Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you throw toys and clothing away?

214 replies

painfullyshywhy · 20/05/2021 10:56

I give everything to the charity shop or ask around or try to sell online (but that is so time consuming I don't bother anymore unless the item is brand new with tags) and I just can't stand the thought of good stuff being chucked in the bin.

Now, my parents are serial thrower away-ers eyeroll and my younger sister actually threw away a massive bag of fairly trendy clothing including a cardigan that my mum thought I had borrowed and she had given me a real telling off for losing it. I never borrowed it dsis had nicked it and then thrown it away instead of giving it back to dmum who lives with her! she could have put it outside her bedroom door but instead she black bagged it ready for the tip!
My old lego sets were all dumped even though I asked if I could have them for my kids when my siblings were too old for them. The same with my old guitars which I tried to bring home but was stopped because dsis wanted to learn. dumped mere weeks later.
Why do they do this?
I just can't understand why someone would throw away good stuff especially when people have shown an interest in having it! especially your own child or grandchildren!

It makes me so mad!

Another relative asked if I wanted any clothes for ds and dd as they are having a sort through. I said yes ill come to pick the bags up on xxx day. got there and they had thrown them in the bin as bin day is Tuesday and you said you'd come on Wednesday.
just tell me! or don't tell me because now I know a big black bag of good clothes are rotting in landfill instead of being reused.

I see bin bags of good stuff and toys being thrown out on my street daily. (everyone uses a little green area as a dumping ground and the council collects every 4 weeks or so) and I just don't have the space to save it all!

The cost of some things, to throw it in the bin, sometimes not even used... it blows my mind! I don't know how people can do it.

I know I sound preachy but it just feels cruel. my family know how much it upsets me, and its like they revel in telling me what they've thrown away.
The kicker is that they have about 6 charity shops and a shelter to pass before they get to the dump. and I have said I will come and get whatever you're throwing away and take it to the charity shop or give to friends children who are the same age or have xxx interests.
I don't understand it. this is more of a rant but. I needed to get it off my chest before I ring my parents up and explode!

OP posts:
looptheloopinahulahoop · 20/05/2021 15:54

Toys are really difficult to recycle. I wish there were collection containers for them like there are for clothes/shoes/small electricals/books.

I don't want to have to go into a charity shop with the stuff, the staff sigh because it's another load of junk for them to sort through even when it isn't junk, and then they want you to do Gift Aid etc.

Clothes are easy though because you can take to a recycling centre, usually next to the supermarket.

CatsArePeople · 20/05/2021 15:40

i'm a bit of a hoarder, i find it hard to throw away things which might be useful someday so someone, my DH is even worse.
But when push comes to shove, i find throwing out easier than trying to "rehome".

1990s · 20/05/2021 15:36

@StreetLightsHoney

It's not great.

If you're on Mumsnet you're fairly likely to have children. They're who you're giving the world full of landfill and the associated problems to

@1990s I have children. I still don’t care. I don’t think it’ll negatively affect them or any grandchildren I may have.

If OP thinks throwing stuff away makes me evil she’d be horrified at my refusal to recycle and the myriad of other things I do/don’t do.

I was about to write an explanation of why that's not the case. Then I realised there was no point.

StreetLightsHoney · 20/05/2021 15:18

It's not great.

If you're on Mumsnet you're fairly likely to have children. They're who you're giving the world full of landfill and the associated problems to

@1990s I have children. I still don’t care. I don’t think it’ll negatively affect them or any grandchildren I may have.

If OP thinks throwing stuff away makes me evil she’d be horrified at my refusal to recycle and the myriad of other things I do/don’t do.

Embracingthechaos · 20/05/2021 14:40

Stuff that's in good condition goes to charity or gets sold. Something that's well worn but still usable goes up on fb marketplace as free, first come first serve.

I've never had anything that didn't get picked up for free off fb marketplace. I suppose at that point I would possibly just chuck it out.

Palavah · 20/05/2021 14:35

Completely agree - a colleague told me she won't wear wool/leather because she's vegan, but her plastic clothes can shed and poison the ocean, no bother.

LaBellina · 20/05/2021 14:28

I was having a chat about this with an elderly lady last week. She said when she had her SC, toys and clothes were much more expensive and people treated their stuff with much more respect and second hand was much more common. Because everything is so cheap these days, people feel comfortable to throw everything away without thinking twice about the environmental impact. I have recently decided to stop buying clothes made of synthetic materials because they shed microplastics each time you wash them and instead only buy clothes made of natural materials and buy less. Any old clothes or toys that I have are sold or given to friends or charity. I remember my mother used to cut old underwear or other rags that nobody wanted to use as a second hand, into pieces and she used them as shoe polish cloth or cleaning cloth for the bathroom.

painfullyshywhy · 20/05/2021 14:26

Thats the problem though, I am trying my hardest to reduce my consumption and waste and help where I can. But then I have no control over other people who are throwing out more in a week than I have been able to 'save' in a year.
It passes me off that someone can not care.

A child died because of air pollution, how can people say that it isn't their problem.
It is everyone's problem

OP posts:
MotherWol · 20/05/2021 14:22

Anything that's saleable goes to the charity shop, on a local FB free group, or to the baby bank. It's my responsibility as a consumer to dispose of the things I own responsibly, and yes, that's probably more hassle than just binning it, but if I acquired it in the first place the burden is on me to get rid of it, not to ask future generations or the developing world to clear up after my consumerist ways.

Pinkpaisley · 20/05/2021 14:17

I throw away things that are too worn or broken for the charity shop. I rarely bother selling things myself because I just can’t stand the hassle and I don’t really need the money these days. I did do personal sales when dd was younger and I was a sahm so I had more time and money was more dear.

These days we keep a hamper just for collecting things for the charity shop. Kids change and grow so much I realized it was easier just to keep a bin going at all times. It makes things so much easier to have a designated spot. Just yesterday, dd pointed out that none of the cats seemed to like a particular, really nice, cat toy so she was dropping it in the charity bin.

DelurkingAJ · 20/05/2021 14:13

Old pants and school socks...I was set to textile recycle them but emailed DS2’s infants school and they’ve bitten my hand off because they have kids who have accidents...I’ll wash it all at 60 and take it in. Win-win.

1990s · 20/05/2021 14:08

@emilyfrost

thanks idiots who rejoice in sharing how wasteful they are. Well done- most of us think you're evil)

Oh yes, throwing away stuff you don’t want anymore certainly makes you evil 😂

It's not great.

If you're on Mumsnet you're fairly likely to have children. They're who you're giving the world full of landfill and the associated problems to.

CrotchetyQuaver · 20/05/2021 14:04

I throw away properly worn out stuff - holes rips etc. Children adult so no toys there but shredded ripped dog toys also go in the bin. In my area it is incinerated and the energy from that goes to make electricity so I don't feel bad about it...

Nothing irritates me more than seeing worn out tat being offered for sale or it being passed on to a charity to deal with. Some they can sell for rags but dirty soiled stained stuff? Envy

MsMoppet · 20/05/2021 14:02

@Ilovemaisie

Babyhere ok valid points. Although I have never had a charity shop inspect any donations I have dropped off. And I have been doing charity shop drop offs for over 25 years.
Me too. I've donated clothes and books to various charity shops over the last 25yrs and not once has anyone made me wait while they sort!
emilyfrost · 20/05/2021 14:00

thanks idiots who rejoice in sharing how wasteful they are. Well done- most of us think you're evil)

Oh yes, throwing away stuff you don’t want anymore certainly makes you evil 😂

richtea4 · 20/05/2021 13:59

I'm the same as you, can't send anything to the tip unless it's trashed, always taking stuff to the charity shop. I don't bother selling anything because for me it's more hassle than it's worth.

RaspberryCoulis · 20/05/2021 13:44

@Ragwort

Painfully I do sell brand new socks and underwear in my charity shop ... it comes as corporate donations from big companies but even at really cheap prices it is hard to sell those sorts of things. I've said this many times on Mumsnet but we get donated brand new school uniform (unbranded ie; black/grey trousers/skirts) and even at £1 per item I can't sell them ...

I find customers are very 'discerning' fussy about buying clothes for children from charity shops and would rather buy new which is sad - particularly when many items in my charity shop are brand new and clearly labelled!

Hello @Ragwort, remember you from other threads and I'm a volunteer in the same chain as you.Totally agree that underwear is hard to sell, and we can't shift new school clothes however cheap you price it. In fact, our manager has decided to stop selling children's clothing altogether as it takes up space in the shop and just doesn't sell well at all.

I do agree that there is a balance to be struck - no, charity shops don't want all your broken junk that you can't be arsed to tip. But on the other hand, nobody wants everything in landfill. Our shop recycles all textiles so no old socks, sheets, stained t-shirts etc will go to landfill. If things aren't fir for sale, they can be used in other ways. Plants shred old clothing for use in mattress stuffing or sofas, and the warehouse where rags are sorted for our chain is heated using a boiler fuelled by burning what's left over. If you have textiles to donate and mark the bag as rags, the volunteers will love you.

I don't think i've ever thrown away an item of clothing, ever, into the bin with the general waste. Clothing has always gone into recycling. Natural fabrics can also go into compost.

Toys - we do get a load of broken stuff into the shop and I think it is because people feel guilty about chucking it away and kid themselves on that someone would be grateful for it. All they're really doing is shifting the responsibility for throwing it out onto someone else.

The REAL problem is that everyone's buying too much stuff in the first place...

Runnerduck34 · 20/05/2021 13:29

Generally I try and give away or sell anything that is still good, however i must admit during lockdown i hired a skip and cleared out the loft and did chuck it all in the skip.
Some stuff was in good or reasonable condition but some if it was out of fashion ( clothing) or defunct, videos, cassettes etc it would have been hard to get rid off elsewhere and charity shops were closed.
Also it would have been a monumental effort and with the best will in the world I have charity shop bags that have been in my understairs cupboard for a year,.
The skip hire people do metal/ plastic/ paper recycling anyway so hopefully not too bad!

Think the key is to sort it little and often and dont let it build up so its not such a massive job!

Ragwort · 20/05/2021 13:27

Painfully I do sell brand new socks and underwear in my charity shop ... it comes as corporate donations from big companies but even at really cheap prices it is hard to sell those sorts of things. I've said this many times on Mumsnet but we get donated brand new school uniform (unbranded ie; black/grey trousers/skirts) and even at £1 per item I can't sell them ...

I find customers are very 'discerning' fussy about buying clothes for children from charity shops and would rather buy new which is sad - particularly when many items in my charity shop are brand new and clearly labelled!

littlebillie · 20/05/2021 13:25

We freecycle things we can't take to a charity shop ie furniture etc

motheroftwoboys · 20/05/2021 13:25

Evangelical about re-cycling and I buy pretty much all of my clothes from E-bay. Designer at a fraction of the price. Anything I buy that doesn't fit goes back on to e-bay. Stuff not really worth selling goes to Charity Shops or put in one of the charity bags that we get through the letter box for later collection. We are busy sorting out in our attic so enjoying dividing into sell/bin/freegle/charity shop. It is amazing what people take on freegle and is a great option as they come to collect it. If you agree a day/time then you can just leave it outside the house. We have a lot of china, glass and pictures up there that is going on freegle at the weekend as it is too complicated to sell on e-bay and not so easy to take to a charity shop without the car.

MegaClutterSlut · 20/05/2021 13:23

I save anything good that I don't want and either do a bootsale or charity shop them. I only bin things that are well used or broken

EveningOverRooftops · 20/05/2021 13:18

I repair any clothes I don’t want before taking to the charity shops eg replacing buttons sewing seams etc

Ditto toys that are safely repairable.

Broken/unrepairable things are repurposed. Buttons taken off shirts, fabric cut and saved then donated to craft groups or made into new things here.

I occasionally offer known broken items as spares online as there are people like me who might need a part in the item I’m offering for free. I passed on a broken blender (my jug had broke, the lady who took it her motor had broke) to keep another one in circulation. I’ve offered for free attachments for items that have broken people have happily taken. Last time my hoover broke so I took all the parts off and offered them online for free. They went to 3 separate people to mend their own hoovers. One took the hose another the brush heads and one wanted the dust bin as hers was cracked.

Win win I say.

StopPokingTheRoyalTitDear · 20/05/2021 13:17

I never bin stuff unless it’s broken- charity shop or Facebook market place for everything we don’t want or need anymore or pass things on to those who need it- friends, women’s refuge, a foster carer I used to know.

Not only do I hate waste I really feel it’s our responsibility as society to avoid stuff going to landfill as much as possible so recycling stuff where possible should be second nature.

rookiemere · 20/05/2021 13:15

In Scotland there is a charity www.kidsloveclothes.co.uk/ who provide nearly new and new clothes to DCs who have had to leave the family home for example due to domestic violence or been referred by social workers.
They only hand out non damaged stuff and would be absolutely grateful for any new school clothes. They may be able to advise of similar charities in people's areas.

Swipe left for the next trending thread