Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be surprised at how many Mumsnetters are fine with pornography? II

735 replies

Judy1234 · 16/11/2007 17:30

Continuing the previous thread - people's sexuality varies hugely and what some people think is disgusting is good fun for others. It's impossible to generalise and say XYZ practice is wrong or repugnant and I agree with the posts at the end of the other thread that porn often just reflects what people do. Obviously you pick where your own interests lie and are glad human beings are diverse.

OP posts:
Elizabetth · 18/11/2007 20:40

This one's for Madamez because she ignored it the last time around I posted it (I think Nina Hartley might be a bit of a heroine of hers) -

"Modern porn has become increasingly savage. "You're seeing more of these videos of women getting dragged on their faces, and spit on, and having their heads dunked in the toilet," says even pro-porn campaigner Nina Hartley."

"I also don't think men who watch porn, be it gonzo or any other type, see women as wanting to be hurt/humiliated."

That's not what I said Norma I said what does it say about men and boys who watch this sort of stuff (and a good number of them do whatever the deniers try to claim) that they want to see women hurt and humiliated. Not one porn defender has picked up on that. They don't want to think about it because the answer is really frightening. What would people think of whites wanting to watch black people treated in this way? Or gentiles getting off to jews being treated in this way (oh and Nazi porn is a sub-genre BTW).

Tortington · 18/11/2007 20:40

i stop my kids from watching things that are not age appropriate - so would and did let my kids watch toma nd jerry beet shit out of eat other - they didn;t beat shit out of other kids becuase of my fantastic parenting.

there are always and will always be unstable people that will take things they see on telly and act on it - the question is how far should we legislate and in the process curtail the freedom of others.

ChristopherHitchins · 18/11/2007 20:40

Is Martin Amis going to show up?

onebatmother · 18/11/2007 20:39

norma hiyaah.

  1. I was trying to say although i am concerned about individuals - my bigger concern is the whole of the rest of the female world.
I think individual suffering can sometimes be a distraction strategy for both pro- and anti-porn feminists) 2 we\'re already in disagreement about the extent to which gonzo's tropes are/have always been mainstream and we don't seem able to come to an agreement on that. cf Daddyj 3 i think individual men might not come away with that thought - but nevertheless it is certainly the message that gonzo porn brings to the world, and imo (but debatably) the message that some, more mainstream porn offers. 4 of course.
ChristopherHitchins · 18/11/2007 20:39

I am watching...

Judy1234 · 18/11/2007 20:38

Yes, agree with normabutty. Just because some aspects of something might be regarded by some as more dreadful doesn't mean you then tar the rest with the same brush. I don't believe people are sufficiently affected by what they see or view whether it's a violent James Bond movie or sado-masochistic sex or whatever that we should ban images. It's a sledgehammer to crack a nut even assuming there is a nut there to crack. I assume most men have or do look at porn. I am not sure of the stats for women. Most men don't then expect all women to do XYZ and most men's views on sexuality are probably more moulded by the relationships they have had or how they were made, whether gay, bi or whatever, than what they've read.

OP posts:
policywonk · 18/11/2007 20:38

tried... not... to... post...

Monkeytrousers · 18/11/2007 20:36

Oh, and here you all are back again Talk about addictive!!

policywonk · 18/11/2007 20:35

OBM I think there are lots of studies out there, I just doubt that they 'prove' anything one way or the other. It seems commonsensicalistic to me to say that watching violent porn will make men (or, at least, some men) more likely to act out their sexual urges in a violent way. I mean, how many of us stop our kids from watching television that contains portrayals of aggressive behaviour because we don't want them to mimic the behaviour they see?

CodDickinson · 18/11/2007 20:30

oh not jsut the pro pron ones

onebatmother · 18/11/2007 20:30

and actually daddyj feel a bit guilty at the mo bcs distracted by RL and really just dipping in.
I think you're right tho that we need tests about perception of women pre- and post- viewing mainstream and other porn, and v surprised that there appear to be none when as you? said it's been done with violent films/v games etc. (tho i think results were v much challenged..)
and of course that would never present full picture. would be as start though.

normabutty · 18/11/2007 20:30

"individuals (and their consent) are irrelevant for the broader purposes of the debate..

it's irrelevant if some of us (small-ish percentage) like pain/humiliation..

the question is, is it good for men who view porn to think that many/most of us like being humiliated?

But in reality, is it not the point of gonzo that the women don't like it?? and that they are therefore humiliated?"

I'd like to disagree with this and give comments on it too.

  1. I don't think that individuals and consent and the fact some women like pain/humiliation is irrelevant. Mainly because so far (as far as I can see) the 'anti-porn' people have failed to acknowledge that some people choose to go into porn and enjoy making porn.

  2. Imo, most men don't watch gonzo porn. Afaik most men just want to watch people fuck, it doesn't have to be gonzo for them to enjoy it. Though I stand to be corrected if someone can show me stats (and please don't tell me that bangbros is the most used paid-for site...since it appeared to me that there were 3 free sites that were popular from the list that was posted...and it also doesn't make clear from the name of the site how much gonzo people are watching from the site as opposed to 'softer' porn)

  3. I also don't think men who watch porn, be it gonzo or any other type, see women as wanting to be hurt/humiliated. In fact I think that is quite insulting to men. I think most men treat women with respect and are very accepting of women's limits and preferences. I've found that men want to please their partner and that doing what turns their partner on is much more of a turn on for a man than doing what they may have seen in a porn film.

  4. Men who do see women as something to hurt/humiliate may turn to porn to satisfy those feelings and I concede that those men may watch more and more extreme porn and get ideas from that. However I also believe it is not porn to blame for those men's personalities and issues. I believe it is to do with a number of factors - parents, childhood, environmental...in other words social issues that would have had that effect regardless of porn. Though I am willing to admit their behaviour possibly worsens from watching porn.

DaddyJ · 18/11/2007 20:30

fishy, who are you accusing of being a closet man??
Sooner or later they will be found out..

ChampagneAndFlowers · 18/11/2007 20:28

YES COD there are more blokes posting on here than women. No wonder it is so pro porn.

onebatmother · 18/11/2007 20:25

its a short way of say O pause F pause F pause S longer pause are you UTTERLY mentalist???

CodDickinson · 18/11/2007 20:24

does anyone on htis thread think there are more MEN posting on ti thna it otherwise seems?

Tortington · 18/11/2007 20:24

"so far no pro-porn person has actually properly engaged wiht the idea that many of us have raised -"

i would consider myself pro-choice no pro porn.

"individuals (and their consent) are irrelevant for the broader purposes of the debate.."

wellt hat would rather depend on the debate - you cannot argue about a power relation and who has it and who hasnt without this being an integral part*

"it's irrelevant if some of us (small-ish percentage) like pain/humiliation.."

i agree - but i do not think that any one person should determine the level of any argument, to some people this question and the debate around it affects or comments on an aspect of their daily lives and that is how they will comment. and it is not you who shoudl deternine otherwise.

"the question is, is it good for men who view porn to think that many/most of us like being humiliated?"

well its not the only question - its a question of many. intentional humiliation is disgusting as per the gonzo thing you mentioned as i havent seen it but something intentionally sexually humiliating women is disgusting - rather than the humiliation being encapsulated in the genre. Some women may think the genre of porn disgusting and humiliating - but this is where we come back to the issue of individuals and their consent. if the individuals both partake ins omething which they consent to and them commit that to be watched by other people then whilst some people may find the genre humiliating, some do not. the participants may not, the consumers may not.

But in reality, is it not the point of gonzo that the women don't like it?? and that they are therefore humiliated?

taking on board your former comment about indivuduals - you shouldn't argue this point shoudl you - becuase it has no relevence

DaddyJ · 18/11/2007 20:22

MT, there is always more to add

  • why cut the debate short?

You have spent 6 years researching this field
and have a library of information about it.
When you joined the thread I was looking forward
to reams of facts, figures, studies and links from you.

So far you have not hit your stride yet.

You say that all porn is morally dubious.
I read the Martin Amis article and went looking for the
high-end gonzo porn made by Andrew Blake.

From what I can tell from the promotional material on his
website and the interview with Amis, Blake's gonzo does not
seem morally dubious.

So, is he an exception in porn industry?
Are there any exceptions?

DaddyJ · 18/11/2007 20:16

obm, good to have you back,
that is a very valid question, er, sheesh!
(what does sheesh mean?)

What we need is some way of finding out whether
consumption of such porn actually changes men's
view of women and their behaviour towards them.

It's like the debate about violent video games.

Maybe MT has some studies or books about this?

onebatmother · 18/11/2007 20:16

LEM do people really give you grief for being a SAH feminist? how v v v stewpid of them, give them a kick.

Elizabetth · 18/11/2007 20:14

Wrong mademez. What Robert Jensen described in his article was a sample from mainstream pornography. Max Hardcore's videos regularly featured high in the Adult Video News Charts. BangBros the most popular paid-for site in the UK is full of woman-hatred and the ejoyment of humiliation of women. You've got porn directors saying the overt cruelty is the way the industry has gone, even Nina Hartley is concerned about it. You're just telling basic untruths now. It's such a totally BS way to conduct a discussion.

And do you know what the "sucking and fucking" as you call it is prostitution on camera. How is that defensible? Buying and selling women's bodies for men's profit (and don't pretend it isn't men that make the majority of money from porn) is called pimping. And the viewers are basically johns by proxy.

Are you a member of Feminists Against Censorship Madamez, BTW?

Monkeytrousers · 18/11/2007 20:13

Cheers. Just one more post to Dr Northerner, who I neglected to answer way up there asking which cultures had no concept of female orgasm.

Female climax is observed to be, as far as we can tell, continent upon, individual attitudes and cultural practices (and genetic factors) such as socially conditioned expectations, their attitude toward men, marriage and their self image.

?Arapesh women?rarely experience orgasm ? no concept of a female sexual climax even exists for them ? whereas among the Mundugmor or Samoan?s the female orgasm is considered part of sex.?

From; The Woman That Never Evolved by Sarah Blaffer Hrdy. ISBN 0-674-95540-4

onebatmother · 18/11/2007 20:11

and that gonzo is bcming more mainstream?

this is above and beyond the arguments that have been put for vanilla/mainstream being pretty grim in an dof themselve.s

onebatmother · 18/11/2007 20:09

sorry just catching up and again dipping in and out.

sheesh. MT, walnut, Ozy all v well said.

so far no pro-porn person has actually properly engaged wiht the idea that many of us have raised -

which is ..

individuals (and their consent) are irrelevant for the broader purposes of the debate..

it's irrelevant if some of us (small-ish percentage) like pain/humiliation..

the question is, is it good for men who view porn to think that many/most of us like being humiliated?

But in reality, is it not the point of gonzo that the women don't like it?? and that they are therefore humiliated?

madamez · 18/11/2007 19:54

Elizabetth: much of the extreme porn you describe is a minority preference which doesn;t sell in anything like the quantities that the standard suck&fuck, glossy or 'amateur' does. A percentage of the unappealing stuff is made by people who have actually read far too much condemnation of porn and thinkg this is what the audience like: they tend not to make much money out of it, because the majority of the audience want to see other people enjoying sex.