Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be surprised at how many Mumsnetters are fine with pornography? II

735 replies

Judy1234 · 16/11/2007 17:30

Continuing the previous thread - people's sexuality varies hugely and what some people think is disgusting is good fun for others. It's impossible to generalise and say XYZ practice is wrong or repugnant and I agree with the posts at the end of the other thread that porn often just reflects what people do. Obviously you pick where your own interests lie and are glad human beings are diverse.

OP posts:
lucyellensmum · 18/11/2007 23:01

I hardly think that paris hilton is a prime example of a poor young lass taken exploited by the porn industry!

Monkeytrousers · 18/11/2007 22:54

Doesn't stop them being mainstream though Custy. No one seems to care, that being my point, or one of them.

Monkeytrousers · 18/11/2007 22:53

NO, because often - if you read some of the comments even on here about them - they deserve our contempt.

So much for porn improving your rep. These women have other things going for them of course. Hilton has a fortune to fall back on so won't really feel any hardship in fiscal terms, but she will have a hard time being taken serously or escaping her past.

Titmus was canny and used the exposure to her advantage. She didn't go into porn though, just erotica. Now she is acting on stage.

Tortington · 18/11/2007 22:52

i dont think anyone here would argue that non consensual filming and subsequent non consensual releasing of sex films was ok.

Elizabetth · 18/11/2007 22:48

Oh yeah, and Paris Hilton went into a video store in Canada recently that were advertsing the video her scumbag boyfriend made of her and tried to get them to stop advertising it. She's obviously not happy about what happened to her either.

Doesn't stop people watching and enjoying those videos though does it, MT?

Monkeytrousers · 18/11/2007 22:43

Can I just add that Abbi Titmus is quoted as saying that she views everyone who has watched 'that' video as violating her. She has never consented to it being published and has never made any money from it. As far as she was concerned it was a private exploration.

Elizabetth · 18/11/2007 22:37

Oops link

To quote a bit from it (some porn users talk about their habits) -

"Sex just seemed so ordinary; it was no longer thrilling or magical the way it had been before I-porn. I actually had to make a conscious decision to quit. I was worried that I was becoming compulsive and even dependent on it. The fact that porn was altering my sex life scared me. When I don?t have those images in front of me, I just can?t get that aroused. Sex is no longer as physiologically exciting.
Rajiv, porn user

I?ve definitely noticed that naked images that used to arouse me don?t anymore, so I had to move on. I found that I was getting numb to basic images. I needed to keep progressing to more explicit stuff.
Dave, porn user

It?s kind of silly, but my standards changed. Women who were otherwise good-looking but weren?t as overtly sexy as the women in porn don?t appeal to me as much anymore. I found that I look more for women who have the attributes I see in porn. I want bigger breasts, blonder hair, curvier bodies in general. Just better-looking overall.
Harrison, porn user

It?s become more severe as time has gone on...for some reason, with porn, in order for me to get excited, I need to notch it up one level. It?s got to be more extreme. Seeing women demeaned is somehow a turn on.
Tyler, porn user"

Elizabetth · 18/11/2007 22:32

Heh, thanks ChampagneandFlowers. I read your thread and your dh sounds like a complete knob for doing that.

The other thing I couldn't believe on your thread was the women popping up to say how random blokes had shown or offered to show them porn. It just shows how bad its got. I wonder if the chipshop lady had "consented" for everybody and their taxi-driver to watch her most intimate moments - probably not.

Any woman can speak up against porn - we just have to do it. This is a really good website which has loads of information about what porn is really like and what it does to people - www.oneangrygirl.net/antiporn.html

DaddyJ · 18/11/2007 22:12

I stand corrected,
the legislation is still being drafted.

This Guardian article provides more background.

In fact, it's almost a summary of this thread.

Judy1234 · 18/11/2007 21:58

I think the new violent porn legislation is not yet in force and still time for pro porn people to lobby against it. So go forth and email your MP to tell him a lot of women actually quite like porn and even if they don't they will defend the right of those that do to have it.

OP posts:
onebatmother · 18/11/2007 21:40

ok now.

onebatmother · 18/11/2007 21:39

just came down to get some water! off now.

policywonk · 18/11/2007 21:36

GO TO BED, woman

onebatmother · 18/11/2007 21:34

he's posting around.

DaddyJ · 18/11/2007 21:30

Sorry about mentioning Netmums.
First thing on this thread that really needs to be deleted.

go to bed, obm you must be shattered

onebatmother · 18/11/2007 21:26

yes mt think that too, it coincided with push towards less apparently'directed' stuff in tv/film. and as with those media, 'reality' brings a whole new set of questions about the possibility of ever 'documenting reality'.

was a reaction to the plasticization of mainstream porn and i think, for a moment, had some kind of relative integrity?

ChampagneAndFlowers · 18/11/2007 21:25

onebatmother this is the thread www.mumsnet.com/Talk/2724/425689

My man is a perv,no doubt.

onebatmother · 18/11/2007 21:23

okay, night night.
up since five again again.
six kids into central london for ds's birthday treat. what was i thinking?
will check in tomorrow.

Monkeytrousers · 18/11/2007 21:23
Monkeytrousers · 18/11/2007 21:22

..ane the whole think about an unscripted piece is that anything can happen. The language of docu translated to porn!

onebatmother · 18/11/2007 21:20

sorry no, talking about champagne's link.

DaddyJ · 18/11/2007 21:20

Good. Apologies once more for the vitriol earlier.
(weeelll, vitriol by Netmum's standards!)

Monkeytrousers · 18/11/2007 21:19

(Although I am informed and inspired by some elememts of traditional feminism.)

onebatmother · 18/11/2007 21:19

pol found malumuth rather vague..

dj i think you're right, it certainly meant 'real, without fake tits etc' ten years ago.

But was under the impre. that the general understanding of the word has moved towards the 'real chicks get treated like shit' idea now.
was my understanding but prepared to be wrong.

normabutty · 18/11/2007 21:18

""I also don't think men who watch porn, be it gonzo or any other type, see women as wanting to be hurt/humiliated."

That's not what I said Norma I said what does it say about men and boys who watch this sort of stuff (and a good number of them do whatever the deniers try to claim) that they want to see women hurt and humiliated. Not one porn defender has picked up on that. They don't want to think about it because the answer is really frightening. What would people think of whites wanting to watch black people treated in this way? Or gentiles getting off to jews being treated in this way (oh and Nazi porn is a sub-genre BTW)."

My comment wasn't aimed at you Elizabetth. I was replying to another poster.

However in response to your question about "what does it say about men who want to watch the sort of stuff where women are hurt/humiliated, the answer has a few parts to it tbh.

  1. I think there are some men who see it as pure fantasy, it's something they can't do in real life and wouldn't even consider doing in real life. They think that because it is 'on film' it is, in a sense, not real. Those people are hypocrites. Those people cannot and will not understand that the people starring in it are real.
  2. I think there are also some men who actually enjoy being more powerful than women, they get off on making women do what they want. I think these men have 'issues' which could for a number of reasons - e.g. sexual abuse, bad parenting, social interaction problems, and the like.

Neither 1 or 2 are acceptable in my opinion.

There is also another option, which I think is by far the majority of men:
3) I think there are a number of men (the majority of the men who watch this type of porn) who are not able and probably wouldn't want to do it in real life. It is a fantasy for them and they understand that the people in the porn film are purely acting (with full consent).