Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we shouldn’t have another lockdown to protect vaccine refusers?

266 replies

Susie477 · 17/05/2021 18:35

Everyone over 40 or in high-risk groups has now been offered a vaccine. The overwhelming majority, including me, have gratefully taken up the offer. A small minority have refused the vaccine, as is their right, of course.

Now we are seeing new ‘variants of concern’ and unvaccinated vulnerable people in some areas are now being hospitalised because they have been infected.

Some people are now calling for extended restrictions in these areas to prevent the new variant spreading. Why should responsible people who have been vaccinated be punished by yet more lockdown because idiots in their communities are too stupid or too selfish to get vaccinated?

OP posts:
JesusInTheCabbageVan · 17/05/2021 20:09

If we had to lock down, it would be to protect the vaccinated as they are still more likely to be the ones who get ill

You what?

RedcurrantPuff · 17/05/2021 20:09

And of course there are people who can’t have the vaccine. That’s why it’s more important for the rest of us who can to have it.

RedcurrantPuff · 17/05/2021 20:08

And the government won’t tolerate it either. If people think the government are going to keep taking the financial hit of lockdown, furlough etc due to people who don’t want the vaccine I expect we will see de facto mandatory vaccination pretty soon.

JesusIsAnyNameFree · 17/05/2021 20:07

@XenoBitch

Are you seriously comparing the two? 🙄

No, am fed up with the use of language surrounding the vaccine. "Called up"... like it is a draft. "Refused", when it is not forced.

Well it fucking well should be.
RedcurrantPuff · 17/05/2021 20:06

I think once we have reached the point where the population could be fully vaccinated we will have a lot of angry people and a backlash if our freedoms have been curtailed solely due to refusers.

MercyBooth · 17/05/2021 20:03

Christmas being a prime example

WTF was that press conference about on the 19th December then? The clogged up ports in Kent when France reacted to it. This gaslighting, rewriting of history and minimization of the sacrifices ppl have already made will ensure ZERO co operation in future. Sick of the gaslighting. Christmas WAS cancelled for many. London AND Essex were in tier 4.
Well fool me once shame on you fool me twice shame on me. People will NOT do another fucking lockdown or more restrictions when a few months later certain quarters are going to gaslight minimize and pretend it never happened. No Fucking Way. Ungrateful and abusive.

XenoBitch · 17/05/2021 20:00

Are you seriously comparing the two? 🙄

No, am fed up with the use of language surrounding the vaccine. "Called up"... like it is a draft. "Refused", when it is not forced.

MercyBooth · 17/05/2021 19:58

The Government need to guarantee support. Both emotional AND financial for anyone who does have an adverse reaction to the vaccine. Shouldnt be a problem and wont cost much as reactions are so rare.

freakyfridays · 17/05/2021 19:58

GappyValley

Actual scientists don't have a uniform opinion on the subject, and no-one has any idea of the impact on unborn babies...
Good for you if you kept it simple and didn't do too much research, but you are being ridiculous to think people trying to do the best for their kids find it "easy".

Waxonwaxoff0 · 17/05/2021 19:58

@freakyfridays

Lockdown was to protect the elderly and vulnerable and the NHS, not us.

because you don't use the NHS? Confused

Barely, but the point is the NHS is not currently overwhelmed, at least not with Covid patients, which was what lockdown was for.
JesusIsAnyNameFree · 17/05/2021 19:58

@XenoBitch

I did not refuse the vaccine. It is not being forced on me, so is not something I "refuse". I have declined my invite. Do you "refuse" to go to a wedding if invited?
Are you seriously comparing the two? 🙄
freakyfridays · 17/05/2021 19:56

Lockdown was to protect the elderly and vulnerable and the NHS, not us.

because you don't use the NHS? Confused

GappyValley · 17/05/2021 19:56

@freakyfridays

I’m pregnant It was a really easy decision for me to take Listened to doctors advice, took advice, got jab. Decision done

How is that relevant?

You found it easy, and you were lucky.

Other mothers might not find it so easy, as no one knows what the effect on the baby are, and other mothers ended up with high temperature for days, which is never good for the baby either.

Some doctors and paediatricians do not recommend the jab for pregnant women btw. As much as we would love a straight answer, it really is not that easy.

Im not ‘lucky’ to be able to make a decision Confused I just have more than half a brain and am able to judge that when entire medical professions conclude benefits far outweigh risks, it’s the right thing to do

I think as a society, we are pretty much over pandering to people who have run out of common sense and get their information from Facebook rather than, you know, actual scientists

freakyfridays · 17/05/2021 19:56

Who? Children? The most vulnerable are the over 50s and those with conditions that make them vulnerable, and all but a small number of children and others who for other reasons can't have the vaccine (e.g. due to chemo) have been offered it, many have had 2 doses.

where on earth are you?

People over 40 are still struggling to find a spot to book their first jab here! (South East).

Waxonwaxoff0 · 17/05/2021 19:54

YANBU. Everyone under 40 is low risk, people under 40 need to understand that we did not lock down to protect them in the first place. I am 30 and healthy so haven't been offered the vaccine yet. Lockdown was to protect the elderly and vulnerable and the NHS, not us.

XenoBitch · 17/05/2021 19:53

I did not refuse the vaccine. It is not being forced on me, so is not something I "refuse". I have declined my invite. Do you "refuse" to go to a wedding if invited?

OverTheRubicon · 17/05/2021 19:50

@elliejjtiny

There are lots of vulnerable people who haven't been offered their first jabs yet.
Who? Children? The most vulnerable are the over 50s and those with conditions that make them vulnerable, and all but a small number of children and others who for other reasons can't have the vaccine (e.g. due to chemo) have been offered it, many have had 2 doses.

I'm very sympathetic to those who cannot take a vaccine and are therefore at risk. However we do not shut down every year to protect the vulnerable from flu, even though more children die from flu than from covid - at what point would you make the cutoff?

If there is a variant that bypasses the vaccine or is highly risky for younger people then I would absolutely support another lockdown. If we need to pause a full reopening due to the Indian variant I absolutely support that too. But the risk now is so much lower and the risk of continuing as things are is pretty high.

freakyfridays · 17/05/2021 19:49

Pottedpalm
I don’t see anything the OP’s post to indicate that she thinks the vaccine is a cure-all.

Apart from implying that the only reason for restrictions would be the people who are not vaccinated?

SlipperyDippery · 17/05/2021 19:49

A lot of people on this thread talking about those adversely affected if we don’t lockdown and that’s fair enough. I haven’t been vaccinated and my husband is a doctor who gets redeployed to covid ICU during peaks so I’m not exactly sitting pretty with no risk.

But we also have to consider the colossal suffering lockdowns cause, and we have been in one for months. For much of the country (including the north where I am) we barely came out of it. We have to balance the competing interests and consider the needs of those harmed by lockdown as well. It really really isn’t as simple as saying if cases rise the moral thing to do is lockdown again.

And yes, people will die from lockdown - according to ONS modelling it will be nearly a million years of life lost over the next 5 years because of it. It’s not about me wanting to go to the pub because I’m bored.

JesusIsAnyNameFree · 17/05/2021 19:49

We are seeing more people in their 30s hospitalised around the world this time around. Can we protect them according to you or shall we just let 'em perish?

Changednameforthispost11 · 17/05/2021 19:48

I get what you mean op and agree with you if it was just those vaccine refuses who would be affected.

But I think at the moment that’s too simplistic a view. The under 40’s and children are a large group and they deserve the chance to be kept as safe as possible before they get the vaccine. The more it spreads among them, even if they don’t become very ill, the more chance of it further mutating plus there is the risk of long Covid. As mentioned above, there are also those who will only get limited benefit from the vaccine as they are immunosuppressed.

I think they should continue with the slow reopening, but stop if numbers start rapidly rising. Sensible measures should remain in place. They should vaccinate as many people as quickly as they can too.

GappyValley · 17/05/2021 19:48

@Pixxie7

It is still not known how much protection the vaccine is against new variants. We just have to accept that the future is unknown and accept any decisions made.
It’s very known Lots of data published today showing that it’s effective against the Indian variant, just as it’s been effective against all the others

Every time a new variant occurs, we get the same ‘oh but the vaccine might not be effective’ and then all the data shows it’s effective but then we still have to wait for the whataboutery for the next variant by people obsessed with the idea that there are ‘so many unknowns’
It’s getting so boring now

freakyfridays · 17/05/2021 19:48

I’m pregnant
It was a really easy decision for me to take
Listened to doctors advice, took advice, got jab. Decision done

How is that relevant?

You found it easy, and you were lucky.

Other mothers might not find it so easy, as no one knows what the effect on the baby are, and other mothers ended up with high temperature for days, which is never good for the baby either.

Some doctors and paediatricians do not recommend the jab for pregnant women btw. As much as we would love a straight answer, it really is not that easy.

Pottedpalm · 17/05/2021 19:47

@freakyfridays

You are very naive if you think the vaccine is a miracle cure (or miracle prevention more accurately).
Ugh! This seems to be the favourite put-down at the the moment. ‘You are very naive’. I don’t see anything the OP’s post to indicate that she thinks the vaccine is a cure-all.
GappyValley · 17/05/2021 19:45

@freakyfridays

And frankly, massive YABU to think it's such an easy decision for someone who is pregnant for example.
I’m pregnant It was a really easy decision for me to take Listened to doctors advice, took advice, got jab. Decision done