Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

One at Uni, one at work…

937 replies

BelleClapper · 20/05/2021 12:23

How do you square this without causing resentment?

Dd (17) is working full time on an apprenticeship course. We are charging her rent/keep/petrol equivalent to 25% of her take home.

DS (18) up until now was planning to leave college and get a job. He announced yesterday that he is now accepting the three University offers he got a while back. As an aside he’s just split up with his GF of two years who was absolutely definitely in no way the reason he wasn’t going…

So we will be in a position of taking money from DD and sending money to DS. Which has totally changed the dynamic. I’m really conscious of causing resentment from DD who already suffers a bit with middle child syndrome and jealousy.

If you’ve been in this situation what did you do? I want DD to contribute for lots of reasons, none of which go away just because DS now needs three more years of support.

OP posts:
Belladonna12 · 21/05/2021 10:51

@UrAWizHarry

The daughter is earning 12k a year, whilst living at home subsidised by her parents. The fact that the OP is charging board doesn't change that, unless people think that you can get a house, full utilities, a phone, tax etc paid for £250 a month. Yes, you can nitpick about the amount but 1k a month disposable income for a 17 year old is high, so why shouldn't she contribute towards the household?

The son will be getting (say) 5k a year from loans, whilst living away, subisidised by his parents. The costs involved are different, he's not living at home and will leave with debt. Giving him a bit of money to support himself is probably the only way he could actually afford to go.

The key thing is to support both kid's decisions independently in the most appropriate way. They've made different choices and the OP is helping them to achieve them. Seems fair to me.

He will probably earn a lot more than the DD and if he doesn't he won't have to pay the debt back. Ultimately, there will probably be a financial advantage to having a degree so the last thing OP should be doing is weighing things even more in his favour.
Egghead81 · 21/05/2021 10:41

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

PaperbackRider · 21/05/2021 10:27

Ove 18, case by case. You'll never convince me or many others that its ok to charge your children to live at home when they are still children, unless you have no choice at all.

Egghead81 · 21/05/2021 10:22

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

PaperbackRider · 21/05/2021 10:15

it’s not fair for you to imply that OP is a bad parent for guiding her daughter in the art of financial management

I don't care if you think thats unfair. There are many ways to teach financial management without charging a child to live in the family home. It's simply wrong.

PastaLaVistaBBY · 21/05/2021 10:12

@PaperbackRider

17 year olds who are working pay keep. Their parents no longer get child benefit for them and it's only right they should contribute towrds their costs at this stage

Maybe on your planet. Most of us don't charge our children to live in the family home when they are still actually children.

This is your decision and it’s absolutely fine for you to take it, but not with that tone which suggests only you are morally in the clear and anyone who does things differently is a bastard.

It’s perfectly acceptable to let your working children live at home for free.

It’s also perfectly acceptable to charge them a nominal amount to help them learn the value of managing money and paying bills.

By all means, choose the former option for yourself and your kids. But just as you would understandably disagree if someone implied you were a bad parent for raising entitled children who don’t know how to manage money, it’s not fair for you to imply that OP is a bad parent for guiding her daughter in the art of financial management.

UrAWizHarry · 21/05/2021 10:10

@Lubiluxe

Omg I can't believe people actually charge their CHILD rent. Wow. Shocked me. To each their own though of course.
OMG it's not a 5 year old we are talking about, it's a 17 year old who has way more disposable income than most people at her age.
SwimBaby · 21/05/2021 10:09

When I was sixteen I worked in a bank and paid my parents £40 per month (35 years ago). I then decided office work wasn’t for me and left after a year and went to college and did A levels. I then stopped paying the £40. I think if your DC is working full time they should pay something. I think the fact that the DD is doing an apprenticeship has slightly confused things. I already replied earlier that I thought the amount was a bit high but then I ready about the OP driving her to week so £250 for keep and transport sounds about right. I think the fact that the DS is going to uni is separate. I have 3 DC and have always believed in treating them fairly but not necessarily identically.

PaperbackRider · 21/05/2021 10:06

17 year olds who are working pay keep. Their parents no longer get child benefit for them and it's only right they should contribute towrds their costs at this stage

Maybe on your planet. Most of us don't charge our children to live in the family home when they are still actually children.

Lubiluxe · 21/05/2021 10:05

Omg I can't believe people actually charge their CHILD rent. Wow. Shocked me. To each their own though of course.

Newkitchen123 · 21/05/2021 10:05

I went to uni. My brother didn't. I've no idea how my parents worked out the finances. It never occurred to me that it was any of my business whether they took money from my brother or supported him.

Comefromaway · 21/05/2021 10:02

17 year olds who are working pay keep. Their parents no longer get child benefit for them and it's only right they should contribute towrds their costs at this stage.

I remember I was 16 when I first paid Keep. I had finished my GCSE's and got a part time job in the holidays before starting A levels. I earnt £50 per week (the same amount that a YTS would have been paid back then) & I paid £25 Keep. The rest I saved. My mum did argue for this as she'd come from a family where you paid Keep and chose what you spent the rest on whereas my Dad came from a family where you had to hand over all of your wages every week and his mum doled out pin money. My mum didn't agree with that.

My brother left school totally at 16. He's 5 years younger than me so figures would have been different back then but he started an apprentiship (I think YTS had been phased out by then) and paid Keep. He lived at home for the next 5 years and saved for a deposit. Over the years my parents have helped both of us out with things at different times and neither of us feel hard done to.

PaperbackRider · 21/05/2021 09:49

My main reason being she is now a working member of the family and bills need paying

she's a child, and all of those bills would still need paying whether she was in school or anything else.
17 year olds don't pay their parents bills, unless said parent can't manage without or they're selfish gits.

LettyLoman · 21/05/2021 09:39

I think you stand by what you've agreed in your original post. My main reason being she is now a working member of the family and bills need paying, your son will be in debt when he leaves uni, if your son gets a job and still lives at home he to will be paying the same percentage of his salary.

I don't agree with taking money and keeping it for them. They need to learn to make candid decisions on what to spend money on and when to save money. Should you have money lying around when they need driving lessons or first month deposit then you help them out.

Comefromaway · 21/05/2021 09:33

@UrAWizHarry

The daughter is earning 12k a year, whilst living at home subsidised by her parents. The fact that the OP is charging board doesn't change that, unless people think that you can get a house, full utilities, a phone, tax etc paid for £250 a month. Yes, you can nitpick about the amount but 1k a month disposable income for a 17 year old is high, so why shouldn't she contribute towards the household?

The son will be getting (say) 5k a year from loans, whilst living away, subisidised by his parents. The costs involved are different, he's not living at home and will leave with debt. Giving him a bit of money to support himself is probably the only way he could actually afford to go.

The key thing is to support both kid's decisions independently in the most appropriate way. They've made different choices and the OP is helping them to achieve them. Seems fair to me.

Finally some sense.
UrAWizHarry · 21/05/2021 09:31

The daughter is earning 12k a year, whilst living at home subsidised by her parents. The fact that the OP is charging board doesn't change that, unless people think that you can get a house, full utilities, a phone, tax etc paid for £250 a month. Yes, you can nitpick about the amount but 1k a month disposable income for a 17 year old is high, so why shouldn't she contribute towards the household?

The son will be getting (say) 5k a year from loans, whilst living away, subisidised by his parents. The costs involved are different, he's not living at home and will leave with debt. Giving him a bit of money to support himself is probably the only way he could actually afford to go.

The key thing is to support both kid's decisions independently in the most appropriate way. They've made different choices and the OP is helping them to achieve them. Seems fair to me.

LolaSmiles · 21/05/2021 09:31

This is a ridiculous misrepresentation of what I actually posted. Someone asked what my bills were compared to what she was paying. And I listed the home comforts to illustrate that she will be having a much cosier lifestyle than her student brother
Exactly, you listed things that you're already doing, that you would be doing whether or not she lived there, in order to justify taking money from a 17 year old child.

He chose to go to university. Presumably you and he looked at finances and he made that choice.

I can't imagine saying to my DC one you has to pay me because you get all the benefit of stuff I buy anyway and home comforts that I would have anyway before doubling down that the child at home has a cushtie life and a cosier life compared to the sibling that I'm funding.

You said up thread that you were conscious of DD feeling like the middle sibling with issues, but then your actions are likely to reinforce that.

Will you be making your son pay when he comes home in university holidays? Or will he be told he can live at home for free as long as he does the dishes occasionally?

sashagabadon · 21/05/2021 09:30

Belle flapper, your plans are fine! I’ll have similar situation in one child will go to uni and one child won’t ( most likely) and I’ll probably take abit of board off the working child but probably save it for them but maybe not, depends really. It’s a good financial education imo. Life isn’t free. They also won’t be incurring the debt the uni child will.

BelleClapper · 21/05/2021 09:29

Yes!

OP posts:
Comefromaway · 21/05/2021 09:29

@Bourbonic

I mean surely it's simply a case of she is still at home and he isn't??

If he changed his plans then he'd stay home and would pay rent?

YES YES YES.

The OP has said, several times that if he changed his plans and stayed at home/got a job he too would be paying towards his keep.

Bourbonic · 21/05/2021 09:28

I mean surely it's simply a case of she is still at home and he isn't??

If he changed his plans then he'd stay home and would pay rent?

Comefromaway · 21/05/2021 09:27

Assuming my ds does take a year out and doesn;t find a job straight away then he will be living off £79 per week.

I will charge him £50 keep regardless of what he earns. Because that's what happens in our family when you leave education. My dd will be studying in London and I'll be giving her far more money. When she leaves education it willbe the same situation. When ds goes to uni (if he does) I will support him then.

My dh's parents treated both of their kids equally according to some on here in that they gave them both nothing. Difference being dh's sister left school at 16 and got a job in retail. She lived at home rent free for 10 years. Had no outgoings except her car and socialising.

Dh on the other hand did A levels and went to uni. His grant (was grants back then) was based on his parents income so he didn't get very much. Nowhere near enough to live on. His course was very hours intensive including weekends so working part time wasn't an option. The only way he managed was to move in with me.

Fair treatment for both kids yes?

BelleClapper · 21/05/2021 09:24

DS will get the minimum maintenance, as I have said already, repeatedly.

OP posts:
BelleClapper · 21/05/2021 09:23

Unfortunately some of us take a dim view of charging a child go live at home because your bills are £3000, and then listing off all the home comforts that the adult wants and would be paying for anyway as a way to justify taking money froma child.

This is a ridiculous misrepresentation of what I actually posted. Someone asked what my bills were compared to what she was paying. And I listed the home comforts to illustrate that she will be having a much cosier lifestyle than her student brother.

I don’t know why I’m still reading. It’s like picking a scab.

OP posts:
Comefromaway · 21/05/2021 09:21

There is a sliding scale in between those figures.