Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be surprised at how many Mumsnetters are fine with pornography? II

735 replies

Judy1234 · 16/11/2007 17:30

Continuing the previous thread - people's sexuality varies hugely and what some people think is disgusting is good fun for others. It's impossible to generalise and say XYZ practice is wrong or repugnant and I agree with the posts at the end of the other thread that porn often just reflects what people do. Obviously you pick where your own interests lie and are glad human beings are diverse.

OP posts:
Monkeytrousers · 19/11/2007 14:54

But I don't Madamez. What vested interest do I have?

And yes, this is what the site is for. But when people are obvioulsy in a great deal of pain, it's just perhaps a bit self serving to hijack for your own positive agenda.

Anyway, it was just an aside. I have no wish to villify you for your choices either. I am a 'good' feminist

Walnutshell · 19/11/2007 14:52

absolving of responsibility? or too harsh?

madamez · 19/11/2007 14:51

MT: if I have a vested interest then so do you. With regard to other threads about peoplke's relationships, I appreciate that sometimes in the beginning I did kind of heolp hijack discussions (which is more due to me being used to a different style of forum where threads would wander off at all sorts of tangents all the time). But sometimes I do feel (with regard to relationship threads) that a different persepective on sexual issues might be helpful to people with questions or problems and isn;t that what the site is supposed to be for?

Monkeytrousers · 19/11/2007 14:50

self validating?

Walnutshell · 19/11/2007 14:48

"And that the things that are wrong with them are things that were and are wrong with the rest of society first and on a much bigger scale." 'Art' reflecting life reflecting art....

Monkeytrousers · 19/11/2007 14:44

You might be right. And good for you.

But in the past you have joined threads about peoples husbands becoming addicted to porn, about how it is ruining their families and lives, only to defend porn on the whole.

I understand you have a personal vested interest, and obvioulsy a great need to validate that interest, which may be telling of something in itself. This thread is the arena for that, not the realsionship threads though, which is maybe why your opinions on porn are often argued with - they are just aired in the wrong forum. I have probably been influenced by that in these debates with you - MN baggage!

madamez · 19/11/2007 14:38

I doin't think I am ignoring the exploitation of women in the industry. I have always tried ot make sure that any project I am inovlved in featuers consenting adults only, discussed pay in advance, discussed exactly what is in the script and who does what to whom. I have persuaded other people to stop giving work to a particular individual whose behaviour was unacceptable (conning people and an inability to keep his hands to himself). I have contributed time and money to initiatives helping migrant sex workers.
nd I still maintain that sex work and porn are not wrong. And that the things that are wrong with them are things that were and are wrong with the rest of society first and on a much bigger scale.

Monkeytrousers · 19/11/2007 14:35

For one I'm not anti-porn, to say I was anti-porn would be like saying I was anti-the common cold. I am concerned about the morality of industrial porn and the well documented costs involved to the women in the industry.

Monkeytrousers · 19/11/2007 14:32

Well you go out and try it for yourself then.

Monkeytrousers · 19/11/2007 14:32

I have never ignored the voices of women in the indusrty, I have went to great lengths to say that a minority of women will do this by unabiguous choice and that they should not be villified for that (but they will be regardless).

We also however, should not ignore the voices of women in the industry who talk of endemic exploitation.

normabutty · 19/11/2007 14:31

That is where we disagree MT, because I do not believe that money for sex has to involve exploitation.

normabutty · 19/11/2007 14:29

MT - I'm not suggesting that women should be 'forced' into prostitution because of their financial circumstances and this is what the anti-porn people are failing to see. The pro-porn argument is purely that people should be able to enjoy having sex, watching sex, being paid for sex, etc. We believe this is possible without exploiting women.

Monkeytrousers · 19/11/2007 14:29

Norma, I think whereever money is involved exploitaion is involved. If it were a free transaction then we could be sure that it wasn't. All I am saying is that you cannot be sure, even with non violent industrial porn, that exploitation is not involved. For that reason I avoid it.

But even us as women discussing this are pretty irrelevent. Even if we all decided to boycott porn until we could be sure that every woman in it was expessing their true sexuality, it would have little effect because men drive the market not women.

Monkeytrousers · 19/11/2007 14:25

Norma: Well I'd rather women were helped to find other choices before needing to go into any form of prostitution.

There will always be a minority of women who have extremely high libido's coupled with a taste for exhibitionism as Madamez has desctibed.

We have said there is nothing 'wrong' with this, or these women's chouces to display their acts for further erotic fulfillment. But these women are not representative of women on the whole. They are representative of a minority of women.

madamez · 19/11/2007 14:24

Voyeurism isn't wrong. Nor is prostitution. Coercion is wrong, but so is prohibiting consensual behaviour on the grounds that you don't like it.

ANd the basic reality that all the anti-porners fail to grasp is that by blaming all sexism and inequality on porn and sex work, they are getting the wrong end of the stick. Societies which prohibit women from sexual expression, prohibit them from selling sex (except in one lifetime deal to the highest bidder ie marriage) are not societies which favour women's advancement. If you stick to just the narrow example of the UK, women's rights have improved ocnsiderably since the social upheaval of the 60s, along with the delcline in censorship. We don;t have a fully equal world yet but we are still going forwards, not backwards, and open communication about sex rather than a paranoid projection of all one's worst fears onto some shitfing spectre called 'pornography' is what will improve the situation. .To some extent and in some cases, women in the sex industry who defend their rights to work as they choose and not be treated as morons, victims or less-than-human are speaking out for the rights of women not to have their sexuality controlled and policed by other people , not to be condemned for indulging in sex how, when, why and with who they like. Including doing it for money.Because condemnation of sex workers or a complete refusal to take them seriously is really not very far at all from telling women that they have to stay within certain limits (cover yourself up, only have sex with your husband, have children when you're told to not when you want to) and that every choice a woman makes must impact on all women so whatever she decides she can be blamed for something...

normabutty · 19/11/2007 14:23

MT - I don't think any of the pro-porn people are saying exploitation isn't happening. I think they're arguing that it doesn't have to happen. I think the pro=porn side are saying with proper regulation and rights for workers the industry could be succesful without the exploitation. (unless of course you think that prostitution by definition - i.e. being paid for sex - is exploitation, this I think is where Elizabetth and I disagree)

Monkeytrousers · 19/11/2007 14:22

Elizabetth's argument is a personal one, some of which I don't agree with, some I do.

From my perspective, and based on my research on female sexuality, industrial porn subverts female sexuality to resemble male sexuality, and therefore isn't representative of the majority of women.

That is not to say women don't like sex, or even pornography, but that the argument that is it just representing what happens in real life is not tenable.

normabutty · 19/11/2007 14:20

Well I thought she was arguing for us to have empathy with the women used in porn films. I thought she was saying that if we had any empathy with those women we wouldn't want to watch porn.

I don't disagree with the idea that we should empathise with the women's circumstances that have perhaps lead them into porn. However I am still pro-choice, even if the choices available are limited. I also argue that some porn stars want to do the job.

Monkeytrousers · 19/11/2007 14:18

as far as I am aware the debate is about industrial porn - as when penetration is explicit.

The banning debate is seperate, this was a debate seems mostly about the morals of industrial porn. Some people don't seem to be aable to get the idea that a lot fo women are exploited by the industry and that many porn actresses (they are called actresses because it is a performance) have very troubled backgrounds which make the concept of 'consent' and 'choice' very murky.

kittock · 19/11/2007 14:14

Alright - I really wasn't going to get drawn in yet again, but you win.

What is it actually a consistent argument for? Elizabetth and others have ruled out the idea of banning anything (even stuff which those whom she calls "pro-porners" have suggested might be worth consideration of a ban)and dismissed many "pro-porners" calls for regulation of the industry - so what are we all actually arguing for?

But the main thing I object to is the repeated use of false logic in applying the features of certain types of pornography to all pornography.

I don't see how you can have a reasoned debate about something that you haven't defined and which you use to mean different things as and when it suits you. The meaning of pornography in this debate has veered wildly across the thread from anything involving photographs of naked women to extreme gonzo porn. If we're talking about extreme and violent porn, let's have a debate about that. If we're talking about all representations of sex, that's something different. It's like wrestling a bucket of eels.

I could go on, but I promised myself I woudn't.

Monkeytrousers · 19/11/2007 14:00

There seem to be two tactics being used by the pro-industrial porn'ers, and they are ad hominem and reductio ad absurdum. Attacking the person not the argument, or making ridiculous claims about the argument then trying to claim the whole argument is therefore ridiculous itself.

JeremyVile · 19/11/2007 13:53

Kittock - please do let us know when you are ready to expand further on your last few posts.

I'm sure it will be thrilling

normabutty · 19/11/2007 13:48

at Kittock.

I'd say Elizabetth has been consistent in her argument.

I disagree with some of her points but I don't think she's been inconsistent. I've found it quite difficult to argue with in the sense I feel we go round in circles...it's the money aspect, it's the degrading aspect, it's the men using the women aspect, it's the money aspect...

I don't really see why anyone has to get personal about how Elizabetth has made her points tbh. It is difficult if you feel someone hasn't responded to an attempt to further understand their argument though.

Monkeytrousers · 19/11/2007 13:46

Well i think if the insinuation that Elizabeth's argument was/is nothing but a hysterical diatribe it doesn't stand up and is a bit of cheap shot to be honest.

kittock · 19/11/2007 13:40

Not at this point no