Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be surprised at how many Mumsnetters are fine with pornography? II

735 replies

Judy1234 · 16/11/2007 17:30

Continuing the previous thread - people's sexuality varies hugely and what some people think is disgusting is good fun for others. It's impossible to generalise and say XYZ practice is wrong or repugnant and I agree with the posts at the end of the other thread that porn often just reflects what people do. Obviously you pick where your own interests lie and are glad human beings are diverse.

OP posts:
VictorianSqualor · 17/11/2007 20:33

The actresses that you cna easily read about are the ones that want to tell everyone how awful it was, probably because they've realised people treat them different because of their jobs and want to distance themselves from it, there are more stories of actresses not enjoying it because that's the ones that give the shock value.

Rather than just linking all the horror stories why not try to work out the percentage of actresses those stories make up.

Monkeytrousers · 17/11/2007 20:33

But the evidence backs up Elizabetth's instincts about porn - it is damaging to women, more so the women that are in it than women not though, but that doesn't mean these women should be villified anymore than they already are by society.

Look up the thread on Ulrika Johnson to see what many people on this site think of a woman who has children from different partners, never mind being a porn star. She has been labelled a "slut" and far worse. The great thing about MN is that it is a massive source of data on general opinion; even though it is limited to those who own computers and can afford boradband, but are also the ones with the voting power politically too.

VeniVidiVickiQV · 17/11/2007 20:33

My issue with Elizabetth saying she has not seen it is that she has asked for evidence, and when links produced - she says she wont look to determine that this is the case. Then she'll say she's seen no evidence.

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 20:29

Oh god, I haven't said one goddamned thing about banning it. You change behaviour by changing social views about something - a bit like the way racism (although it still exists) is much less socially acceptable than it used to be.

It is an indictment of our society that people, mainly men, find it entertaining for women to be (ab)used this way. Pornography has always been about woman-hatred but now its becoming much more overt, yet people are still trying to pretend that's not what its about.

VS your view isn't objective in the slightest. I told you I've been on both sides of the fence - I used to think porn was harmless and that people who objected to it were prudes. I've moved on from that position when I got in touch with my empathy.

"Maybe once you take your fingers out of your ears and agree that some of the actresses are probably having a whale of a time, then maybe others will listen to you."

You know one or two might be having a whale of a time as you put it, because nothing is impossible in this world, but the majority are doing it for the money, because their sexual boundaries have already been so damaged by rape or abuse that they see being used again as all they are good for. Do you really think a woman in bukkake or ATM is having a whale of a time? The reports of tears in porn scenes means either the performers are really good actresses (and most trained actors can't cry on demand) or they are really being hurt. Linda Lovelace said she was having a great time doing Deep Throat, she said it because she was trying to survive.

Monkeytrousers · 17/11/2007 20:27

"...but there are also a great deal more that enjoy their job, and enjoy sex that is not what you may call normal."

I think you will find that the evidence says the opposite. A minority are in it by unambiguous choice, the majority are not.

That is the objective view - the same applies for prostitution.

Xenia, there is a very important difference between 'display' and actual penetration. Women do seem to be empowered and have more choices from the former, but their choices and quality of life is substantially lowered by the latter. That is verifiable data and there is huge amounts of it.

I am certainly not talking of banning anything, I haven't read anyone here doing that, but I haven't read every post either. As far as I'm concerned the banning angle is a pseudodebate.

Judy1234 · 17/11/2007 20:22

I didn't quite get what was being said about which women in which parts of the world wax/shave but that's probably not quite the point of the thread anyway.

OP posts:
VictorianSqualor · 17/11/2007 20:22

MT, I agree, I don't think you have to have seen something to be able to argue it.

I do however think that basing your opinion on a few articles from some disgruntled porn stars or a handful of abuse stories is probably as bad as those who are refusing to take Elizabetth's points because she hasn't seen said films.

Judy1234 · 17/11/2007 20:20

Of course you can disagree with something without seeing it.

of course there are aspects of the porn industry which are abhorrent just as there are things that I dislike about my own church or whatever. But I don't think in general overall the church or the porn industry is wrong or abhorrent. We can all pick out examples of corruption or abuse in just about anything but the core issue is whether we think women and men should be paid for displaying themselves sexually (although in a sense that is all dating is anyway).

I just think the libertarian argument wins out and is much more important than the supposed protection you'd give to men and women in the industry if you banned it.

OP posts:
VictorianSqualor · 17/11/2007 20:20

Elizabetth, you too could be accused of 'putting your fingers in your ears' you go on and on about porn being degrading and humiliating to women, as I have said time and time again, I DO NOT WATCH PORN! So surely my view is objective? I have read all the links everyone has posted, I can see that of course, there are some people who have been abused in the industry, but there are also a great deal more that enjoy their job, and enjoy sex that is not what you may call normal
Maybe once you take your fingers out of your ears and agree that some of the actresses are probably having a whale of a time, then maybe others will listen to you.

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 20:15

I think it's the verbal equivalent of putting their fingers in their ears and going "la, la, la - can't hear you"/

People who object to porn are generally not going to look at it because they see it as the sexual abuse of women thus its not something they want to participate in.

People who do watch porn aren't going to admit to what is actually in porn because it would require taking a different view of something they've persuaded themselves as harmless.

Monkeytrousers · 17/11/2007 20:11

I think there is a wealth of data out there which makes it possible to find out about porn without having to view a lot of it. I think it's a bit of a weak argument to try to dismiss Elizabetth's position because of that.

There are some things I don't agree with in your posts Elizabetth, but I some points I think are valid.

It's important not to throw the baby out with the bathwater here

Monkeytrousers · 17/11/2007 20:07

It is still ongoing actually

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 20:06

You don't remember what that study was do you, MT? It sounds interesting. The advertising gives a very clear idea of what is in mainstream porn and what pornographers are marketing to a their general audience.

And like I said if people don't want to take my claims at face value, I linked to the Robert Jensen article up there who has seen mainstream porn and describes all sorts of cruelties, humiiation and sadism that exist within it. As does the Gail Dines video on the other thread - she has seen a great deal of porn and describes the same things.

Monkeytrousers · 17/11/2007 20:04

Not in some countries - and don't forget anal sex (buggery) between consenting adults was illegal until recently

VeniVidiVickiQV · 17/11/2007 20:01

Linda Lovelace's story is a sad one. I've seen the odd clip of Deep Throat but find it completely unappealing. I refuse to watch Animal Farm. It is wrong. And illegal.

Monkeytrousers · 17/11/2007 19:59

OBM, are you really 15??

BTW, I am very slowly trying to put together a documentary re contemporary female sexuality, my partner is a community film maker, but not in my field so I am scouting for companies I could pitch to if you know any? My email is porla . wright @ msn . com (without spaces - just do that to stop more spammers)

Monkeytrousers · 17/11/2007 19:55

Matthew parris is quite an astounding idiot, isn't he?

onebatmother · 17/11/2007 19:53

MT me too with spam after research.

Monkeytrousers · 17/11/2007 19:49

Elizabetth may not have seen it but I have, and I'm afraid she is right. Double anal and the kind of humilation porn is mainstream, if not the most popular.

There was a study in the porn ad's in the back of magazines, film, computer, lads mags, games mags (it's quite easy to do it yourself if you are at the newsagents) and ad's double anal is very common. These ad's are also generally sexually explicit with genitals greyed out, but the poses are still very regognisable as explict and are as arousing - if not more so - than the images themselves by their titilation level.

On a personal anecdotal level, after doing some research I started to get spammed by porn (spyware and viruses are another reason to be careful about what sites you click on) one said this, "Let us fuck your girlfriend for $1000" and the another, "Yes we know it hurts, but we still want to fuck young girls up the arse."

3andnomore · 17/11/2007 19:47

Must say, I read through the earlier link of Elisabeth's...about what happens in usual, ordinary hard core porn, and some of it did make me feel a bit icky....so did the reference to feckling/fickling (or whatever it is called)....

Whilst I agree with Xenia that sex means many things to many people and well, personally to me it also so depends on my own mood as much on my personal boundaries of what I would be willing to try, Porn seems to be a whole different thing....I suppose if it is done completely wht te consent of all involved, whilst I don't have to liek it, it doesn't bother me to much, as then indeed it will be fantasies that were fulfilled, possibly by the actors themselfs....however, if illegal actions, any sort of pressure, etc....are added....then no NOT GOOD!

However, still don't get the reference about the sexualisation of our children...it wouldn't effect them until they are grown up, and by then I am hoping they make the right choices.

Monkeytrousers · 17/11/2007 19:41

DaddyJ ? ?Particularly if one chooses to argue that porn should be banned
because gang rape is now mainstream.?

Not sure who is asking for it to be banned. Asking for porn to be banned is like asking abortion to be illegal ? it won?t stop it.

Maybe the focus should be on ethical porn ? animation perhaps, but people don?t even care that their cheap shoes come from child exploitation so why would they worry about female exploitation when getting their rocks off is so accessible and also strangely compulsive?

LuckySalem · 17/11/2007 19:41

I cannot beleive this is still going on, I turned this off a while ago.

My answer is - NO you're not being unreasonable to be surprised.

The discussion is going round and round and isn't getting anywhere.

I'm afraid I agree with DaddyJ in that you cannot say that something is showing something if you have not seen it yourself. Especially as quite a few people (who are not pro porn) says its not there.

Personally I have nothing against the mainstream porn which shows straightforward sex. I do not particularly like anal sex BUT I don't think it should necesarilly (sp) be banned. There should be stricter controls over the industry.

My personal thoughts on how this can be accomplished is to raise the age limit to 21 (for PORN not sex), We need a "police" for porn, an agency who can make sure that there is safety at all times. Maybe we can make all porn filmers have a certificate that is looked at every month (or so) if there is no ticket then the film can not be broadcast.

And to an extreme maybe we can get lie detectors in to make sure the woman is wanting to do what is put before her and that there is no underlying reasons she (OR HE) is doing it.

Anyway, I've had enough of the thread as it's just going in circles.

ZebedeesGhost · 17/11/2007 18:24

Erm excuse me, but Eliz made a sweeping generalisation which was offensive to me. Of course i am going to try and refute it, and if she didn't believe me I am happy to send evidence. I am not a prude, and nor is it pornographic. I get no pleasure from that and am merely interested in correcting a severe misconception.

The reason we ended up talking about pubic hair - or lack of - is because you equated it to some sort of genital mutilation scenario!

And how is anything that I have said an invasion of privacy?

This is ridiculous...

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 17:08

Also I objected to Norma offering me porn so I'm definitely not discriminating on the basis of sex although hearing that kind of thing from a man is worse because I have been harassed and sexually assaulted by men (including obscene phonecalls).

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 17:06

I don't think there are any examples of my discriminating against men. I've criticised men with regards to the porn industry because they are its creators, owners and consumers.

The difference between a general discussion about sex acts in porn and Zebedeee discussing his own partners' genitals and sexual prolictivities is that the latter is an invasion of privacy of the women he's talking about. Also (and I'm not saying that Zebedee is doing this) it's not unknown for men to gain cheap thrills by talking explicitly about sexual matters to women who don't want to hear about it - have you never had an obscene phone-call? So its best to steer clear from that kind of personal revelation particularly as it didn't actually add anything to the conversation. Also best for him to steer clear of offering to send photographs of his pubic hair to a strange woman he is disagreeing with on the internet. It seems like he had a misunderstanding of what is appropriate in public conversation with strangers.

Swipe left for the next trending thread