Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you throw toys and clothing away?

214 replies

painfullyshywhy · 20/05/2021 10:56

I give everything to the charity shop or ask around or try to sell online (but that is so time consuming I don't bother anymore unless the item is brand new with tags) and I just can't stand the thought of good stuff being chucked in the bin.

Now, my parents are serial thrower away-ers eyeroll and my younger sister actually threw away a massive bag of fairly trendy clothing including a cardigan that my mum thought I had borrowed and she had given me a real telling off for losing it. I never borrowed it dsis had nicked it and then thrown it away instead of giving it back to dmum who lives with her! she could have put it outside her bedroom door but instead she black bagged it ready for the tip!
My old lego sets were all dumped even though I asked if I could have them for my kids when my siblings were too old for them. The same with my old guitars which I tried to bring home but was stopped because dsis wanted to learn. dumped mere weeks later.
Why do they do this?
I just can't understand why someone would throw away good stuff especially when people have shown an interest in having it! especially your own child or grandchildren!

It makes me so mad!

Another relative asked if I wanted any clothes for ds and dd as they are having a sort through. I said yes ill come to pick the bags up on xxx day. got there and they had thrown them in the bin as bin day is Tuesday and you said you'd come on Wednesday.
just tell me! or don't tell me because now I know a big black bag of good clothes are rotting in landfill instead of being reused.

I see bin bags of good stuff and toys being thrown out on my street daily. (everyone uses a little green area as a dumping ground and the council collects every 4 weeks or so) and I just don't have the space to save it all!

The cost of some things, to throw it in the bin, sometimes not even used... it blows my mind! I don't know how people can do it.

I know I sound preachy but it just feels cruel. my family know how much it upsets me, and its like they revel in telling me what they've thrown away.
The kicker is that they have about 6 charity shops and a shelter to pass before they get to the dump. and I have said I will come and get whatever you're throwing away and take it to the charity shop or give to friends children who are the same age or have xxx interests.
I don't understand it. this is more of a rant but. I needed to get it off my chest before I ring my parents up and explode!

OP posts:
Ilovemaisie · 20/05/2021 11:28

Happycat apologies if you have a genuine reason for not going out (illness, mental health etc) but do you really not go anywhere? You don't take your kids to the library or swimming or anything? (Non covid times obviously). Have you considered passing things on to other parents at the school? At my daughter's primary schools some things like baby slings got passed from person to person so much they were practically communal.

1990s · 20/05/2021 11:28

It would make me mad too!

Most of those things thrown in the dump will be in the ground for years and years.

I don't know how anyone can't feel bad about that.

flashbac · 20/05/2021 11:27

Gosh. People who throw usable stuff away should be ashamed of themselves. Angry
Don't you have any WhatsApp/facebook/freecycle groups for goodness sake?
Not only that but there are destitute people out there who could make better use of the stuff.

CeeceeBloomingdale · 20/05/2021 11:26

That’s awful, I only throw things away that are broken and unfixable. I try and pass on to friends or through Facebook pass it on sites. If that fails I send them to the charity shop. I hate the throw away mentality.

Ilovemaisie · 20/05/2021 11:25

OP you should figure out what the re sale value of your old Lego would be (Lego secondhand market is huge) and send the bill to your sister. Or say you are reporting her for theft. (Ok - extreme measures but might make her stop and think)

Happycat1212 · 20/05/2021 11:25

I don’t pass any no (except corner shops) , I only take my kids to school and back, if I want to go to the shops, I need to get a bus to them.

BabyhereBabythere · 20/05/2021 11:25

I wonder if it was our area perhaps (London) and they often had people dumping stuff outside so probably got fed up of that and then checked everything

853ax · 20/05/2021 11:24

I pass clothes onto other or charity shops. If they bad condition give to recycling often clubs here have fundraiser where they get money for recycling old clothes.
Toys again to charity shops however I do throw out bad quality stuff ( kinder egg toys)
Can't believe they throw out Lego it a toy that can't be used over and over and never breaks
On the other side I try to be mindful of not buying too much stuff. Think reduce is the best thing we can do for environment

BabyhereBabythere · 20/05/2021 11:24

@Ilovemaisie

Babyhere ok valid points. Although I have never had a charity shop inspect any donations I have dropped off. And I have been doing charity shop drop offs for over 25 years.
We didn’t for a long time but they started before covid and then obviously with covid they were then shut anyway.

I dont really like to throw stuff away but it’s a case at the moment of get it sorted out and out of the house

Jellybabiesforbreakfast · 20/05/2021 11:23

Nope, never throw anything away unless it's ripped or broken or parts missing.

I try not to buy new clothes, books or toys as much as possible either. Clothes for my DC are hand-me-downs or bought second-hand unless I really like something I see. Toys and books are mostly second-hand from ebay and similar places (unless craft stuff, which we buy new) and they go to the charity shop when we've finished with them.

Ilovemaisie · 20/05/2021 11:23

Happycat you must leave the house at some point though. You probably pass dozens of charity shops (or recycling bins) en route to any where you go.

Miljea · 20/05/2021 11:22

My DB is very easy come, easy go, so it might have something to do with personality traits.

He, due to poor financial management, had to move out of his two bedroom house. He hired a skip, and into it he threw brand new, still wrapped items that he hadn't got round to opening. It was criminal!

But what pissed me off most was that, in that skip, were my old LPs that he'd taken from the family home years before, when I was abroad.

He knew they were mine, but because they were now surplus to his requirements, he threw them out.

I have a W ork acquaintance/ friend who had a chip on her shoulder about a not-wealthy childhood.

She'd buy her DD designer baby/ toddler wear, then make a point of telling us how she'd chucked them out when DD had outgrown them to prove she was now wealthy enough to have such a low regard for price and quality.

Finally, do I recall reading that Marie Kondo, after clearing up all of her own stuff, set to work on her sister's, without her permission?

Ilovemaisie · 20/05/2021 11:21

Babyhere ok valid points. Although I have never had a charity shop inspect any donations I have dropped off. And I have been doing charity shop drop offs for over 25 years.

BeastOfBODMAS · 20/05/2021 11:20

@Iminaglasscaseofemotion lots of charity shops receive clothes that are not sellable and have a regular rag collection where they receive £ by weight.
Labelling them as rags means a volunteer doesn’t need to sort through them first.

billy1966 · 20/05/2021 11:20

Your family sound awful OP, revelling in throwing away stuff that you asked to be given?
Who does that.

I agree with you.

I pass everything on.
My children were never hard on clothes and 95% was past on in perfect condition, usually through friends that would know of someone.

I passed perfect bikes, scooters and even a large ping pong table that mine were no long using.

I hate to think of things ending up in the dump.

Recycle, recycle all the way here.
I hope my children will follow our lead.

It is easier to dump I get that.
But is worth the effort to pass things on, particularly when they are good quality items, barely used.

Sparklybanana · 20/05/2021 11:20

Facebook marketplace. If it's good I'll try and sell it but otherwise I just offer it for really cheap or free and run the gauntlet of timewasters. I've gotten rid of a lot of the kids things this way and made back enough to pay for the kids clubs. I hate, hate, hate throwing away things, and even more so if they still have life in them. Someone will usually want them - even marked bibs and old muslins. IMO, it's definitely worth trying. We did take a bag of stained or torn textiles to the recylcing centre and I still feel guilty even though they should be recycled as opposed to dumped.

HOkieCOkie · 20/05/2021 11:19

I try not to throw anything away if I can help it, charity shops can sell bags of rag for cash and I offer Thorne for free or a small fee in selling sight. Only things I’ve thrown lately are so baking trays which have gone all horrible.

Soubriquet · 20/05/2021 11:19

@Iminaglasscaseofemotion

Put clothing that isn't fit for resale in bag and label it 'rags' and take to charity shop. Why is that a hassle? Genuine question.

Why would the charity shop want a bag of old clothes labelled rags? The whole point is they sell th on. I find that a bit insulting actually.

Depends on the charity shop

Some will donate bags of clothes to the rag man for money. Others don’t and will have to dispose of them

Check with the store if they want ragged clothes or not before donating them

BabyhereBabythere · 20/05/2021 11:19

New one (not meeting lol)

Ilovemaisie · 20/05/2021 11:19

Charity shops sell rags to the rag recycling people. They get money for the rags. It saves them time if rag items are pre sorted from good items because they don't have to spend hours sorting it. The bags go straight to the rag recycling.

ChocOrange1 · 20/05/2021 11:18

With clothing they could at least put them into one of those big clothing donation bins rather than just the normal household waste. That's just lazy to be honest.

I do think there is a big throwaway culture in this country (and probably elsewhere, I wouldn't know)

BabyhereBabythere · 20/05/2021 11:18

@Ilovemaisie

Babyhere I am curious about what made it such a hassle? Put stuff (that is in good condition) in bag and take to charity shop. Put clothing that isn't fit for resale in bag and label it 'rags' and take to charity shop. Why is that a hassle? Genuine question.
Charity shop- they wanted me to wait whilst they inspected everything and would rummage through and want to hand back stuff )it was all good quality but if they had too many jumpers for example ) I wanted to drop and go they wanted me standing waiting while they picked best/needed things

-selling. Holding onto stuff and no shows/late shows. Hagglers and time wasters

-giving away- lots of issues as with selling. People wanting me to take numerous pictures of the item and then changing the day and time
One person once upon collecting a free scooter coming back 3 months later that it was broken and demanding I pay for a meeting one as it was ‘a birthday present’ and I’d let them down !!!!

Happycat1212 · 20/05/2021 11:18

No I don’t go to the shops at all, I get everything online and I don’t drive to cart around big toys or bags of clothes to charity shops.

Ilovemaisie · 20/05/2021 11:17

Happycat how much time does it take to go to a charity shop? Do you go to regular shops? Or cafes/library/dentist/wherever? They are places usually found near charity shops? It takes a minute to drop stuff off.

Iminaglasscaseofemotion · 20/05/2021 11:15

Put clothing that isn't fit for resale in bag and label it 'rags' and take to charity shop. Why is that a hassle? Genuine question.

Why would the charity shop want a bag of old clothes labelled rags? The whole point is they sell th on. I find that a bit insulting actually.

Swipe left for the next trending thread