Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be surprised at how many Mumsnetters are fine with pornography? II

735 replies

Judy1234 · 16/11/2007 17:30

Continuing the previous thread - people's sexuality varies hugely and what some people think is disgusting is good fun for others. It's impossible to generalise and say XYZ practice is wrong or repugnant and I agree with the posts at the end of the other thread that porn often just reflects what people do. Obviously you pick where your own interests lie and are glad human beings are diverse.

OP posts:
Walnutshell · 19/11/2007 12:52

Exactly. How could we progress in the right direction if we are to be stifled in this way? Sounds like an excuse for maintaining the status quo...

Elizabetth · 19/11/2007 12:50

"the idea is to get sexual pleasure for the consumer."

Yup men get sexual pleasure from using and degrading women. Scary.

normabutty · 19/11/2007 12:50

"And how many women raped by their husbands ever get justice? The answer is incredibly few.

Women are not protected from sexual violence by laws which is why the claim that a bit of union organising and some regulation (what form would this regulation take by the way) is so incredible."

surely then by that reasoning we shouldn't bother having these laws. Perhaps we should ban marriage so that women can't be raped by husbands.

Do you not think that a society in which porn is regulated and gives the women starring in porn films rights also gives them a better standing within society. Do you not think that by changing society's view about trading sex as a commodity (and by that I mean changing it so that society does not look down on it) then gives all women more chance of getting rape convictions and therefore getting justice. Surely the only way to increase the number of convictions for rape is to make society realise that every woman has the right to say no at any time and that there is no shame in reporting rape (how many women do not report rapes because they worry about their past being used against them?)

Elizabetth · 19/11/2007 12:49

""People keep using this specious argument that if you do one bad thing, you can't criticise anything else, which again is nonsense." - I tried to say this earlier, but you have put it so much better! (It's the same if you are a vegetarian - "what, so are your shoes made of leather?" god help me)"

Oh yeah, very, very ANNOYING.

It's their consciences pricking. They haven't got an argument so they go on the attack. Nobody has to be consistent across the board in order to justify doing the right thing in some areas.

Tortington · 19/11/2007 12:49

"The idea behind pornography is the degradation and oppression of women. It is a tool used by men to ensure that women stay in second place, sexually serving them"

tosh. the idea is to get sexual pleasure for the consumer.

Elizabetth · 19/11/2007 12:47

"msl. you've addressed NOTHING in that post. and that's how you do it isn't it?"

I have addressed it.

"my point was that not all lesbian pornography is aimed at heterosexual men, neither is an imitation of heterosexuality nor is it bought by heterosexual men. i wondered where this left your argument that all pornography is about men degrading women. that pornography per se does this."

I never said that lesbian pornography was aimed at heterosexual men, I said that what they were doing was an imitation of heterosexual porn. Heterosexual pornography existed long before "real" lesbian porn came into existence. Some misguided lesbians decided to copy what they saw. It's called the pornofication of our society, where it leaks into cultures and areas where it didn't exist in any form before.

The idea behind pornography is the degradation and oppression of women. It is a tool used by men to ensure that women stay in second place, sexually serving them. Just because it is copied in by other groups doesn't detract from that initial point. And I also said earlier that even if it were true that lesbian porn was non-exploitative, it wouldn't make mainstream heterosexual pornography (the biggest market both in terms of cash generated and number of consumers) any less exploitative.

Lesbian porn does have a male audience (as well as its female one). The fact you don't know that says to me you know less about it than you think you do.

"please if you would address the point being made."

I did address your points - the fact that they are based on false premises.

Walnutshell · 19/11/2007 12:46

"People keep using this specious argument that if you do one bad thing, you can't criticise anything else, which again is nonsense." - I tried to say this earlier, but you have put it so much better! (It's the same if you are a vegetarian - "what, so are your shoes made of leather?" god help me)

Walnutshell · 19/11/2007 12:45

norma - my understanding of feminism is that it (rightly) incorporates a broad spectrum of beliefs central to which is the concept that women are equal to men. Equal does not imply same.

"I would rather have to work twice as hard for my money than get it simply because a company is worried about being sued." - I find that a worrying statement. I presume you are against tokenism - great - however, sometimes it takes a worry about being sued for a company to act FAIRLY and in accordance with the law.

kerala · 19/11/2007 12:42

With you all the way Elisbetth

Elizabetth · 19/11/2007 12:40

"I daresay her motivation for being pissed off was the fact that she wasn't being renumerated for her performance."

Wow, what a fucking callous, nasty thing to say. You appear to be unable to regard her as a human being with feelings, particularly with feelings about being put on display sexually for people to take a good long voyeuristic look at.

"I do not give a flying fuck about her morals, i am not one to talk based on my past, however this woman courts publicity at every opportunity, i think you are being niave if you think she is seriously bothered by this. This also detracts from your very valid and worthwhile argument about the obvious exploitation of women in porn."

It detracts from nothing. All you've done is laid bare once again the callous, lacking in empathy stance of the pro-porn brigade.

"I like looking at porn, i like to watch anal, i have not watch bukkake or bondage films so cannot comment, i would be deeply offended by what you describe as gonzo porn, but that does not make me a mysoginist as you seem to think everyone who likes porn is. I dont want to watch the men, i like to watch the women as i guess it fuels my own personal fantasy. "

Yeah, everybody likes to watch the women. You're getting off on their exploitation and degradation.

"BUT if IF you had bothered to get down from your high horse long enough to read my posts properly you would have realised that i have stated on more than one occasion that i am not comfortable with the exploitation of women in porn and because of that i will not be watching it. I will stick to my more than adequate imagination. "

Well I'm glad you're not going to watch it any more but up there you're saying you like it, so which is it?

"My DP likes to watch porn with me, he certainly does not get off on denegrating women, i actually think he quite likes them - how strange, a man that actually likes women and admires their bodies, in your world they clearly dont exist. I am not comfortable with this argument because you insist on making it personal and draw me into making direct comments towards you. You clearly have issues and you clearly are presenting a well thought out, well researched argument, but you do need to accept that not everyone who watches porn is a woman hater!"

I don't need to accept that in the slightest. Porn is based on misogyny - the idea that women's bodies can be bought and sold for men's enjoyment. Men who use it are, like I said earlier, misogynists.

"As for exploitation, where do you buy your clothes? I personally only buy from charity shops because i have a problem with exploitation in the clothing industry, i do not however take it upon myself to slag off everyone who buys their clothes from GAP!"

I get my clothes from fair trade shops and I buy very few of them. People keep using this specious argument that if you do one bad thing, you can't criticise anything else, which again is nonsense.

Elizabetth · 19/11/2007 12:40

"I daresay her motivation for being pissed off was the fact that she wasn't being renumerated for her performance."

Wow, what a fucking callous, nasty thing to say. You appear to be unable to regard her as a human being with feelings, particularly with feelings about being put on display sexually for people to take a good long voyeuristic look at.

"I do not give a flying fuck about her morals, i am not one to talk based on my past, however this woman courts publicity at every opportunity, i think you are being niave if you think she is seriously bothered by this. This also detracts from your very valid and worthwhile argument about the obvious exploitation of women in porn."

It detracts from nothing. All you've done is laid bare once again the callous, lacking in empathy stance of the pro-porn brigade.

"I like looking at porn, i like to watch anal, i have not watch bukkake or bondage films so cannot comment, i would be deeply offended by what you describe as gonzo porn, but that does not make me a mysoginist as you seem to think everyone who likes porn is. I dont want to watch the men, i like to watch the women as i guess it fuels my own personal fantasy. "

Yeah, everybody likes to watch the women. You're getting off on their exploitation and degradation.

"BUT if IF you had bothered to get down from your high horse long enough to read my posts properly you would have realised that i have stated on more than one occasion that i am not comfortable with the exploitation of women in porn and because of that i will not be watching it. I will stick to my more than adequate imagination. "

Well I'm glad you're not going to watch it any more but up there you're saying you like it, so which is it?

"My DP likes to watch porn with me, he certainly does not get off on denegrating women, i actually think he quite likes them - how strange, a man that actually likes women and admires their bodies, in your world they clearly dont exist. I am not comfortable with this argument because you insist on making it personal and draw me into making direct comments towards you. You clearly have issues and you clearly are presenting a well thought out, well researched argument, but you do need to accept that not everyone who watches porn is a woman hater!"

I don't need to accept that in the slightest. Porn is based on misogyny - the idea that women's bodies can be bought and sold for men's enjoyment. Men who use it are, like I said earlier, misogynists.

"As for exploitation, where do you buy your clothes? I personally only buy from charity shops because i have a problem with exploitation in the clothing industry, i do not however take it upon myself to slag off everyone who buys their clothes from GAP!"

I get my clothes from fair trade shops and I buy very few of them. People keep using this specious argument that if you do one bad thing, you can't criticise anything else, which again is nonsense.

Heathcliffscathy · 19/11/2007 12:37

pmsl. you've addressed NOTHING in that post. and that's how you do it isn't it?

my point was that not all lesbian pornography is aimed at heterosexual men, neither is an imitation of heterosexuality nor is it bought by heterosexual men. i wondered where this left your argument that all pornography is about men degrading women. that pornography per se does this.

please if you would address the point being made.

Elizabetth · 19/11/2007 12:31

"Ekra - I also believe that not on pro-porn person has said that abuse and exploitation in the porn industry is ok. I believe they have all called for that abuse and exploitation to be ended by means of legal rights for porn stars and regulation of the industry. (which follows Madamez's analogy with marriage, whereby it is not illegal for a husband to force his wife to have sex, etc.)"

And how many women raped by their husbands ever get justice? The answer is incredibly few.

Women are not protected from sexual violence by laws which is why the claim that a bit of union organising and some regulation (what form would this regulation take by the way) is so incredible.

Elizabetth · 19/11/2007 12:28

"staggered that you think lesbian porn is for men (i'm talking about lesbian porn, films made in the main by lesbians for lesbian consumption.). staggered that you think it is an imitation of heterosexual normality."

I didn't say they were made for men. I pointed out that a lot of men bought it. That's true. A lot of men do buy "On our Backs"

"that is such an ignorant position. you seem to view pornography as exclusively heterosexual. and if it isn't, you cannot use the paying men exploiting poor degraded women argument so it seems you can't possibly acknowledge that there might be pornography out there that by it's very nature does not fit that template."

Well obviously I don't as I acknowledged the existence of lesbian pornography.

"this does smack of an argument which is being made about pornography but in fact which is veiling some incredibly narrow definitions of what is 'acceptable' sexually."

Porn isn't sex. And don't bother trying to paint me as a prude. That's a bullshit argument too.

"if lesbian porn is a poor imitation of heterosexuality does it follow that you believe that lesbian sexuality (whatever that is....sexuality cannot be pinned down to some normative definition and that is the whole point) is a poor imitation also? or do you think that whilst there are lesbians doing their thing, a thing which is not an imitation of heterosexual sex, they are not depicting it on film because they are not interested in viewing it?"

Lesbian sexuality doesn't equal lesbian pornography. The fact you can't separate the two is your problem not mine.

"either way your stance is ridiculous."

It's not ridiculous it makes sense and it has substance. Unlike your arguments against it.

LaDiDaDi · 19/11/2007 12:27

MT, I can't believe that you cannot recognise "stridently anti-porn" as a description of some of the views, not specifically yours, expounded on this thread!

OrmIrian · 19/11/2007 12:21

Equality does not rule out differences between men and women norma. It prevents people from treating them differently where inappropriate.

normabutty · 19/11/2007 12:18

I should point out I do not think men are superior or women inferior. Just that they are different.

normabutty · 19/11/2007 12:17

Just on a side note regarding feminism. I am absolutely not a feminist in the usual sense. I do not want equal pay to a man, for example. I would rather have to work twice as hard for my money than get it simply because a company is worried about being sued. I don't believe in equality because I believe there are fundamental differences between men and women.

Walnutshell · 19/11/2007 12:12

I feel exactly the same as you Orm. I'm sure we're not the only ones but I struggle to find a like-minded soul. Some days I can't read the newspaper for fear of how antagonised I will get. Ah well, that's another thread.

OrmIrian · 19/11/2007 12:11

Of course walnutshell. And the sooner I manage to get that into my thick head the easier I'll find the world I suppose...

Monkeytrousers · 19/11/2007 12:09

People (and all animals) enter into relationships for joint evolutionary reasons - mostly to have children. Porn is a means of entertainment, third party entertainment at that.

Walnutshell · 19/11/2007 12:08

Ah, yes, sorry (again) - forgot about that norma. I do understand her point about porn generally but I think it has been overused to the detriment of the rest of her argument.

Walnutshell · 19/11/2007 12:07

Oh well, Orm, feminism has had it's day and been declared useless for women and society and - guess what - a lot of women believe it.

normabutty · 19/11/2007 12:05

The 'nice bit' is relevant. Elizabetth has on many occasions refused to believe there is any 'nice bit' out there. It was claimed (I think by E tho I may be wrong) all porn is degrading to women.

normabutty · 19/11/2007 12:04

not one

Swipe left for the next trending thread