Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be surprised at how many Mumsnetters are fine with pornography? II

735 replies

Judy1234 · 16/11/2007 17:30

Continuing the previous thread - people's sexuality varies hugely and what some people think is disgusting is good fun for others. It's impossible to generalise and say XYZ practice is wrong or repugnant and I agree with the posts at the end of the other thread that porn often just reflects what people do. Obviously you pick where your own interests lie and are glad human beings are diverse.

OP posts:
Walnutshell · 19/11/2007 10:02

HEAR HEAR EKRA

ekra · 19/11/2007 09:59

This is a fascinating debate and I am writing mostly in support of Elizabetths arguments.. It appears to be a debate with many geay areas. I am happy to acknowledge those gray areas but it is disturbing to me that there are a number of pro-pornography celebrators here who will not acknowledge the grey areas and they are happy with an ?anything goes? approach.

Men must be pissing themselves laughing that they?ve managed to get women to champion and defend their abuse of women.

Only 10 years ago there existed a sort of self-policing amongst women whereby men wouldn?t be given the time of day if they disclosed that they looked at material which referred to women as sluts, talked about ripping up their insides or destroying their pussy!

I fear that as misogynistic pornography becomes more mainstream (which it has if Nuts and Zoo are anything to go by) by the time my daughters are at University, they?ll be thought of as prudes by their fellow females if they don?t participate in the campus ?beach babe, writhe about a pole in your bikini and compare your tits, stage show? And if it becomes so very normalised, how are my daughters even going to discriminate between what is degrading and what is expected of them by everyone else?

Oh yes, but it?s just a bit of harmless fun

Walnutshell · 19/11/2007 09:48

"As for exploitation, where do you buy your clothes? I personally only buy from charity shops because i have a problem with exploitation in the clothing industry, i do not however take it upon myself to slag off everyone who buys their clothes from GAP!"

LEM - it always troubles me when people decide that you can't have an opinion about something unless you live according to an impossible set of rules. I don't think this thread has presented an argument simply about whether loving couple A watch consenting couple B having a shag on screen. It's much more about the wider context in which porn operates and a very relevant comment on a society that accepts anything in the pursuit of financial gain or sexual gratification.

lucyellensmum · 19/11/2007 09:37

I'm not misunderstanding you LEM. Paris Hilton got very angry in a porn shop recently because they were advertising the video made of her. She is clearly not happy about it.

I daresay her motivation for being pissed off was the fact that she wasn't being renumerated for her performance. I do not give a flying fuck about her morals, i am not one to talk based on my past, however this woman courts publicity at every opportunity, i think you are being niave if you think she is seriously bothered by this. This also detracts from your very valid and worthwhile argument about the obvious exploitation of women in porn.

I like looking at porn, i like to watch anal, i have not watch bukkake or bondage films so cannot comment, i would be deeply offended by what you describe as gonzo porn, but that does not make me a mysoginist as you seem to think everyone who likes porn is. I dont want to watch the men, i like to watch the women as i guess it fuels my own personal fantasy. BUT if IF you had bothered to get down from your high horse long enough to read my posts properly you would have realised that i have stated on more than one occasion that i am not comfortable with the exploitation of women in porn and because of that i will not be watching it. I will stick to my more than adequate imagination. My DP likes to watch porn with me, he certainly does not get off on denegrating women, i actually think he quite likes them - how strange, a man that actually likes women and admires their bodies, in your world they clearly dont exist. I am not comfortable with this argument because you insist on making it personal and draw me into making direct comments towards you. You clearly have issues and you clearly are presenting a well thought out, well researched argument, but you do need to accept that not everyone who watches porn is a woman hater!

As for exploitation, where do you buy your clothes? I personally only buy from charity shops because i have a problem with exploitation in the clothing industry, i do not however take it upon myself to slag off everyone who buys their clothes from GAP!

lucyellensmum · 19/11/2007 09:24

I'm not misunderstanding you LEM. Paris Hilton got very angry in a porn shop recently because they were advertising the video made of her. She is clearly not happy about it.

I daresay her motivation for being pissed off was the fact that she wasn't being renumerated for her performance.

I like looking at porn, i like to watch anal, gagging porn just makes me laugh, but that does not make me a mysoginist as you seem to think everyone who likes porn is.
I dont want to watch the men, i like to watch the women as i guess it fuels my own personal fantasy. BUT if IF you had bothered to get down from your high horse long enough to read my posts properly you would have realised that i have stated on more than one occasion that i am not comfortable with the exploitation of women in porn and because of that i will not be watching it. I will stick to my more than adequate imagination. My DP likes to watch porn with me, he certainly does not get off on denegrating women, i actually think he quite likes them - how strange, a man that actually likes women and admires their bodies, in your world they clearly dont exist. I am not comfortable with this argument because you insist on making it personal and draw me into making direct comments towards you. You clearly have issues and you clearly are presenting a well thought out, well researched argument, but you do need to accept that not everyone who watches porn is a woman hater!

As for exploitation, where do you buy your clothes? I personally only buy from charity shops because i have a problem with exploitation in the clothing industry, i do not however take it upon myself to slag off everyone who buys their clothes from GAP!

Walnutshell · 19/11/2007 08:24

It is tomorrow Champers!

floopowder - eagerly awaiting your really interesting new thread...

ChampagneAndFlowers · 19/11/2007 01:48

I gueuss Elizabeth has gone to bed. Oh well, speak to her tomorrow.

flooplowder · 19/11/2007 01:27

Nope, I've just got in from work and having some down time before bed. I am very suprised that this thread is still going on. Wouldnt mind going to a rave tho its been a few years since I've been to one of those.

ChampagneAndFlowers · 19/11/2007 01:25

Elizabeth -are you still around?

JeremyVile · 19/11/2007 01:02

Have you just stopped by the PC on your way to refilling your punch bowl and MCing the nu-rave dance off in you lounge floopowder?

flooplowder · 19/11/2007 00:59

Is this STILL going on!!! How boring you lot are.

minorityrules · 19/11/2007 00:57

Ok, I'll ask again

How does gay (man) porn affect us poor meek unable to think woman if ALL porn is bad (in your eyes)

LaDiDaDi · 19/11/2007 00:55

I want to know what those who are stridently anti-porn would like to see happen in real-life?

I think that the only way to go is to have a highly regulated and very transparent porn industry to ensure that all pornography prodecued is consensual and safe for the performers who are properly renumerated along with education in a much wider context. It may sem a bit chicken and egg but I think that the only way to prevent the very degrading/abusive imagery been made would be to change societal views about women in general. Even then what one woman views as abhorrent may be perfectly acceptable and sexually exciting for another.

Another point I have is about who, ie what demographic, views the pornography that is described as particularly demeaning to the women involved? I wonder if it is angry young men who feel disenfranchised and disillusioned in today's society. Young men who are out of work (or see no need for work), who feel no role for them as a father to their offspring etc etc? This isn't meant to excuse anyone's behaviour but perhaps to make us think about what can be done.

Elizabetth · 19/11/2007 00:51

"so women are just too thick to realise they are being forced into something that they have no choice over. all women in the sex industry are too stupid to realise that ? women have no power when it comes to the sex industry - the services they offer they offer becuase really they would rather be working as a doctor but havent got the money."

No women make the decisions they feel are right for them within the very limited circumstances our male-dominated society affords women. That doesn't make anybody stupid, it just makes society unequal and unkind to people in desperate situations.

Do you need money to become a doctor? I'm not sure what that argument is supposed to mean.

"well i think thats a capitalist bullshit choice we all make - i chose not to fuck on camera and make lots of money being subjugated by a male dominated industy weiling its power over poor defenseless me. i chose instead to be poor."

Most women in pornography do not make a lot of money unless they retain the rights to their films (and I only know of Jenna Jameson who did that and it appeared to be more the work of her husband) so this rich or poor argument doesn't hold any water.

"i think its a bullshit argument to imply that women have no choice. they do. i think your whole argument disenfranchises women and their choices and their lifestyles in the sex industry."

I think you are blind to the circumstances a lot of women who go into porn find themselves in. I don't disenfranchise anybody. The porn industry does that to women portraying us as secondary beings designed to sexually service or be degraded by men.

Elizabetth · 19/11/2007 00:46

"E asks questions but then refuses to answer"

You're wrong (or lying) I've answered lots of questions.

It appears that certain people ask questions becasue they can't be bothered to construct even the semblance of an argument.

EricL · 19/11/2007 00:35

It's a sad replacement for the real thing isn't it?

I used to buy porn when i was a wide-eyed teenager but haven't touched it since i discovered the real thing.

I think i am in a minority though.

Tortington · 19/11/2007 00:31

her sexuality or that of anyone else is indeed not at question here and has nothing to do with the debate

i rather think its swings and roundabouts - at the moment there are more people arguing in the defense of porn - but earlier there was only a couple and quite a lot of anti.

JeremyVile · 19/11/2007 00:24

I dont get why E keeps being asked to explain her own sexuality/sex life.
What does that have to do with the general debate?
Also, it's quite unfair to expect her to answer all questions when, apart from anything else, she is mostly arguing her points single handedly (which I dont think is indicative of the ratio of views held - it's just that she has super human stamina - I for one just looked at the thread early on and thought 'I can't be arsed').

Tortington · 19/11/2007 00:21

so women are just too thick to realise they are being forced into something that they have no choice over. all women in the sex industry are too stupid to realise that ? women have no power when it comes to the sex industry - the services they offer they offer becuase really they would rather be working as a doctor but havent got the money.

well i think thats a capitalist bullshit choice we all make - i chose not to fuck on camera and make lots of money being subjugated by a male dominated industy weiling its power over poor defenseless me. i chose instead to be poor.

i think its a bullshit argument to imply that women have no choice. they do. i think your whole argument disenfranchises women and their choices and their lifestyles in the sex industry.

ChampagneAndFlowers · 19/11/2007 00:17

Elizabeth -Would you have sex with a woman?

minorityrules · 19/11/2007 00:17

No word on homosexual porn either, I asked that in the first thread

E asks questions but then refuses to answer

Elizabetth · 19/11/2007 00:08

Mainstream lesbian porn is created by men for men.

The other stuff is sadly lesbians imitating the worst of heteronormativity. Also a lot of men are consumers of that kind of pornography too.

Even if lesbian porn was non-exploitative it still wouldn't undermine any of the arguments I've made about mainstream heterosexual pornography which comprises the vast majority of pornography created and viewed.

ChampagneAndFlowers · 19/11/2007 00:07

What do you mean lesbian porn? I am curious?

hunkermunker · 19/11/2007 00:03

So no word on lesbian porn then?

I'd say that if women do it with other women, then nobody's exploiting anybody, by your argument.

Elizabetth · 19/11/2007 00:01

Also those questions were rhetorical. They constitute an argument even if nobody does choose (that's what choice means, where people have real options, not the bullshit pretence of "choice" in porn) to answer them.