardless of age, and more than £5.77 an hour which is probably roughly what she is on it earns £12k per year. Whether a full time job is likely is another matter.
Changemusthappen · 20/05/2021 14:54

HRTHT - apprenticeship is training - maybe yours isn't but that's not right, you should be getting some training.

What will you do when your son has finished uni and comes home, possibly without a job. I assume you will support him?

I think the easiest way to do this is to say, right a degree course is 3 years. We will support all children for 3 years from 18-21 regardless of the route they choose. Afterall uni doesn't suit everyone and frankly is a waste of time for many.

For those who have said said that it's her choice not to go to uni. My brother went to uni, he was encouraged. I didn't want to go but wasn't encouraged anyway and yes, I do have middle child syndrome.

Swipe left for the next trending thread