Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you throw toys and clothing away?

214 replies

painfullyshywhy · 20/05/2021 10:56

I give everything to the charity shop or ask around or try to sell online (but that is so time consuming I don't bother anymore unless the item is brand new with tags) and I just can't stand the thought of good stuff being chucked in the bin.

Now, my parents are serial thrower away-ers eyeroll and my younger sister actually threw away a massive bag of fairly trendy clothing including a cardigan that my mum thought I had borrowed and she had given me a real telling off for losing it. I never borrowed it dsis had nicked it and then thrown it away instead of giving it back to dmum who lives with her! she could have put it outside her bedroom door but instead she black bagged it ready for the tip!
My old lego sets were all dumped even though I asked if I could have them for my kids when my siblings were too old for them. The same with my old guitars which I tried to bring home but was stopped because dsis wanted to learn. dumped mere weeks later.
Why do they do this?
I just can't understand why someone would throw away good stuff especially when people have shown an interest in having it! especially your own child or grandchildren!

It makes me so mad!

Another relative asked if I wanted any clothes for ds and dd as they are having a sort through. I said yes ill come to pick the bags up on xxx day. got there and they had thrown them in the bin as bin day is Tuesday and you said you'd come on Wednesday.
just tell me! or don't tell me because now I know a big black bag of good clothes are rotting in landfill instead of being reused.

I see bin bags of good stuff and toys being thrown out on my street daily. (everyone uses a little green area as a dumping ground and the council collects every 4 weeks or so) and I just don't have the space to save it all!

The cost of some things, to throw it in the bin, sometimes not even used... it blows my mind! I don't know how people can do it.

I know I sound preachy but it just feels cruel. my family know how much it upsets me, and its like they revel in telling me what they've thrown away.
The kicker is that they have about 6 charity shops and a shelter to pass before they get to the dump. and I have said I will come and get whatever you're throwing away and take it to the charity shop or give to friends children who are the same age or have xxx interests.
I don't understand it. this is more of a rant but. I needed to get it off my chest before I ring my parents up and explode!

OP posts:
Mummyratbag · 20/05/2021 12:29

The thought that charity shops throw unopen bags of donations has my blood running cold! I only donate stuff in good condition and make sure I wash/iron/sew on loose buttons etc...

As for the soft toy thing - school fairs (when they run again) - teddies/soft toys are really popular. Teddy Tombolas where they can win one for 20p go down well and take plenty of money.

flashbac · 20/05/2021 12:28

@emilyfrost

YABU. If I paid for it it’s mine to do with I want with.

I pretty much throw everything away when we’re done with it because I can’t be arsed sorting it/storing it/taking it to charity etc.

Disgusting
TheGumption · 20/05/2021 12:27

Blimey I had no idea people were this ignorant! I couldn't bring myself to bin stuff like that.

painfullyshywhy · 20/05/2021 12:25

I knew posting on here would upset me (thanks idiots who rejoice in sharing how wasteful they are. Well done- most of us think you're evil)
But its actually made me feel so much better having people agree with me and share how fair they go to keep an item being useful.

And I wish charity shops sold pants and socks! they cost so much
Nurseries and schools will take them for accidents.
Some teachers even have to buy them in because people don't tend to return the school pants. My school used to write xxx school on them but we kept them. I loved wearing my school pants but not on PE days! Grin Shock naughty mum

OP posts:
Ragwort · 20/05/2021 12:22

Some things do just need to go straight to the recycling centre or tip ... I manage a charity shop and broken, damaged toys are the worst things ... people seem to think that volunteers have time to sort through endless boxes of broken toys or sell things with 'just a couple of pieces missing'' or 'just needs a quick repair'. We can recycle textiles but please be thoughtful about what is donated to a charity shop ... it is quite an eye opener seeing what people try to off load onto us. Barely 40% of donations are actually in a resalable condition ... most of time is spent sorting and trying to get rid of (responsibly) unsaleable donations Sad.

rookiemere · 20/05/2021 12:22

If it's tricky to get to a charity shop a lot of the bigger supermarkets have big bins in the recycling area where you can deposit donations.

I thunk a lot of the bags that come through the door are a bit of a scam, but maybe it's better going in there and someone making something out of it, rather than going to the tip ?

freakyfridays · 20/05/2021 12:21

@SirenSays

Omg it hurts my heart to read about people throwing toys away. My dog Loves soft toys so much (and making me sew them back up a hundred times) but they're impossible to find cheaply. I've even recently considered buying a job lot from a fairground supplier.
Check your local facebook groups and market place.

Mine are full of people offering bags of FREE soft toys , no one takes them!

SirenSays · 20/05/2021 12:18

Omg it hurts my heart to read about people throwing toys away. My dog Loves soft toys so much (and making me sew them back up a hundred times) but they're impossible to find cheaply. I've even recently considered buying a job lot from a fairground supplier.

Wakeupsunshinex · 20/05/2021 12:16

YANBU. Anything broken beyond repair gets binned in our house. Everything else is either donated or put on Facebook marketplace, generally for free depending on the item. We don't drive so usually take a taxi to drop things off to charity shops or take a couple of bags at a time. We have a lovely local baby charity that do collections, they've taken all our old prams/cots/toys. Its really not hard to hand stuff on to others!

emilyfrost · 20/05/2021 12:15

YABU. If I paid for it it’s mine to do with I want with.

I pretty much throw everything away when we’re done with it because I can’t be arsed sorting it/storing it/taking it to charity etc.

freakyfridays · 20/05/2021 12:12

I am more than happy to give away anything to friends and family.

If no one is interested, I try to give to the school or to some specific local charity who need stuff, otherwise it does end up at the tip.

Charity shops locally bin half the stuff anyway (big uproar on the local sites following resident witnessing full unopened bags chucked away routinely Grin )

and offering on free sites just bring CF reselling them or time-wasters.

Most of my kids toys have ended up in the bin, and another load will follow shortly once I have time to sort their bedrooms out. It's a shame, but I can't live in a mess and hoard everything!

Hospitals USED to take plastic toys, they don't at the moment, so it's for the tip. No one wants soft toys anywhere. Which is a bit sad!

HelgaDownUnder · 20/05/2021 12:12

Our economy is structured so stuff - clothes, household goods, electrical etc is cheap, short-lived and not repairable.
Even relatively expensive items are not always priced up for longevity. They are just prettier and maybe made with higher welfare standards for workers. Even environmental standards mostly focus on emissions and packaging, not longevity to minimise waste
Over-zealous donating of junk is what makes charities leery about donations, so I sometimes err on the side of trash for cheaper items in 'well used' condition. If a new item cost a pittance to buy, the value of one that's a bit shabby is basically nil.
I do think establishing a routine with a particular charity shop makes it easier to donate. The one I use has a commercial loading zone where you can park for 10 mins at off-peak times, and a bunch of special wheelie bins that you can wheel up to the car. So easy! Once I discovered the system I offloaded about 8 wheelie bins worth that I'd been hoarding out of guilt. A lot was unwanted gifts, still in packages, along with nice, pre-DC office clothes I no longer wore, or even fitted. Now I'm down there with a black bag every few weeks.

zukiecat · 20/05/2021 12:12

My DC are adults so we don't have toys anymore,

Anything else is given away on Olio, given quite a lot of things away on there. I'm just about to put a Slow Cooker on, it's easy, and everything always goes within a day.

girlmama32 · 20/05/2021 12:11

I donate/sell where possible or I will advertise it free. We get charity bags through the door a lot too which is convenient if you haven't got time to take it to a shop. A lot of charities will now come and collect it for you if you bag it up and book with them, which takes seconds.
I think not having time is a poor excuse. I hate the thought of stuff being thrown away when there are people struggling to clothe their children and themselves.

Bear2014 · 20/05/2021 12:10

Nope, barely at all. And we get a lot of our stuff second hand to begin with. Toys that are broken and beyond repair go in the bin. Otherwise they get passed on to friends or just left outside on the wall and people take them. Clothes go to friends, charity shop or the fabrics bin in the recycling area.

HunterAngel · 20/05/2021 12:09

I try really hard not to throw away things that are still useful. Anything in really good condition gets sold or donated. Clothes that are stained or damaged get used for cleaning cloths or sent to textile recycling. I hate dumping stuff that someone could use.

ForgedInFire · 20/05/2021 12:08

Are you me? I hate throwing perfectly good things away and I have a sister who will just chuck anything in the bin. She just buys brand new stuff constantly and throws away nearly-new clothes and toys. I've offered to take the stuff to the charity shop for her but she won't donate it and I don't understand it

painfullyshywhy · 20/05/2021 12:07

@Ilovemaisie

OP you should figure out what the re sale value of your old Lego would be (Lego secondhand market is huge) and send the bill to your sister. Or say you are reporting her for theft. (Ok - extreme measures but might make her stop and think)
@Ilovemaisie I did check on ebay and it ranged from 200-300 I was gutted because I had only left it because she wanted it. My children wanted it too but I thought 'she only has another year or so of childhood interests- mine can wait. I can't afford to replace that even secondhand.

I did go mad to be honest, I actually left and cried. It doesn't matter thought because they think I am just trying to save money or something.

My nan once picked up a baby t-shirt that was dropped and dirty, brought it home, washed it and dried it and gave it to me. She said she thought I could use it and it was a waste. She also listened and got my dd stuff from charity shops when I told her I'd prefer that.

My Dc and Dd were really shook up by our planet (we couldn't even finish it) and they were really into second hand, no plastic if we can help it, and litter picking etc etc etc so not only does it upset me but I've passed on my fear and upset to my children. Which is half good and half bad because I find myself upset daily by the sheer amount of waste poisoning our environment (not using a broad term here i am actually talking about local environment effecting me and my family personally- like the local dumping ground attracting rats and foxes love the foxes to our door) it is upsetting.
I have joined a local area group on Facebook and it is full of people complaining and taking photos of fly tipping in our local area with the odd lost keys post.
I do blame the shops not the people. Things are sold so cheaply and made so badly that it is no wonder people don't see value in a brand new primark coat.
and I'm so sorry about your lps . I feel your pain. its something you can't get over because if it was sold then at least they are acknowledging the value. but throwing in a bin just says 'i am a selfish see you next Tuesday'
and they are!

OP posts:
Palavah · 20/05/2021 12:07

YANBU.

I have had success giving stuff away on the Olio app. Not just for food. Excellent for stuff that could be useful to someone eg packing boxes, unused paint, old bedding, etc.

JackRabbitSlimsTwistContest · 20/05/2021 12:07

I either sell or donate 95% of old toys or clothing

Any broken plastic toys go in the plastic recycling box

Only thing I throw out are broken and non recyclable things and old underwear

JackieTheFart · 20/05/2021 12:05

YANBU. I feel terribly guilty taking stuff to the tip that has to go in the non-recyclable stuff even if it’s completely broken.

Absolute madness to not even send to charity clothing that won’t be worn.

SlipperyDippery · 20/05/2021 12:04

Honesty I couldn't not. I think if I'm going to buy it then it's my responsibility to dispose of it properly. The pp who said it goes in the tip as its too much faf. Well that's the responsibility and potential for faff you take on if you consume things as far as I'm concerned

Totally agree. It infuriates me how many people either don’t know or don’t care how damaging our throwaway culture is to the planet, and by extension those most vulnerable to the effects of climate change.

HoppyHop · 20/05/2021 12:04

Yep, I'm with you on this. Although the doorstep charity bags seem to do well around us.
I either charity shop or offer on local freebie FB site. Very occasionally use eBay/marketplace. I only bin broken things.
Over the last 12mths a primary school PTA in our town has been collecting unwanted good condition clothing, books, toys etc. and have run a FB Charity shop. They announced this week they have raised £10,000!

1990s · 20/05/2021 12:02

Another good tip is if you offer things for free you will have a certain amount of time wasters.

Offer something on Gumtree etc for a nominal amount £5 etc and you will get people who will turn up.

Tried and tested!

Malacath · 20/05/2021 12:02

I live literally opposite the dump, and I go out of my way to sell/donate anything useable by any means before resorting to throwing things away, even if it means cycling 20 minutes into town to get to a charity shop. I take pride in making sure things are clean and work well before I pass them on. I've bought so many things for my children second hand, shame it's getting more difficult to find things that fit them in the style they'd like/suits them as they get older. Anything that can be repurposed inside the house or garden stays until we've had maximum use out of it. Cannot stand throwing out perfectly good stuff.

Swipe left for the next trending thread