Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be surprised at how many Mumsnetters are fine with pornography? II

735 replies

Judy1234 · 16/11/2007 17:30

Continuing the previous thread - people's sexuality varies hugely and what some people think is disgusting is good fun for others. It's impossible to generalise and say XYZ practice is wrong or repugnant and I agree with the posts at the end of the other thread that porn often just reflects what people do. Obviously you pick where your own interests lie and are glad human beings are diverse.

OP posts:
jofeb04 · 17/11/2007 14:30

How much regislation (sp?) is there in the industry (I don't know the legal side)?

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 14:30

"But, what do you think of a loving couple filming themselves having sex, or taken photos?"

I think they are inspired by porn, it's a monkey see, monkey do situation. Also I think the woman in the situation has to be very careful because the so-called "loving" male partner may be very keen to pass the images round his friends or post them on the internet as a trophy (reader's wives anyone?). It happens a lot much to the woman's detriment.

"Do you realise that some women want to be in porn, just as some want to be Topless models etc?"

Again I think it's promoted so heavily as somehting acceptable and the fact that so many other avenues are closed to women, it seems like an attractive option. Wanting money and attention isn't wrong per se, what's sad is that young women have to take their clothes off to get it. Young men don't have the same problem.

Monkeytrousers · 17/11/2007 14:30

Bodil Joensen was in Animal Farm, another sad story. There was a C$ documentory about her - details at bottom of the link

Walnutshell · 17/11/2007 14:29

"i have no problem with prostitution either. obviously there are aspects to this "proffession" that need regulation to ensure teh safety of teh women involved but in broad terms i do not object to prostitution."

BUT! That is the context in which prostitution exists - unregulated, unsafe - so your lack of objection is irrelevant!

Walnutshell · 17/11/2007 14:27

DaddyJ - a mooncup or porn? Hardly the same league. That's the point - not much is in the same league. Why make such unhelpful comparisons?

I expect if Eliz did watch some of what you suggest her opinion would be, umm, the same...

mamazon · 17/11/2007 14:26

If a woman is being paid to have sex she is by definition being prostituted, whether there are cameras there or not.

i have no problem with prostitution either. obviously there are aspects to this "proffession" that need regulation to ensure teh safety of teh women involved but in broad terms i do not object to prostitution.

How do i feel about watchign Deep throat. i dont remember seeingany rape scenes. im not even sure im thinking of the correct film. (she goes to the Dr as she can't orgasm, teh Dr finds that her clitoris is down her throat - is that the right one?)

if is is the correct film i only remember that particular scene.

As for Animal farm i switched it off as the idea that a woman would find it enjoyable to have intercourse with an animal is distastefull to me. but from waht i know of the woman she was a porn actress for many years, she left the industry and bought a farm. she got very friendly with her animals and would have sex with them frequantly. an old porn producer came to visit her and found out about her "relationship" with her animals and offered large amounts of cash to let him film her.

she was clearly a very troubled woman.
yes the producer saw an oppertunity and took advantage of it. but he hadn't forced her to do anything she hadn't been doing already.
i dont like the idea of it and i wouldn't wish to see it again but its not a film that could define the entire industry.

Im trying not to defend teh industry in general as there are some aspects of it that i find disgusting. and women are often encouraged to go further than they normally would by film makers who see them only as a comodity. but this is true of the men in the industry as well.
in fact its true of many industries.

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 14:26

She says she was raped to make the film. Chuck Traynor was a violent pimp and a criminal, Kittock.

The denial levels rise once again as the truth about porngraphy and exactly what is turning people on comes out.

Zebedee I'm sorry, I wouldn't normally say this, but I don't believe you. The clients of male escorts are overwhelmingly men even if the escort himself is straight. One of the themes in porn for anybody who is willing to notice it, is male self-delusion.

The fact that a woman being used in bestiality doesn't even make you balk means that I'm not going to engage with you any further. Our beliefs about humanity and every person's right to dignity are too far apart.

Walnutshell · 17/11/2007 14:26

Again DaddyJ, I ask - how much and how varied a diet of porn does one have to digest before able to comment?

DaddyJ · 17/11/2007 14:25

hold on, MT, just reading your previous post -
bloody fast-moving this!

DaddyJ · 17/11/2007 14:25

If I started a mooncup thread saying how
silly the idea is
I would be laughed out of town, Elisabetth!

What makes you think you can get away with
accusing MNers of being complacent when all
your information is 2nd/3rd hand and exclusively focuses on the negatives?

Monkeytrousers · 17/11/2007 14:24

That post takes us almost right back the the beginning Jofe, and round we go again...

Walnutshell · 17/11/2007 14:24

This is my problem jofeb04 - people are getting defensive about porn because they are limiting their imaginations to that which can be regarded as 'safe' but that just isn't a true picture. More's the pity.

Zebedee - when retelling how you were a male escort to get through uni you probably expect and receive a pat on the back. If you were a female and "twizzled" around pole, you would not generally get the same response. Do you get the difference yet?

Monkeytrousers · 17/11/2007 14:23

Hang on daddyJ, just becasue bangbros doesn't contain douple anal doesn't mean other mainstream stuff does. It does!

kittock · 17/11/2007 14:22

I don't think racial hate literature is comparable with your average jazz mag.

DaddyJ · 17/11/2007 14:22

MT, this is not about consuming porn,
but about reviewing the evidence and coming
to a measured conclusion.

You cannot do that if you are physically unable
to look at the evidence.

Even in child abuse cases the jury has to sit
through the evidence and, as far as I know,
review the releveant footage/pictures.

Monkeytrousers · 17/11/2007 14:21

and so you should

jofeb04 · 17/11/2007 14:21

Elizabetth,
Just want to ask a question. Through the thread, you have been talking about horrendous aspects of porn, I don't think anyone can deny it.

But, what do you think of a loving couple filming themselves having sex, or taken photos?

Do you realise that some women want to be in porn, just as some want to be Topless models etc?

Monkeytrousers · 17/11/2007 14:21

Sexual response isn't complex - quite the opposite, that's why porn is so successful. It does differ between the sexes though

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 14:20

MT I try not to be - my point is that I'm being hit from both sides, with tactics that I haven't used toward the pro-porn people here.

I'm really just highlighting the dishonest rhetorical devices being used which do get in the way of debate.

ZebedeesGhost · 17/11/2007 14:20

"It's funny how men don't put themselves through university doing the same thing isn't it, Walnutshell?"

I worked a few times as a male escort to give me some extra cash at uni. does that count?

I didn't feel exploited and had some interesting experiences, both sexually and otherwise.

I watched Animal Farm years ago, I thought it was unpleasant and wondered how the participants could do it... they were all consenting though as far as i know. It's more an issue about animal cruelty than female exploitation surely?

kittock · 17/11/2007 14:20

I think I would need to do some proper research into the Linda Lovelace case before I can comment on that Elizabetth

DaddyJ · 17/11/2007 14:20

mamazon, she reads about it. Yes, I could not believe it either.

Elisabetth, let me repeat this point until you get it:

Your op said hate porn had gone mainstream.
cestlavie showed us that Bangbros is the most popular commercial porn site.
The categories and the imagery on Bangbros does not contain anything that you go on about (rape, violence, double anal).

Ergo: hate porn has not gone mainstream.

You refuse to, in fact you cannot, look at the evidence.
You have no credibility.

Monkeytrousers · 17/11/2007 14:19

Oh Xenia, don't be so silly.

Walnutshell · 17/11/2007 14:18

Kittock, you don't have to respect a vagina to want to look at one.

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 14:18

Oh I don't know. Racial hate literature features images of its targets. Doesn't mean those people have the warm fuzzies about those they are abusing.

Anyhow, how do you feel about having watched Deep Throat now you know that Linda Lovelace was raped to make it, Kittock?

Swipe left for the next trending thread