Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be surprised at how many Mumsnetters are fine with pornography? II

735 replies

Judy1234 · 16/11/2007 17:30

Continuing the previous thread - people's sexuality varies hugely and what some people think is disgusting is good fun for others. It's impossible to generalise and say XYZ practice is wrong or repugnant and I agree with the posts at the end of the other thread that porn often just reflects what people do. Obviously you pick where your own interests lie and are glad human beings are diverse.

OP posts:
Walnutshell · 19/11/2007 12:04

But in any situation it's not all bad - surely the point of the debate is the very abusive and damaging side of porn. The 'nice bit' (if you like) where everyone is participating freely isn't really relevant except that it blinds people to what is going on because no one wants to be even remotely linked to something so horrific.

normabutty · 19/11/2007 12:03

Ekra - I also believe that not on pro-porn person has said that abuse and exploitation in the porn industry is ok. I believe they have all called for that abuse and exploitation to be ended by means of legal rights for porn stars and regulation of the industry. (which follows Madamez's analogy with marriage, whereby it is not illegal for a husband to force his wife to have sex, etc.)

OrmIrian · 19/11/2007 12:03

ekra - "Only 10 years ago there existed a sort of self-policing amongst women whereby men wouldn?t be given the time of day if they disclosed that they looked at material which referred to women as sluts, talked about ripping up their insides or destroying their pussy"

Yes, I thought that too. I was beginning to wonder if I'd imagined it... Post-feminism for you!

normabutty · 19/11/2007 12:00

Ekra - I believe Madamez's point was that while abuse happens in some marriages there are other perfectly happy marriages...similarly there is some abuse in porn but there are some porn stars who are perfectly happy in there job. She's saying it's not all bad.

Walnutshell · 19/11/2007 11:59

Right - my fault for not reading the link. Thanks.

normabutty · 19/11/2007 11:57

Walnutshell - the link MT provided regarding legalised prostitution in Nevada suggested that the rights of prostitutes were less than those of 'normal' women. I was merely responding to the article by saying that legalising prostitution should not mean prostitutes lose rights. I was trying to point out that the article only shows that stricter regulation and enforcement of legislation was needed.

ekra · 19/11/2007 11:53

I don't think your analogy works. I don't think people are trying to ban sex. People are speaking out against abuses and exploitation that takes place in the pornography industry.

Plenty of people speak out and offer support to women who are abused by their husbands. What is disturbing is that there are women here who won't acknowledge that any abuse is taking place. So, let's look at the issue using the marriage analogy.

Imagine we're talking about women who are beaten unconscious by their husbands. Imagine if some of the responses on here were:

"She?s asking for it if she stays with him. Perhaps she likes it. She consented to the marriage. It's not doing any harm. It's normal for a husband to hurt his wife, if that's what they both want. She knows what she is doing. She is a grown women who has made her own choices, if she didn't want to be hurt, she wouldn't stay in the marriage"

There would be a little more than an outcry if those types of responses emerged.

Walnutshell · 19/11/2007 11:52

Have I missed the bit where someone was suggesting prostitutes be deprived any rights? That is certainly not my opinion and I haven't garnered it from this thread.

Madamez - are you saying that if a married woman believes that the porn industry is generally unfavourable to women, she is a hypocrite?

madamez · 19/11/2007 11:29

I do think it is a very closely related issue though MT: particularly in that, while horrible abuses of women do go on in marriage (and no one disputes that) many women also have happy marriages that they enter into out of their own free will...

normabutty · 19/11/2007 11:29

MT - the link you provided was interesting (sorry I missed it earlier but I was away this weekend...I didn't read all the links as I was trying to catch up with the 430 messages). However from what I read on it...it seems that tighter regulation is needed. No-one is suggesting that women should be forced to live or work under those conditions.

"The brothel prostitutes often live in prison-like conditions, locked in or forbidden to leave."
"One pimp starved a woman he considered too fat"

These should absolutely not be allowed. These are basic human rights issues.

"Then there is the fact that legal prostitutes seem to lose the rights ordinary citizens enjoy. From 1987, prostitutes in Nevada have been legally required to be tested once a week for sexually transmitted diseases and monthly for HIV. Customers are not required to be tested. The women must present their medical clearance to the police station and be finger-printed, even though such registration is detrimental: if a woman is known to work as a prostitute, she may be refused health insurance, face discrimination in housing or future employment, or endure accusations of unfit motherhood. In addition, there are countries that will not permit registered prostitutes to settle, so their movement is severely restricted."

Again, this is society viewing prostitutes as 'second class' citizens. I believe prostitutes should be entitled to the same opportunities as any other woman.

Monkeytrousers · 19/11/2007 11:23

aplos for typos

Monkeytrousers · 19/11/2007 11:22

That is an issue. It is a seperate one, and an even more compelx one than we are having here. The bartered bride, female circumsision (which is a way of ensuring the verginity of such women, are related but seperate issues. We shouldn't muddy the water too much if we want to feel we are having a constructive debate.

madamez · 19/11/2007 11:07

Those of you who are so anti-porn and sex work: what are your views on marriage? Given that marriage has long involved the buying and selling of women and even now something like one in four women are or have been violently abused by their husbands...

Monkeytrousers · 19/11/2007 11:00

I think what generally happens after prostitution is legalised is that politicians wash their hands of these women - and it does not halt women trafficking either.

I read a statistic the other day - not sure what it was in - that it is very likely that 1-10 men who visit prostitutes are raping women forced into the trade.

What was alarming is that in a study, only about 3% said this would stop them - they were more likely to have pause if the woman was unattractive or they were fearful of disease.

Monkeytrousers · 19/11/2007 10:58

I thought the same as you, but this gave me pause link

Monkeytrousers · 19/11/2007 10:55

Did you read the link I posted to the article about legalised prostitution in the US?

normabutty · 19/11/2007 10:42

"Well just ask yourself why prostitutes are vilified in all societies."

Actually I'd be more tempted to ponder why society views prostitutes in this way. Personally I would like to see prostitution legalised, in order to create a safe environment for these women. I think it is the narrow-mindedness of society that vilifies these women. If it were seen as more acceptable by society then perhaps these women would feel able to report rapes/assaults against them without feeling that no-one will care.

Monkeytrousers · 19/11/2007 10:36

Well just ask yourself why prostitutes are vilified in all societies.

Soph, most mainstream industrial porn is for male hetrosexuals, and most lesbian depictions in these are of male lesbian fantasy.

That isn't to say 'real' lesbian porn exists, just that is has a minimal market share.

normabutty · 19/11/2007 10:29

"Norma, Elizabeth isn't anti-sex. I think you are missing the point about industrial porn, not home grown free porn."

MT, I'm just trying to establish whether it is the money aspect or the 'degradation' that is the issue. I can't understand why it is degrading for a porn star to do those sexual acts if it not degrading for a couple to do them unless there is an issue with the fact they are paid. If that is the case then really the discussion is about whether people should be allowed to pay for sex, rather than the discussion being about women being degraded by porn.

I just feel the debate is going in circles...if an argument is made regarding the acts themselves not being degrading, the anti-ponr seem to respond by commenting on the money aspect (in that women only do it because they are desperate for money). If a counter argument is made about the money, the anti-porn people go back to saying the acts are degrading. I'm simply trying to clarify which is the actual issue.

Heathcliffscathy · 19/11/2007 10:24

staggered that you think lesbian porn is for men (i'm talking about lesbian porn, films made in the main by lesbians for lesbian consumption.). staggered that you think it is an imitation of heterosexual normality.

that is such an ignorant position. you seem to view pornography as exclusively heterosexual. and if it isn't, you cannot use the paying men exploiting poor degraded women argument so it seems you can't possibly acknowledge that there might be pornography out there that by it's very nature does not fit that template.

this does smack of an argument which is being made about pornography but in fact which is veiling some incredibly narrow definitions of what is 'acceptable' sexually.

if lesbian porn is a poor imitation of heterosexuality does it follow that you believe that lesbian sexuality (whatever that is....sexuality cannot be pinned down to some normative definition and that is the whole point) is a poor imitation also? or do you think that whilst there are lesbians doing their thing, a thing which is not an imitation of heterosexual sex, they are not depicting it on film because they are not interested in viewing it?

either way your stance is ridiculous.

Walnutshell · 19/11/2007 10:22

Yes, it is the levels of complexity that seem to have made the debate what it is on this thread. I suspect a lot of posters who describe themselves as pro-pron would agree with Elizabetth's comments if they could put to one side the simple issue of whether or not one likes to watch a consenting couple (or more) have sex (in whatever way).

Monkeytrousers · 19/11/2007 10:19

Norma, Elizabeth isn't anti-sex. I think you are missing the point about industrial porn, not home grown free porn.

Monkeytrousers · 19/11/2007 10:16

Ladidadi - No one, I think, is "stridently anti-porn", I'm certainly not; it's more complex than that.

normabutty · 19/11/2007 10:12

"I have made up my mind about what my argument is. Pornography is prostitution by proxy, men pay other men to fuck women for them and degrade them. A whole lot of things flow from that including judgements about those particular men's characters."

Thank you for clarifying that Elizabetth, I think it was starting to get lost with all the questions and comments.

I agree with most of what you say. If we define prostitution as being paid for sex, which is generally regarded as the definition, then yes pornography is prostitution by proxy. Admittedly it is 'dressed up' and appears less seedy than a woman walking the streets (to many people) but ultimately it is someone being paid for sex.

As approx. 72-73% of the viewers of porn are male, I would generally go along with it being men who pay for porn. I would also say that they are paying men (since I believe the majority of directors/producers are male) to produce the porn. I'd also agree that in general the porn is of the form where a woman gets fucked.

However I don't really agree that the woman is being degraded. I guess this is the only part of your argument that I disagree with. I don't feel that the sexual acts in themselves are degrading to women, unless the women are forced into them. I am willing to admit though that a lot of porn actresses are taken advantage of, by which I mean they feel they have to do certain things in order to make money. This is why I feel there should be more regulation, such as that suggested by Madamez earlier.

I would be interested though to know whether you find sexual acts such as ATM, blow jobs, anal are degrading in general or just in porn. I'm trying to determine if it's the fact the women are paid for these acts that make it degrading or whether it is the acts themselves. I'm wondering whether it would be considered degrading in each of the following circumstances:

  1. a consenting couple doing those acts in their own home, privately.
  2. a consenting couple doing those acts in their own home and filming it for private use
  3. a consenting couple doing those acts in their own home and filming it...then releasing it via the internet for general viewing.
  4. consenting porn stars doing those acts for money and it being released for general viewing.
policywonk · 19/11/2007 10:06

DaddyJ... do you mean to tell me that this government has made a big hoo-hah about a piece of legislation on the back of a media storm, and then gone on to bury it quietly when the attention dies down??

How very unlike them.