Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

One at Uni, one at work…

937 replies

BelleClapper · 20/05/2021 12:23

How do you square this without causing resentment?

Dd (17) is working full time on an apprenticeship course. We are charging her rent/keep/petrol equivalent to 25% of her take home.

DS (18) up until now was planning to leave college and get a job. He announced yesterday that he is now accepting the three University offers he got a while back. As an aside he’s just split up with his GF of two years who was absolutely definitely in no way the reason he wasn’t going…

So we will be in a position of taking money from DD and sending money to DS. Which has totally changed the dynamic. I’m really conscious of causing resentment from DD who already suffers a bit with middle child syndrome and jealousy.

If you’ve been in this situation what did you do? I want DD to contribute for lots of reasons, none of which go away just because DS now needs three more years of support.

OP posts:
LolaSmiles · 21/05/2021 09:19

This thread has turned into a pile on from posters looking for an excuse to stick in the boot without actually thinking in any way sensibly or clearly about the situation
There's loads of posters giving advice. It's not sticking the boot in to point out that taking money from one whilst propping up the other isn't fair in many people's opinion.

The OP could easily let her daughter live at home for free (especially given her daughter is a CHILD and considered a minor by law), and financially support her son. That way both are being supported for rent and some living costs.

Unfortunately some of us take a dim view of charging a child go live at home because your bills are £3000, and then listing off all the home comforts that the adult wants and would be paying for anyway as a way to justify taking money froma child.

Nanny0gg · 21/05/2021 09:19

@BelleClapper

And the reason I’ve ‘harked on’ about her earnings is because people keep saying ooh she’s only on a reduced apprenticeship wage. She isn’t.
An apprenticeship is education.

One of my DC did one and we supported them as though they were at uni(very low wage) and they didn't pay us until qualified

Comefromaway · 21/05/2021 09:18

[quote ChubbyMsSunshine]@BelleClapper I agree that DD should continue to pay you to live at home. But it's not fair you then give DS money.

Is he not eligible for a student loan? [/quote]
This has been explained many, many times.

His student loan is dependent on the OP's income. If she earns less than £25k he can get a loan of £9,488 so she wouldn't have to give him anything. If OP earns more than £60k he will only get £4,700. The government expect the OP to make up the difference.

Hardbackwriter · 21/05/2021 09:17

[quote ChubbyMsSunshine]@BelleClapper I agree that DD should continue to pay you to live at home. But it's not fair you then give DS money.

Is he not eligible for a student loan? [/quote]
I honestly don't know why you'd think 'I know absolutely nothing about the university finance system but you know what, I'll ignorantly weigh in anyway'

Newkitchen123 · 21/05/2021 09:15

I haven't read the recent responses, just the OP's responses.
Nothing wrong with kids learning the value of money. Nothing wrong with kids learning that fair doesn't always mean equal.
Well done to you OP for bringing up kids who won't end up with a sense of entitlement.

tensmum1964 · 21/05/2021 09:07

@SnarkyBag

An apprenticeship wage at that age is very very low and I’d consider her still in a form of education. I think funding one at uni whilst taking money off a low wage apprentice is pretty shit frankly.
This
PastaLaVistaBBY · 21/05/2021 08:44

Presumably DS will be back in the holidays? Does he pay keep then?

Sure, if he’s living at home and enjoying the same benefits (accommodation, utilities, food, lifts etc) as OP’s daughter.

Fishandhips · 21/05/2021 08:40

@PastaLaVistaBBY

Some posters are being absolutely insane. What you’re proposing is fine. You can’t have the exact same rule for each child, because their circumstances are totally dissimilar.

If your daughter wasn’t living at home, she would be paying rent, utilities, petrol, food and social spending out of her wage. That would cost her many times more than the £200 she gives you in return for those things. You’re therefore subsidising her to the tune of hundreds of pounds a month. Just because you aren’t physically handing her the cash doesn’t mean you aren’t giving her a great deal of financial support.

Your son also needs financial support - it just so happens that instead of providing him with services (like a home, food, lifts etc) you’re providing him with the financial means for him to purchase those things in the location of his university.

The situations really aren’t that different - both children are receiving from you significant support which meets their individual needs. There’s no point in you giving cash to your daughter when what she needs is services, and no point giving services to your son when what he needs is cash. But in both instances you are giving them the support they need, tailored to their circumstances.

This thread has turned into a pile on from posters looking for an excuse to stick in the boot without actually thinking in any way sensibly or clearly about the situation.

Presumably DS will be back in the holidays? Does he pay keep then?
BelleClapper · 21/05/2021 08:37

Also ‘tough shit kid, I had to etc’ is grossly unfair.

At her age I was living rough, my relationship with my parents completely broken.

I would have given anything to be living at home like my siblings, earning money and paying keep. I have worked fucking hard to give my kids a privileged and safe life. I’m just doing my best.

OP posts:
PastaLaVistaBBY · 21/05/2021 08:37

Some posters are being absolutely insane. What you’re proposing is fine. You can’t have the exact same rule for each child, because their circumstances are totally dissimilar.

If your daughter wasn’t living at home, she would be paying rent, utilities, petrol, food and social spending out of her wage. That would cost her many times more than the £200 she gives you in return for those things. You’re therefore subsidising her to the tune of hundreds of pounds a month. Just because you aren’t physically handing her the cash doesn’t mean you aren’t giving her a great deal of financial support.

Your son also needs financial support - it just so happens that instead of providing him with services (like a home, food, lifts etc) you’re providing him with the financial means for him to purchase those things in the location of his university.

The situations really aren’t that different - both children are receiving from you significant support which meets their individual needs. There’s no point in you giving cash to your daughter when what she needs is services, and no point giving services to your son when what he needs is cash. But in both instances you are giving them the support they need, tailored to their circumstances.

This thread has turned into a pile on from posters looking for an excuse to stick in the boot without actually thinking in any way sensibly or clearly about the situation.

ChubbyMsSunshine · 21/05/2021 08:36

@BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz

Why are you funding ds going away to uni? He can go to a local one and remain at home for free, or fund the shortfall in his accommodation himself.
Not everyone lives near a university!
ChubbyMsSunshine · 21/05/2021 08:30

@BelleClapper I agree that DD should continue to pay you to live at home. But it's not fair you then give DS money.

Is he not eligible for a student loan?

bloodyhell19 · 21/05/2021 08:29

@BelleClapper

Oh whatever. I’ve been here long enough to know that once the pile on starts there’s no stopping it. Think what you want about our family dynamics. There’s no point me saying anything else.
Consider the reasons why there might be a pile on. Must be awful dry & dusty with your head in the sand.
bloodyhell19 · 21/05/2021 08:28

@BelleClapper

Also there’s a ridiculous amount of student bashing going on, even just saying I’m defending my son, what do I need to defend him from? He’s making a perfectly normal decision to go to university and that means we are expected to fund him to some degree. And no matter how many times I say he’s expected to get a job, people still keep telling me he needs to.

Have a Confused.

You can @ me OP, I don't bite. I have three degrees & a Masters, I'm not student bashing. I'm pointing out that from my point of view - because that's what you've asked for on a public advice forum - you're being unfair with DD and DS.
BelleClapper · 21/05/2021 08:27

Oh whatever. I’ve been here long enough to know that once the pile on starts there’s no stopping it. Think what you want about our family dynamics. There’s no point me saying anything else.

OP posts:
bloodyhell19 · 21/05/2021 08:25

@BelleClapper

Comprehension not your strong point then.

I am personally doing an apprenticeship - I still have to pay my mortgage. Nothing to do with dd paying or not. It was just an aside.

No OP, I think the fact that you have mentioned your own sibling resentment and are bound to make the same mistake with your own kids means comprehension isn't your strong point.

Again, think on the reason why you chose to draw a parallel between your daughter's income and the fact that you are doing an apprenticeship and still have to pay a mortgage.

I'll tell you what it sounds like: a mother saying tough shit kid, I had to do it and so do you. She's 17.

BelleClapper · 21/05/2021 08:24

And the reason I’ve ‘harked on’ about her earnings is because people keep saying ooh she’s only on a reduced apprenticeship wage. She isn’t.

OP posts:
BelleClapper · 21/05/2021 08:23

Also there’s a ridiculous amount of student bashing going on, even just saying I’m defending my son, what do I need to defend him from? He’s making a perfectly normal decision to go to university and that means we are expected to fund him to some degree. And no matter how many times I say he’s expected to get a job, people still keep telling me he needs to.

Have a Confused.

OP posts:
BelleClapper · 21/05/2021 08:20

Comprehension not your strong point then.

I am personally doing an apprenticeship - I still have to pay my mortgage. Nothing to do with dd paying or not. It was just an aside.

OP posts:
bloodyhell19 · 21/05/2021 08:12

@BelleClapper

Can I just reiterate that DD is on 12k a year. That’s 25% more than minimum wage for her age, so the fact it’s an apprenticeship is neither here nor there.

I’m doing an apprenticeship currently, I still have to pay the mortgage…

Your words OP ^

Before anyone jumps on me and says I’m using DDs wage to prop myself up, I just mean that it may be that we NEED her contribution in a way we don’t right now.

Also your words ^

You co-related your DD's wage with your mortgage repayments without any encouragement so think about that for a minute. You're being very unfair on your daughter and you've bent over backwards to defend your son in your posts but harked on about how much your younger daughter earns repeatedly and cherry picked the answers to suit your current thought process while eyerolled and Confused at anyone with an opposing thought.

You're taking from your daughter with one hand - when you don't need to - and giving to your son with the other.

NotSorry · 21/05/2021 07:26

Hope you’re ok @BelleClapper and have managed to work out what advice will help your situation Flowers

BelleClapper · 21/05/2021 07:11

I’m probably going to leave this thread now because it’s taken a turn for the absolutely insane. It’s very upsetting to keep reading that I’m a vile child abuser who loves my son more. And lots of posts from people who clearly haven’t even read my posts, I have never once said anything like ‘I have a mortgage to pay so she needs to pay’ for example.

Fwiw on a thread I had about ‘keep’ before DD started work the overwhelming majority was in favour of it.

We aren’t treating DD any differently ffs, until Wednesday dinner time we thought DS was leaving college in July and getting a job, and he would have been paying proportionally to his wage.

If DD had chosen to stay at college and then onto University then we’d be paying for that. There’s no inequality.

DD is happy to pay her way, she is proud to be working and earning. DS has picked up more chores because he has more time at home currently. He has no money in his pocket aside from the small amount of pocket money, DD is buying clothes and energy drinks and went to the fair without a second thought.

The reason I said we will AIM to save the money they pay is because I’m all too aware of how life can change, at the moment I’m earning money in a stable job but four years ago I was in the depths of Bipolar depression and couldn’t work. Before anyone jumps on me and says I’m using DDs wage to prop myself up, I just mean that it may be that we NEED her contribution in a way we don’t right now. Life isn’t black and white.

Anyway, I have to go and do the work/school drop off before starting a 14hr shift at work so I think I’m going to hide the thread now.

OP posts:
anotherday235 · 21/05/2021 07:07

I think it's fair enough. Your daughter will still have tons of money left each month. Plus you are saving it for her anyway. As long as you would do the same if the situation was reversed it all seems fine. Parents are obliged to contribute to uni costs unless the child is eligible to the full maintenance loan, if he comes home in summer and works then maybe charge 25% of his wage then.

KingdomScrolls · 21/05/2021 07:07

My brother did an apprenticeship I went to uni, I always worked part time in term time and full time in the summer. Neither of us paid rent to our parents. When we were both working full time having finished studying we paid £25 a week and that was at our insistence and we were earning a lot more than your daughter. The agreement was we were saving for property deposits. We both bought a property at 25/26, neither of us has debt other than mortgage and are both financially sensible, we grew up in a commuter town just on the outskirts of London. I've never understood the MN theory that taking your child's money and giving it back to them amounts to teaching life skills. I also think it's a much better lesson to give a young adult time and opportunity to save for themselves to get onto the property ladder than gift deposits or let them get into a trap of renting long-term and not having enough money to save a substantial amount. There are so many complaints here about how hard it is to buy property. If I were your daughter it would make me feel you were taking my money and giving it to my brother because we'd made different educational choices. That sibling resentment you feel, you're about to replicate it.

drpet49 · 21/05/2021 06:51

* I’m really conscious of causing resentment from DD who already suffers a bit with middle child syndrome and jealousy.*

^Is it any wonder? When you treat her so differently to your DS?