Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be surprised at how many Mumsnetters are fine with pornography? II

735 replies

Judy1234 · 16/11/2007 17:30

Continuing the previous thread - people's sexuality varies hugely and what some people think is disgusting is good fun for others. It's impossible to generalise and say XYZ practice is wrong or repugnant and I agree with the posts at the end of the other thread that porn often just reflects what people do. Obviously you pick where your own interests lie and are glad human beings are diverse.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ThrowbackTo07 · 10/11/2022 23:35

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

RollOnSummertime · 29/12/2007 19:19

Havent read all the thread but think pornography can influence a persons behaviour, i.e. men that watch it could possibly act out what they have seen.

Remember that young girl backpacking in Thailand (sorry cant remember her name, she was 21), she was speding New Years with her friends and was raped and murdered by 2 Thai men who had been watching porn all night. Poor girl.

Judy1234 · 29/12/2007 19:17

He uses a lot of "may"s in that though so I don't think it proves anything. He seems to be saying 25% of men who might be a bit more sensitive and violent than others might be influenced if they view violent material. I cannot see any proof of that and certainly nothing that would make me think we ought to censor material and James Bond films or whatever violence or sex people like to watch in a free society.

OP posts:
holidaywonk · 29/12/2007 18:43

article about Neil Malamuth

I have no idea whether it is peer-reviewed.

Do you believe that watching violent imagery in video games/films makes those predisposed to violence more likely to act out their impulses? Because it seems to me that that is a pretty widely-accepted premise.

DaddyJ · 20/11/2007 18:09

policywonk, I had not forgotten about your post!

I found this page on the bbc website which carries comments against the law
and which led me to this site that has a pretty
comprehensive overview of who is against the legislation and why.

In addition, there is some information on its progress in Parliament.

According to them the government has widened the applicability of the law considerably.

Have not had the time to read the actual government papers, though.
Given your handle I hope I can leave that to you

NoNameToday · 20/11/2007 12:43

Elizabetth, I'm sure we'll cross swords again somewhere, but at least we are reassured it is done with honesty and conviction.

Elizabetth · 20/11/2007 12:22

Good spot, BTW, onebatmother!

Elizabetth · 20/11/2007 12:17

Thank you very much for your support, NNT. Given our recent history on other parts of the board, I've got to say I really appreciate it. It's very generous of you to extend me that.

I thought Zebbedee was on dodgy ground when he started claiming to have been a male escort and talking about explicit details of sex but what's being described on that other thread is just . Hope you are OK, dividedself.

NoNameToday · 20/11/2007 12:00

I was pleased to see that in her posts Elizabetth was very capable of 'holding her own' without resorting to nastiness .

Some people agreed with her point of view and some didn't, but a few attempted to denigrate her for her strong beliefs, using her refusal to be drawn into viewing the very things she finds unacceptable to justify their argument that she wasn't sufficiently informed to venture an opinion.

I don't need to view videos of child abuse,happy slapping, cock fighting, dog fighting etc to know that I find those practises unacceptable, so why should anyone suggest that someone needs to view anything to find the idea behind it unacceptable before they can register their disapproval?

For those who are comfortable with pornography, fine, but please don't suggest that people who aren't comfortable with it should view it in it's entirety to satisfy your own needs for justification.

onebatmother · 20/11/2007 10:32

divided didnt[' read his bit except the offer to send eliz some of his porno.. which I thought was gross
am going back now to check escort????! stuff
hope you didn't mind my post but I felt sick when I read your thread.

dividedself · 20/11/2007 10:29

Farking hell
I've just read what that idiot has written - first thing I've known about this fantasist being an escort. I think he was paying them - must have been!

onebatmother · 20/11/2007 10:26

can I please warn you all that one of the posters to this thread may be very questionable - please see here for details.

Elizabetth · 19/11/2007 23:00

Nope, everybody has a bias, the difference is I don't have my livelihood invested in this argument as you do.

Monkeytrousers · 19/11/2007 22:55

Soph, please by this www.amazon.co.uk/gp/offer-listing/074254351X/ref=dp_olp_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1195505217&sr=1-1 Who's Afraid of Charles Darwin: debating feminism and evolutionary theory]] even if you only raed the bits about bias and biophobia

onebatmother · 19/11/2007 22:51

I think some people use the word 'bias' to mean 'firm position for or against something'

Others use it to mean 'vested interest in supporting or defending'.

You may be at cross purposes with this one.

Monkeytrousers · 19/11/2007 22:48

You are right ladidadi, way up there. Some are.

madamez · 19/11/2007 22:34

Elizabetth: are you trying to claim that you are free from bias?

Elizabetth · 19/11/2007 22:31

You'll deny everything Madamez. Then again as your career is in the porn industry, although not as a porn performer as I understand it (so why you were getting called "lucky" earlier on is beyond me) it's understandable. You have a bias and you will deny all evidence that challenges it.

I didn't realise you were famous for going on to threads where women were in pain because of their partners' porn use and rah-rahing porn either but I guess you have to protect your livelihood. Strangely enough though, I don't think a few people on a message board, even if they are exposing the truth rather than the lies that the porn industry propagates, are going to make much difference.

And funnily enough the porn-defenders have offered the some total of nothing in the way of figures, evidence or facts on this thread. Funnily enough that doesn't seem to bother you though.

On the other hand that doctor is a professional who can report on trends he sees with his child patients.

Rhubarb · 19/11/2007 21:59

madamez, you are wanted here - we can't start without you!

madamez · 19/11/2007 21:58

Elizabetth: that article proves nothing at all. It's one bloke's opinion, and he doesn;t give any figures in support of it. His assertion that girls who 'view that stuff feel compelled to copy it' may be paraphrased but it's pretty unsulting to sugest that they have no minds of their own. He may also be falling into the absolutely classic psychologist error of extrapolating from what he encounters ie: people who come to me are messed up, they report X behaviour pattern therefore X behaviour pattern is The Problem - ignoring the fact that people who engage in X behaviour without problems don't turn up in psychologists' consulting rooms.

Elizabetth · 19/11/2007 21:24

www.theage.com.au/news/national/sex-acts-copied-from-online-porn-sites/2007/11/04/1194117879189.html

Back for one more thing, I think this needs to be added to here, an article I just came across. It confirms all the worst fears about what being exposed to pornography can do to children, particularly now when it is so culturally acceptable and mainstream -

"Sex acts copied from online porn sites

GIRLS only just into puberty are copying sexual acts they see in internet pornography, believing they must be normal, child psychologist Michael Carr-Gregg said.

Dr Carr-Gregg said large numbers of teenage girls had engaged in behaviour such as group sex or anal sex, which they wouldn't have done without seeing it online.

"Girls have new sexual practices. We've found that when they view that stuff they feel compelled to copy it," he said yesterday.

"It's causing young women to do things they wouldn't have done but because it's online they think it's normal. We are talking about girls who have just come into puberty."

He said a survey on cyber-bullying run via Girlfriend magazine showed that 41 per cent had been asked to post a naked or semi-naked picture of themselves on the internet.

"That's incredibly high, and it's against the law. If you take a picture and send it, you are manufacturing and distributing child pornography.

"Kids don't understand the seriousness of what they are doing, or that whenever they send something to cyberspace, it can't be taken back.""

Monkeytrousers · 19/11/2007 21:01

Yes, Xenia you are right. gayness (for men at least) does seem to be something you are born. Femnale sexuality is known to be more 'plastic' - thought to be concerned with the need to create female alliances to counter male agression (to offspring) in our evolutionary history

Monkeytrousers · 19/11/2007 20:49

oops, wrong thread

Monkeytrousers · 19/11/2007 20:49

Reading list for today (!) is The Woman That Never Evolved

Mothernature

www.amazon.co.uk/gp/offer-listing/074254351X/ref=dp_olp_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1195505217&sr=1-1 Who's Afraid of Charles Darwin: debating feminism and evolutionary theory]]

The first one especially with regards to female evolved sexuality and the last for a wonderful debate on feminsm and evolution. I'd defo recomment that one to you Soph as it concernes your question directly, and better than I could recount.

Judy1234 · 19/11/2007 20:33

Base on observation. I know a lot of gay men and most have felt gay from a very young age. Same with a lot of other sexual inclinations.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread