Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you throw toys and clothing away?

214 replies

painfullyshywhy · 20/05/2021 10:56

I give everything to the charity shop or ask around or try to sell online (but that is so time consuming I don't bother anymore unless the item is brand new with tags) and I just can't stand the thought of good stuff being chucked in the bin.

Now, my parents are serial thrower away-ers eyeroll and my younger sister actually threw away a massive bag of fairly trendy clothing including a cardigan that my mum thought I had borrowed and she had given me a real telling off for losing it. I never borrowed it dsis had nicked it and then thrown it away instead of giving it back to dmum who lives with her! she could have put it outside her bedroom door but instead she black bagged it ready for the tip!
My old lego sets were all dumped even though I asked if I could have them for my kids when my siblings were too old for them. The same with my old guitars which I tried to bring home but was stopped because dsis wanted to learn. dumped mere weeks later.
Why do they do this?
I just can't understand why someone would throw away good stuff especially when people have shown an interest in having it! especially your own child or grandchildren!

It makes me so mad!

Another relative asked if I wanted any clothes for ds and dd as they are having a sort through. I said yes ill come to pick the bags up on xxx day. got there and they had thrown them in the bin as bin day is Tuesday and you said you'd come on Wednesday.
just tell me! or don't tell me because now I know a big black bag of good clothes are rotting in landfill instead of being reused.

I see bin bags of good stuff and toys being thrown out on my street daily. (everyone uses a little green area as a dumping ground and the council collects every 4 weeks or so) and I just don't have the space to save it all!

The cost of some things, to throw it in the bin, sometimes not even used... it blows my mind! I don't know how people can do it.

I know I sound preachy but it just feels cruel. my family know how much it upsets me, and its like they revel in telling me what they've thrown away.
The kicker is that they have about 6 charity shops and a shelter to pass before they get to the dump. and I have said I will come and get whatever you're throwing away and take it to the charity shop or give to friends children who are the same age or have xxx interests.
I don't understand it. this is more of a rant but. I needed to get it off my chest before I ring my parents up and explode!

OP posts:
1990s · 20/05/2021 19:08

@freakyfridays

You don't know any charity shops that open weekends? Really?

you don't know people who work weekends? Confused really?

icollectclothes literally does what is says in the title.

I'd be surprised if there isn't a fairly simple way for most people not to dispose of things without binning them.

woodhill · 20/05/2021 18:25

We are lucky as our LA takes away textiles which is helpful

woodhill · 20/05/2021 18:15

@TheFlis12345

I am genuinely shocked and saddened by how many lazy, selfish and irresponsible people there are on here Angry We barely throw anything away, if it’s usable it gets given away via social or a charity shop and if it’s not, it gets recycled if at all possible. Even holey socks are washed and put in the rag bag for the local charity shop to sell.
Yes just awful
StressMagnet · 20/05/2021 18:12

I go through my kids clothes twice a year. It's such little hassle to thin out grown stuff for charity that way. I feel guilty throwing stuff to landfill. All clothes get recycled unless it's totally trashed

freakyfridays · 20/05/2021 18:06

You don't know any charity shops that open weekends? Really?

you don't know people who work weekends? Confused really?

picturesandpickles · 20/05/2021 18:04

Throw very little away, I coudn't throw a bag of clothes in the bin. I do not recycle every last scrap of fabric but I charity shop, recycle and use scraps for things like cleaning cloths.

SleepingStandingUp · 20/05/2021 18:02

@freakyfridays

How much of a hassle can it be to put stuff in a bag and take to a charity shop Vs putting stuff in a bag and taking it to the tip?

many people work during business hours when the charity shops are actually opened. Who will take a day or half a day off just to drop things there?

You don't know any charity shops that open weekends? Really?
ballroompink · 20/05/2021 18:01

I have thrown away broken toys and completely destroyed clothes but in general I try to sell or give away anything decent, take other stuff to a charity shop or put in a clothing bank, or take to the recycling centre. Selling can be a pain in the backside but we have sold all our baby items via Facebook (pushchair, highchair, crib etc.) no problems.

freakyfridays · 20/05/2021 17:53

How much of a hassle can it be to put stuff in a bag and take to a charity shop Vs putting stuff in a bag and taking it to the tip?

many people work during business hours when the charity shops are actually opened. Who will take a day or half a day off just to drop things there?

Twocanplay · 20/05/2021 17:53

I normally give things away on free fb sites

SixDegrees · 20/05/2021 17:44

How much of a hassle can it be to put stuff in a bag and take to a charity shop Vs putting stuff in a bag and taking it to the tip?

I can’t speak for anyone else, but for me it’s a 5-10 minute drive to the tip that’s open 6 days a week and takes anything, Vs a 30 minute drive to the charity shop, plus the added hassle of having to arrange an appointment at the charity shop in advance to drop off the donations.

thenorthernluce · 20/05/2021 17:33

Google your closest refugee charity and phone/email to ask what they need for their service users. I did this recently with lots of decent baby items, maternity clothing, toys and books, stuff that was far too much of a hassle to sell. The lady I dealt with was nearly in tears, she was so grateful, and I was just so pleased my stuff was going straight to someone desperately in need with no recourse to public funds.

SleepingStandingUp · 20/05/2021 17:33

@StreetLightsHoney

It's not great.

If you're on Mumsnet you're fairly likely to have children. They're who you're giving the world full of landfill and the associated problems to

@1990s I have children. I still don’t care. I don’t think it’ll negatively affect them or any grandchildren I may have.

If OP thinks throwing stuff away makes me evil she’d be horrified at my refusal to recycle and the myriad of other things I do/don’t do.

I'd go with ignorant/stupid rather than evil.
SleepingStandingUp · 20/05/2021 17:28

@BabyhereBabythere

I used to sort things and sell/giveaway or donate to the charity shop Ended up being HUGE amounts of hassle so everything goes to the tip now
How much of a hassle can it be to put stuff in a bag and take to a charity shop Vs putting stuff in a bag and taking it to the tip?
Ragwort · 20/05/2021 17:22

Hello Raspberry I thought you must have changed your name as I hadn't seen you around for a while. Hope your shop is doing well, ours is doing very well since we reopened Smile.

SixDegrees · 20/05/2021 17:00

As a general rule, I’ll try to pass things on if they’re in decent condition. I agree it’s wasteful to throw things out if they’re in good condition.

There’s a charity clothes bank in the car park at my nearest supermarket, so I can drop off clothes, shoes and other clothing accessories there, and there’s a Little Free Library (basically a book swap) in my village that’s handy for dropping off books.

But charity shops aren’t an easy option for everyone. There’s no charity shop in the village I live in, or the next few.
I have a car so I can drive to charity shops, but going to one is basically a special trip that’s taking me out of my way. I try and only do that when I’ve got a boot full of donations, but charity shops can’t always take a lot at once right now.

It’s honestly a lot less effort for me to get to the nearest tip.

TeenMinusTests · 20/05/2021 16:52

Some of my DD's best clothes used to come from charity shops.
We didn't have a children's clothes supplier in our small town (we now have one v.pricey boutique one, so still hopeless) so it was far less trouble to pick up random nice bits when I saw them than go on an expedition.

ineedaholidayandwine · 20/05/2021 16:50

The only clothes and toys that go in the bin are ruined or broken. Toys she's grown out of i give to charity or to a friend or family with a younger child.

ChocOrange1 · 20/05/2021 16:46

I don't tend to look at kids clothes in the charity shop. They usually have a very small range of sizes and 1 or 2 items in each size. I guess it's a vicious cycle, if people bought kids clothes they would stock more.

I buy and sell kids clothes in Facebook marketplace

RaspberryCoulis · 20/05/2021 16:45

Throw things away...

There is no "away". Away is landfill. Landfill is filling up. Wastefulness is everyone's problem and yes if you just throw things in the bin without any thought to where it goes next, wear an outfit once and chuck it, or don't care about litter/waste I'm going to judge you to fuck for it.

33goingon64 · 20/05/2021 16:44

I literally can't compute the knowledge that some people throw perfectly good clothes into landfill.

Donitta · 20/05/2021 16:36

Charity shops often whinge and refuse to accept the whole lot, they want to cherry pick and leave you with the rest to dispose of. FB marketplace is just ridiculous, people expect you to inconvenience yourself when you’re giving stuff away for free. So I do end up chucking some good stuff in the bin because I don’t want them hassle of trying to give it to someone.

ChocOrange1 · 20/05/2021 16:34

@freakyfridays

and kids shoes, what are you supposed to do with them?

Some of them are nearly new, kids grow fast - and again, school shoes bought last spring didn't get much use. No one wants them! Fair enough, but what do you do with them? They end up in the tip because there's only so much hoarding you can do in a normal size house.

Pair them up and put in the charity clothing bin (those big metal ones that you find next to the bottle bank) They will recycle them or send to disadvantaged communities.
ChocOrange1 · 20/05/2021 16:26

People seem to want to pay more for new Primark than second hand Next (or such like)
Yes this is certainly true with highstreet clothes. We buy a lot of frugi and scandi stuff, holds is value really well and people will take stuff with stains/rips etc if the price is right (or free) to use for craft projects or to repair.
Obviously it costs more in the first place - although not a lot more at sale prices - but far less waste, and you recoup a good chunk of the cost on selling.

I could buy a frugi dress for £25 and sell it for £20 after a years use. I could buy a dress from asda for £12 and be lucky to get 50p second hand.

Wanderlust20 · 20/05/2021 16:15

I'm with you, just no need! I put everything on Gumtree for free, there's usually someone who is happy to take it! And takes hardly any effort at all.

Swipe left for the next trending thread