Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be surprised at how many Mumsnetters are fine with pornography? II

735 replies

Judy1234 · 16/11/2007 17:30

Continuing the previous thread - people's sexuality varies hugely and what some people think is disgusting is good fun for others. It's impossible to generalise and say XYZ practice is wrong or repugnant and I agree with the posts at the end of the other thread that porn often just reflects what people do. Obviously you pick where your own interests lie and are glad human beings are diverse.

OP posts:
onebatmother · 16/11/2007 20:00

vs I agree and second all you say about sex. but I don't think we're talking about sex..

although I know you don't agree, I think that sex and porn are critically different things.
So admire (and share to an extent) your sexual at-ease-ness (sorry) but it doesn't bring me closer to your views on ponr.

sorry i've said this before.

VictorianSqualor · 16/11/2007 19:53

Just promise me the toaster was for toast

VictorianSqualor · 16/11/2007 19:51

Something I wanted to say wrt the beginning of this thread, doing things that turns my partner on turns me on, I get a thrill from seeing how randy I make him and that power is a real buzz to many women. I wear lingerie for him, make-up I know turns him on, I say words that I know get him going (words he wouldnt hear me say at any other time) yes, this is done for him, but because I love his reaction, IMO, having a good sexual relationship with someone means partly doing things to please them, and they you, (I bought up the subject of anal sex earlier after this thread and dp said if it was something I would like to do to him I could- with a sextoy obviously!)
Bouncing off each other and enjoying each other's vibes is a big part of it, or at least for me.

LEM, as many have said brave post, but I think really it's quite normal!! I enjoy the same things and I know friends of mine do too.

onebatmother · 16/11/2007 19:40

lEM - absolutely understand no no no not a freak!

but things like that are v different when blown up to a macro level ie not in bedroom but on screen. It takes on a different power, different meaning, different function. I think.

also can i second bravery comment.

sorry, so should have put dc's to bed by now hence brevity

minorityrules · 16/11/2007 19:39

It think anal followed by oral

onetiredmummy · 16/11/2007 19:38

As long as it doesn't get into the carpet

KerryMum · 16/11/2007 19:37

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

onetiredmummy · 16/11/2007 19:35

Yees, I'd like to know too...

KerryMum · 16/11/2007 19:33

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Elizabetth · 16/11/2007 19:28

I'm not upset Lucy. Do you think you might be projecting your own feelings possibly, this is a very disturbing subject after all? I was pretty pissed off yesterday when I was getting attacked, but I'm not upset.

You didn't upset me, you annoyed me but I expressed my annoyance (and gave a little something back), so don't worry about it.

onetiredmummy · 16/11/2007 19:27

LEM - I admire your comments & honesty about the BDSM subject.

Elizabetth · 16/11/2007 19:26

I do need to stop, but it's to get on with the evening LucyEllensMum, not because I have some kind of issue. I mean I do have issues with porn but I think that is a normal healthy reaction rather than this numb acceptance of its viciousness that we see displayed here.

Being disturbed by porno images and empathising with the women in it is the healthy reaction, being turned on by ATM, gagging porn, "pussy destoyers', barely legal etc etc is the unhealthy one.

So thanks for your concern but honestly my view is that probably quite a few of the porn users here need to talk to someone rather than vocifeously defending their habits (and sometimes attacking the people who disagree with them in the process). Finding out why their empathy for vulnerable women seems to be blunted might be a good place to start.

lucyellensmum · 16/11/2007 19:23

honestly elizabeth, i really do think you should stop. I dont want to think that you are going to have a shit weekend because you are going to be haunted by this thread. Your posts elsewhere have always been really usefull, sympathetic and supportive, you are a great Mnetter and im really upset that i have upset you. Please just give yourself a rest from this, its clearly upsetting you.

Elizabetth · 16/11/2007 19:21

You know that girl in the BangBros article I linked to was crying. It means she didn't like what was being done to her. Sex that a woman doesn't want is rape. Just because she was paid for it doesn't mean that what was done to her didn't damage her (and she didn't get paid her boyfriend stole the money).

I was going to cut and paste a Robert Jensen article that describes the sort of things that are done to women in mainstream porn (he has watched it) but then I had to second guess myself because probably the descriptions would be enough to get me banned from Mumsnet. They are incredibly offensive and disturbing.

If you are still in denial about what porn is like these days, please read the article in this link (it's a better option than going to the BangBros website and being disturbed and offended) -

mwcnews.net/content/view/3286/26/

lucyellensmum · 16/11/2007 19:19

elizabeth, i havent read the other thread, but please dont take this the wrong way, im going to step away from this thread now, as i jokingly made some stupid comments and upset you, BUT i can see this whole thing is actually quite upsetting for you, so much so that you feel you need to be quite vociferous in your campaign. Might i suggest that you stop. Seriously, you obviously have some personal issues with this and this thread seems to have taken a shitty turn for you. I think carrying on will be upsetting for you and that is why i am not going to comment any further. I think this is something that you should discuss, but not here.

Elizabetth · 16/11/2007 19:14

"oh Elizabeth come....on - if you are trying to make a cohesive and intelligent argument then admit you have never seen the source of that which you are arguing against - i think it is relevant to the person with whom you are discussing - no?"

I can't watch porn. It literally disturbs me now because I was exposed to it when I was a kid (see other thread) and as a young adult. I can't watch women being abused because I feel empathy with them. I'm not the only person who has this problem. People with PTSD can be caused to have flashbacks with porn.

I haven't lied about the contents of BangBros or any other porn. Ass to mouth exists, gagging porn exists, gang rape scenes exist, double penetration exists. I'm not going to watch those things because I don't want to see women being tortured but I'll definitely speak out against them and about the whole of pornography which is based on hatred of women.

Also I have seen porn, I know its content and I understand the mindset that creates it and watches it.

lucyellensmum · 16/11/2007 19:11

onebatmother, i would definately NOT want to see that on a site like bangbros, but i DO like my DP to say that to me when we have sex, does that make me a freak? We have a very equal (in fact the power probably tips more in my direction if we are honest)relationship but sometimes, i like it a bit rough around the edges. I think lots of women do, or is it really just me? I havent name changed to post this and i post alot here, but im not ashamed of my views and i would hate to think that people would judge me on my posts too. But i guess we live in a judgemental society.

DaddyJ · 16/11/2007 19:09

And that's where my concern comes in that
I voiced on the other thread in response to
ruty and others:

Porn constantly evolves - how can we say:
right, you have crossed a line now?

onebatmother · 16/11/2007 19:08

v good post oenophile esp the bit about women who enjoy sex deserving contempt

lucyellensmum · 16/11/2007 19:08

christ, that is not good, i would have to agree that that site is not good, and elizabeth that does sound outrageous as well. That sort of language about a woman is disgusting and even Daddyj, you have to admit that is wrong. Especially as the site appears to be aimed at young men?? Dont know, havent seen it, not going to look, ive not eaten!

I think Elizabeth, your points about this site in general are very valid. Can i just ask as i dont have time to read the other thread how you would feel about porn where the actress was well paid, good at her job and happy to perform all sorts of things, within reason.

Also, what does Ass to mouth mean, that surely cannot be what i think it means - [vomit]

DaddyJ · 16/11/2007 19:07

Oenophile, that is the real debate, I agree with you there!

And I do hope mmj comes back to add to that point.

But what to do?
What to do about rap & hip-hop which made
the 'ho' and 'beatch' popular in the first place?

onebatmother · 16/11/2007 19:07

interesting daddyj
i think i think that the language is critical.

ie plain fucking fine (well not, but i've gone on about that already)

plain fucking plus 'fuck you you fucking little bitch etc etc" v different.

Tortington · 16/11/2007 19:05

"Do you really think that is a priority for me, persuading Custardo to trust me?"

oh Elizabeth come....on - if you are trying to make a cohesive and intelligent argument then admit you have never seen the source of that which you are arguing against - i think it is relevant to the person with whom you are discussing - no?

DaddyJ · 16/11/2007 19:05

I bet you want to be rude
now that you have been exposed as a fraud!

This is like an episode of Rogue Traders -
go on, let rip, dogy anti-porn merchant, you

Tortington · 16/11/2007 19:03

well if pretty women are having sex on telly with ugly men in a van for money - then considering there is no welare system in america - perhaps poverty as opposed to porn should be looked at in one of the wealthiest nations.

if this girl did it becuase of low self esteem - then - its not a law that needs to be passed - or else we should also ban chocolate for fat people " for their own good"

the arguments just dont add up