Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be surprised at how many Mumsnetters are fine with pornography? II

735 replies

Judy1234 · 16/11/2007 17:30

Continuing the previous thread - people's sexuality varies hugely and what some people think is disgusting is good fun for others. It's impossible to generalise and say XYZ practice is wrong or repugnant and I agree with the posts at the end of the other thread that porn often just reflects what people do. Obviously you pick where your own interests lie and are glad human beings are diverse.

OP posts:
Judy1234 · 17/11/2007 14:58

A very important issue (see Matthew Parris' good article in today's Times about Thought Crime) is that even if we disagree with other people's views we should be defending their right to express them and that includes their sexuality. In other words the liberty argument is so important ideally we'd be prepared to die to defend the rights of those with whom we don't agree to peddle their views as it were. That has always been a key thing about the UK, that people can come here and express views. Yet so many recent Labour Government laws have tried to make us all clones of each other and criminalise anyone who is different.

OP posts:
Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 14:55

How many people here know a woman who has paid for sex from an escort?

One in ten UK men have used a prostitute.

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 14:54

You're also admitting that men do get ideas from watching porn that they wouldn't have otherwise.

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 14:53

So you're basically saying without this fantastic "education" (that doesn't exist at the moment) men may try to copy what they see on unwilling women, because porn won't show them the difference in fact it will show them the opposite.

VictorianSqualor · 17/11/2007 14:50

If these people were already educated then porn would be seen as a fantasy, a film of sex that was not a reality, and those who may be otherwise considering 'copying' the films would know that that was only able to be done if the partner was a willing participant.

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 14:48

I explained how the Bang Bus represents a gang rape scenario. Your inability to grasp that isn't really my problem. A woman trapped in the back of a van being pressured to undertake sexual acts is in a rape situation. Many women would be too terrorised to say no.

Judy1234 · 17/11/2007 14:48

Some single women my age (40s) do pay for male escorts. I never have but it's done. Also I do know (not in the biblical sense of course) some young student men who are good looking and go on the books of those agencies. However it's silly to suggest it is equally the case, male and female. Women find it easier to sell their bodies. It's why female models earn much more than male models. Women arguably look better than men actually. We are seeing some improvements if that's the world - hen nights to male strippers etc and more media/ads which show men being exploited and that evening out is a good thing. it's happening.

Women commercially exploit their bodies everytime they try to look good in a meeting or a bar. I am sure many men do as well. I don't see why the exchange of raw cash makes it any the worse. At least it's honest.

OP posts:
Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 14:47

Victorian Squalor, you've kept mentioning education all the way through this. What sort of an education do you think pornography gives people, particuarly the mainstream heterosexual porn which I have generally been referring to throughout the threads?

DaddyJ · 17/11/2007 14:46

Was it not you who did not want to talk to me anymore?

At the moment, I am engaging with MT but, yes,
your op is the subject - this is your thread after all.

And it would be nice to get an answer -
still no sign of that gang rape is there?

VictorianSqualor · 17/11/2007 14:45

Elizabetth how do you know?? Have you ever been a male escort?? Or have you read one or two interviews on a website and decided that is enough evidence?

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 14:44

Well then what you are describing isn't sexual Zebbidee and thus has nothing to do with this discussion which is about commerical exploitation of women's bodies.

When people use the term "escort" they usually mean someone who is paid to have sex (whether male or female). There virtually no market for men to be paid for sex by women, men's clients are almost always other men.

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 14:41

Only in your eyes DaddyJ and maybe a few of the porn-defenders. Although you keep engaging with me, I'm guessing if you thought I really had no credibility you wouldn't feel the need to bother.

Robert Jensen did watch porn to report back on it. Have you read his article that I linked to up there? How would rate his credibility. And more importantly what do you think of the contents of his article and his descriptions of cruelty in mainstream porn?

VictorianSqualor · 17/11/2007 14:41

"I think they are inspired by porn, it's a monkey see, monkey do situation. Also I think the woman in the situation has to be very careful because the so-called "loving" male partner may be very keen to pass the images round his friends or post them on the internet as a trophy (reader's wives anyone?). It happens a lot much to the woman's detriment.
"

Why the male??? I have seen my friends boyfriends penis on her phone camera, is that not the same as him showing people her on his???

ZebedeesGhost · 17/11/2007 14:41

"The clients of male escorts are overwhelmingly men even if the escort himself is straight. One of the themes in porn for anybody who is willing to notice it, is male self-delusion."

You don't have a clue do you... they are not. Typically, I escorted a woman to a dinner date, she paid me, and i went home, for example. I never had a male client in the six months i did it. I was an escort not a rent-boy. Yours is the delusion, not mine.

And since when has this been a theme in porn? Porn is not an intellectual endeavour fgs, you won't find Fellini, or Scorsese directing it. It's about people having sex. The delusion, if any, is always in the eye of the beholder.

"Zebedee - when retelling how you were a male escort to get through uni you probably expect and receive a pat on the back. If you were a female and "twizzled" around pole, you would not generally get the same response. Do you get the difference yet?"

No, I don't expect a pat on the back... why would I? The difference as far as i see is in society's acceptance of the male in this role and not the female, or have i missed something?

minorityrules · 17/11/2007 14:40

i've seen animal farm. It isn't a 'film' per se, it is a series of short clips put together

I don't know anyone who watched it saw it as titilating or erotic. Everyone I know watched it as an OMG freak show.

Yes, the woman was damaged, possibly even deranged. That can never be called mainstream and is very much a niche

Linda Lovelace, she was in an abusive relationship, he put her in porn. A friend of mine was amde to sit in a corner if her arsehole partner felt like it. Abuse is abuse, lindas was sexual, many other women are abused in a different way. One maniac doesn't make all porn bad

VictorianSqualor · 17/11/2007 14:39

I have seen Animal Farm, in fact it may have been you I discussed it with previouslt Elizabetth, it was disgusting, but it was ILLEGAL, pron is not ILLEGAL, there is the difference.

Not once has anyone said that women are never abused or degraded in porn, not once.

However, woman and men are raped and abused on a daily basis in the real world, it is a horrible fact, but true, so of course you are going to be able to find stories in which women in the porn industry were abused. Just like you can find women in any industry that have been abused, it isn't porn's fault, it is society that allows this to happen, and not because of porn.

I have said this time and time again, maybe porn needs stricter controls, Maybe those films in which there seesm to be violence (which may be acted or even enjoyed) should have more regulations around filming. The porn industry is possible to change, but to do that people need to accept there is nothing wrong with porn per se, just people who abuse it.

EDUCATION, Is the answer, I know my children will not end up in porn against their wishes, because of the way I shall teach them about sex, relationships, feelings and respect, so if they do end up in porn, then it will be their choice as it is something they want to do, not because of some misinformed view of what they should be or what they should do.

DaddyJ · 17/11/2007 14:38

What is relevant, Elisabetth, is that you cannot watch
the evidence I put in front of you.

That's what robs you of any credibility.

DaddyJ · 17/11/2007 14:36

MT, I am not asking anyone to go and enjoy themselves
on Bangbros - this is a serious debate about
our liberties and about what kind of society we
want to live in.

We need to take the trouble to inform ourselves,
there is no way around it.

Particularly if one chooses to argue that porn should be banned
because gang rape is now mainstream.

Regarding your last post, maybe I am leading a sheltered porn life
but I have not come across double anal in mainstream porn.
Would that not be extremely painful for the blokes, too?

jofeb04 · 17/11/2007 14:35

Ok, I'm off. This is one discussion that can go round and round (as it has many times before!)

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 14:34

"I expect if Eliz did watch some of what you suggest her opinion would be, umm, the same..."

Yup that's exactly right. DaddyJ thinks I haven't seen any porn but the thing is I have. I've seen the stuff that the people think is OK. They think it's OK because now there is something much worse to compare it to. It was always awful, it's just got even worse.

Our boundaries, our empathy our sense of humanity are gradually being eroded and it's women who suffer the most from this. Look at Zebbidee, only concerned with the animals involved in bestiality, completely callous about the effect on a woman's psyche that something like that would have. But hey men want to see women xxxxxx xx x xxx in a farmyard so who cares what it does to them.

jofeb04 · 17/11/2007 14:34

Walnutshell, legislation in porn.

Human trafficing is another aspect all together (for example, many drug dealers in the area I live in have been illegally brought in).

DaddyJ · 17/11/2007 14:33

Walnut, there is no need to have consumed any porn to comment here but
you need to be able to review the evidence that
we put before you - otherwise how can you comment on it?

jofeb04 · 17/11/2007 14:33

Myself and dh's photos were never from the thought of porn.

It is experimenting!

Walnutshell · 17/11/2007 14:33

How much regulation in prostitution, jofeb04? Have you heard of human trafficking...?

Monkeytrousers · 17/11/2007 14:32

off on a break now - catch up later

Swipe left for the next trending thread