Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be surprised at how many Mumsnetters are fine with pornography? II

735 replies

Judy1234 · 16/11/2007 17:30

Continuing the previous thread - people's sexuality varies hugely and what some people think is disgusting is good fun for others. It's impossible to generalise and say XYZ practice is wrong or repugnant and I agree with the posts at the end of the other thread that porn often just reflects what people do. Obviously you pick where your own interests lie and are glad human beings are diverse.

OP posts:
Monkeytrousers · 17/11/2007 13:45

Stippers are not porn actresses. There is no public penetration in stripping

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 13:45

You keep telling yourself that jofe, even while the evidence mounts up proving the exact opposite.

Who here has seen Deep Throat?

Who here has seen Animal Farm?

mamazon · 17/11/2007 13:44

i know a woman whose top fantasy is rape. obviously it is controlled but she has actually asked her partner to rape her on many occasions.

its nto just a male thing elizabeth. women can be just as sexually charged as men.

i think the mistake you are manking is assuming all women feel the way you do. that sex is somehow dirty or wrong.

i like nothing more than walking through a bar and knowing that the men find me atractive (ok its been a while) and wanting me sexually.
i dont feel objectified i feel empowered and much more confident.

jofeb04 · 17/11/2007 13:43

These women do get paid ... and apart from a few cases, they can say NO.

ZebedeesGhost · 17/11/2007 13:42

"I don't know why but it always creeps me out when men talk about their female partners' sexual proclivities. Especially when amazingly enough it coincides so perfectly with what they like."

eh? That's not true, I don't like anal sex much, i find it too painful - that's giving not receiving. However, if my partner wants to do it then fine, if she also wants to give me a blowjob afterwards then that's fine too, I don't force or make her do those things.

Of course it must coincide with what I like at least in some way! It's not a fun experience to 'sit' through an hour of S&M when you hate it. that's what being together and sharing is all about.

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 13:42

"I get off on knowing my dh wnats to shag my brains out because he desires me, because he wants to do things to me. And because we are consenting adults we discuss what we like and what we don't like. Then when the sex is over we have a healthy and loving and respecftful relationship."

Not really sure what your relationship with your dh has to do with the transaction in porn where women are used and sexually objectified by strange men (johns) in order that they can imagine they are the ones f*cking her. Unless you think that after they have watched her in porn they have loving and respectful relationships with the women they watch. That would keep porn performers very busy indeed.

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 13:39

Yeah, the thing is if he'd been a chef the worst he could have done to Linda Lovelace was get her to chop vegetables if he wanted to exploit her within his industry.

Him being a pimp meant she was raped and gang-raped; and then orally raped to make a film that millions of people have watched and got sexually excited over.

Getting aroused from a woman's rape has to be at least in the top ten sickening things in our world. Can you imagine what it would have been like for her knowing that so many people had enjoyed watching the crimes committed against her?

With regards to women in the industry a tiny handful of women doesn't make the industry any less male-dominated any more than handfuls of women in any other industry do the same thing. The difference with pornography of course, is like I keep saying, men have commoidified women and buy and sell them in porn.

DrNortherner · 17/11/2007 13:39

Elizabetth I am intrigued to know how a women who feels she is an object if a man dares to desire her can have an exciting and fulfilling sex life. It baffles me.

I get off on knowing my dh wnats to shag my brains out because he desires me, because he wants to do things to me. And because we are consenting adults we discuss what we like and what we don't like. Then when the sex is over we have a healthy and loving and respecftful relationship.

Sex does not always have to be satin sheets and roses. It can be down right dirty

mamazon · 17/11/2007 13:38

there is nothing degrading in watching people enjoy sexual activity.

there may be scenes that you would find uncomfortable to be participating in but thats the joy of porn. you can use it to spark your own imagination, to fantasise without actually having to go through with it.

there are fringes of the sex industry where women are persuaded to take part in deliberatly degrading and humiliating scenes. this is a particular genre of pornography and yes i would rather it didn't exist but i also accept that the performers in these films are paid to take part, are legally responsible for their own decisions and are able to say no if they do not want to.

i find pornography quite empowering actually. like teh strippers that explain it as being very controlling of men. by showing their body they have the full attention of all the men in the room, they are being paid just to have men look at them as they are that beautifull.

Monkeytrousers · 17/11/2007 13:38

I won?t defend a point I never made. I never equated paedophilia with porn, although it is an offshoot of porn in itself, just a different niche market.

And the whole question of consent is also central here. Consent is usually something defined from a male perspective, especially in law, which is why there is a lot of confusion about it in rape prosecution policy. I am working on a paper about this problem at the minute.

Porn being very addictive, I don?t think it would be wise for an unsupported person to wade in in the name of research. Porn investigators are very closely supported to make sure they don?t become desensitised to the stuff they see ? as is common with a lot of porn usage. Hence the problem with chronic users defining what is extreme and what is not.

An analogy to heroin or other very addictive drugs might suffice ? you don?t need to get addicted to see the harm it inflicts on people, families and society.

We are sexual beings, and porn exploits our proclivity to desire sex in the same way manufactures of salty, fatty sugary foods do. We have evolved to seek out these foods because of their high nutritional value, but too much of them is anti-adaptive. The same can be said of sex addiction. There is a logical middle ground that has nothing to do with being anti-sex, but an objective observer in how porn can exploit human sexuality and send it down a road of desensitisation, addiction and exploitation of the consumer, not even the people involved.

As for links to the studies, you won?t find that particular study in an online paper but published in this book. You can get a shorter paper online but it doesn?t contain all of the data.

As for the rest, I have spent the last 5-6 years studying this, so I could post my whole library to you, but I?m not sure how far you?d get through it.

And I think we can be sure that there is no art in porn, erotica maybe..it;s interetsing in a cultural sense, not artistic

.

zippitippitoes · 17/11/2007 13:32

well because women don't always see themselves as objects in a sex scenario

DrNortherner · 17/11/2007 13:32

I'm not Zebedee no Elizabetth

I still maintain Linda Lovelace was a victim of her evil husband. He would have been an evil fucker what ever industry he was involved in.

Som emen like porn, some women like porn. There are many sucesful females in the industry including Candida Royalle, the women Zebedee linked to and Dian Hansen - America's most sucessful porn editor.

They are the proof that it is not a humiliating and degrading industry.

If you as a viewer feel degraded when watchjing porn that is an entirely different issue to the actress being degraded.

Some women have a problem with pornography because of the problem women have with female competition. Women can feel insecure about other attractive women and that ca cause huge problems imo.

jofeb04 · 17/11/2007 13:31

Elizabetth,
Do you reaise that porn between a loving couple, is different to porn that is barely illegal?

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 13:30

I don't think so ZTT. Perhaps you could explain your reasoning.

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 13:29

I don't know why but it always creeps me out when men talk about their female partners' sexual proclivities. Especially when amazingly enough it coincides so perfectly with what they like.

zippitippitoes · 17/11/2007 13:29

but doesn't that imply that women don't enjoy or take an intitiative in sex

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 13:27

Yes of course it is, zippitippitoes. I can't believe you are even asking that question.

Women see porn and they seem themselves as the objects to be used and to please men (a very basic example of this is the numbers of women getting Brazilian waxes - a direct result of what porn actresses are expected to do to themselves). Also if their male partner is watching porn they may see themselves as in competition witht he women in pornography - it happens quite a lot.

Men see themselves as the protagonist in the film (it's why they keep calling it a "fantasy" because they fantasize being him). Like I said they pay other men to f*ck women for them. It's a male bonding experience.

ZebedeesGhost · 17/11/2007 13:26

"...defend their porn" !

Get a grip... it's not our porn, you seem to be tarring everyone with the same brush.

My previous partner, liked watching lesbian porn, i.e. two women pleasuring each other. She used to find it herself. She's on mumsnet btw, and is well respected - i.e. very normal.

I felt no need to respond to you point by point as others had already done so, read the links i posted in any case.

You can't make the wild accusations that you do and not expect people to be annoyed. That could be your intention though... Good discussion anyway.

zippitippitoes · 17/11/2007 13:23

is it

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 13:22

The point is that men's experience of pornography and women's experience of pornography is very different.

jofeb04 · 17/11/2007 13:20

Dr Northener - not sure if you were talking to me then ... but that was what my argument is.

It can not (and should not) be made illegal.

But, there could be stricter controls on it (not sure legally what they are anyway!)

zippitippitoes · 17/11/2007 13:20

men are mumsnetters too

thankfully
it makes the discussion broader

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 13:17

Heh, its interesting how many men have turned up to defend their porn on an almost wholly women-dominated board.

When I was talking about Mumsnetters I was thinking of the typical poster here who is female.

DrNortherner · 17/11/2007 13:16

People buy Cocaine but it is ilegal because it is wrong.

Porn is legal because it's not wrong/bad. Not because people buy it.

That's a crazy arguement.

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 13:15

"Linda Lovelace was clearly a troubled woman suffering from terrible domestic violence. Unfortunatley domestic violence happens all over the world, and I don't think it can be tarred with the same brush as porn."

It wasn't domestic violence he was a pimp who pimped her out to other men. Her first experience of prostitution was a gang rape he organised in order to "season" her to it. He married her to stop her being able to testify against him. Most husbands, even the violent ones don't sell their wives to other men. To pretend it was simply domestic violence rather than a way for him to make money from her body is ridiculous.

"Linda's problems were caused by her husband, not the porn industry per se."

She was raped to make the most famous porn movie of all time. And you pretend that has nothing to do with the porn industry? Denial levels are rising steeply I see.

"Since Linda's revelations the mainstraim porn industry has vastly improved their working conditions and I do not beleive all women working in porn are victims. It's frankly not true."

Prove it.

"Candida Royalle is a famous porn actress who established her own company specialising in making porn aimed at women as oppsed to the usual male orientated audience. She has been hugely sucessful and maintains the fact that women have a right to porn also."

That's one. One woman in a sea of men, but the one woman is enough for people to pretend that it's all equal and hunky dory rather than a male created, male run industry based on the prostitution and sale of women's bodies to other men.

Are you Zebedee by the way? You answered the points I made to him.

Swipe left for the next trending thread