Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we shouldn’t have another lockdown to protect vaccine refusers?

266 replies

Susie477 · 17/05/2021 18:35

Everyone over 40 or in high-risk groups has now been offered a vaccine. The overwhelming majority, including me, have gratefully taken up the offer. A small minority have refused the vaccine, as is their right, of course.

Now we are seeing new ‘variants of concern’ and unvaccinated vulnerable people in some areas are now being hospitalised because they have been infected.

Some people are now calling for extended restrictions in these areas to prevent the new variant spreading. Why should responsible people who have been vaccinated be punished by yet more lockdown because idiots in their communities are too stupid or too selfish to get vaccinated?

OP posts:
partyatthepalace · 18/05/2021 08:59

No one is suggesting that OP. We’ll have another lockdown if the NHS is at risk of overwhelm, not otherwise.

I share your frustration at vaccine refusers, but not everyone who is middling vulnerable has had the chance of 2 jabs yet - some not even one.

I think we are some way off another lockdown, but we’re also some way off being able to relax much.

MargaretThursday · 18/05/2021 08:59

The safety data for pregnant women isn’t based on the U.K, it’s based on the US. 90,000 pregnant women there have received the vaccine with no issue. That’s the basis on which it was recommended here.

Firstly the US only started giving the vaccine in mid December. That's 5 months ago, so there can't be much data on people who had it in the first trimester.

And Thalidomide isn’t a vaccine. It's a medication. Medications and vaccines can both have side effects.
And my point was that when something causes a side effect, especially one that can sometimes occur naturally, it takes time to realise that it isn't just "one of those things". Thalidomide had a horrific effect, and still took 5 years for them to link it.
For the example I gave. 60 children a year a born with a limb deficiency. That varies from being the end of a finger, through to all four limbs missing. There's about 700k children born each year (UK), so that's less than 0.01% of births.

  • Limbs are formed in the first 5 weeks of pregnancy, so they'd have had to have the injection then to effect the development of a limb, so the US market wouldn't have had the vaccine at that stage and given birth, and no, a missing limb isn't always picked up at the scan. I'd reckon at best about 50/50 are picked up at the scan. DD's was, but plenty aren't, even among people who had several scans for other reasons. I'd reckon the numbers of limb deficient babies could probably increase ten times and it still would take time to realise it wasn't just one of those things because it would still be small numbers. You get unusual clusters in random distribution, so a hospital suddenly having two in quick succession is unusual, but I do know of it happening. For example overall a limb deficiency is twice as likely in a girl. However dd was one of very few girls at her limb centre when growing up-it was about 75% boys. Just one of those random things.

*I am not implying that the Covid Vaccine causes limb deficiency or any other birth defect. As far as I am aware, there are no links being investigated. However I am saying that I understand if someone doesn't want the injection because they are pregnant as I would say they can't state with certainty that it won't.

MaxNormal · 18/05/2021 08:50

I am incensed that the road map maybe derailed and the majority who have followed the rules, and have had their vaccines etc arw going to be subject more restrictions, with its detrimental effects all because people were too selfish to get vaccinated

Don't fall for it. This is Johnson's fuck up where he refused to red list India for too long due to his precious post Brexit trade deal.
They are now lying and putting the blame onto the plebs as usual.

Changednameforthispost11 · 18/05/2021 08:43

@LunaMuffinTop

I’m going to get my 2nd vaccine tomorrow I lost 2 family members 10 days apart to Covid all my family have had the vaccine the only ones who haven’t are my 7 year old niece, my 18 month old niece and my husband who has a serve needle phobia he faints at the sight of a needle and because of that he point blank refuses to get the vaccine I’ve offered to get him tattoo numb and we’ll test that and if that works then he will go and get the vaccine. My friend can’t have the vaccine because he’s allergic to them and he’s been offered no alternative he has just been left unvaccinated.
Tell your dh that if he were to be hospitalised with covid the first thing they would probably do would be to insert a venflon into his hand which involves a needle which remains in for his entire length of stay to give drugs if needed.

The vaccine is probably about 3 seconds!!

I know what I’d prefer if I was needle phobic!

Pottedpalm · 18/05/2021 08:31

@Toty

Oh ffs, when did MN turn into the daily mail. Do people actually fall for these targeted sensationalist headlines Hmm. The Only reason further lockdowns are now needed is because of our governments continual monumental cock ups, allowing all these varients in to the UK in the first place, even then these lockdowns were about covering up the fact the our NHS isn't fit for purpose, they are not and never have been about saving lives. The majority of vaccine refusers won't have even been offered a vaccine yet so how the fuck is it their fault. I'm 47 and haven't been offered my vaccine yet. The rest of the UK is way behind England.
Its not about ‘falling for’ sensationalist headlines. Figures on vaccine refusers currently hospitalised are clear. And where do your statistics showing that the majority of refusers haven’t been offered the vaccine come from?
AHobbyaweek · 18/05/2021 08:29

@Lucidas I have checked the data and they are basing the "90,000 had no issues" on the fact that more side effects have not been reported by those 90,000. They are not following them up fully like normal trials and the majority have not had their babies to see if there was any effect. They are trying to recruit them to record the data properly and see what if any effect there is but so far have not recruited enough of them that have had their babies to tell.
I am keeping up with the developments there to make my own decision.

Toty · 18/05/2021 08:19

Oh ffs, when did MN turn into the daily mail. Do people actually fall for these targeted sensationalist headlines Hmm. The Only reason further lockdowns are now needed is because of our governments continual monumental cock ups, allowing all these varients in to the UK in the first place, even then these lockdowns were about covering up the fact the our NHS isn't fit for purpose, they are not and never have been about saving lives.
The majority of vaccine refusers won't have even been offered a vaccine yet so how the fuck is it their fault. I'm 47 and haven't been offered my vaccine yet. The rest of the UK is way behind England.

Theredjellybean · 18/05/2021 08:19

I agree OP... Widely reported that majority in hospital with Indian variant had refused vaccination.
I am incensed that the road map maybe derailed and the majority who have followed the rules, and have had their vaccines etc arw going to be subject more restrictions, with its detrimental effects all because people were too selfish to get vaccinated.

kikisparks · 18/05/2021 08:12

YABU, I’m pregnant but due to age can’t get vaccinated yet, despite the fact that we are a vulnerable group in the 3rd trimester. Not everyone who is vulnerable has been offered the vaccine yet.

osbertthesyrianhamster · 18/05/2021 08:11

[quote Peaplant20]@GappyValley yes but they haven’t been prioritised despite being classed as critically vulnerable and given than most pregnant women are under 40 that means most Pregnant women haven’t been vaccinated.

@osbertthesyrianhamster all very well saying that about under 40s but as long as there are a large proportion of people unvaccinated then there is a strong probability of the virus mutating in those people, potentially creating a variant that the vaccine doesn’t work as well against or that does affect younger people worse.

If it was the other way around and they started vaccinating younger people first I’m sure a lot of people would think differently and think that we should continue to protect the older population.[/quote]
I doubt that. Increasing number of people are done with these lockdowns. They have devastating effects. This virus is here to stay.

SoupDragon · 18/05/2021 08:09

Everyone over 40 or in high-risk groups has now been offered a vaccine.

Only 20,287,403 out of the entire U.K. population have received both doses.

Letsgetreadytocrumble · 18/05/2021 08:08

@Kokapetl

If a vaccine is 90% effective that's still one in ten of the most vulnerable who could potentially end up hospitalised or dead.

Apart from the younger adults who haven't even been offered the vaccine, children are not getting it at all and they can still get seriously ill with Covid. I wouldn't mind keeping a few restrictions (masks, some distancing, limits on numbers indoors) to stop children ending up with damaged hearts for example.

I don't think that's how vaccine efficacy percentages work.

Young people, old people, vaccinated people still get very ill and die of flu every year, tens of thousands of them, and we don't lock down for that. Are you proposing restrictions forever?

BatshitCrazyWoman · 18/05/2021 08:06

Bloody hell, what's happened to Mumsnet?? I was quoting @GappyValley from the first or second page 🙄 but the quote isn't showing.

BatshitCrazyWoman · 18/05/2021 08:05

I completely agree. I've no idea why I'm reading this, as I avoid reading most Covid threads. I follow Mac n' Chise on Twitter, she posts studies showing the effectiveness of the various vaccines.

Peaplant20 · 18/05/2021 08:02

@GappyValley yes but they haven’t been prioritised despite being classed as critically vulnerable and given than most pregnant women are under 40 that means most Pregnant women haven’t been vaccinated.

@osbertthesyrianhamster all very well saying that about under 40s but as long as there are a large proportion of people unvaccinated then there is a strong probability of the virus mutating in those people, potentially creating a variant that the vaccine doesn’t work as well against or that does affect younger people worse.

If it was the other way around and they started vaccinating younger people first I’m sure a lot of people would think differently and think that we should continue to protect the older population.

Lucidas · 18/05/2021 08:01

@MargaretThursday

Bollocks - pregnant women can safely have the vaccine. They have been in other countries, they have been here

They can't say yet whether it's safe for pregnant women. It's not just about if they immediately lose the baby, but there could be issues after birth that wouldn't be coming out in enough numbers yet. Look at Thalidomide, that took 5 years for doctors to make the connection. I'd expect it to be quicker now because I'd expect them to be looking out for it however, let's say it also causes missing limbs.
There are 60 babies a year born with missing limbs in the UK (my dd is one of them). Most of them for an unknown cause.
How many people in the UK so far have had both injections and then given birth? I'd suspect very few. So even if it doubled the risk, I doubt it would yet be statistically significant.

I don't think it's unreasonable for a pregnant lady to be nervous. I would myself, and I am generally pro vax.

The safety data for pregnant women isn’t based on the U.K, it’s based on the US. 90,000 pregnant women there have received the vaccine with no issue. That’s the basis on which it was recommended here.

And Thalidomide isn’t a vaccine.

MargaretThursday · 18/05/2021 07:59

Bollocks - pregnant women can safely have the vaccine. They have been in other countries, they have been here

They can't say yet whether it's safe for pregnant women. It's not just about if they immediately lose the baby, but there could be issues after birth that wouldn't be coming out in enough numbers yet. Look at Thalidomide, that took 5 years for doctors to make the connection. I'd expect it to be quicker now because I'd expect them to be looking out for it however, let's say it also causes missing limbs.
There are 60 babies a year born with missing limbs in the UK (my dd is one of them). Most of them for an unknown cause.
How many people in the UK so far have had both injections and then given birth? I'd suspect very few. So even if it doubled the risk, I doubt it would yet be statistically significant.

I don't think it's unreasonable for a pregnant lady to be nervous. I would myself, and I am generally pro vax.

x2boys · 18/05/2021 07:57

I live in Bolton in the post code of particular concern,I'm fully vaccinated as is my DH,I think people are getting it now,they are offering the vaccines to people over the age of 16,there were massive ques at the Essa academy over the weekend I believe which is a vaccine hub ,I hope this isn't to little to late .

borntobequiet · 18/05/2021 07:55

YABU because it would be to protect the NHS, and the population as a whole, not vaccine refusers.

osbertthesyrianhamster · 18/05/2021 07:53

@GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER

Yesterday I heard from a friend of relations of hers in their 50s who are refusing the vaccine, not for any medical reason. But they’re expecting to be able to go on holiday as usual to one of the European countries which is likely to be on the cards for holidays again soon.

Friend fervently hopes that they will not be allowed to go without proof of vaccination, since she thinks that’s the only thing likely to change their minds.

Must say I agree with her, so 🤞.

Under 40s are not at great risk of complications of the disease.
CheeseIsMyJam · 18/05/2021 07:50

So you're not bothered about protecting the under 40s? We don't matter?

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 18/05/2021 07:46

Yesterday I heard from a friend of relations of hers in their 50s who are refusing the vaccine, not for any medical reason. But they’re expecting to be able to go on holiday as usual to one of the European countries which is likely to be on the cards for holidays again soon.

Friend fervently hopes that they will not be allowed to go without proof of vaccination, since she thinks that’s the only thing likely to change their minds.

Must say I agree with her, so 🤞.

GappyValley · 18/05/2021 07:45

@PrincessNutNuts

  1. Bollocks - pregnant women can safely have the vaccine. They have been in other countries, they have been here
If they chose to disregard medical advice, that’s their look out
  1. Also bollocks. One fully vaccinated person has been hospitalised, and they were described as ‘very frail’
GreatBritishBummertime · 18/05/2021 06:20

If we need to lockdown again it would be for the NHS, not much point refusing it.

I am coming round to vaccine passports though. IF an area is known to have a higher than average transmission rate, why should vaccine refusers to able to swan around restaurants and indoor leisure spreading? If there's a valid clinical reason like pregnancy, or you just haven't been offered it yet I'd make you exempt.

GlitterNails · 18/05/2021 02:13

I am CEV and should have been done in group 4 but unfortunately due to a series of cockups and other complications with the NHS sorting it out I only had my first five weeks ago. Had they not just brought the second jab forward to eight weeks I wouldn’t have had my second until July.

And I’m not the only CEV person in this boat as I know many were having the same issues I had too.

I still haven’t left my house but would really like to start living again sometime soon.

This is just a general comment in that no, not all CEV have had both jabs.