Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be surprised at how many Mumsnetters are fine with pornography? II

735 replies

Judy1234 · 16/11/2007 17:30

Continuing the previous thread - people's sexuality varies hugely and what some people think is disgusting is good fun for others. It's impossible to generalise and say XYZ practice is wrong or repugnant and I agree with the posts at the end of the other thread that porn often just reflects what people do. Obviously you pick where your own interests lie and are glad human beings are diverse.

OP posts:
Monkeytrousers · 19/11/2007 13:39

Do you want to be more specific Kittock?

kittock · 19/11/2007 13:38

well if that's a strong consistent argument god preserve us from hysterical diatribes

Monkeytrousers · 19/11/2007 13:33

Ariel Levi defined porn as the art of sex demonstration, not real sex, but a parody.

JeremyVile · 19/11/2007 13:30

Elizabetth

Click the 'ignore' button on this thread and be satisfied that you have put forward a strong, consistent argument for your views (and you have done so in the face of some pretty idiotic, personal insults being spouted back at you at times).

Elizabetth · 19/11/2007 13:26

You're calling an act of prostitution on film "people fucking" which is incredibly misleading. That's what I mean by being unable to grasp the basic realities of porn.

I know my position on prostitution being wrong is an opinion but its an opinion back up by an awful lot of evidence and experience of women in prostitution.

3rd time lucky - I'm really gone!

Monkeytrousers · 19/11/2007 13:25

Jofe, again, no one is disputing that there are some women who choose to do it. What we are saying is that it is complicated and very FEW women actually do choose unambigously.

Monkeytrousers · 19/11/2007 13:24

Norma - "Ok, just a response to that last post Elizabetth. Voyeurism and prostitution are wrong in your opinion. These are not 'basic realities' as you put it. They are not facts, they are opinions.

I don't think there is anything wrong with either as long as no-one is forced to do anything against their wishes."

Voyerism is a fetish, I wouldn't know if it could be called 'wrong'. I don't know enough about it. On a basic level films appeal to us via a voyeuristc level. I don't think there is anything 'wrong' with watching people fuck, but mostly, people choose to do it in private. It isn't representative of the human species to do it like dogs. Some do, but it still isn't the 'norm' which is why some people think it's weird - which it might be, rather than 'wrong'.

Women only go into prostitution when all other avenues are exhausted ot they feel they have no other choice. Therefore it is not, on average, anyones wish to be a prostitute and attract the vilification they do by men and women alike. In this sense, it can been seen as being more 'wrong' than voyeurism, just bacause of the palpable stress and pain it causes women and their families. Like one of the prostitutes in the article said, "No one wants to be sold."

Tortington · 19/11/2007 13:19

elizabeth your arguments have been put clearly and very well a good debate i think - although att imes youhave become angry and this taints your responses

First off it's voyeurism, give it its real name. "Voyeurism isn't wrong" sounds a bit different doesn't it. Who wants to be a voyeur after all?

you can call it what you will - i dont think voyeurism sounds and better or worse - and certainly wouldnt make me feel dirty or seedy by want of calling it another name.

"Secondly "people fucking" sounds like two people who both want to do it when in fact in pornography you are watching someone being paid to be fucked which as everybody knows is called prostition. Prostitution is most definitely wrong."

well the merits or not of prostitution can lead onto a whole other discussion, but i dont think that prostitution in its essense is wrong.

2The fact that you can't even grasp these basic realities, is yet another example of why I really, really have to leave this thread."

they are your realities not mine. this doesn;t make either of us wrong just we have differnt points of view.

jofeb04 · 19/11/2007 13:18

I am pro-porn (legal, and not interested in anything violent etc) and pro-choice.

I know that there are women and men involved in the industry who doesn't want to be, and I feel that there needs to be further legislation stating that everyone has to give consent etc.

However, please realise that some women choose to do this.

Monkeytrousers · 19/11/2007 13:17

Eliz - "The idea behind pornography is the degradation and oppression of women. It is a tool used by men to ensure that women stay in second place, sexually serving them."

I don't agree with this idea, as I don't agree with the idea that rape is a tool used by men to keep women in place - the power not sex idea. But that is a different debate adn thread perhaps

normabutty · 19/11/2007 13:16

Ok, just a response to that last post Elizabetth. Voyeurism and prostitution are wrong in your opinion. These are not 'basic realities' as you put it. They are not facts, they are opinions.

I don't think there is anything wrong with either as long as no-one is forced to do anything against their wishes.

Elizabetth · 19/11/2007 13:09

OK one more thing -

"watching people fucking - people fucking isn't wrong - there is no egredation involved unless you consider fucking to be degrading."

First off it's voyeurism, give it its real name. "Voyeurism isn't wrong" sounds a bit different doesn't it. Who wants to be a voyeur after all?

Secondly "people fucking" sounds like two people who both want to do it when in fact in pornography you are watching someone being paid to be fucked which as everybody knows is called prostition. Prostitution is most definitely wrong.

The fact that you can't even grasp these basic realities, is yet another example of why I really, really have to leave this thread.

Tortington · 19/11/2007 13:07

JV your verbal vitriol was justified - forgive my naivety in thinking you coulnt possibly be responding to my post at that level.

Elizabetth · 19/11/2007 13:04

"Only 10 years ago there existed a sort of self-policing amongst women whereby men wouldn?t be given the time of day if they disclosed that they looked at material which referred to women as sluts, talked about ripping up their insides or destroying their pussy"

This really sums up why I'm so suprised at how many women here will defend porn to the nth degree, including acts of vicious torture against women.

I am going to leave this conversation because the pro-porn side have addressed frankly nothing that has been brought up here, insisting that their exceptions (like lesbian or gay porn or hubby practising his porno-direction skillz with the home video camera) prove that the industry as a whole isn't about degrading and hurting both the women in pornography and women as a group, and just plain ignoring any FACTS that get in the way of their fanatasies about how marvellous porn is. Instead we get the same tired old myths banged out again and again, as if repeating them would somehow counteract the arguments and evidence that has been presented here.

It does come down to empathy, either you think it's OK for women to be bought, sold and used by men for their pleasure or you don't. The facts are on the anti-porn side because no industry that treats human beings in this way could possibly be ethical or good for the people it used in its enterprises. Women are hurt by porn, both in the making of it and by its existence. Women are damaged by it. Most women in porn don't come out whole, they come out drug-addicted, with PTSD, poor and sometimes even dead. That is because they are used (or to put it in the words of a porn director "used up").

The good thing however is that there are obviously quite a number of women who are willing to face the reality and to speak out against it refusing to accept that this is just what we have to put up with because some men like it.

JeremyVile · 19/11/2007 13:03

I didn't think you were.
I was responding to your post.

kittock · 19/11/2007 13:03

It's like a cross between "The Moral Maze" and a chimpanzee's tea party.

Tortington · 19/11/2007 13:02

sorry that should read - i was not responding to the gag porn stuff. rather than i am not going to with stomping of feet. i was responding to a comment elizabeth made.

Tortington · 19/11/2007 13:01

i am not responding to your gag porn conversation with another mumsnetter JV. calm down theres a love.

kittock · 19/11/2007 12:57

This whole thread is nuts. I'm beginning to suspect that Melanie Philips is behind it all.

JeremyVile · 19/11/2007 12:56

....nor the context, nor the motivation behind them.

JeremyVile · 19/11/2007 12:54

That's bollocks Custy - 'fucking' does not even begin to cover the acts that are being discussed.

Walnutshell · 19/11/2007 12:53

No one has suggested that people having sex is wrong - why does this keep coming up?

Walnutshell · 19/11/2007 12:52

Sorry, that was obv in answer to "Nobody has to be consistent across the board in order to justify doing the right thing in some areas. "

Tortington · 19/11/2007 12:52

the women arn't degraded - the sexual please ure is not from degredation its from watching people fucking - people fucking isn't wrong - there is no egredation involved unless you consider fucking to be degrading.

JeremyVile · 19/11/2007 12:52

LEM - You said that gag porn makes you laugh - why is that?

Do you find humour in someone choking generally? If the person was choking on some food for instance, is that funny?

Or is it funny because it's a penis she's choking on? Is it because she looks so utterly without dignity? It surely looks farcical to see a naked woman on the verge of vomiting because she has a penis rammed so far into her mouth.

The things that make it amusing to you are probably the same things thast make it sexually arousing for those who enjoy gag porn.

I just dont understand how anyone could see that as anything but upsetting - knowing that these men are getting off on seeing a woman being humiliated and in physical discomfort/pain.