Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be surprised at how many Mumsnetters are fine with pornography? II

735 replies

Judy1234 · 16/11/2007 17:30

Continuing the previous thread - people's sexuality varies hugely and what some people think is disgusting is good fun for others. It's impossible to generalise and say XYZ practice is wrong or repugnant and I agree with the posts at the end of the other thread that porn often just reflects what people do. Obviously you pick where your own interests lie and are glad human beings are diverse.

OP posts:
VictorianSqualor · 17/11/2007 16:47

Elizabetth, I'm afraid I don't see how it is unappropraite on a thread about porn, in which genitals, sex acts and preferences have been discussed for Zeb to do the same, male or not, if I mentioned my genitals would that be the same? or if I mentioned my partners?
Yet another example of your discrimination against men.

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 16:40

That's two people who offered to send me porn or something similar on these threads. Norma wanted to make a porn movie with her husband for me and now Zebedee wants to send me a piccie of his pubes and god knows what else - the implication certainly seems to be there.

I was actually more offended by Zebedee's discussion of his various partners' genitals (really inappropriate for a man to be doing that on a mainly women's board - far too much like the dirty phonecaller scenario) which is why I tried to put the focus back on him. I'm sure you're right though that that was the intention of his remark, OBM.

onebatmother · 17/11/2007 16:32

respectfully ZG, it rather sounds as if you're trying to humiliate and embarrass E with that remark.

ZebedeesGhost · 17/11/2007 15:22

"(look at Zebbidee wanting his partners to have their pubic hair shaved, I wonder if he does the same to himself, probably not)."

WTF! at what point did I ask for my partners to be shaved? i said i had no preference as long as they were clean. And FYI I am partially shaved... i can send you a pic if you want. Or would that be pornographic? ;-)

VictorianSqualor · 17/11/2007 15:22

Elizabetth, I DO think porn is okay, what I do not think is ok is that some people are not taught properly about sex and relationships as a teenager and grow up with messed up views regarding it as fdirty and seedy or a way to make someone love you or a way to big and clever or a way to control people, etc, etc.

My problem is not porn per se, but sex and tha attitudes surrounding it.

If everyone understood sex was a totally personal thing, and ok in every aspect as long as it was totally consensual and done for the right reasons, ie personal choice/preference then the porn industry would be safer, and the few people you can seem to find who were treated badly (all quite a while ago from what I have seen) might not have slipped through the net of safe, fun, responsible, respectful sex.

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 15:22

Actually come to think about it the Swedish army and other parts of the government have recently decided no longer to use hotels that have pay per view porn as they regard it as degrading and harmful to women.

Everybody gets so tittilated by the sexy Swedes yet they seem to be moving to quite a different position regarding porn and prostitution and the treatment of women.

Walnutshell · 17/11/2007 15:21

Exactly right about Sweden, Eliz. You can't just pick one bit of a country's policy or culture and tack it onto another - the UK just isn't in the same league as Sweden when it comes to equality.

Walnutshell · 17/11/2007 15:20

Matthew Parris really is an ar$e.

Sorry, I can't be more constructive than that.

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 15:19

I most certainly did not bring up pornography in Sweden as I know nothing about it.

What is true in Sweden is that buying sex is illegal and most of the country are behind the move. It's a much more humane place for women than most parts of the world.

Walnutshell · 17/11/2007 15:18

It's great to all have different opinions but not to the extent where morality is dissolved. In a society there have to be agreed values in order to function and all this wishy-washy "I'm so liberal, anything goes" attitude is brilliant for academic debate but doesn't provide grounds for a consistent moral code. It's a very harsh world, sometimes softly softly just doesn't cut it. More's the pity.

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 15:18

I'm not asking you to feel guilty Kittock. I thought you might feel bad or disturbed about it or empathy for Linda Lovelace. Maybe even angry at the pornographers for doing that to her and for duping the audience.

Watching someone's rape for entertainment (even if you weren't aware that's what it was at the time) is surely a terrible thing.

ZebedeesGhost · 17/11/2007 15:18

"This discussion is moving on so rapidly I've just noticed that you're saying the Bangbros thing is staged - even if it were the consumer wouldn't necessarily know that so the point about them wanking over humiliation may still be true."

Yes that is true... personally, I would expect it to be staged as they need a license in the US to film this... It's also too well produced (in a cheap porn context).

VictorianSqualor · 17/11/2007 15:17

kittock, good post, I agree, especially wrt education, Sweden ahs such education, and Elizabetth bought up the way pornography is in sweden on the last thread, it is because of the education.

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 15:16

I don't think you were playing devil's advocate VS. If you thought porn was OK you wouldn't be calling for this education in the first place to counteract its effects.

The point of course is that education doensn't just happen in a designated setting, we are learning all the time. Porn teaches men how to hurt and degrade women and treat them as sexual objects. It reinforces the idea that women are there to sexually serve men (look at Zebbidee wanting his partners to have their pubic hair shaved, I wonder if he does the same to himself, probably not).

kittock · 17/11/2007 15:14

E - I'm really not in denial. I have said several times on this thread that where the making of pornography has involved criminal behaviour this should be stamped on like any other criminal behaviour.

I can't in all honesty say that I feel guilty for watching Deep Throat 15 years ago. Obviously I did not go to the cinema with the intention of seeing a woman raped. (The attraction was in seeing a ludicrous male fantasy from 20 years earlier that had become a cultural icon).

Obviously I believe that rape and sexual coercion are wrong just as other serious and violent crimes are wrong. I don't think banning pornography would help.

Decent regulation of the industry, and better sex education are my best ideas so far. I have asked what measures you would like to see taken. Please can I ask you again, as I have truly no idea what you actually want.

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 15:12

Matthew Parris was defending Chris Langham downloading child pornogrphy. Good grief, he called it a thought crime.

VictorianSqualor · 17/11/2007 15:11

No, Elizabetth, I'm just playing Devil's Advocate, you believe men do what they see on porn movies, of course, being men they have absolutely no imagination of their own, or any idea of what they should/shouldn't do to a woman as she is just an object so educate them.

You can't stop people watching porn, you cant stop people acting in porn, you can educate people against the dangers of the darker side of every industry.

I'm not pretending that there are not any women who are not forced into or co-erced into doing things they feel uncomfortable with, but I am saying they don't do it just because of men, and that if they were better educated they would be able to say NO when they wanted to.

KerryMum · 17/11/2007 15:10

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Lauriefairycake · 17/11/2007 15:08

and I definitely do not believe in censorship or 'banning' anything

I'm liberal me - would rather persuade others - and protect the vulnerable (used to hand out condoms in the dead of night to prostitutes when I was a women's officer at university). Fairly dangerous when I look back at it now.

This discussion is moving on so rapidly I've just noticed that you're saying the Bangbros thing is staged - even if it were the consumer wouldn't necessarily know that so the point about them wanking over humiliation may still be true.

ZebedeesGhost · 17/11/2007 15:07

"And it is within this context that porn operates so whether Jenny BigTits is absolutely delighted and paid a fortune to participate in a porn movie is rather irrelevant."

Not sure I entirely agree but do see your point. It's actually males that have difficulty in accepting a female's role isn't it? And in the same way a female has difficulty in accepting the male role?

Anyway, am off to watch some porn have some lunch...

Lauriefairycake · 17/11/2007 15:04

2 points:

  1. I think that the description of the BangBros site on Wikipedia is enough for me to think it is woman-hating porn without me having to look at it. It is the concept that is woman-hating to me, the thought that a woman from low socio-economic status could be picked up, driven round in a van and then persuaded to have sex for money and then dumped without the money is just awful.

I can imagine (empathise) with being hungry/poor and being persuaded to do something for money. The thought that I would then have sold my body and then pushed out of a van with no money seems pretty hateful to me. Especially when the men go on to make a load of money from it - there's something about men wanking off not just to the sex but to the humiliation of the woman not getting money that seems hateful to me

  1. Porn has plenty of women being coerced/exploited/pimped/raped/forced on to drugs - (I have no doubt for the sake of the views of others on here that there are some who 'choose' who do it). However because you can't really know what you're getting in mainstream (unless you just pass round videos of your mates doing it) ie. a fully responsible , non-coerced individual then why watch it ??

Why if there's even a small chance you're watching a 14 year old or someone being raped or someone being drugged or coerced - just why ??

Sex is important to me - just not enough to accidentally be getting off on the abuse of someone else to it.

And because of that I avoid it

Walnutshell · 17/11/2007 15:04

Xenia, I have just put that article down in absolute disgust. It reflects a privileged portion of society who can choose not to engage in the seedy side of life but feel able to espouse about how it should be from their well-padded armchairs. Parris is a prat. His comments about child porn are appalling.

ZebedeesGhost · 17/11/2007 15:00

"Well then what you are describing isn't sexual Zebbidee and thus has nothing to do with this discussion which is about commerical exploitation of women's bodies.

When people use the term "escort" they usually mean someone who is paid to have sex (whether male or female). There virtually no market for men to be paid for sex by women, men's clients are almost always other men."

My god, that is so not true! What planet are you living on? The market these days is massive, in fact there was a documentary on channel 4 a few months ago about this very subject.

An escort is someone who 'escorts' another person somewhere, that's generally what they/I do/did. You can have sex with the client if you want but that is up to you (and them), you don't have to, it's not prostitution. You aren't paid to have sex.

If a client sees you as a sex object then that is their view, some don't, some do. C'est la vie.

As for Bang Bus, not my thing personally, but they are all actors and it is set up. So how is it gang rape or illegal in anyway? You haven't actually explained this Eliz, all you've said is that gang rape is a bad thing, fine I agree... Bang Bus IN YOUR EYES represents that, it doesn't in reality because all parties are consenting... let's move on...

Walnutshell · 17/11/2007 15:00

"The difference as far as i see is in society's acceptance of the male in this role and not the female, or have i missed something?" - exactly Zeb. And it is within this context that porn operates so whether Jenny BigTits is absolutely delighted and paid a fortune to participate in a porn movie is rather irrelevant.

DaddyJ, Elizabetth hasn't compromised her credibility by not reviewing all that you put before her - that's simply ludicrous. The debate is wider than just DaddyJ's links to porn.

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 15:00

I'd have defended Linda Lovelace's right to sue the porngraphers who used the crime against her to make millions of dollars.

Swipe left for the next trending thread