Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be surprised at how many Mumsnetters are fine with pornography? II

735 replies

Judy1234 · 16/11/2007 17:30

Continuing the previous thread - people's sexuality varies hugely and what some people think is disgusting is good fun for others. It's impossible to generalise and say XYZ practice is wrong or repugnant and I agree with the posts at the end of the other thread that porn often just reflects what people do. Obviously you pick where your own interests lie and are glad human beings are diverse.

OP posts:
Monkeytrousers · 17/11/2007 12:56

I really don't think you need to watch porn to understand what goes on in it; there is enought writtren pon ther subject to get a fair picture.

That's like saying we need to watch on line paedophillia before we can condemn it - we don't obvioulsy.

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 12:52

I understand your point completely NNT. To talk about porn you have to talk about it and that can be very disturbing - people will hear things they don't want to know about.

I'm being criticised for not actually having seen some of the things that I know go on in porn, which is a terrible catch-22, because there is no way in the world I am going to look at that kind of abuse of women. The descriptions are bad enough.

It's what porn relies on though, that people will keep silent about what's in it and what is done to women in it (the viewers because they don't want people to know what turns them on and what they are watching, and everybody else because who wants their mind polluted with that kind of stuff). Instead we get fantasies about how its an "empowering" career choice.

Monkeytrousers · 17/11/2007 12:51

dissonance as in cognitive dissonance

Monkeytrousers · 17/11/2007 12:49

People defend it because they need to justify their decisions -

"People don't justify stupid decisions because they are bad people, on the contrary, no one wants to admit they are a fool andf might have been very mistaken about something.

Moreover, as our actions and logic become further and further separated, we tend to hold tighter onto our original notions. Instead of admitting that we were wrong, we justify our actions even more strongly."

That's from a review on the book I posted about dissonence theory.

NoNameToday · 17/11/2007 12:45

Elizabeth, you asked if you are being unreaonable to be surprised at how many mumsnetters were fine with pornography.

I don't believe you are, I also am surprised.

Yes, I could have stopped reading, but I read it to see If I was being unreasonable.

However, after reading the thread I feel I have been exposed to more porn in the last few days than at any other time in my life!

Yes, I could have stopped looking, but I read it to see If I was being unreasonable.

That is not a criticism against any of the people who have posted that they are comfortable with their practices

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 12:38

I'm just going to keep reiterating the point. Everybody's heard of Deep Throat, right? - one of the most famous porn films ever. Some people here have probably watched it. Well Linda Lovelace said that every time someone watched that film they were watching her being raped.

The funny thing is that when she was still in the power of Chuck Traynor the pimp who married her so she couldn't testify against him, she became famous as the star of it and went on lots of talk shows claiming how much she loved what was done to her.

When she finally escaped from him she was able to tell what had really happened to her - how she had been forced to make the film (apparently the bruises are visible on her when you watch it) and she was in terror for her life. Most people didn't believe her (and still don't) because it's not a sexy story is it - a woman brutalised rather than a sexy actress who's a complete exhibitionist and loves every minute of having a penis inserted right to the bottom of her throat (she had to be hypnotised so she didn't gag). Nobody wants to think of the violent pimp in the background threatening her and beating her up.

Thats the sort of denial we're seeing here all the nonsense about how women make the porn, how the performers "choose" it (when like I said it is much more likely that porn chooses them), that men and women are equally exploited, that the woman hatred that is visible in every frame of porn isn't there.... the list goes on.

I still don't understand why people defend it and I'm no more enlightened after these threads than I was at the beginning.

Monkeytrousers · 17/11/2007 12:37

I agree with the prostitution analogy. There really isn't any way to deny that; it is what it is what it is...

Walnutshell · 17/11/2007 12:34

I agree Elizabetth, what you have described is very much mainstream. I think there are many people who choose not to see it because the continuing inequality between the sexes is extreme and terrifying and easier to deny.

Monkeytrousers · 17/11/2007 12:29

DeathBySnooSnoo, not sure if the rise of lads mags (which are actually on the decline in sales now, the market is so saturated) has at it?s heart the wish to control female sexuality. I think what goes on there is a pretty fair exchange, beautiful women advertising their ?fitness?, and getting modest to good financial reward for it, some get a career in the media, and all get greater exposure to potencial mates of higher status. The men are just as ?exploited? if there as any exploitation going on at all.

I can see why it isn?t to everyone?s taste to have scantily clad women everywhere, especially for women who are past that prime ? the problem seems to be that many women don?t want to feel that they have to compete on that level, and I would agree with that. Our society does need to value women for something more than the aesthetics of their sexual prime, but the market loves sex as it sells ? we are in a cultural bind it seems to me.

The extreme end of patriarchy controlling women is what we observe in Islamic societies, where women are not educated, are covered up and closeted indoors and not allowed out without a chaperone.

Paedophilia will never become mainstream ? is the comic strip you are talking about isn?t ironic? Is it in Viz?

VVV, women are massively empowered by things like the pill abd by the right to obtain abortion. These things are the bedrock of civilisation from a female perspective if fairness and freedom are what you are aiming for. These will be the first things to go should, say, the UK become an Islamic or any other religious fundamentalist society. Religion controls demographics by denying women freedom to express their sexuality, which is not coy, but very active ? but importantly still more discriminating than male sexuality.

Men do need the women to make porn, but the costs to these women are great, especially in terms of reputation and socially. This in turn has consequences for their mental health.

Jenna Jameson is a bit of a tragic figure ? she was gang raped and leaft for dead before getting into porn. Interviews with her on the subject leave you in no doubt that she still has huge unresolved issues about her self worth. Many in porn have borderline personality disorder too.

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 12:27

"I wonder whether this continues throughout the industry though - both the 'transparent' part that I agree is a question of taste - take it or leave it, up to you - and the 'underground' part which is a different and darker entity and the bit most labelled "anti-porn" are probably concerned about."

I'm concerned about all pornography because it treats women's bodies as commodities. It is prostitution by proxy. Men pay other men to f*ck women for them.

There seems to be some kind of belief that because what I've described is really horrible, it must be underground or out of the mainstream and I don't know why that is. This stuff is mainstream, it is common, it's what the male viewers demand. Please read this article by Robert Jensen (I think I"m going to keep posting it until people really engage with it) where he describes what he saw just picking out a few porn videos in a normal video store -

mwcnews.net/content/view/3286/26/

I can't post the description here because it's too offensive but this is what porn consists of - sexual abuse of women on film.

Walnutshell · 17/11/2007 12:26

"I just watched naked men posing for women photographers on "British Sex". Is THIS degrading to men?"

KerryMum - firstly, this is the age old issue of power - you simply can't make a straightforward comparison when you are dealing with men and women as groups. If only you could - that would indicate true equality! But, to answer your question - it possibly is degrading to some men and this should be respected. But if you are to analyse each individual's view you cannot progress as a society so some generalising has to be incorporated. And generally the power balance would suggest that the programme you described was less degrading to men than if the subjects were women.

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 12:20

'The exploitation level is the same for both sexes in any case. Women need boob jobs, a nice butt, and toned figure, men need silicon implants in their penises, and a six-pack. ;-)"

This isn't true. Men in mainstream porn are't having penises shoved in their bottoms then expected to suck them with the excrement still on them. Men aren't being doubly penetrated with the consequent damage to their rectums and vaginas that that causes. Men aren't gang banged or featured in gagging porn where they choke and vomit on penises.

As for mainstream pornography studios being owned by women, that's a hell of a claim to make and I'm sure you have plenty of evidence to back it up (and no Nina Hartley and that gang don't count, they aren't mainstream). Have a look at Adult Video News porn charts and point out which films in the top 50 are directed and produced by women.

The claims about Jenna Jameson are also ridiculous. It was her husband/pimp who realised he could make so much money out of her by keeping the rights to her films. He ran the company - she was the talent or rather the commodity.

Finally which male porn actors have had silicon implants in their penises because just about every female porn perfomer has had her breasts mutilated like that. Could you name a few names please?

"Porn was the best technical sex education I could have had pre-university... it was way more useful than A-Levels. ;-)"

What porn does is teach men to despise women and view their bodies as objects. How do you know the women you are ogling like it BTW?

Walnutshell · 17/11/2007 12:07

I wonder whether this continues throughout the industry though - both the 'transparent' part that I agree is a question of taste - take it or leave it, up to you - and the 'underground' part which is a different and darker entity and the bit most labelled "anti-porn" are probably concerned about.

Monkeytrousers · 17/11/2007 12:01

Custy, 'fanny envy'? How on earth..?!

Well, just in case any one else thought I was getting Freudian, paternity surity means to be sure of their status of fathers - men can never be as sure of this as women can be 100% sure that they are the mother to a child (maternity surity).

The fear of cuckoldry is innate to all men; it is very costly for a man to invest in children that he thinks is his, but aren;t. This is why women are controlled the world over and their sexuality constrained by patriachal institutions.

Alot of male insecuities are manifest in policy, especially rape prosecttion policy.

ZebedeesGhost · 17/11/2007 11:59

Just a quick point, but a significant portion of the top studios producing regular porn are managed and were formed by women. One would hope that this is an effort whether consciously or not to alleviate some of the perceived exploitation of women in the industry. For people with the right physical assets it's just another way for them to earn a living, what's wrong with that? It's their choice, and it's your choice to watch - or not.

The exploitation level is the same for both sexes in any case. Women need boob jobs, a nice butt, and toned figure, men need silicon implants in their penises, and a six-pack. ;-)

I entirely agree that porn exists because the two sexes find each other visually stimulating. I don't find it wrong to enjoy looking at a woman who is happy for me to look at them, I'd close my eyes when any of my sexual partners took their clothes off if that was the case.

Porn was the best technical sex education I could have had pre-university... it was way more useful than A-Levels. ;-)

VeniVidiVickiQV · 17/11/2007 11:54

Yes, very much so.

Jenna Jameson is a good example of this. She was a producer/director and very bankable. She could dictate that she had the same male partner in all films.

Women can exert a huge amount of power in the industry generally, and often command far more than men, because as with mainstream actors - they have fans and popularity that allows them to demand more. Their appearance can determine whether a film will be a 'hit' or not.

Women often move from being actresses in films to producing and directing. They seem to have a better 'eye' for what is wanted, according to articles I have read.

Walnutshell · 17/11/2007 11:43

VVVQ - but does this power you describe result in female control over the industry? Power through pay? I doubt it.

Walnutshell · 17/11/2007 11:41

"Men and women find each other visually stimulating. It's how we keep the human race going."

Yes, Xenia, but it's all about context. It would be fine if porn was developed in a respectful society where men and women are considered and treated as equals, but sadly that is not the case hence the ongoing very relevant debate.

VeniVidiVickiQV · 17/11/2007 11:36

Crikey. I didnt realise that Elizabetth hadnt seen any of the stuff that she was arguing against. I'm therefore assuming she didnt look at the links I posted either. Which may well be why she isnt convinced by the evidence. Because she hasnt looked at it! PMSL.

Kinda blows the "I dont buy into what posters "friends" say" argument she had on the previous thread. Because she is relying on second/third hand information herself, from untrusted sources (Wikipedia). On the internet ffs!

At least I've seen close at hand (of course you'll only have to take my word for it ) elements of the porn industry through my ex-colleagues who used to bring in copies of their work that they were proud of.

I agree with MT about maternity and paternity being the underlying cause of discrimination. But I think therein lies the power of women in the porn industry. Not in all cases of course (I havent ever disputed that there are darker, awful, abusive parts of the industry), but the fact that women can use their sexuality to exert power over a man is one that keeps the industry going. The men need the women in order to produce this stuff.

WideWebWitch · 17/11/2007 11:11

I've only started reading the thread, so only got a third of the way through but I agree with Elizabetth. I'm surprised and horrified at how porn has become normalised and I shouldn't be surprised, but still am, at how many mumsnetters think it's fine.

Squeakybrushes · 17/11/2007 11:10

runs away scared

DeathBySnooSnoo · 17/11/2007 11:08

have a look at that link to 'object' i posted last night.apparently ann summers sells a porn mag that has a comic strip called 'chester the molester'

KerryMum · 17/11/2007 11:01

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

DeathBySnooSnoo · 17/11/2007 11:00

'Because men have no paternity surity, and women are always sure of their maternity; thus is the route of all sex discrimanation that tries to impose controls on female sexuality. '

is this the reason for the rise of lads' mag culture in the past 10 years or so?i have been contemplating this point and wondering if male insecurity at no longer being needed other than to provide sperm is the root cause of this backlash against womens' rights.

the biggest concern i have is how far things will go.if there is already a magazine that has an 'amusing' comic strip about a paedophile,how long will it be before paedophilia becomes mainstream as well?

where will it end?

KerryMum · 17/11/2007 10:40

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.