Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

One at Uni, one at work…

937 replies

BelleClapper · 20/05/2021 12:23

How do you square this without causing resentment?

Dd (17) is working full time on an apprenticeship course. We are charging her rent/keep/petrol equivalent to 25% of her take home.

DS (18) up until now was planning to leave college and get a job. He announced yesterday that he is now accepting the three University offers he got a while back. As an aside he’s just split up with his GF of two years who was absolutely definitely in no way the reason he wasn’t going…

So we will be in a position of taking money from DD and sending money to DS. Which has totally changed the dynamic. I’m really conscious of causing resentment from DD who already suffers a bit with middle child syndrome and jealousy.

If you’ve been in this situation what did you do? I want DD to contribute for lots of reasons, none of which go away just because DS now needs three more years of support.

OP posts:
DreamingNow · 20/05/2021 15:39

Atm you are in a situation where

  • one child is giving you £200 per month
  • the other will be given money (how much? £200 more?)

Both are in education.

How is that fair? How is that your ds ‘paying his way’ too?

DreamingNow · 20/05/2021 15:38

@BelleClapper

Apprenticeships are 80% work and 20% training.
You are missing the point. Training isn’t just being in class. It also happens when you are on the job. The 80% job is training in the job. It’s still training. Hence why companies will not expect the same level or amount work done by an apprentice than someone on the job. Hence why many companies will expect you to stay working for them for a few years afterwards. Because they have spent money and time and resources training said apprentice.
Bambam2019 · 20/05/2021 15:36

If your DD wasn’t paying board/rent, would you still be able to afford to support your son? If she completes her apprenticeship and decides she wants to go to uni, will you financially support her? Even if they are both away studying at the same time?
When DS has finished uni will you charge him the same percentage of his wage in rent?
I do think it’s good for parents to support their children through uni (i was) but not at the expense of another child!

Belladonna12 · 20/05/2021 15:36

I wouldn't charge your DD board and lodging as that's bound to lead to resentment considering you are actually giving your other DC money. I don't get the argument that people need to learn about using some of their wage for board and lodging. It's not as if they will have the choice when they are older so why do they need the lesson when they're younger? If you don't think she should be spending all her wages just take a proportion and save it and let her know that you are doing it.

memberofthewedding · 20/05/2021 15:34

Parents who refuse to support their children financially may cause a lifetime of resentment. Certainly I never forgave mine for making it so much more difficult.

I would regard apprenticeship as a form of "in work learning" rather than a full time job per se.

When I wanted to study full time for my chosen profession (librarianship) my parents would not support my decision unless I continued to give them for my "keep" the same amount as when I had been working full time. Fortunately my employer nominated me for a course with alternate periods of study and full time working. So my periods in work supplemented me for when I was studying so far as paying for my "keep" was concerned. I eventually managed to qualify - it took 3 years - but always resented my parents for their meanness and lack of support. I moved out as soon as I could afford it - just as my sister gave birth to a child and my money was most needed at home.

Bambam2019 · 20/05/2021 15:32

@Planty13

I would only take money off DD if you will 100% put it aside for her. The thought that she is essentially topping up her brothers Uni income isn’t comfortable with me. He needs to get a job as well. They are both still in education.
Agreed!
SallySycamore · 20/05/2021 15:30

a8mint I actually tutored 9-11 year olds for secondary school entrance exams. A friend taught music theory. So I think if you can exploit a niche it's ok — I only did two hours a week, but could easily have done more. But yes, the market is very saturated for tutoring GCSE/A-level.

Snakeprint · 20/05/2021 15:30

I take 10% of the apprenticeship wage and out it in a savings account for dd as a deposit on a house.

Dogoodfeelgood · 20/05/2021 15:28

I was charged rent as a teenager whilst studying at uni and it was awful, made me feel unwelcome and didn’t support a good relationship with my parents. It also taught me nothing about money and certainly nothing at all about the importance of saving. I won’t charge my teenagers rent because of this. Two situations where it’s fine: it’s truly a poverty issue and you genuinely need the money - fine. Or if your teen is some kind of layabout who needs the extra incentive to move out/get a job.

If your child is working hard or studying then I don’t see the point of charging them anything if you don’t need to, it’s just mean spirited - that was certainly my experience of it.

DeadlyMedally · 20/05/2021 15:27

@lakesidelife

The shortsightedness of insisting that someone can only take a university course within traveling distance of the family home seems more likely to cause long term resentment.

Why anyone would want to limit their dc's life chances so much unless they absolutely had to I cannot understand.

It is expected that parents will financially support their dc at university, it is baked into the financial structuring. I am surprised that so many people are resistant to this idea, although not OP.

The same is true for an apprenticeship. There is a reason that the minimum wage is lower than that for an adult (with all the responsibilities that entails). In theory, a degree should allow the son to get a significantly better paying career than an apprenticeship would. If it won't, he probably shouldn't be going.
LolaSmiles · 20/05/2021 15:24

Fairness is not the same as sameness.
I agree. It doesn't have to be pound for pound the same because circumstances are different.

Giving an allowance to one child at university, whilst letting the other live at home rent free would be fair, but not the same.
Giving one child an allowance whilst charging the other to live at home seems unfair to me.

lakesidelife · 20/05/2021 15:23

The shortsightedness of insisting that someone can only take a university course within traveling distance of the family home seems more likely to cause long term resentment.

Why anyone would want to limit their dc's life chances so much unless they absolutely had to I cannot understand.

It is expected that parents will financially support their dc at university, it is baked into the financial structuring. I am surprised that so many people are resistant to this idea, although not OP.

DeadlyMedally · 20/05/2021 15:23

@Comefromaway
Only because the expectation is that a 17 year old does not have regular financial obligations and will be doing less onerous work than an adult.
I may be wrong, but I don't think a child taken into care would be expected to pay their own way before the age of 18 so it will come across as callous when a parent makes them.

ElphabaTWitch · 20/05/2021 15:22

I think your being unfair op. Your son could stay at uni u til he’s well into his 30s if he really wants. Will you still support him then?? I feel for your dd. How you going to feel when your son leaves uni and can’t get a job? Or gets nmw job cos he can’t get one in his chosen field ( which is highly likely). If I was your dd I’d not be best pleased with you tbh.

looptheloopinahulahoop · 20/05/2021 15:21

This is where being, and having, an only child has its advantages/limitations.

Personally I think you should treat your children as individuals and not make decisions for one based on the decisions you make for the other.

Each of the OP's kids have made different decisions and will be treated differently. There may be a time in the future when one is better off than the other and the OP may be able to help one more than the other. Heck, maybe one sibling will help out the other! My uncle helped my mother out financially when she divorced my dad.

Fairness is not the same as sameness.

JellyBabiesSaveLives · 20/05/2021 15:20

So she is training for her career and gets 9k a year spend on herself.

Your ds is getting a degree and will get 9k a year (student loan plus means-tested parental contribution to loan) but that has cover rent, food, bills, and transport. He'll get a part-time job to make up the shortfall.

At the end of it your Dd will have the money you've taken and saved for her.
Your ds will have student debt.

I think your dd is better off here.

Comefromaway · 20/05/2021 15:20

@looptheloopinahulahoop

I know lots of 17 year olds living elsewhere in order to either study or work away from their home area

Really? Lots?

One of ds' classmates went to a residential agricultural college at 16. The rest all attend local sixth form and technical colleges and live at home. There were over 200 in his Y11 year group.

My daughter is a trainee dancer. It's very common for kids to leave home at 16 to study at a specialist college. She did it herself.

Or we also know some who moved away to get apprentiships in specialist areas not available locally.

LolaSmiles · 20/05/2021 15:19

Comefromaway
I agree with you that some parental support is expected at university. What I find upsetting is how many parents seem to think that their children are only deserving of support if they go to university.

dreamkitchenhelp · 20/05/2021 15:19

You are absolutely doing the right thing.
£250 is not an unreasonable amount to charge.
If you are able to save a bit for her in the future, then great.
She is working, she needs to know that she needs to contribute to the house hold.
Your son's situation is different. will leave with debt.

There are a lot on entitled young adults out there and reading this thread I am not surprised. I paid rent as soon as I started work and I didn't expect not to.

OP you are doing absolutely the right thing.

looptheloopinahulahoop · 20/05/2021 15:18

I know lots of 17 year olds living elsewhere in order to either study or work away from their home area

Really? Lots?

One of ds' classmates went to a residential agricultural college at 16. The rest all attend local sixth form and technical colleges and live at home. There were over 200 in his Y11 year group.

TolkiensFallow · 20/05/2021 15:18

Also your daughter has made quite a sensible decision and will feel like she’s being penalised for it. She’s avoiding loads of debt and not all university courses lead to a good wage, lots of students just live the high life for 3 years and leave in debt to minimum wage jobs. She sounds a smart cookie and will see it that you’re funding her brothers party life style.

If he wants you to pay his rent, he can stay at home.

Comefromaway · 20/05/2021 15:17

[quote user1497207191]**@BelleClapper* Maintenance grant will only cover two thirds of rent, for a start.*

So why doesn't he get a part time job to earn the shortfall. It's what most Uni students do[/quote]
Most uni students get a job to help with their extra living expenses. Parents are expected to top up to the maximum loan amount. This has been said over and over.

nokidshere · 20/05/2021 15:16

So why doesn't he get a part time job to earn the shortfall. It's what most Uni students do

Because part time jobs rarely cover the shortfall in rent and the cost of living. Some parental support would still be required

LolaSmiles · 20/05/2021 15:15

I agree with @Usernameismyname01 - just have it as a clear rule, if you are earning you contribute, if you are in education, you don't
That's what my parents said.

The result was at different times for different siblings:
Situation A: you're working full time and doing training, but we want full board, life skills, learn the value of money, blah blah blah.
Situation B: You're doing a course whilst working and doing placements, but you still need to pay us board
Situation C: you dropped out of college so of course you can live here for free for an extra year whilst you redo your courses. It's so tough for you. You have a part time job but you keep your money.
Situation D: You are going to university. You do realise we can't support you. Money doesn't grow on trees. You'll need need get a job if you want to study there.
Situation E (several years later): Of course you can have an allowance. Tuition fees are £9,000 now. Zero consideration that the cost of tuition fees was no different as it went to the university. Allowance given until early 20s.
Situation F: You've not got a job yet, live with us for free. You've got a job, live with us for free because it's only part time. Just chip into the food shop a few times. You quit your job, that's OK. Live for free.
Situation G: Yes you've already paid board, but can you just (insert things to buy whilst out that easily come to over £50). If you're going to Destination A, can I come with you... whilst we're out can we just go to Destination B that is actually completely out of the way and costs more in petrol and parking.

The reality was they, like many parents, were quite happy to keep moving the goal posts and engaged in mental gymnastics to claim it was fair.

TolkiensFallow · 20/05/2021 15:14

To challenge some of the thinking a bit... I’m now 40 but i had several periods of living at home rent free and I’ve never had any problems with debt or not realising I’d need to pay bills.

I had a part time job in school/college and the money was mine to keep. I had to save for my own car and pay petrol and insurance.

I had a gap year, I worked for 6 months, saved and travelled for 6 months. I learned to save and was grateful my mum didn’t charge me rent as it made my earning go further.

At uni I worked, took out a loan and paid my way. I wasn’t sent money from home and I wasn’t shocked that I had rent and bills.

After uni I returned home, worked and saved to go travelling again. Didn’t pay rent, again, very grateful.

After travelling I returned home again, lived there for a year rent free, got back on my feet, saved some money and bought a house aged 25. Ive never had trouble with debt or been surprised by mortgage and bills.

My mums policy was that life is hard enough and she’d like to make ours easier.

I was exceptionally grateful to my mother for not charging me rent and as adults myself and my siblings will happily pay maintenance bills, for gardening and cleaning now that she’s elderly and we have disposable income.

Just wanted to show that charging your children rent isn’t the only way to raise capable human beings.

OP what’s your daughters long term plan? Is she saving to move out or buy somewhere? If you don’t need that couple of hundred a month, letting her put it in savings could make a real difference to her future.

Swipe left for the next trending thread