Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be surprised at how many Mumsnetters are fine with pornography? II

735 replies

Judy1234 · 16/11/2007 17:30

Continuing the previous thread - people's sexuality varies hugely and what some people think is disgusting is good fun for others. It's impossible to generalise and say XYZ practice is wrong or repugnant and I agree with the posts at the end of the other thread that porn often just reflects what people do. Obviously you pick where your own interests lie and are glad human beings are diverse.

OP posts:
madamez · 18/11/2007 19:48

That many industries (probably every single one) involve some exploitation and bad practice and abuse of workers is not in dispute. But the answer is to improve workers' rights and conditions, not to drive the industries underground (which reduces protection of workers still further and leaves room for more and worse exploitation, health risks, etc). Looking at sexually explicit material for entertainment rather than education, performing sex acts for money, specific sex acts that some individuals find unappealing or distasteful: none of these things are inherently wrong or bad.

Ozymandius · 18/11/2007 19:47

Personal pleasure (and of course pornography gives a kind of reflex pleasure, that it is what it is for) can never be more important than protecting society from something harmful. Plenty of people around find beheading videos trilling and enjoyable. They would no doubt find mocked up scenarios of white people being beheaded very pleasing. The fact that some people find something sexually arousing does not mean it is good. Plenty of men find images of young girls in school uniforms very sexually exiting. Does that mean those images are 'good'? I'd say not.

Walnutshell · 18/11/2007 18:44

LuckySalem ? why can?t you believe this discussion is still going on? One discussion on MN doesn?t put the world to rights so the debate will always continue - and quite rightly so. I laughed out loud at your concept of ?porn police? ? don?t you realise that this is entirely impossible and therein lies the problem? Please don?t think that two consenting people having sex on film is really what is being debated here ? it isn?t.

MT ? Yup, Parris is incredibly idiotic. I may have to stop putting money into his pocket by stopping purchase of The Times.

VictorianSqualor ? again, a poster that diminishes the argument by reducing it to the relative handful of female porn stars that enjoy their job ? so what? Irrelevant.

A lot of posters have developed their argument around the issue of Elizabetth not viewing the porn cited in this thread ? a very weak defence. This undermines the crucial part of the argument against porn which is about every woman?s right to experience life without feeling undermined by her own sexuality as described by another.

?The banning thing is a red herring, a non argument, a false dichotomy - but that is a well known rhetotical trick (straw man) that people use when their argument is on shaky logical ground.?

  • hear, hear, MT, well said.

Xenia: ?I would say that outweighs damage done to some women.? ? plain offensive. Very very offensive actually. It really is like talking to a child, MT.

I leave (for now) saddened that people choose to be so blinded to the world and would rather win on academic debate than have some moral backbone.

Well done E & MT for putting so much so eloquently.

normabutty · 18/11/2007 18:36

Right, didn't think this would still be going after my weekend away but it is so I might as well carry on debating.

Firstly, please don't make assumptions Elizabetth (and I realise this is way back on the old thread...but I did read everything I'd missed while away) my dh did take it up the arse.

Zebedee...I'll have the pics if Elizabetth doesn't want them

I haven't watched Deepthroat or Animal Farm. Animal Farm wouldn't be my kind of thing, I'm not into bestiality.

I think that Xenia sums it up quite well in saying that we should be retaining rights to personal choice and freedoms. I also think that ATM, gang bang, barely legal porn is FINE as long as the people involved are legal and have given consent. I really don't see how it improves our society to control what consenting adults do sexually.

WideWebWitch · 18/11/2007 16:17

Great posts Elizabetth and Monkeytrousers.

Elizabetth · 18/11/2007 15:58

Gonzo porn is described in many of the articles that have been linked to here - including the Max Hardcore link and the Martin Amis article. All of them contain disturbing content -

www.guardian.co.uk/weekend/story/0,3605,458078,00.html

mwcnews.net/content/view/3286/26/

citypages.com/databank/19/893/article4117.asp

lucyellensmum · 18/11/2007 15:37

I have a very haunting image in my head now - Gonzo porn??? I always knew sesame street was a bit dodgy. Seriously though - what is it?

Porn is such a difficult area to decide on. TBH, i would be happy watching pretty much anything if i thought all concerned were being treated fairly. I have seen animal farm, weird, just plain weird! I really when pushed, don't know how i feel. I will admit freely that i like porn, i find it extremely arousing. I also like bondage and find light bondage in films (where it is clear that there is CONSENT) arousing. BUT it does leave a bad enough taste in my mouth (pardon the pun) for me to not buy it and to even not really want to watch the couple of videos we have, just in case.

I do think it is possible to be a liberated woman doing very nicely thankyou in the porn industry. I just think that sadly, like many industries, that it takes a strong woman to be at the top of the industry and be involved on her terms. There are definately female porn stars out there who are making alot of money. That of course doesnt detract from the many women who are being exploited by porn, it would be niave to think otherwise.

So, what to do? I dont have the answer i really really dont, its the same as prostitution, legalise? I think so, but maybe even thats not as simple as it appears.

Judy1234 · 18/11/2007 15:36

Yes, but I tend not to view what I don't find erotic.

OP posts:
Elizabetth · 18/11/2007 15:22

MT, I've really enjoyed your contributions to these threads. It's good to be part of a discussion with someone who is so well-informed.

Elizabetth · 18/11/2007 15:15

You know I've asked the question about five times now but what does it say about men and boys, that many of them want to watch double anal, gagging porn, bukkake, bestiality (so many men have seen Animal Farm), gonzo porn, ATM etc. etc. What does it say that they want to see women brutalised in this manner? Not one person who has defended porn has answered that - all they've done is hidden behind women's so-called consent. Women aren't coming up with these ideas for porn, it's the men who make it and sell it who do that because they know that's what their male consumers want.

Xenia, have you ever actually seen any porn and if so, what kind, because the way you're talking about it, it doesn't sound like you have. People who have an objection to porn don't have issues with bodies, they have issues with the way bodies are used and exploited in porn. MonkeyTrousers is right - it's a moral argument and the porn-defenders still haven't provided anything concrete to support their side just a constant refrain that women in porn "consent". Well women "consent" to work in Nike sweatshops too but it doesn't mean that we have to support them.

Side note: LEM, feminsts (if they have any understanding of feminism at all) support women who do traditional woman's work like child-rearing. The best book I've read about the way women are devalued is "Counting for Nothing: what men value and what women are worth" by Marilyn Waring.

Monkeytrousers · 18/11/2007 14:59

You are deluded if that is what you think Madamez. But you have a vested interest in thinking that way and your bias, very public bias, explains why you would go to such lengths to turn a blind eye to the onjective and huge documented evedence of exploitation in the sex industies.

DaddyJ, it has been explained in great lengths here, but most chose to ignore the important nuance and detail of the argument and, it seems, are having arguments with phantoms.

It gets very boring after a while. I think this thread ended last night. See you around on the boards.

DaddyJ · 18/11/2007 14:36

Come on, MT, that's not fair towards children.
Children are full of curiosity and want to find out about their world.

If they don't understand something,
more often than not it is because you have failed to explain it properly.

madamez · 18/11/2007 14:25

Monkeytrousers, saying that 'industrial' porn, by which I assume you mean all porn commercially produced and sold in quantities, is morally dubious is not a fact. It's an opinion.

lucyellensmum · 18/11/2007 13:59

I consider myself a feminist (shock horror a SAHM who is a feminist, how can this be ) and i like porn.

Judy1234 · 18/11/2007 13:56

Lots of feminists like porn by the way. There's certainly a reasonably large subset of them that do.

Anyway clearly there's a gulf of views on this point. Thank goodness (so far) it's still a lawful activity.

OP posts:
lucyellensmum · 18/11/2007 13:55

Yes, i think that is a very good point Jeremy. Oh and i so know what you mean about the song (ohhhhh, brush your teeth in circles................arrrrgghhh)

lucyellensmum · 18/11/2007 13:53

i suppose it is easy for me to say all that seeing as my DD is quite the feminist and doesnt like that sort of thing. I just think that i was defining the differences, i certainly wouldnt want DD to make a career of it.

JeremyVile · 18/11/2007 13:51

Sorry, I was just noting that the exceptions you say you would be happy with are not really representative of what most would class as porn.

JeremyVile · 18/11/2007 13:50

Er.... I meant no, a resounding NO!!

(I was too busy singing along to the cbeebies washing/teeth brushing song....it's like aural Crack that tune... )

lucyellensmum · 18/11/2007 13:48

not sure what you mean jeremy

NoNameToday · 18/11/2007 13:47

Unfortunately lucyellensmum, I think it is sometimes just a slippery step from one to the other, particularly when it is a few years hence nad the fresh dewy eyed look has gone, and other fresher 'meat' is on the market.

JeremyVile · 18/11/2007 13:45

So, the answer to that question is a resounding YES, LEM!

lucyellensmum · 18/11/2007 13:43

"Maybe this has been said before (don't have time to read 427 posts!) but can I ask the people on this thread who don't have a problem with porn: would you be happy if your mother/ sister/ daughter was featured in a porn mag, and would it not bother you to know that men would be w**king over their image? (this is a genuine question, not rhetorical)" by Mrs theiryhenry?

OK - this might not sit well with some people but this is my standpoint. Were it my mother i would just thing - eeeeeeeeeeeewwwwwwwww, shes 73!!! gross
I have a 17 year old daughter, if she were in a porn film i would be HORRIFIED and personally castrate all concerned (even if she earnt a million pounds doing so and directed it herself!). However, if IF she was in a magazine like playboy then, providing i knew that she was totally OK with it, had chosen to do it and the pictures were not graphic or showing sex scenes then actually, i would be quite proud of her. Maybe i am being niave but my daughter is BEAUTIFUL and turns heads in the street. IF she CHOSE to do that then i would have no problems, i would probably insist on accompanying her to photoshoots etc and i might feel a bit uncomfortable but if we had control, why not?? But then i do think that saucy mags are a whole different ball game from porn films which i would NOT be happy about.

Monkeytrousers · 18/11/2007 12:49

Oh FS Xenia, no one has hang ups about sex or thew human body, but the morality of an industry predicated on the massive exploitation of women - and children too actually.

It's like talking to a child.

I think there is little need to add to anything - the moral argument is there for everyone to see. Nothing more needs to be added

Judy1234 · 18/11/2007 11:58

"would you be happy if your mother/ sister/ daughter was featured in a porn mag, and would it not bother you to know that men would be w**king over their image? (this is a genuine question, not rhetorical)"

You just have a different mind set from some of us. It doesn't mean you're right or we're wrong but the fact you can't believe people think like the pro porn people do is fascinating.

Why should I have sexual hang ups about the human body. I love naked pictures. The human body is one of the most beautiful things on earth. All the old painters always painted it. And why not? So, no I wouldn't. I would have concerns if something they did might jeopardise their employment prospects but that's me being annoyed with how some other people view that type of activity and wanting that prevailing view to change rather than having an objection to the sale per se.

OP posts: