Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

One at Uni, one at work…

937 replies

BelleClapper · 20/05/2021 12:23

How do you square this without causing resentment?

Dd (17) is working full time on an apprenticeship course. We are charging her rent/keep/petrol equivalent to 25% of her take home.

DS (18) up until now was planning to leave college and get a job. He announced yesterday that he is now accepting the three University offers he got a while back. As an aside he’s just split up with his GF of two years who was absolutely definitely in no way the reason he wasn’t going…

So we will be in a position of taking money from DD and sending money to DS. Which has totally changed the dynamic. I’m really conscious of causing resentment from DD who already suffers a bit with middle child syndrome and jealousy.

If you’ve been in this situation what did you do? I want DD to contribute for lots of reasons, none of which go away just because DS now needs three more years of support.

OP posts:
MikeWozniaksGloriousTache · 21/05/2021 18:22

I think this just goes to show OP there is no right or wrong way to do things, and someone will always think whatever you do you’re doing it wrong.

angela99999 · 21/05/2021 18:13

My two DS both went to uni, one lived at home and the other away. Obviously we had to subsidise the "away" one whilst the other lived rent free at home. In fact DS who lived away saved quite a lot of money before he went and used all his student loans, he's now in his mid 30's and has only just paid them back. The other lived a boring life at home (his choice) but has always been debt free. There was never any mention of unfairness about this.
Personally I think the one who lived away made the most of his opportunities and I don't resent paying for everything. I'd have been equally happy to pay for the other one to go, but he chose not to.
Like the OP I've always regarded them as entirely separate decisions

MadamePompom · 21/05/2021 18:10

My mum charged me rent when i started working full-time and unbeknowntome kept it in a bank account for when i needed it for buying a house. I plan on doing this for our sons when the time comes if they live with us when start working.

fakeplantsdontlookreal · 21/05/2021 18:09

YANBU, they have chosen different career paths and DD will be earning throughout her apprenticeship, on a decent wage, with hopefully a good salary at the end of it, while DS won't earn a penny for a further 3 years.

DS should be encourage to get a job to subsidise himself and you can send him something if you can afford it.

It doesn't mean that you shouldn't charge DD, her living expenses will probably work out cheaper than DS's anyway.

BelleClapper · 21/05/2021 18:07

And the grant/loan is £4422.

OP posts:
BelleClapper · 21/05/2021 18:00

@peppermintpat

Just noticed you said maintenance grant only covers ⅔ of rent! Where's he hoping to rent?? My boy shared with 3 others and ate and drank perfectly well on the grant (first year in halls, second and third year in a private house).
Halls are c£6.5k
OP posts:
TA365 · 21/05/2021 17:59

@Owesye

I’m blown away you’re charging when she’s on £12k a year! Seems really mean and unfair. They’ve got plenty of time in life to pay rent and mortgages and bills m. Glad my parents doesn’t have this thought process!
I'm on 12k a year and am living independently, paying rent, bills, food shop and commute costs. Paying a percentage of her wages is only help OPs DD learn to manage her money and giving her a taste of real life which will be invaluable to her when she decides to move out and live independently or with a spouse.

It is for all of these reasons that I disagree with sending money to DS, at least on an on going basis. I'd advise OP to tell DS to get a part time job whilst at uni, that along side student loans should be enough for him to live on (it is for thousands of other students) and will teach him all the same skills and lessons that DD is learning because she is paying her way.
DD is on an apprenticeship, which means that she's studying whilst she is working, so I don't see how DS getting a job whilst at uni is any different.
So if I was in DD's shoes, I'd probably be a little sore. It would be one think if he was living at home rent free whilst at uni, but if you're actively sending him money whilst charging her then I do think that is unfair.

Maybe you should sit down with DS and come up with an agreement that you will support him financially for a X weeks so that he has time to settle in to uni and find a job before he has to support himself.

peppermintpat · 21/05/2021 17:59

Just noticed you said maintenance grant only covers ⅔ of rent! Where's he hoping to rent?? My boy shared with 3 others and ate and drank perfectly well on the grant (first year in halls, second and third year in a private house).

littlebillie · 21/05/2021 17:59

@BelleClapper

It sounds like your taking her money to give to her and in your replies it does seem like you’re full of excuses for him and she has to just suck it up? I might be wrong maybe I read it wrong, I don’t want to offend you.

I really can’t see where I’m making excuses for him. We are expecting him to get a job, until a couple of days ago we were expecting him to work full time.

People have run away with weird assumptions that poor Cinderella-like DD has to work to pay the rent she owes while Golden Boy DS gets a fully free ride through life. I’ve never said anything amounting to that.

I think we are about to be in a similar position to you, we have discussed income and decided that while living at home 40-50% of income should be saved each month, primarily to get used to living in a budget and also understanding that when they leave only a small potion of income would be available for fun stuff.

I don't think we are saying that they can't touch the money they save but learning to manage money is a key adult lifeskill.

BelleClapper · 21/05/2021 17:58

@Lulu49

YANBU belleclapper the one working should be paying rent, of course she should. presumably she could have chosen the uni route? Her choice. She’s not on low wages for an apprenticeship. You are being fair, being fair doesn’t mean treating both the same regardless. If she had decided to go to uni you would have done the same for her and if he had chosen to work you would have charged him rent. She has the choice if she doesn’t want to live according to your rules, she can vote with her feet and soon see how much it REALLY costs in the big wide world.
Thank you. I should say that DD is perfectly happy with the arrangement, it was me who was worried about resentment etc but she couldn’t care less.

They are good kids.

OP posts:
RRK593 · 21/05/2021 17:57

Actually educating her about the value of money and importance of saving (for the home comforts, deposit, mortgage etc) and helping to set up savings goals for when she's older/moves out is another approach which might be better? Especially if you don't need the money you get from her.

This way it creates independence to organise her own finances whilst she is in control of her money which she works hard for just as you do. Young people now days need every helping hand to manage to get a house/car etc.

peppermintpat · 21/05/2021 17:56

My son went to uni and I didn't send him a penny. A/ because he didn't need it B/ isn't that what the grant is for?

Your DS will have to learn to live within their means as DD will be doing.

Comefromaway · 21/05/2021 17:55

@Toomuchtrouble4me

Why does he need support? He can get a loan and a job?
Is this the latest cancel the cheque.
Lulu49 · 21/05/2021 17:54

YANBU belleclapper the one working should be paying rent, of course she should. presumably she could have chosen the uni route? Her choice. She’s not on low wages for an apprenticeship. You are being fair, being fair doesn’t mean treating both the same regardless. If she had decided to go to uni you would have done the same for her and if he had chosen to work you would have charged him rent. She has the choice if she doesn’t want to live according to your rules, she can vote with her feet and soon see how much it REALLY costs in the big wide world.

Toomuchtrouble4me · 21/05/2021 17:53

Why does he need support? He can get a loan and a job?

BelleClapper · 21/05/2021 17:53

Honestly this whole thread has gone a bit batshit with assumptions and projection.

OP posts:
BelleClapper · 21/05/2021 17:52

It sounds like your taking her money to give to her and in your replies it does seem like you’re full of excuses for him and she has to just suck it up? I might be wrong maybe I read it wrong, I don’t want to offend you.

I really can’t see where I’m making excuses for him. We are expecting him to get a job, until a couple of days ago we were expecting him to work full time.

People have run away with weird assumptions that poor Cinderella-like DD has to work to pay the rent she owes while Golden Boy DS gets a fully free ride through life. I’ve never said anything amounting to that.

OP posts:
Weareallvirgins · 21/05/2021 17:52

@BelleClapper why cant your uni child (sorry adult) get a job whilst at uni.....

Hertsgirl10 · 21/05/2021 17:47

Also if doing an apprenticeship then she is still in education? She’s still learning.

Hertsgirl10 · 21/05/2021 17:46

Has he not worked up I till now? My daughter just finished a 2 year college course and works 20 hours a week. She pays for the stuff that she needs herself.
All of the girls in the college work at least 20 hours a week.

My son has a job to start when he’s 16 next months and has a full time college course to start in September. It can be done.

He can work and go to uni, most people do this.

It sounds like your taking her money to give to her and in your replies it does seem like you’re full of excuses for him and she has to just suck it up? I might be wrong maybe I read it wrong, I don’t want to offend you.

My daughter is on the same wage as yours a year and she pays her driving lessons, saves 200 a month and the rest she buys clothes, take aways, nights out ect. She does dip into her savings now and then but that’s up to her.

Bibidy · 21/05/2021 16:54

Ps. My dad did, however, march me out of the door when I was 17 and 'encouraged' me (strongly!) to get a part-time job so that they didn't need to give me spending money anymore, or pay for my phone, clothes, car, make-up, social events etc. Which probably amounted to similar to what my friends were paying in board, and some of them were still having their big expenses like cars paid for.

Different strokes! At some point you have to start fending for yourself financially in at least some respects.

Bibidy · 21/05/2021 16:50

Threads like these are always divided into those who will happily support their DC into adulthood and those who think they should be self supporting at 16

I just don't really get the outrage over it. My parents never asked me to pay any board and I appreciated that, but several of my friends did pay their parents each month. Neither was unusual and for those parents who did get their kids to pay it certainly wasn't an indication that they expected them to be self sufficient at 16. In fact most of them still had everything done for them (dinners, washing, cleaning, tidying) whilst paying so it certainly wasn't done to make them look after themselves completely.

I think if someone is earning a FT wage then it's totally fair if parents want to ask for a contribution, for whatever reason. It's also fine if they don't. I don't think there's a wrong or right here really, and I definitely don't think that just because you are assisting one child who's currently in a situation where he needs it means that you automatically have to change the arrangement with another who is working full-time.

ForThePurposeOfTheTape · 21/05/2021 15:58

Threads like these are always divided into those who will happily support their DC into adulthood and those who think they should be self supporting at 16

I suspect that if dd did her apprenticeship then decided at age 21 to do further study at uni then OP would help her financially as she'd get a smaller loan.

LolaSmiles · 21/05/2021 13:54

Threads like these are always divided into those who will happily support their DC into adulthood and those who think they should be self supporting at 16
I don't think it's as black and white as that.
I don't have an age where I say that is definitive age for no parental support, but I strongly believe parents should be fair and that it's categorically wrong to be charging a minor to live at home unless the family financial situation genuinely required it (especially if the attitude seems to be that the child should be grateful for the cushtie life they have, look at all the home comforts they have that the parent would otherwise be paying for).

I saw the selective levels of financial support given across my siblings at various times from late teens to early adulthood. I have no doubt my parents would claim they were teaching us life lessons, making us good with money, it really didn't. It highlighted existing patterns in favouritism that parents would deny existed, and has influenced some adult relationships.

Morethanwordsonapage · 21/05/2021 13:10

I always had to pay board, even when I earned a low apprenticeship wage. Resented it at the time but got used to it. Then when I later went to uni (4 years later than the normal age) I was completely self sufficient (with student loan) and had part time jobs. I was stunned when other students had their parents paying their rent and phone bills for example. One of those friends even now is awful with money. Got into trouble over council tax in a house share...never budgets, always has someone to bail her out. I wouldn’t want to instill that in my child really, so I agree OP with what you’re doing.

Swipe left for the next trending thread