Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be surprised at how many Mumsnetters are fine with pornography? II

735 replies

Judy1234 · 16/11/2007 17:30

Continuing the previous thread - people's sexuality varies hugely and what some people think is disgusting is good fun for others. It's impossible to generalise and say XYZ practice is wrong or repugnant and I agree with the posts at the end of the other thread that porn often just reflects what people do. Obviously you pick where your own interests lie and are glad human beings are diverse.

OP posts:
onebatmother · 17/11/2007 21:37

daddyj can i come back to it another time if this thread is still going?
ds birthdya tomorrow got to wrap presents and out of action mn-wise for next 24 hours.

eliz to be absolutely fair i think ozy was talking about the shaved pube guy not daddyj?

Monkeytrousers · 17/11/2007 21:37

It would pointlessly sophomoric exercise debating the whys and wherefores of a ban, however DaddyJ.

Yes, I second that OBM with regards to Ozymandius.

Elizabetth, the debate is there for people to read and make up their own minds. I feel you have made your point very well.

I don't think there is anything more to add - not by me anyway. I think it has been argued well.

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 21:36

Bordeline abusive, DaddyJ. Borderline abusive. Please take no for an answer.

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 21:35

Don't have a debate with me then. Leave me the hell alone.

DaddyJ · 17/11/2007 21:35

Then, Elisabetth, do not start highly explicit threads about porn!

Threads on which you mention the most extreme
forms of porn over and over and over again.

DaddyJ · 17/11/2007 21:34

Elisabeth, there is only one guy on the pictures.

But you would not know that.

That's why I am not sure how we
can have a debate with you when you have
no knowledge of the specifics.

onebatmother · 17/11/2007 21:34

jh yes there is an issue!

think about what you are saying about what men think about women!

it's actually entirely irrelevant if the individual women care or not, in some respects.

what matters is that porn is supporting men who want to call women bitches while, or perhaps because, they're fucking them.

i think it was monkeytrousers who earlier made the point that it's women who enjoy sex who often get the most emphatic 'you dirty whore, now you're going to really get your just deserts type treatment'.\

this is not simply about the women involved, it's about what we want our sons to think about women in general.

i like sex, i want my daughter to enjoy it, and my son to enjoy it.

but is this about enjoying sex?>

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 21:33

Did you read what Ozymandius said about your insistence that I watch porn when I've already told you how much it would disturb me DaddyJ? She was right, it is borderline abusive.

DaddyJ · 17/11/2007 21:33

obm, I think mainly I have focused on it,
most other posters have discussed other
aspects of porn with E & MT.

Thank you for having a look anyway.

I don't want to push you too hard but
can you tell me what aspect of the visuals,
i.e. the pictures, remind you of coercion?

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 21:31

There's lots of things I dont' like DaddyJ but I don't call them all gang rape. I call things that are gang rape scenarios "gang rape scenarios" and OBM is right that the issue of consent when a woman is surrounded by men who want to sexually use her is a dodgy one. What happens when a woman says no to two men, to three men, to ten men? Most women wouldn't be able to fight off a single man let alone a group of them.

DaddyJ · 17/11/2007 21:30

Look, Elisabeth, I have worked my way through
most of your (btw very interesting) articles
about the porn industry to understand your point of view better.

I am currently reading the Amis one so
apologies for slow post speed.

It would be nice if you could extend that
same courtesy to us and engage with the
evidence that we put before you.

You cannot make it up as you go.
This debate is far too important for that.

onebatmother · 17/11/2007 21:29

no, probably not. but it's not a totally insane thing to say, given my previous coercive point (see how I've learnt to spell coercive in the last 5 mins.)

the pro's have over-focussed on it, i think.

and I do think it's possible that they've done so to avoid dealing with other, very scary for all of us, points that E has raised.

Jaquelinehyde · 17/11/2007 21:28

Yes I 100% agree that there are a lot of men who like to hear the verbal abuse in porn but if the people within the porn are happy and secure with the language being used then surely there is no issue.

onebatmother · 17/11/2007 21:25

jh - this is a critical part of the debate.
some of us feel that while there are some women who like to be called bitches, there are an awful lot of porn consumers, mainly male, who like to hear women being called bitches.

DaddyJ · 17/11/2007 21:24

obm, that's a very dangerous route to take, though, is it not!?
Calling anything we don't like 'gang rape'.

Rape is a serious crime. Is it right to bandy it about so carelessly?

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 21:23

I called it a "gang rape scenario". Are you really that much of a literalist that you can't understand the point I'm making?

A woman trapped in the back of a van with three men pressurising her into sexual acts is in a rape scenario, particularly when she is horribly verbally abused. I'm not saying the actresses are gang raped, I"m saying that they are portraying acts that in real life are rape. These things are done to women, they aren't fantasies. Women have been tricked into vans, forced to have sex and then thrown out into the street. The men who do it will even claim the women "consented" because she'd be too frightened to fight back. The Bang Bus portrays this sort of treatment of women as entertainment.

Jaquelinehyde · 17/11/2007 21:21

When I use the term abuse I meen someone spanking, being whipped verbal abuse etc

and by natural I mean home movies or amatures (sp) not staged just stick the camcorder on and have some fun.

and elizabetth yes some men do love to call women bitches and love watching women being called bitches. The same as some women love to be called it, and how some men love to be calle a bastard or worse.

It takes all sorts you know and just because one person finds it repulsive doesn't make it wrong as long as it is consentual.

onebatmother · 17/11/2007 21:21

ok daddyj i understand your position on the gang rape point.

i don't think e needs or wants anyone to speak for her.

but for me, i wouldn't have used that exact expression - but I prob would have thought it.

however seems to me that there is a strongly coersive element in a sexual scenario involving more than one penetrator.

perhaps not, in a court of law, gang rape but ...?

DaddyJ · 17/11/2007 21:20

obm, yup, that's where the disagreement is,
you would say it's mainstream, I would disagree.
For the time being!

DaddyJ · 17/11/2007 21:16

Ozymandius, Walnuts, I think your thoughtful posts require a response:

The point is not that the op has not viewed porn or is not a porn consumer.
Of course she is not. And it is irrelevant.

The point is if she calls something 'gang rape'
it has to be accurate.

If I understand correctly even in child abuse
cases the evidence HAS to be seen by the jury
and the judge.
Why should it be any different on this thread?

onebatmother · 17/11/2007 21:16

hmm not sure that w w w joke comes across so well textually, you kind of have to hear it to get it..

text text text, that's all i ever think about..

onebatmother · 17/11/2007 21:14

oh sheesh daddyj I appreciate your grin, but that's my point - we don't agree about the extent that gonzo is maintstream.

i think that the site that we discussed before (forgot name already) clearly shows gwibm but i don't think you did?

you thought it was textual not sexual

wah, wah, waaah.

Elizabetth · 17/11/2007 21:13

I'd have stopped after the last thread then Ozymandius, but someone restarted it. :P

I'm sure you're right though. There's only so much rational argument a person can use coupled with plenty of evidence before its quite clear that people aren't listening and there is something else going on rather than the desire for a discussion. Thanks for your support and your very eloquent post.

And really most of the posts I've made have been to offer an alternative to the standard rah-rah porn position that is forced down our throats constantly (and if people are going to deny that I'd remind them that they now sell Playboy-branded items to schoolgirls in WH Smith - how bad do things have to be that that is acceptable?). Like I said earlier it was important for me to see it, so maybe it will make other people who object to porn feel less alone.

DaddyJ · 17/11/2007 21:10

'gonzo-which-is-becoming-mainstream' -
obm, I enjoy debating with you!

Yes, that is the big question, to what extent is it mainstream.
How popular is it really?

onebatmother · 17/11/2007 21:10

to Ozy