Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be surprised at how many Mumsnetters are fine with pornography? II

735 replies

Judy1234 · 16/11/2007 17:30

Continuing the previous thread - people's sexuality varies hugely and what some people think is disgusting is good fun for others. It's impossible to generalise and say XYZ practice is wrong or repugnant and I agree with the posts at the end of the other thread that porn often just reflects what people do. Obviously you pick where your own interests lie and are glad human beings are diverse.

OP posts:
Monkeytrousers · 17/11/2007 21:09

The Amis article is really good - thanks for that Elizabetth

onebatmother · 17/11/2007 21:09

Brava!

DaddyJ · 17/11/2007 21:08

MT, climb down the high horse regarding banning, please.

Why are you having this debate then?
As Elisabetth says, to change minds and eventually
to get everyone to agree that Something Must Be Done About It,
i.e. banning it.

What Xenia is saying is highly relevant if we take
your arguments to their conclusion so not sure why you are
reacting so prickly to this.
Earlier on in the thread policywonk, myself and others
debated passionately whether and how a ban would work.

We are certainly on the right page but you really need to follow the
thread before raising your voice.

Ozymandius · 17/11/2007 21:05

Elizabeth, I'd advise you to give up, even though I agree 100% with you.
There are plenty of intelligent, thoughtful people who are deeply concerned about the effect that the saturation of pornography has on our society will have on our children.
Plenty of us are concerned in a way that goes beyond our personal craving for personal gratification, which seems the obsession of many of those on this thread.
Some of us do value women for more that the sum of their orifices, and don't want to live in a society that is happy to see women bought and sold.
I find it deeply offensive that on this thread you are aggressively and repeatedly 'offered' pornography and told your opinion is valueless because you do not consume pornography. We all know we don't have to watch, hear or endure murder/child abuse/fraud/blackmail/racist abuse and discrimination to know it is wrong - not just for individuals but for society as a whole. A society in which black people are routinely abused, degraded, used for their bodies and bought and sold can never be equal. For me, the same applies to pornography. I feel there is something warped and sadistic in the consistent pushing for you to view pornography by porn fans. That is especially relevant for the men who try to push pornography on a woman who has explained her rational and deeply personal reasons for her revulsion. It's coercive and borderline abusive. They sound to me a bit like Langham with his defence of his love of watching child abuse - 'you need to see it to understand it'. We don't accept it from him, and personally, I don't accept it from you.
But Elziabeth, you are an intelligent person, and you know that people who support a bad thing simply because they personally enjoy it will never change their view. Most of us realise that just because something gives people pleasure does not mean it is good - and that applies to stolen goods, the proceeds of fraud, sex with children or the pleasure of violent vengeance, all of which may be hugely pleasurable to some, but which comes at a cost to society and individuals. I would guess that most of the intelligent thoughtful people on this site are too repelled by the content of this thread to post here, but believe me, we too dream of an equal, equitable, non-abusive society, in which porn is as unacceptable as child prostitution and drink-driving. A world where women don't feel that their bodies are objects for sale. Nobody's talking of banning anything, we just despair of a society in which pornography is deemed purely another recreation. We want a deeper change than just banning pornography. We dream of a society in which people are valued as human beings, not as holes. Maybe Sweden is the way forward. I certainly hope so, for my three daughters' sake as well as for my son and all of society.

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 21:04

Because porn directors probably fancy themselves as "film-makers", madamez, rather than the pimps they actually are. They're always trying to give themselves the gloss of respectability, but buying and selling human bodies is never going to be respectable.

I'd just like to know why men want to call women "bitches" during sex Jaqueline, and please don't fob me off with the "women like it" crap. It's pretty clear that there are men out there who like this stuff and like it a lot

onebatmother · 17/11/2007 21:03

jacqueline how can 'natural' abuse include consent throughout the act>?!!

you can't consent to abuse, otherwise it's not abuse.

you can consent to something that then turns into abuse tho, very easily.

onebatmother · 17/11/2007 21:01

no not dot co dot co dot co uk

rather: kate @ minimum dot co dot uk

something like that anyway. i'm sure it'll get here eventually...

madamez · 17/11/2007 21:00

Though getting tired of banging head against brick wall, one more point to make. If what all porn viewers really want is to see is rough stuff, why is the porn industry spending so much money on huge glossy extravaganzas like Pirates or Fashonistas or the star-wars pastiche that I've forgotten the name of?

Jaquelinehyde · 17/11/2007 21:00

I've followed this debate but this is my first post on the subject. Having listened to both sides of the argument I think it is fair to say that both sides are talking sense.

It is unquestionably wrong for anyone to be sexualy abused physically or verbally without their consent and yes there should be stricter controls in place to ensure movies/pics etc that do this have no place on the market.

However movies that include abuse (staged, acted or totally natural) should be available for the general public as long as there was full consent from all people involved and that the consent remains throughout the act.

I know I have no problem being called a bitch during sex because when your having that kind of sex it's quite a turn on, but to others the thought of that is repulsive and bordering on abuse (when it clearly isn't because it's consentual) and until people in this argument can put aside what they personally like or dislike sexually it is difficult to get a sensible debate on what is abuse.

onebatmother · 17/11/2007 20:59

Mt kate @ minimum dot co dot uk

onebatmother · 17/11/2007 20:54

sorry just dipping in and out now and then but Eliz, I do think that your last post of 20.29 states your point in a very accessible way.

  1. even if some of us enjoy powerplay, this kind of porn is not about us, its about Women, with a capital W. The women in the gonzo-becoming-mainstream films aren't supposed to be women who love it - precisely the opposite. They're supposed to be women who don't like pain, but are going to get it anyway.
  1. I've looked at too much porn, and there's a huge difference between how pain is represented in fetish/bdsm and how it is represented in gonzo-which-is-becoming-mainstream porn. You can hear when a woman is in real, scary, pain - pain that isn't a teasing, sexy pain but just actual pain like if someone was breaking your leg, but you'll be hurt even more if you whimper. You hear that sound a lot in the latter. It's a really upsetting sound.

I think the ones who are having a fabulous time, really enjoying 'pain', are overwhelmingly in the fetish/bdsm category, where women-in-control-of-their-own-destinies are very well represented.

  1. the majority of porn consumers who are enjoying women in 'pain' - real or pretend - aren't fetish consumers (where the boundaries are very clearly set), they're just people who are increasingly thinking (gonzo to mainstream)that seeing women in pain is okay. More than okay, in facct.

sorry about hyphens, up at 5 again today.

nice to hear your position re ban Elizabetth, maybe missed it before, but v well said.

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 20:54

"But you haven't factored in the sexual pleasure countless women who aren't in the industry get out of the porn, have you? I would say that outweighs damage done to some women."

I think you've just summed up the pro-porn position. Who cares who gets hurt as long as people get their orgasms? Where is the humanity in getting sexual pleasure from someone else's pain and degradation? I can't believe you said that actually.

Monkeytrousers · 17/11/2007 20:50

Think the Amis article deserves a link

Judy1234 · 17/11/2007 20:50

But you haven't factored in the sexual pleasure countless women who aren't in the industry get out of the porn, have you? I would say that outweighs damage done to some women.

It's like saying cars are bad because some people are knocked over.

OP posts:
Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 20:50

"I would have thought the pro pornographers like me are probably already a very small minority"

Are you serious? Pornography is a mulit-billion dollar worldwide industry. Porn viewers (not just its defenders) number in the tens of millions. Porn is a large and powerful industry.

MT doesn't get spam from anti-porn people in her mailbox, she gets it from pornographers who want to fuck someone's girlfriend.

I wish you would address one thing I've said Xenia. For example what about that quote from the porn director. What do you think the experience of being sexually used up is like for a woman - to be reduced to gang bangs and double anal? How do you think she feels about herself and within her body after having that done to her?

Monkeytrousers · 17/11/2007 20:46

And for women, the costs outweigh the benefits - that is the evidence, not an opinion.

Monkeytrousers · 17/11/2007 20:45

"Certainly it's better to try to persuade people to change views than ban things."

Xenia - NO ONE IS TALKING ABOUT BANNING ANYTHING, GET ON THE SAME PAGE, PLEASE

Monkeytrousers · 17/11/2007 20:44

There is a comic/tragic Ali G - Jenna Jameson interview around too.

Judy1234 · 17/11/2007 20:43

Certainly it's better to try to persuade people to change views than ban things. I would have thought the pro pornographers like me are probably already a very small minority, though particularly if you did a survey of women only. I think you've already run the battle of hearts and minds, surely? I suppose you could try to shame men into it being so beyond the pale to use porn they give it up may be.

I think the ability for men and women to be aroused via new media, both within and outside their home is a great enhancement to the sex lives of many. I do think however that clearly some women (and some men) are abused in the sex industry although I'm not sure £30 for a photo session is worse than working a long shift on a minimum wage at Macdonalds.

Is it not the case that the benefits outweigh the disadvantages?

OP posts:
Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 20:41

This is what one porn director says in a piece by Martin Amis about the porn industry about what it's like for women in the industry -

?The girls could be graded like A, B, and C. The A is the chick on the boxcover?here you have a borderline A/B doing a double anal. Directors will remember that. She'll get phone calls. For a double anal you'd usually expect a B or C. They have to do the dirty stuff of they won't get a phone call. You've had a kid, you've got some stretchmarks ? you're up there doing double anal. Some girls are used in nine months or a year?a hundred movies in four months. She's not a fresh face anymore. Her price slips and she stops getting phone calls. Then it's, ?Okay, will you do anal? Will you do gang-bangs?' Then they're used up?the market forces of this industry use them up.?

-Porn director quoted in Martin Amis' ?A Rough Trade?

Commodities to be used up and then discarded.

Monkeytrousers · 17/11/2007 20:40

If these women were trained actors they'd be acting on stage.

I don't know why you say you are coming from an unbiased position, yet refuse to entertain any evidence that contradics your personal opinion.

FWIW, I only have my opinion becasue of the evidence I have looked at over the years. I began thinking porn was harmless; or more accuratly, just not thinking about it. I did respond to it personally and found it arousing - show me a human being who isn't to some extent - but I changed my opinion on the basis of evidence, not wishful thinking.

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 20:38

They aren't really my instincts MT. I've seen porn movies. I've seen lesbian scenes and double penetration. From what people here are saying, they've only seen the "tamest" (although it's still hateful of women) porn like I have. I'm just telling them (as are others) that the market has moved on to stuff that is much much worse.

There are a lot more women in porn saying its fab, saying its wonderful (as they choke on some guy's penis) VictorianSqualor. Why aren't you accusing them of being liars. Most women who are ashamed of porn and prostitution don't say a word about what happened to them - they are silenced by people like you calling them liars.

Imagine being abused and then disbelieved on top of that.

Monkeytrousers · 17/11/2007 20:36

Evidence provided here is not worth anything. Real studies have been carried out under strict guidelines to rule out bias and the like. They are the ones you need to be looking at. Mumsnet can only tell you about peoples opinions and preferences, not objective facts about the world of porn.

VictorianSqualor · 17/11/2007 20:35

Oh and Elizabetth, do you not think that if these tears are so rife in the porn industry maybe, just maybe like the 'trained actors' they have ways of making them happen?

Monkeytrousers · 17/11/2007 20:35

The banning thing is a red herring, a non argument, a false dichotomy - but that is a well known rhetotical trick (straw man) thap people use when their argument is on shaky logical ground.

Swipe left for the next trending thread