Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be surprised at how many Mumsnetters are fine with pornography? II

735 replies

Judy1234 · 16/11/2007 17:30

Continuing the previous thread - people's sexuality varies hugely and what some people think is disgusting is good fun for others. It's impossible to generalise and say XYZ practice is wrong or repugnant and I agree with the posts at the end of the other thread that porn often just reflects what people do. Obviously you pick where your own interests lie and are glad human beings are diverse.

OP posts:
jofeb04 · 17/11/2007 13:14

Whilst people are buying porn - be in dvd's, magazines or online - it is never going to be made illegal.

And the main problem in this thread (imo) is that people are suggesting that all porn is bad, when in reality loving couples have taken photos of videod (sp?!) themselves.

DrNortherner · 17/11/2007 13:14

Good post zebedee

DaddyJ · 17/11/2007 13:13

MT, in the case of the op we are!!

We CANNOT call something gang rape
when there is NO gang present and
there is NO rape going on.

In a very abstract sense you might be right, MT,
but we have long left the abstract nonsense behind
and are now talking specifics.

Without specifics this 1200 post debate will simply
go around in circles.

ZebedeesGhost · 17/11/2007 13:12

Elizabeth, do you know what ;-) means? it means the last bit was tongue-in-cheek.

"What porn does is teach men to despise women and view their bodies as objects. How do you know the women you are ogling like it BTW?"

No it doesn't. In the present climate as many women as men treat the opposite gender as a sex object... have you been out to a night-club recently or read the female equivalents of FHM like Cosmo?

Porn was a great education for me sexually, I know more ways of having sex than just the missionary position thank you. It gave me the knowledge that there are many ways to have sex which are both exciting and pleasurable for both partners. Have you ever had anal sex? It seems not as I have only ever removed my penis once to find that it had any sort of faecal matter on it, and my partner admitted she needed a poo! I personally will do anal sex if my partner wants it, and it has been my partners who have asked me to do it, I don't ask as i prefer other ways tbh.

I don't deny that there IS some horrible stories regarding the porn industry about and I am not about to justify any of them. They disgust me as much as the next person. But then exploiting child-labour en-masse for the production of cheap clothing for the west is disgusting too... Do you shop at GAP or Primark? I don't watch porn that shows things I don't like, such as multiple penetrations, women being restrained etc... it doesn't excite me. I tend to watch porn WITH my partner in any case, so it has to be mutually erotic. It's not wank material for me. It's also a good way at exploring sexual fantasies with your partner - as in talking about them with the possibility of indulging them.

Anyway, some links for you -

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jenna_Jameson
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suze_Randall
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christie_Hefner
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tera_Patrick

etc...

Stop being so English! You are repressed! ;-)

DaddyJ · 17/11/2007 13:10

Have you got a link to those studies, MT?
I think they would add to the debate.

E, ever since I have found MN very little.
This place is more addictive than porn!
I will tell you more about myself in a second
but let's first discuss the issue in hand -
it is crucial to your op!

DrNortherner · 17/11/2007 13:09

It is easy to condemn peodophillia witout seeing it - it is ilegal.

Porn is not.

Monkeytrousers · 17/11/2007 13:09

In an acedemic sense you would have to see it. But you can also read a trascript or review and get the jist. We aren't talking about artistic interpretation here!

Walnutshell · 17/11/2007 13:08

I don't think the only point made here has been about whether or not all women working in porn are victims. That is to oversimplify the wider motivation, distribution and impact of porn.

jofeb04 · 17/11/2007 13:08

Elizabetth,
Some porn is because the women wants to do it, it is not necesseraily degrading to that women, and not all women who are in these videos are doing it because they are on drugs/have had problems in their past.

Some women want to do it

Walnutshell · 17/11/2007 13:07

I don't buy the argument that you need to see porn to debate it - not least of all because the issue is not simply about what is on a particular piece of footage. Also, how much do you need to see before you have a valid enough viewpoint? How varied a range?

DrNortherner · 17/11/2007 13:07

Linda Lovelace was clearly a troubled woman suffering from terrible domestic violence. Unfortunatley domestic violence happens all over the world, and I don't think it can be tarred with the same brush as porn.

Linda's problems were caused by her husband, not the porn industry per se.

Since Linda's revelations the mainstraim porn industry has vastly improved their working conditions and I do not beleive all women working in porn are victims. It's frankly not true.

Candida Royalle is a famous porn actress who established her own company specialising in making porn aimed at women as oppsed to the usual male orientated audience. She has been hugely sucessful and maintains the fact that women have a right to porn also.

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 13:06

The porn users will never ever admit that what they are watching is the degradation of women.

DaddyJ · 17/11/2007 13:06

Because a grown man and a grown woman
having consentual sex is NOT the same as paedophilia.

Hence my shocked comment to, MT.

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 13:05

How much porn do you watch DaddyJ? Same question to Zebedeeghost if he's still around. Also what kind of genres would you say the porn you watch were?

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 13:05

How much porn do you watch DaddyJ? Same question to Zebedeeghost if he's still around. Also what kind of genres would you say the porn you watch were?

DaddyJ · 17/11/2007 13:04

Elisabetth (sorry, I kept on misspelling your name),
the nature of the porn in question is central to your point, though.

If you/we don't look at it we cannot judge
whether it glorifies violence towards women
or simply contains footage of a men and a woman
having sex.

jofeb04 · 17/11/2007 13:03

Elizabetth,
Some porn is violent, and I would never want to see that, for obvious reasons.

However, some porn is because the women wants to do it, it is not necesseraily degrading to that women, and not all women who are in these videos are doing it because they are on drugs/have had problems in their past.

DaddyJ · 17/11/2007 13:02

MT, you said we don't need to see paedophilia to condemn it.
Absolutely.

But we do need to see consenting adult pornography to be able to discuss it, non?

Monkeytrousers · 17/11/2007 13:01

oops, beforehand not before 'hand' haha

DaddyJ · 17/11/2007 13:01

I read the report about lapdancing in Camden
and the interview with a disillusioned UK lapdancer
and, MT, there is one major issue with it:

It's preaching to the converted.
There is no attempt at putting the point across persuasively,
to reach out to the neutral or even to people like me
who are sympathetic but would actually rather like to see
the evidence for why the whole thing should be banned.

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 13:01

Read it again DaddyJ. MT said you don't need to see something to condemn it. Another example would be only reading the descriptions of the photographs that came out of Abu Graib rather than seeing them directly or to know of and condemn beheading videos.

Monkeytrousers · 17/11/2007 13:00

daddyj - "All pornography is the same as child pornography?"

I have no idea how you could make such an inference from my post. No that is not the case and it is not what I said.

Monkeytrousers · 17/11/2007 12:59

Studies show most men aren't aroused by 'rape' scenareos or scenes of sexual violence.

Electrodes are actually attached to the penis and baseline arousal levels discerned before hand obvioulsy, to rule out the risk that the men find the environment unarousing.

There really is a lot of research about human sexuality.

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 12:59

Good points, MonkeyTrousers.

DaddyJ · 17/11/2007 12:58

MT, that's quite a statement there.
All pornography is the same as child pornography?

I promised a quick comment on the other site,
coming right up.