Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be surprised at how many Mumsnetters are fine with pornography? II

735 replies

Judy1234 · 16/11/2007 17:30

Continuing the previous thread - people's sexuality varies hugely and what some people think is disgusting is good fun for others. It's impossible to generalise and say XYZ practice is wrong or repugnant and I agree with the posts at the end of the other thread that porn often just reflects what people do. Obviously you pick where your own interests lie and are glad human beings are diverse.

OP posts:
Elizabetth · 18/11/2007 23:59

That is the question I've asked again and again in this thread custardo that only one person bothered to answer (and to be honest her answer was complete bollocks).

I've answered loads of questions on these threads (go back and check) and I'm happy to do so if I think people are really interested in engaging with discussion and not just barking out questions then sitting back and demanding they be answered. If people want to talk about lesbian porn or whatever then MAKE AN ARGUMENT.

I have made up my mind about what my argument is. Pornography is prostitution by proxy, men pay other men to fuck women for them and degrade them. A whole lot of things flow from that including judgements about those particular men's characters.

Tortington · 18/11/2007 23:54

your not playing by your own rules - and thats not fair. you asked 3 questions there.

to which my answer wouls be - make your mind up what your argument is. So now its about how seedy the viewer must be.

anything 'forced' and non consensual s wrong and i dont think anyone here would argue otherwise.

Men who like the degredation of women are to be dispised - this i have already argued below if you care to read. As long as the Degredation you are talking about is actual and not a sub text to mean porn as a genre.

ChampagneAndFlowers · 18/11/2007 23:52

Thanks Elizabeth. It makes me hate porn more but DH loves it

Elizabetth · 18/11/2007 23:51

I'm not misunderstanding you LEM. Paris Hilton got very angry in a porn shop recently because they were advertising the video made of her. She is clearly not happy about it.

You've ignored that and used a lot of slippery misogynistic arguments (Oh. My. God. She's been in magaazines) to justify what was done to her. Every woman who has been hurt gets the brush off and nobody wants to address the men who are creating the demand for this treatment of our sex.

Tortington · 18/11/2007 23:50

misogyny. Is it irony that Women can not be empowered to work in the sex industry without their being a sadistic undertone?

opps that was a question....we arn;t supposed to ask those....in a ....dis..cusi..on

Elizabetth · 18/11/2007 23:49

"you could have my finger for a million - thats the personal choice. but i wouldnt fuckon camera for a million - again my personal choice. but i wouldnt take away the right of other people who wanted to earn money that way to do so."

The question is what kind of a person wants to see someone having their finger chopped off? What kind of a person wants to watch a woman gagging on a penis or in bukkake, or having two penises forced into her rectum?

I quoted a porn viewer up there who stated quite directly that it was the degradation of the woman that turned him on. What does that say about him?

What does it say about men that they feel the need to pay other men to f*ck women and then watch the results? That they need to see women sexually objectified and serving them?

lucyellensmum · 18/11/2007 23:49

You clearly are deliberately misunderstanding me, i cant be bothered

lucyellensmum · 18/11/2007 23:46

im not about to read over a thousand threads, i was merely trying to understand your viewpoint, however if you would prefer me to remain ignorant? There ARE women who have made ALOT of money out of porn, Anna someone or other is an example. However i do tend to agree that women do get exploited which is wrong.

IF i had the figure for it, which i dont, and DP had fimed us (he has but we deleted it in a fit of giggles) and i was happy with the results then i would be happy to post it online, but perhaps im just an exhibitionist perv.

Elizabetth · 18/11/2007 23:45

Sophable, you still don't seem to be able to get out of the firing questions mode. How about you answer your own questions then I'll address your arguments. If you think something contradicts my reasoning then go ahead and make the argument but I'm not doing your work for you.

LEM, what you've said about Paris Hilton is what people say all the time about women who have been victimised. No empathy and a lot of misogyny on display.

ChampagneAndFlowers · 18/11/2007 23:43

Thanks Elizabeth. My man is defo a porn addict.

Elizabetth · 18/11/2007 23:40

ChampagneandFlowers, you might find this website useful - it's about porn addiction.

no-porn.com/

I'm not suprised you are angry.

lucyellensmum · 18/11/2007 23:39

have you spoken to DH champagne? What do you mean by constant

Elizabeth, i agree totally with your sentiments but Paris Hilton is hardly wide eyed and niave, sorry but she is not a good example and in my opinion not a victim. I could be wrong but i think just a publicity stunt. I do however think that a prostitute can be raped and is entitled to the same protection as any other woman.

Heathcliffscathy · 18/11/2007 23:39

actually lesbian porn is a really really good example. do you arguments follow in that genre?

and i'm not getting at you, i'm trying very hard to get to the nub of your argument.

Tortington · 18/11/2007 23:38

you could have my finger for a million - thats the personal choice. but i wouldnt fuckon camera for a million - again my personal choice. but i wouldnt take away the right of other people who wanted to earn money that way to do so.

Heathcliffscathy · 18/11/2007 23:37

elizabetth. what about a woman that cajoles her partner into filming her.

and did you look at my comstock films link? is that porn? documentaries about real life couples sexuality including explicit and arguably titillating footage of them having sex?

do you think all exhibitionists are to be reproached? how about lesbian porn? who is exploiting who there?

you have had horrible experiences with seeing things too young. do you see that that experience has coloured your perception of this whole area, just as my personal experiences have coloured mine?

Elizabetth · 18/11/2007 23:37

I've already said that an industry where women's bodies are commodities bought and sold by men is always going to be exploitative LEM.

It's a FANTASY (a real one not the pretend porn kind) that women in porn can become snappy business-women or liberated or empowered or whatever good things that porn-defenders stole from feminism and twisted in order to dress up women sexually serving men as somehow OK (they did it with lap-dancing, stripping, lipstick and high heels too). Being used like that is soul and body destroying. I don't know why you and others are so keen on that fantasy but you seem pretty set on clinging to it.

You keep asking questions which have already been answered LEM. Could you please read the thread because it will save a lot of energy.

ChampagneAndFlowers · 18/11/2007 23:32

LEM- I am thinking seriously of leaving him because of his constant look at porn, and if I am going to be honest I posted under the name of AngryLittleMummy about my lttle one seeing porn that DH left in the video. I was so pissed off about it.

I am so pi%%ed off right now. I don't now what do to tbh.

Elizabetth · 18/11/2007 23:31

Ah the myth of the "good victim". If Paris Hilton doesn't act in a totally ladylike way then it's OK to treat her like that, is it? I mean oh my god she put herself in magazines, that totally gives us all the right to see her having sex in private.

She allowed her boyfriend to film her. Maybe she was just like every other woman who has ever been persuaded by her boyfriend/husband to take sexual images of her that he would never let anybody else see it, wide-eyed, wide-eyed, "I love you far too much for that, this will just be between you and me, darling". Then he rushes off to youtube or the video distributors or wherever. It's always the victim's fault - she can't have been naive or duped or whatever.

lucyellensmum · 18/11/2007 23:30

Elizabeth - just an aside "This thing about force - you could probably persuade quite a few people to have their finger chopped off if you offered them a million dollars. If it was filmed and then people watched it for enjoyment, would it make it OK that the person hadn't been "forced"? "

There was actually a tales of the unexpected that was about just that, i can't quite remember what the twist was though. As for me, yep, you could have my finger for a million, but only the pinky!!

Serious question as your posts have focused on exploitation and that is very valid and from that standpoint i agree with you. But i was just wondering how you feel about porn that is not exploitative that the women starring in it are doing so because they are good at what they do and are business women with no self esteem problems etc etc, in a situation where exploitation is outlawed, what is your opinion then. Or do you object to the whole image of women in porn too, if that is the right word. Just wondered

lucyellensmum · 18/11/2007 23:24

champagne, please don't be thinking about leaving your DH because of porn. If it has a detrimental affect on your relationship that is different, but a bit of wank fodder is hardly cause for divorce, although i have read your other thread and i would have been livid as i said. I do think you need to talk this through with your DP. Its difficult for me to comment on this actually as my DP is a take it or leave it type when it comes to porn, he doesnt look at it alone, im not saying he never has but it is something, because i am ok with it, we look at together, cant be doing with wank mags but we have a few videos, although for the reason that i cannot be sure the women are getting a fair deal, we wont be watching them, these were films we borrowed from friends who borrowed from friends if you see what i mean so i cannot be sure. I do think if it was more legitimised and the Mary Whitehouse brigade didnt force sex underground then there would be more protection for all involved.

lucyellensmum · 18/11/2007 23:19

Nothing to do with her money, im quite shocked you think it is. But she has a track record for questionable behaviour, yes that doesn;t excuse the boyfriend but i think she has put herself in magazines etc etc. So..........also, shes Paris Hilton, i dont think she is so niave to think that someone videoing her doing whatever isnt going to cash in on it . There is real exploitation in the porn industry, i just do not think that woman as a crusader for womens rights. In fact her behaviour in the past has infuriated me and the fact that she seems to be such a role model for young girls, so excuse me if my sympathy is limited. Exploitation is when poor women, for whatever reason are bullied into porn, when women are tricked into porn or coerced by shit bastard boyfriends and this must be stopped, but i just do not understand why you cannot accpet that there are women who are willing participants who do well financially etc. Not all women and that is why i have made a concious decision not to watch porn any more, i have never downloaded from the internet as that is where i would consider exploitation to be rife. When i say not watch porn anymore, i think i might watch it once a year. What we should be campaining for is protection of women who chose this industry, because there is money to be made out of sad guys who want to toss away the evening, and couples who want to watch porn together etc - but the money should be going to the women principally. I should imagine that there are women who exploit other women in the porn industry too.

madamez · 18/11/2007 23:18

INdeed, 'gonzo' porn started out as a contrast to the glossy stuff and initially was more about very basic production values and more natural-looking models. Some of it still is.
And there's no one single reason that's the same for everyone who watches a porn film, any more than there is for everyone who watches a horror film or a romantic comedy.

Elizabetth · 18/11/2007 23:16

Just confiscate all his electronic equipment. He's probably an addict (and a bit of a knob by the sounds of it), then watch the withdrawl symptoms.

This thing about force - you could probably persuade quite a few people to have their finger chopped off if you offered them a million dollars. If it was filmed and then people watched it for enjoyment, would it make it OK that the person hadn't been "forced"?

ChampagneAndFlowers · 18/11/2007 23:12

Yes Elizabeth I really do believe this is how bad it had got. From your last thread which was really interesing (the first post)

I asked DH about the porn he wathces and does he think it is degrading to women and he replied "no, they are not forced into it" I totally disagree on this as I am sure each porn stars circumstances are different.

I am not a porn fan and my DH is shall I leave him? . I REALLY want to .

Elizabetth · 18/11/2007 23:09

What you mean because she was rich it was OK for her boyfriend to do that to her and for everyone else to join in the fun? Does having a few millions in the bank make public sexual exposure easier to handle?

She's not a prime example, she's just another example. As was Abi Titmus, as was the woman from the chip-shop probably, as was Imogen from Big Brother, as was Pamela Anderson who had to share the sex she had on her wedding night with the whole world or at least the voyeurs amongst us ( I wonder how many Mumsnetters would like to volunteer for that particular experience).

Maybe we should have a whole thread on empathy. Because it's sorely lacking on a great deal of this one.